Tax Judges Should Understand Transfer Pricing Issue

 

The Ministry of Finance will add more tax judges in 2011. The ministry requested anyone who has taxation or customs experience, to apply for a tax judge position.

Jeffry Wagiu, Head of the Tax Court Information Services Sub-division, said that the deadline for the application will be on 12 August 2011. He also explained that there is no quota for the position. Currently, there are 41 tax judges in 17 councils.

"Candidates who can meet the qualifications, will continue to the selection process," he said on Friday (5/8).

Jeffry explained that there are five selection phases that have to be followed by the candidates: the taxation knowledge test, profile assessment, essay writing, interview, and health check.

However, Mulia Panusunan Nasution, Secretary General of the Ministry of Finance said that there will be 11 additional judges.

SPECIALITY

Darussalam, a taxation expert, said that every tax judge must have a specific skill. "so that in the near future, they can be more focused," he said to hukumonline.

He viewed that the tax cases will be more varied and difficult. "Tax cases are specific. They could cover value added tax, income tax, international tax, etc. Each case has its own specification," he emphasized.

Darussalam asserted that it would be impossible for a tax judges to comprehend all the tax problem. "Tax cases are sophisticated. I don't believe that tax judges could understand every aspects of the case," he asserted.

Therefore, he said, it is really important to divide judges based on the cases. This means that the tax court will have specialized judges that only handles income tax case, value added tax case, and many more. The recruitment should take a good look at this issue. "It is a common practice, particularly in Europe," he explained.

He also underlined that the recruitment should prioritize judges who have a good comprehension of the transfer pricing issue, which is a way to gain a profit within a group of a multinational company.

Transfer pricing, originally, was aimed at evaluating and assessing a company's performance. However, it has been used to maximize a company's profit and minimize taxes.

This would lead to state losses from taxation, while the business is trying to reduce the taxes owed.

Darussalam believed that transfer pricing cases will increase in the near future, since the Directorate General of Tax is currently conducting a serious investigation regarding the issue.

"If the Directorate uncovers a dispute, it will end in the tax court. That's why the judges need a good comprehension of the transfer pricing issue," he asserted.

(M. Vareno Tarnes / Pirhot Nababan)

 

The Ministry of Finance will add more tax judges in 2011. The ministry requested anyone who has taxation or customs experience, to apply for a tax judge position.

Jeffry Wagiu, Head of the Tax Court Information Services Sub-division, said that the deadline for the application will be on 12 August 2011. He also explained that there is no quota for the position. Currently, there are 41 tax judges in 17 councils.

"Candidates who can meet the qualifications, will continue to the selection process," he said on Friday (5/8).

Jeffry explained that there are five selection phases that have to be followed by the candidates: the taxation knowledge test, profile assessment, essay writing, interview, and health check.

However, Mulia Panusunan Nasution, Secretary General of the Ministry of Finance said that there will be 11 additional judges.

SPECIALITY

Darussalam, a taxation expert, said that every tax judge must have a specific skill. "so that in the near future, they can be more focused," he said to hukumonline.

He viewed that the tax cases will be more varied and difficult. "Tax cases are specific. They could cover value added tax, income tax, international tax, etc. Each case has its own specification," he emphasized.

Darussalam asserted that it would be impossible for a tax judges to comprehend all the tax problem. "Tax cases are sophisticated. I don't believe that tax judges could understand every aspects of the case," he asserted.

Therefore, he said, it is really important to divide judges based on the cases. This means that the tax court will have specialized judges that only handles income tax case, value added tax case, and many more. The recruitment should take a good look at this issue. "It is a common practice, particularly in Europe," he explained.

He also underlined that the recruitment should prioritize judges who have a good comprehension of the transfer pricing issue, which is a way to gain a profit within a group of a multinational company.

Transfer pricing, originally, was aimed at evaluating and assessing a company's performance. However, it has been used to maximize a company's profit and minimize taxes.

This would lead to state losses from taxation, while the business is trying to reduce the taxes owed.

Darussalam believed that transfer pricing cases will increase in the near future, since the Directorate General of Tax is currently conducting a serious investigation regarding the issue.

"If the Directorate uncovers a dispute, it will end in the tax court. That's why the judges need a good comprehension of the transfer pricing issue," he asserted.

(M. Vareno Tarnes / Pirhot Nababan)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info