Palm Oil Businesses Object to Export Duties

 

The Indonesia Palm Oil Association (Gabungan Pengusaha Kelapa Sawit Indonesia - GAPKI) objectsto the implementation of export duties, regulated under Minister of Finance Regulation No. 128/PMK.011/2011 on Exported Goods Subject to Export Duties("PMK 128/2011").  PMK 128/2011 is an amendment to Minister of Finance Regulation No. 67/PMK.011/2010.

Palm oil businesses complained about the export duty figure under PMK 128/2011. PMK 128/2011 increased the export dutyfor palm oil products valued under USD 1.100, particularly those that priced between USD 950 and USD 1.100.

"There is no significant revision tothe export duty scheme and tariffs, compared to the previous regulation," said Fadhil Hasan, Executive Director of the GAPKI, in Jakarta, on Wednesday (7/9).

Fadhil estimated that the price of crude palm oil (CPO) in 2011 and 2012 will bebetweenUSD 1.000 and1.100. Therefore, he asserted, the new export duty regulation is misleading and is not in line with the actual facts.

Under PMK 128/2011, the minimum export duty for CPO is set at USD 750 per ton, fifty dollars more than the previous export duty, which was set at USD 700. Furthermore, theupper limit for the export duty under PMK 128/2011 is set at 22,5 percent, whereasthe previous regulation set the limitat 25 percent for palm products that priced atUSD 1.250. Meanwhile, the export duty for refined, bleached and deodorized oil(downstream products of palmoil) is set at a maximum of 10 percent.Previously the maximum export duty was set at 25 percent.

"That raises a question. Why is a downstream product still subject to an export duty? It is a contradiction if we actually want to encourage the improvement of downstream industries," Fadhil emphasized.

Fadhil asserted that the government should not apply the export duty toCPO downstream products. The government, he said, shouldprovide a tax or non-tax incentive to improve the industry. The big export duty gap between CPO and its derivatives could lead to CPO smuggling.

Further, Fadhil said that there is no proofthat the export duty could improve CPO processing in Indonesia. He explained that during the first semester of 2010, the export level of CPO derivatives was higher thanduring the first semester of 2011; whilst the export duty in 2011 is higher than in 2010.

The palm oil industry business asserted that the export duty for CPO and its derivatives has a negative impact on the entire CPO industry. The export dutyresults ina high-cost economy, without providing any positive benefitsto offset the negative effects of the duty.

The export duty also encourages regional governments to implement retributionsonCPO, since the export duty is not allocated tothe regions.

On the other hand, Dedi Saleh, Director General of Foreign Trade at the Ministry of Trade, advised GAPKI to send a recommendation to the government, asking the government to use the export duty to help palm farmers develop their infrastructure.

However, Dedi asserted that PMK 128/2011 is finalized. "From the government's point of view, the export duty is a good policy to overcome problems regarding raw materials and the improving the downstreambusinesses," he emphasized.

(M. Agus Yozami / Pirhot Nababan)

 

The Indonesia Palm Oil Association (Gabungan Pengusaha Kelapa Sawit Indonesia - GAPKI) objectsto the implementation of export duties, regulated under Minister of Finance Regulation No. 128/PMK.011/2011 on Exported Goods Subject to Export Duties("PMK 128/2011").  PMK 128/2011 is an amendment to Minister of Finance Regulation No. 67/PMK.011/2010.

Palm oil businesses complained about the export duty figure under PMK 128/2011. PMK 128/2011 increased the export dutyfor palm oil products valued under USD 1.100, particularly those that priced between USD 950 and USD 1.100.

"There is no significant revision tothe export duty scheme and tariffs, compared to the previous regulation," said Fadhil Hasan, Executive Director of the GAPKI, in Jakarta, on Wednesday (7/9).

Fadhil estimated that the price of crude palm oil (CPO) in 2011 and 2012 will bebetweenUSD 1.000 and1.100. Therefore, he asserted, the new export duty regulation is misleading and is not in line with the actual facts.

Under PMK 128/2011, the minimum export duty for CPO is set at USD 750 per ton, fifty dollars more than the previous export duty, which was set at USD 700. Furthermore, theupper limit for the export duty under PMK 128/2011 is set at 22,5 percent, whereasthe previous regulation set the limitat 25 percent for palm products that priced atUSD 1.250. Meanwhile, the export duty for refined, bleached and deodorized oil(downstream products of palmoil) is set at a maximum of 10 percent.Previously the maximum export duty was set at 25 percent.

"That raises a question. Why is a downstream product still subject to an export duty? It is a contradiction if we actually want to encourage the improvement of downstream industries," Fadhil emphasized.

Fadhil asserted that the government should not apply the export duty toCPO downstream products. The government, he said, shouldprovide a tax or non-tax incentive to improve the industry. The big export duty gap between CPO and its derivatives could lead to CPO smuggling.

Further, Fadhil said that there is no proofthat the export duty could improve CPO processing in Indonesia. He explained that during the first semester of 2010, the export level of CPO derivatives was higher thanduring the first semester of 2011; whilst the export duty in 2011 is higher than in 2010.

The palm oil industry business asserted that the export duty for CPO and its derivatives has a negative impact on the entire CPO industry. The export dutyresults ina high-cost economy, without providing any positive benefitsto offset the negative effects of the duty.

The export duty also encourages regional governments to implement retributionsonCPO, since the export duty is not allocated tothe regions.

On the other hand, Dedi Saleh, Director General of Foreign Trade at the Ministry of Trade, advised GAPKI to send a recommendation to the government, asking the government to use the export duty to help palm farmers develop their infrastructure.

However, Dedi asserted that PMK 128/2011 is finalized. "From the government's point of view, the export duty is a good policy to overcome problems regarding raw materials and the improving the downstreambusinesses," he emphasized.

(M. Agus Yozami / Pirhot Nababan)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info