The new BlackBerry factory in Malaysia is makingthe Indonesian government uneasy. The sales rate of the Canadian smart phone is much greater in Indonesia than in Malaysia, so the government wants BlackBerrys to be manufactured in Indonesia. To achieve this, the government plans to implement a tax disincentive.
As widely reported, Research In Motion (RIM), the manufacturer of BlackBerry, built a manufacturing factory in Penang, Malaysia to meet BlackBerry production needs in the Asia Pacific region.
The new RIM factory began to operate in Penang, Malaysia on 1July 2011. The factory is expected to increase the number of jobs in Malaysia. This is regrettable for the Indonesian government.
The Head of the Investment Coordinating Agency Gita Wirjawan expressed disatisfaction with RIM’s decision to build a factory in Malaysia, while BlackBerry sales in Indonesia are high. Four million units, with an average price of USD 300 per unit, are expected to be sold in the coming year, while Malaysiahas only sold about 400 thousand units per year.
“But BlackBerry prefers to build their factory in Malaysia. This of course needs to be addressed, since they are aware that BlackBerry growth in Indonesia is the highest in the world.” Gita Wirjawan said in Jakarta, Wednesday (7/9).
To address RIM’s actions, Indonesia will adopt a tax disincentive plan for BlackBerry products circulating in Indonesia, since BlackBerry products made in Malaysia will also be sold in Indonesia.
The disincentive tax policy will not just apply to BlackBerry. Gita asserts that the government will make a list of large scale consumer products that are sold in Indonesia, but are not manufactured inIndonesia.
Another manufacturer that is being highlighted is the German company Bosch. Bosch is already building a solar panel factory in Malaysia, but their products are also sold in Indonesia.
“There should be no reason for manufacturers like this not toproduce in Indonesia. I think a lot of our graduates are capable of making the products. The point is not to have too many products that we consume that are not produced in Indonesia” Gita said.
Moreover, to date, Indonesian mainly exports raw goods. But increasing the manufacturing of consumer goods in Indonesia will result in a higher variety ofexport products. "We should also be exporting goods that have added value," she explained.
According to Gita,the tax disincentive will be implemented so that manufacturers mentioned in the inventory list will build their factories in Indonesia. However,this concept is still being finalized.
“We're still formulating the method. The most important thing is that our children and our grandchildren will be able to produce something, not just export coal,” she said.
Meanwhile in the Ministry of Industry, MS Hidayat said BlackBerry manufacturers may be subject to an additional Value Added Tax (PPn) or Sales Tax on Luxury Goods (PPnBM). Thus, foreign manufacturers will prefer to invest in Indonesia. “Provisions must be created to make investors more interested in investing here in Indonesia if their target market is here,” he said.
The Head of Fiscal Policy, Bambang PS Brodjonegoro, said there are still on going discussions to find the right instruments for manufacturers like this. He emphasized the importance of anticipating smuggling if an additional PPN or PPnBM is implemented. Therefore this policy is still being studied in depth. “Do not let smuggling increase even more due to the implementation of a PPN and PPnBM” he said.
However, Vice Chairman of the Chamber of Commerce for Industry, Research and Technology, Bambang Sujagad asserted that taxing BlackBerrys as a luxury item will be difficult. "If we tax them we will just hassle ourselves. BlackBerry is not a luxury item, it is just another consumer product. It would be wrong toa pply luxury goods [tax on BlackBerrys], it will bring misery to our people who need the technology," he told several media outlets.
Bambang’s assessment is that the Indonesia Investment Coordinating Board (BKPM) saw the investment potential of RIM too late, so in the end RIM preferred Malaysia. According to him, applying this kind of tax should have been done before RIM made the decision to build a BlackBerry factoryin Malaysia. But now the decision to choose Malaysia as a production base has been made and it will be difficult to change.
"We have a lack of awareness for this type of technology investment, there should not just be tax holiday facilities, the land should also be free. It is BKPM duty to find out what could have been done [to attract investors]. BKPM should be more active.” Bambang concluded.
