The Cigarette DefenseTeam (Tim Pembela Kretek), which represents three clients:Enryo Oktavian, Abhisam Demosa Makahekum, and Irwan Sofyan submitted a judicial review on the Elucidation of Article 115 (1) of Law No. 36 of 2009 on Health.
"We will review the Elucidation of Article 115 that stipulates no-smoking areas," said Daru Supriyono, one of the membersof the Cigarette DefenseTeam, at the Constitutional Court office, in Jakarta, Tuesday (16/8).
According to Article 115 of the Health Law several areas are designated as no smoking areas. The no smoking areas are health service facilities, educational institutions, children’s playgrounds, religious places, public transportation, work places, and other public places. The areas will befurther regulated by regional government regulation.
Furthermore, the Elucidation states that every work place, public space, and other place may provide a smoking area.
Daru asserted that the Article actsas if there isa constitutional right for someone to smoke. He said that the Elucidation is not an obligation, since it only states "may" (dapat).
"The word 'may' is not a mandatory obligation. It will not provide legal certainty, and it definitely does not assure someone's right to smoke," he asserted.
Further, Daru emphasized that the Elucidation of Article 115 (1) of the Health Law contradicts Articles27 (1) and 28D (1) of the 1945 Constitution.
Articles27 and 28D more or lessdiscussthe principle of equality before the law.
Daru said that the applicants are active smokers, who cannot smoke in their office because there is no smoking room. "If the word 'may' is erased from the Elucidation, the government has to provide a smoking room in those places," he asserted.
However, Daru warned that smoking is hazardous to human health. That is why, it needs a specific provision, so that it will not disturb other's health. "Public health protection is more important. It needs special attention from the government," he said.
On the other hand, cigarettes are legal products that can be consumed publicly. "If smoking activity is limited for health reasons, what about smoker's rights? Can health protection violate someone's right to smoke?" Daru said.
(Agus Sahbani / Pirhot Nababan)
The Cigarette DefenseTeam (Tim Pembela Kretek), which represents three clients:Enryo Oktavian, Abhisam Demosa Makahekum, and Irwan Sofyan submitted a judicial review on the Elucidation of Article 115 (1) of Law No. 36 of 2009 on Health.
"We will review the Elucidation of Article 115 that stipulates no-smoking areas," said Daru Supriyono, one of the membersof the Cigarette DefenseTeam, at the Constitutional Court office, in Jakarta, Tuesday (16/8).
According to Article 115 of the Health Law several areas are designated as no smoking areas. The no smoking areas are health service facilities, educational institutions, children’s playgrounds, religious places, public transportation, work places, and other public places. The areas will befurther regulated by regional government regulation.
Furthermore, the Elucidation states that every work place, public space, and other place may provide a smoking area.
Daru asserted that the Article actsas if there isa constitutional right for someone to smoke. He said that the Elucidation is not an obligation, since it only states "may" (dapat).
"The word 'may' is not a mandatory obligation. It will not provide legal certainty, and it definitely does not assure someone's right to smoke," he asserted.
Further, Daru emphasized that the Elucidation of Article 115 (1) of the Health Law contradicts Articles27 (1) and 28D (1) of the 1945 Constitution.
Articles27 and 28D more or lessdiscussthe principle of equality before the law.
Daru said that the applicants are active smokers, who cannot smoke in their office because there is no smoking room. "If the word 'may' is erased from the Elucidation, the government has to provide a smoking room in those places," he asserted.
However, Daru warned that smoking is hazardous to human health. That is why, it needs a specific provision, so that it will not disturb other's health. "Public health protection is more important. It needs special attention from the government," he said.
On the other hand, cigarettes are legal products that can be consumed publicly. "If smoking activity is limited for health reasons, what about smoker's rights? Can health protection violate someone's right to smoke?" Daru said.
(Agus Sahbani / Pirhot Nababan)