Moratorium on Mall Construction in Jakarta

 

Construction of shopping centers (malls) in the Jakarta area must be stopped to reduceincreasing numbers of immigrants. Max Pohan,the Regional Development Deputy of the Local Autonomy of the National Development Planning Agency,spoke against new malls, after a gathering (halal bi halal) at Bappenas’ office on Tuesday (6 /9).

According to Max, the construction of new malls attracts residents fromother regions, especially rural areas, to visit Jakarta.  They see Jakarta as a city of dreams and a place to improve their life.

Max hopes the DKI Jakarta Regional Government will suspend mall developmenttemporarily.  Max hopes development will be suspended for "about three to five years, also to improve the existing infrastructure.  The appeal of Jakarta hasto be stopped temporarily, "he said.

It all depends on the DKI Jakarta Regional Government’spolitical will in harmony with the central government's plan. The DKI Jakarta Regional Government needs to encourage private investors to improve infrastructure in other areas outside Jakarta, in order to create an attractive atmosphere for investors in other areas.  The DKI Jakarta Regional Government isimportant becauseit has the authority to grant permission for the construction of malls.

Moreover, improving infrastructure in other areasis also in accordance with the spirit of Law No.17 of 2007 on the Long Term National Development Plan (RPJPN).  “The law outlined that there must be regional development and acceleration outside Java, “said Max.

Meanwhile, other areas also need to be encouraged and assisted to improve infrastructure, so industries can develop and reach their full potential.

Infrastructure can be "adjusted to local resources, which could be agriculture, plantation, cement, or other.  But the infrastructure must be improved,so that people seeking a better life do not have to come to Jakarta,“he explained.

Jakarta recently issued a spatial plan layout area (Rencana Tata Ruang Tata Wilayah/RTRW) 2010-2030. In late August of 2011, after two years of discussion, the Special Jakarta Area Council Representatives (DPRD) finally promulgateddraft legislation for the2011-2030 spatial plan layout area (RTRW).

As widely reported, Governor Fauzi Bowo has affirmed the Jakarta Government’s commitment to implement a mall moratorium until 2012, as it has been done previously.

The spatial regulation mentions the importance of controlling and even limiting the construction of shopping centers, such as shops along the road, except in areas of high economy intensity or multistory buildings.

Urban planning experts from Trisakti University, Yayat Supriatna, said that the restriction to construct malls is necessary.  Currently Jakarta has so many malls.  According to DKI government data, there are about 68 malls in Jakarta.  That means there are more than 13 shopping centers in every municipality.  In fact, Yayat said the actual number is more than a hundred.  These numbers already exceed the ideal limit and also make Jakarta the city with most malls in the world.

However, the government of the Special Area Jakarta should have a clear long-term plan regarding urban planning and a vision of Jakarta as a center of international trade and services, as regulated in the RTRW 2030.

Yayat said that the government of Jakarta should have in-depth studies and calculations on the number of shopping centers needed in Jakarta to achieve the RTRW 2030 vision.  "I'm sure they [ed. studies and calculations]do not exist yet," he said.

In contrast, the General Chairman of the Central Executive Council of the Indonesian Shopping Center Management Association, Alexander Stefanus Ridwan, said that the moratorium would likely reduce the competitiveness of Jakarta.  "Especially if it lasts for three to five years," he said.

According to Stefanus, this happenedduring a moratoriumperiod in Singapore.  When the Singaporean Government implemented a moratorium on the construction of shopping centerstourism decreased.Most tourists visited Malaysia, which was trying to boost the construction of malls at the time, insteadof going to Singapore.

"In Jakarta, the moratorium will be fine if it is only implemented until the end of 2012, but it may be dangerousif it is longer," he said hyperbolically.

In addition, Stephen worried that  Jakarta will losesits competitiveness with neighboring regions if the moratorium onshoppingcenters construction is longer. Currently, several areas around Jakarta areactively building shopping centers, such as the new province of South Tangerang. “Besides this, Jakarta is more competitive” he said.

