Fajrul Falaakh, a law expert, said that the substance of ASEAN Charter Ratification, which is documented under Law No. 38 of 2008, is not a formal legal document (wet in formele zijn). Therefore, he explained that the law cannot be reviewed by the Constitutional Court.
"Presidential regulations and decrees that ratify international conventions, can't be reviewed bythe Supreme Court either," he said ata trial on ASEAN Charter Ratification, at the Constitutional Court, Jakarta, Wednesday (3/8).
Fajrul asserted that Indonesia's procedure regarding international convention ratification is regulated by Law No. 24 of 2000 on International Conventions. "If the Constitutional Court and Supreme Court are authorized to review ratifications, many conventions could be annulled by the court," he said.
He also highlighted the treatment of a House of Representatives' (DPR) approval of an international convention ratification. "This is not the same as the laws that are approved by the DPR and President, which are regulated by Article 20 (2) of the 1945 Constitution," he emphasized.
Furthermore, Fajrul explained that judicial review caused an error subjectum litis--a failure from the subject that filed the judicial review. The applicants, Fajrul said, treated the ASEAN Charter the same way, formally and substantially, as laws that have been reviewed bythe Constitutional Court.
The 1945 Constitution does not authorize the Constitutional Court to be a forum to review international conventions. This is because the Constitutional Court's authority under Article 24C (1) of the 1945 Constitution is not mutatis mutandis with Article 11.
He also added that ratification by a local legal system--laws or a lower level of regulation--are called an international act under the 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties.
The judicial review of the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law was filed by the Alliance for Global Justice, which consists of the Institute for Global Justice, People’s Farmers Union (Serikat Petani Rakyat), INFID Association, Indonesian Farmers Association (Aliansi Petani Indonesia), People’s Coalition for Fisheries Justice (Koalisi Rakyat Untuk Keadilan Perikanan), Migrant Care, Petition 28 Activists, Small Business Women’s Defense Association (Asosiasi Pembela Perempuan Usaha Kecil), and Anti-Debt Coalition (Koalisi Anti Utang).
The Alliance argued that Article 1 (5) of the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law, which regulates the single market principle, will harm national industry and trade. Indonesia has to comply with anything that is decided at the ASEAN level.
Therefore, the Alliance asked the Constitutional Court to annul Article 1 (5) and 2 (2) (n) of the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law, due to its contradiction with Article 27 (2) and 33 (4) of the 1945 Constitution.
(Agus Sahbani / Pirhot Nababan)
Fajrul Falaakh, a law expert, said that the substance of ASEAN Charter Ratification, which is documented under Law No. 38 of 2008, is not a formal legal document (wet in formele zijn). Therefore, he explained that the law cannot be reviewed by the Constitutional Court.
"Presidential regulations and decrees that ratify international conventions, can't be reviewed bythe Supreme Court either," he said ata trial on ASEAN Charter Ratification, at the Constitutional Court, Jakarta, Wednesday (3/8).
Fajrul asserted that Indonesia's procedure regarding international convention ratification is regulated by Law No. 24 of 2000 on International Conventions. "If the Constitutional Court and Supreme Court are authorized to review ratifications, many conventions could be annulled by the court," he said.
He also highlighted the treatment of a House of Representatives' (DPR) approval of an international convention ratification. "This is not the same as the laws that are approved by the DPR and President, which are regulated by Article 20 (2) of the 1945 Constitution," he emphasized.
Furthermore, Fajrul explained that judicial review caused an error subjectum litis--a failure from the subject that filed the judicial review. The applicants, Fajrul said, treated the ASEAN Charter the same way, formally and substantially, as laws that have been reviewed bythe Constitutional Court.
The 1945 Constitution does not authorize the Constitutional Court to be a forum to review international conventions. This is because the Constitutional Court's authority under Article 24C (1) of the 1945 Constitution is not mutatis mutandis with Article 11.
He also added that ratification by a local legal system--laws or a lower level of regulation--are called an international act under the 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties.
The judicial review of the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law was filed by the Alliance for Global Justice, which consists of the Institute for Global Justice, People’s Farmers Union (Serikat Petani Rakyat), INFID Association, Indonesian Farmers Association (Aliansi Petani Indonesia), People’s Coalition for Fisheries Justice (Koalisi Rakyat Untuk Keadilan Perikanan), Migrant Care, Petition 28 Activists, Small Business Women’s Defense Association (Asosiasi Pembela Perempuan Usaha Kecil), and Anti-Debt Coalition (Koalisi Anti Utang).
The Alliance argued that Article 1 (5) of the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law, which regulates the single market principle, will harm national industry and trade. Indonesia has to comply with anything that is decided at the ASEAN level.
Therefore, the Alliance asked the Constitutional Court to annul Article 1 (5) and 2 (2) (n) of the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law, due to its contradiction with Article 27 (2) and 33 (4) of the 1945 Constitution.
(Agus Sahbani / Pirhot Nababan)