Applicant requested that the word 'golf' in Article 42 (2) (g) of Law on Regional Tax and Retribution canceled.
Objected being taxed, nine golf course management company questioned the taxation rules of Article 42 (2) (g) of Law No 28 of 2009 on Regional Tax and Retribution to the Constitutional Court (MK).
Noted as applicants are PT Asosiasi Pemilik Lapangan Golf Indonesia, PT Pondok Indah Padang Golf (Tbk), PT Padang Golf Bukit Sentul, PT Sentul Golf Utama, PT Sanggraha Daksamitra, PT New Kuta Golf and Ocean View, PT Merapi Golf, PT Karawang Sport Center Indonesia, and PT Damai Indah Golf.
"The imposition of Article 42 (2) (g) of Law on Regional Tax and Retribution have harmed the constitutional rights of the applicants because the applicant is categorized as a provider of entertainment services and should be taxed extra [ed:with entertainment taxation] through regional regulations," said the applicant's legal representative, Benny Ponto in a preliminary hearing at the Court building on Thursday (8/9).
To be comprehensive Article 42 stated, (1) The Tax object is organizing entertainment services with charge. (2) Entertainment referred in paragraph (1) is... g. game of billiards, golf, and bowling.
Benny said that Article 42 (2) (g) of the Law on Regional Tax and Retribution turned out include golf as entertainment, so the golf sport business is categorized as entertainment business and become a subject of the extra taxation. While entrepreneurs in other similar sports field such as soccer, futsal, tennis, badminton, basketball, and shooting are not the subject of entertainment tax.
"This is a form of discrimination treatment or unequal treatment for the applicants, besides the golf business is not much different from other sports businesses. Moreover to define golf as entertainment service provider business, and not as a sport business is in conflict to the Law on National Sports System Preamble," said Benny.
He said the entertainment tax for golf business is implemented through the regional government regulation. For example, Tangerang City Regional Regulation No. 07 of 2010 on Local Taxes, golf is subjected to as much 25 percent from each payment made, Depok City Regional Regulation No. 07 of 2010 on Local Taxes set 10 percent tariffs for golf entertainment.
According to him, golf belongs to recreational sports category and sporting achievements. In addition, golf is recognized worldwide as a sporting activity. In fact, there are many golf championship has been hosted both in international and national levels, such as the Olympics or Asian Games event.
Therefore, Article 42 (2) (g) of the Law on Regional Tax and Retribution, especially the word 'golf' is contradictory to Article 28D (1) and Article 28I (2) of the 1945 Constitution. "Stating that article has no binding legal force," He demanded.
Members of the judge panel M. Akil Mochtar suggested the applicant explained [ed. to the Constitutional Court] that they not only subjected to entertainment tax, but also other taxes. "If the review of the article is granted, the applicant still will be also obliged to pay other taxes, it must also be described," he advised.
(Agus Sahbani / Adi Condro Bawono)
Applicant requested that the word 'golf' in Article 42 (2) (g) of Law on Regional Tax and Retribution canceled.
Objected being taxed, nine golf course management company questioned the taxation rules of Article 42 (2) (g) of Law No 28 of 2009 on Regional Tax and Retribution to the Constitutional Court (MK).
Noted as applicants are PT Asosiasi Pemilik Lapangan Golf Indonesia, PT Pondok Indah Padang Golf (Tbk), PT Padang Golf Bukit Sentul, PT Sentul Golf Utama, PT Sanggraha Daksamitra, PT New Kuta Golf and Ocean View, PT Merapi Golf, PT Karawang Sport Center Indonesia, and PT Damai Indah Golf.
"The imposition of Article 42 (2) (g) of Law on Regional Tax and Retribution have harmed the constitutional rights of the applicants because the applicant is categorized as a provider of entertainment services and should be taxed extra [ed:with entertainment taxation] through regional regulations," said the applicant's legal representative, Benny Ponto in a preliminary hearing at the Court building on Thursday (8/9).
To be comprehensive Article 42 stated, (1) The Tax object is organizing entertainment services with charge. (2) Entertainment referred in paragraph (1) is... g. game of billiards, golf, and bowling.
Benny said that Article 42 (2) (g) of the Law on Regional Tax and Retribution turned out include golf as entertainment, so the golf sport business is categorized as entertainment business and become a subject of the extra taxation. While entrepreneurs in other similar sports field such as soccer, futsal, tennis, badminton, basketball, and shooting are not the subject of entertainment tax.
"This is a form of discrimination treatment or unequal treatment for the applicants, besides the golf business is not much different from other sports businesses. Moreover to define golf as entertainment service provider business, and not as a sport business is in conflict to the Law on National Sports System Preamble," said Benny.
He said the entertainment tax for golf business is implemented through the regional government regulation. For example, Tangerang City Regional Regulation No. 07 of 2010 on Local Taxes, golf is subjected to as much 25 percent from each payment made, Depok City Regional Regulation No. 07 of 2010 on Local Taxes set 10 percent tariffs for golf entertainment.
According to him, golf belongs to recreational sports category and sporting achievements. In addition, golf is recognized worldwide as a sporting activity. In fact, there are many golf championship has been hosted both in international and national levels, such as the Olympics or Asian Games event.
Therefore, Article 42 (2) (g) of the Law on Regional Tax and Retribution, especially the word 'golf' is contradictory to Article 28D (1) and Article 28I (2) of the 1945 Constitution. "Stating that article has no binding legal force," He demanded.
Members of the judge panel M. Akil Mochtar suggested the applicant explained [ed. to the Constitutional Court] that they not only subjected to entertainment tax, but also other taxes. "If the review of the article is granted, the applicant still will be also obliged to pay other taxes, it must also be described," he advised.
(Agus Sahbani / Adi Condro Bawono)