The dispute regarding airtime—the call time between the initial connection andend of the connection—between the Indonesian Telephone Booth Business Association (Asosiasi Pengusaha Wartel Indonesia - APWI), PT Telekomunikasi and cellular operators has resurface. Previously, a similar dispute occurred in 2005 and it was resolved through an agreement. The current dispute, however, is being processed in court.
In the lawsuit filed by APWI, PT Telekomunikasi Tbk ("Telkom") and PT Indonesia Tbk ("Indosat") are Defendant I and II, respectively. The lawsuit (case No.156/PDT.G/2011/PN.JKT.PST) is registered in the Central Jakarta District Court.
APWI also named the Indonesian Telecommunication Regulatory Agency (Badan Regulasi Telekomunikasi Indonesia - BRTI) and the Minister of Communication and Information Technology as co-defendants I and II, respectively.
Kristian Masiku, APWI's legal counsel said that the lawsuit was filed due to Telkom's failure to pay airtime costs between April 2005 to December 2006. APWI argues that Telkom should pay the costs, which amounted to IDR 54,56 billion.
"Our client (ed. APWI) has legal standing as a phone booth operator (warung telepon - wartel) to receive airtime payments. The defendants, however, refused to pay their obligations," Kristian said.
On the other hand, Eri Hertiawan, Telkom's legal counsel, said in Jakarta, Tuesday (2/8), that the lawsuit should be filed inthe Administrative Court (Pengadilan Tata Usaha Negara - PTUN). Telkom refused to pay the costs, because it is still waiting for BRTI's decision regarding airtime. Pursuant to the agreement signed on22 June 2010, Telkom, other operators, and PWI agreed to wait for BRTI's ruling on this dispute. However, BRTI has not issued a decree on airtime payment methods, yet.
"Based on the 22 June 2010 agreement, we are not going to pay airtime costs, since we have to wait for BRTI's ruling. BRTI, however, has not issued any decision. Therefore, our position is that BRTI has refused to make a ruling," said Ari Juliano Gema, a member of the defendant’s legal team.
Juliano asserted that BRTI's position could be considered a fictitious negative decision. "And if some party wants to sue BRTI, they have to filed it in PTUN," he emphasized.
Article 3 of Law No. 5 of 1986 on the State Administrative Court states that if a public agency or public official fails to issue a decision that it is responsible for, it will be categorized as a state administrative decision. This is the reason why the defendant’s legal counsel said that the lawsuit should be filed in the PTUN.
Moreover, Kristian asserted that his client is standing firmon the substance of the lawsuit and is confident that the Central Jakarta District Court has jurisdiction over the case.
(Latifah Kusumawardhani / Pirhot Nababan)
The dispute regarding airtime—the call time between the initial connection andend of the connection—between the Indonesian Telephone Booth Business Association (Asosiasi Pengusaha Wartel Indonesia - APWI), PT Telekomunikasi and cellular operators has resurface. Previously, a similar dispute occurred in 2005 and it was resolved through an agreement. The current dispute, however, is being processed in court.
In the lawsuit filed by APWI, PT Telekomunikasi Tbk ("Telkom") and PT Indonesia Tbk ("Indosat") are Defendant I and II, respectively. The lawsuit (case No.156/PDT.G/2011/PN.JKT.PST) is registered in the Central Jakarta District Court.
APWI also named the Indonesian Telecommunication Regulatory Agency (Badan Regulasi Telekomunikasi Indonesia - BRTI) and the Minister of Communication and Information Technology as co-defendants I and II, respectively.
Kristian Masiku, APWI's legal counsel said that the lawsuit was filed due to Telkom's failure to pay airtime costs between April 2005 to December 2006. APWI argues that Telkom should pay the costs, which amounted to IDR 54,56 billion.
"Our client (ed. APWI) has legal standing as a phone booth operator (warung telepon - wartel) to receive airtime payments. The defendants, however, refused to pay their obligations," Kristian said.
On the other hand, Eri Hertiawan, Telkom's legal counsel, said in Jakarta, Tuesday (2/8), that the lawsuit should be filed inthe Administrative Court (Pengadilan Tata Usaha Negara - PTUN). Telkom refused to pay the costs, because it is still waiting for BRTI's decision regarding airtime. Pursuant to the agreement signed on22 June 2010, Telkom, other operators, and PWI agreed to wait for BRTI's ruling on this dispute. However, BRTI has not issued a decree on airtime payment methods, yet.
"Based on the 22 June 2010 agreement, we are not going to pay airtime costs, since we have to wait for BRTI's ruling. BRTI, however, has not issued any decision. Therefore, our position is that BRTI has refused to make a ruling," said Ari Juliano Gema, a member of the defendant’s legal team.
Juliano asserted that BRTI's position could be considered a fictitious negative decision. "And if some party wants to sue BRTI, they have to filed it in PTUN," he emphasized.
Article 3 of Law No. 5 of 1986 on the State Administrative Court states that if a public agency or public official fails to issue a decision that it is responsible for, it will be categorized as a state administrative decision. This is the reason why the defendant’s legal counsel said that the lawsuit should be filed in the PTUN.
Moreover, Kristian asserted that his client is standing firmon the substance of the lawsuit and is confident that the Central Jakarta District Court has jurisdiction over the case.
(Latifah Kusumawardhani / Pirhot Nababan)