(M Vareno Tarnes / Adi Condro Bawono)
The new BlackBerry factory in Malaysia is makingthe Indonesian government uneasy. The sales rate of the Canadian smart phone is much greater in Indonesia than in Malaysia, so the government wants BlackBerrys to be manufactured in Indonesia. To achieve this, the government plans to implement a tax disincentive.
As widely reported, Research In Motion (RIM), the manufacturer of BlackBerry, built a manufacturing factory in Penang, Malaysia to meet BlackBerry production needs in the Asia Pacific region.
The new RIM factory began to operate in Penang, Malaysia on 1July 2011. The factory is expected to increase the number of jobs in Malaysia. This is regrettable for the Indonesian government.
The Head of the Investment Coordinating Agency Gita Wirjawan expressed disatisfaction with RIM’s decision to build a factory in Malaysia, while BlackBerry sales in Indonesia are high. Four million units, with an average price of USD 300 per unit, are expected to be sold in the coming year, while Malaysiahas only sold about 400 thousand units per year.
“But BlackBerry prefers to build their factory in Malaysia. This of course needs to be addressed, since they are aware that BlackBerry growth in Indonesia is the highest in the world.” Gita Wirjawan said in Jakarta, Wednesday (7/9).
To address RIM’s actions, Indonesia will adopt a tax disincentive plan for BlackBerry products circulating in Indonesia, since BlackBerry products made in Malaysia will also be sold in Indonesia.
The disincentive tax policy will not just apply to BlackBerry. Gita asserts that the government will make a list of large scale consumer products that are sold in Indonesia, but are not manufactured inIndonesia.
Another manufacturer that is being highlighted is the German company Bosch. Bosch is already building a solar panel factory in Malaysia, but their products are also sold in Indonesia.
“There should be no reason for manufacturers like this not toproduce in Indonesia. I think a lot of our graduates are capable of making the products. The point is not to have too many products that we consume that are not produced in Indonesia” Gita said.
Moreover, to date, Indonesian mainly exports raw goods. But increasing the manufacturing of consumer goods in Indonesia will result in a higher variety ofexport products. "We should also be exporting goods that have added value," she explained.
According to Gita,the tax disincentive will be implemented so that manufacturers mentioned in the inventory list will build their factories in Indonesia. However,this concept is still being finalized.
“We're still formulating the method. The most important thing is that our children and our grandchildren will be able to produce something, not just export coal,” she said.
Meanwhile in the Ministry of Industry, MS Hidayat said BlackBerry manufacturers may be subject to an additional Value Added Tax (PPn) or Sales Tax on Luxury Goods (PPnBM). Thus, foreign manufacturers will prefer to invest in Indonesia. “Provisions must be created to make investors more interested in investing here in Indonesia if their target market is here,” he said.
The Head of Fiscal Policy, Bambang PS Brodjonegoro, said there are still on going discussions to find the right instruments for manufacturers like this. He emphasized the importance of anticipating smuggling if an additional PPN or PPnBM is implemented. Therefore this policy is still being studied in depth. “Do not let smuggling increase even more due to the implementation of a PPN and PPnBM” he said.
However, Vice Chairman of the Chamber of Commerce for Industry, Research and Technology, Bambang Sujagad asserted that taxing BlackBerrys as a luxury item will be difficult. "If we tax them we will just hassle ourselves. BlackBerry is not a luxury item, it is just another consumer product. It would be wrong toa pply luxury goods [tax on BlackBerrys], it will bring misery to our people who need the technology," he told several media outlets.
Bambang’s assessment is that the Indonesia Investment Coordinating Board (BKPM) saw the investment potential of RIM too late, so in the end RIM preferred Malaysia. According to him, applying this kind of tax should have been done before RIM made the decision to build a BlackBerry factoryin Malaysia. But now the decision to choose Malaysia as a production base has been made and it will be difficult to change.
"We have a lack of awareness for this type of technology investment, there should not just be tax holiday facilities, the land should also be free. It is BKPM duty to find out what could have been done [to attract investors]. BKPM should be more active.” Bambang concluded.
(M Vareno Tarnes / Adi Condro Bawono)