(M Vareno Tarnes / Adi Condro Bawono)

 

Construction of shopping centers (malls) in the Jakarta area must be stopped to reduceincreasing numbers of immigrants. Max Pohan,the Regional Development Deputy of the Local Autonomy of the National Development Planning Agency,spoke against new malls, after a gathering (halal bi halal) at Bappenas’ office on Tuesday (6 /9).

According to Max, the construction of new malls attracts residents fromother regions, especially rural areas, to visit Jakarta.  They see Jakarta as a city of dreams and a place to improve their life.

Max hopes the DKI Jakarta Regional Government will suspend mall developmenttemporarily.  Max hopes development will be suspended for "about three to five years, also to improve the existing infrastructure.  The appeal of Jakarta hasto be stopped temporarily, "he said.

It all depends on the DKI Jakarta Regional Government’spolitical will in harmony with the central government's plan. The DKI Jakarta Regional Government needs to encourage private investors to improve infrastructure in other areas outside Jakarta, in order to create an attractive atmosphere for investors in other areas.  The DKI Jakarta Regional Government isimportant becauseit has the authority to grant permission for the construction of malls.

Moreover, improving infrastructure in other areasis also in accordance with the spirit of Law No.17 of 2007 on the Long Term National Development Plan (RPJPN).  “The law outlined that there must be regional development and acceleration outside Java, “said Max.

Meanwhile, other areas also need to be encouraged and assisted to improve infrastructure, so industries can develop and reach their full potential.

Infrastructure can be "adjusted to local resources, which could be agriculture, plantation, cement, or other.  But the infrastructure must be improved,so that people seeking a better life do not have to come to Jakarta,“he explained.

Jakarta recently issued a spatial plan layout area (Rencana Tata Ruang Tata Wilayah/RTRW) 2010-2030. In late August of 2011, after two years of discussion, the Special Jakarta Area Council Representatives (DPRD) finally promulgateddraft legislation for the2011-2030 spatial plan layout area (RTRW).

As widely reported, Governor Fauzi Bowo has affirmed the Jakarta Government’s commitment to implement a mall moratorium until 2012, as it has been done previously.

The spatial regulation mentions the importance of controlling and even limiting the construction of shopping centers, such as shops along the road, except in areas of high economy intensity or multistory buildings.

Urban planning experts from Trisakti University, Yayat Supriatna, said that the restriction to construct malls is necessary.  Currently Jakarta has so many malls.  According to DKI government data, there are about 68 malls in Jakarta.  That means there are more than 13 shopping centers in every municipality.  In fact, Yayat said the actual number is more than a hundred.  These numbers already exceed the ideal limit and also make Jakarta the city with most malls in the world.

However, the government of the Special Area Jakarta should have a clear long-term plan regarding urban planning and a vision of Jakarta as a center of international trade and services, as regulated in the RTRW 2030.

Yayat said that the government of Jakarta should have in-depth studies and calculations on the number of shopping centers needed in Jakarta to achieve the RTRW 2030 vision.  "I'm sure they [ed. studies and calculations]do not exist yet," he said.

In contrast, the General Chairman of the Central Executive Council of the Indonesian Shopping Center Management Association, Alexander Stefanus Ridwan, said that the moratorium would likely reduce the competitiveness of Jakarta.  "Especially if it lasts for three to five years," he said.

According to Stefanus, this happenedduring a moratoriumperiod in Singapore.  When the Singaporean Government implemented a moratorium on the construction of shopping centerstourism decreased.Most tourists visited Malaysia, which was trying to boost the construction of malls at the time, insteadof going to Singapore.

"In Jakarta, the moratorium will be fine if it is only implemented until the end of 2012, but it may be dangerousif it is longer," he said hyperbolically.

In addition, Stephen worried that  Jakarta will losesits competitiveness with neighboring regions if the moratorium onshoppingcenters construction is longer. Currently, several areas around Jakarta areactively building shopping centers, such as the new province of South Tangerang. “Besides this, Jakarta is more competitive” he said.

(M Vareno Tarnes / Adi Condro Bawono)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info