Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, Malaysian opposition leader, said that Malaysia should abolish corporal punishment for Indonesian workers (tenaga kerja Indonesia - TKI) in Malaysia. His point of view is that there is no practical reason to continue this type of punishment.
"I have always asserted that TKI are not slaves. They are workers. That's why we need to handle their problems humanely," he said at a Public Forumhosted by hukumonline, the Center for Indonesian Law & Policy Studies (PSHK), and the Indonesia Jentera School of Law, in Jakarta, Saturday (30/7).
He also asserted that TKI come from low economic classes. "Don't mess with them," he asserted.
Anwar explained that Indonesian and Malaysian authorities should improve their cooperation, particularly regarding supervision of work agencies. "They (ed. work agencies) should know that they are entitled to do business and make profits. But don't punish the poor workers. Don't take any profits from them," he asserted.
Malaysia, said Anwar, has to imagine what it would be like if their migrant workers were treated the same way. However, he denied the accusation that his stanceis only to gain support as an opposition politician. "Don't make hardship a way to gain support," he asserted.
Anwar explained that he understands migrant workers' situation in Malaysia,since he has met workers who were in hospitals after being imprisoned. In one hospital, Indonesian workers met him to complain about unfortunate incidents. Mostly, they complained about unfairness, torture, and that they were about to be punished.
"I saw with my own eyes, that they were tortured. That was the reason I sent a letter to Ahmad Badawi, the Prime Minister. I wrote about the importance of taking care of migrant workers," he emphasized.
The elimination of corporal punishment is also supported by Anis Hidayah, Executive Director at Migrant Care. Corporal punishment, Anis said, should have been abolished a long time ago by the Malaysian and Indonesian governments.
"We already told this to the Malaysian government. They still allow corporal punishment for Indonesian workers," he said via telephone.
According to Migrant Care, there have been 300 corporal punishment and death penalty cases involving Indonesian workers in Malaysia since 1997. This fact shows that the government has to do more in order to protect Indonesian workers in foreign countries.
"The government, at least, should ask for a moratorium on corporal punishment. It's indeed better if Malaysia could erase it," he said.
Dita Indah Sari, special staff for the Minister of Manpower and Transmigration, said that the government is always trying to ask for commutation from Malaysia. However, Dita asserted, the government cannot push the Malaysian government to change the punishment in its local legal system.
"The type of punishment is different in each country. What we can do is to advocate for Indonesian workers in foreign countries. We try to make the punishment as low as possible, however, we can't change the form of the punishment," she explained.
(M. Vareno Tarnes / Pirhot Nababan)
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, Malaysian opposition leader, said that Malaysia should abolish corporal punishment for Indonesian workers (tenaga kerja Indonesia - TKI) in Malaysia. His point of view is that there is no practical reason to continue this type of punishment.
"I have always asserted that TKI are not slaves. They are workers. That's why we need to handle their problems humanely," he said at a Public Forumhosted by hukumonline, the Center for Indonesian Law & Policy Studies (PSHK), and the Indonesia Jentera School of Law, in Jakarta, Saturday (30/7).
He also asserted that TKI come from low economic classes. "Don't mess with them," he asserted.
Anwar explained that Indonesian and Malaysian authorities should improve their cooperation, particularly regarding supervision of work agencies. "They (ed. work agencies) should know that they are entitled to do business and make profits. But don't punish the poor workers. Don't take any profits from them," he asserted.
Malaysia, said Anwar, has to imagine what it would be like if their migrant workers were treated the same way. However, he denied the accusation that his stanceis only to gain support as an opposition politician. "Don't make hardship a way to gain support," he asserted.
Anwar explained that he understands migrant workers' situation in Malaysia,since he has met workers who were in hospitals after being imprisoned. In one hospital, Indonesian workers met him to complain about unfortunate incidents. Mostly, they complained about unfairness, torture, and that they were about to be punished.
"I saw with my own eyes, that they were tortured. That was the reason I sent a letter to Ahmad Badawi, the Prime Minister. I wrote about the importance of taking care of migrant workers," he emphasized.
The elimination of corporal punishment is also supported by Anis Hidayah, Executive Director at Migrant Care. Corporal punishment, Anis said, should have been abolished a long time ago by the Malaysian and Indonesian governments.
"We already told this to the Malaysian government. They still allow corporal punishment for Indonesian workers," he said via telephone.
According to Migrant Care, there have been 300 corporal punishment and death penalty cases involving Indonesian workers in Malaysia since 1997. This fact shows that the government has to do more in order to protect Indonesian workers in foreign countries.
"The government, at least, should ask for a moratorium on corporal punishment. It's indeed better if Malaysia could erase it," he said.
Dita Indah Sari, special staff for the Minister of Manpower and Transmigration, said that the government is always trying to ask for commutation from Malaysia. However, Dita asserted, the government cannot push the Malaysian government to change the punishment in its local legal system.
"The type of punishment is different in each country. What we can do is to advocate for Indonesian workers in foreign countries. We try to make the punishment as low as possible, however, we can't change the form of the punishment," she explained.
(M. Vareno Tarnes / Pirhot Nababan)