The government wants to renegotiate mining contracts immediately, since many of them are about to expire soon. The Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) has confirmed the renegotiations of 118 mining contracts due to the potential for state losses. The renegotiations will emphasize land and royalty issues.
"We have to renegotiate the contracts to fix royalty payments. The contracts are about to end, and there is an opportunity for extensions," said Hatta Rajasa, Coordinating Minister for Economic Affairs, in Jakarta, Tuesday (26/7).
Further, Hatta asserted, there will be no problems with there negotiations as long as the government still complies with the contracts. "I'm sure that the companies are willing to renegotiate," he asserted.
Work contracts under Law No. 4 of 2009 on Mining and Coal, have been heavily criticized. Many argue that the Mining Law gives too many privileges to mining investors, and needs to be amended.
"The work contracts neglect public interests, and give too many privileges to investors instead," said Pramono Anung, Deputy Speaker of the House of Representative, last week.
Pramono further criticized unfair royalty sharing in the mining industry. He questioned government royalties, which should be used to develop communities in mining areas.
"There is no other way but to renegotiate the existing work contracts," he asserted.
Mining royalties are currently regulated under Government Regulation No. 45 of 2003 on Non-Tax State Income within the Ministry of ESDM (PP 45/2003). Under this regulation, the royalty for gold is set at 3,75 percent of the selling price times the tonnage. In practice, however, some exceptions occur, such as an exception for PT Freeport Indonesia (Affiliate of Freeport McMoRan Copper & Gold). Freeport's royalty is set at 1 percent of the selling price times the tonnage.
In comparison, African countries such as South Africa, Namibia, Tanzania, require significantly higher royalties. These countries set royalties at 3-8 percent of a mining company’s gross income.
The renegotiation with Freeport, however, has not happened yet. "We are still processing it, and there is no progress, yet," Pramono said.
Marwan Batubara, Executive Director at the IRESS (Indonesian Resources Studies), said that the main goal of the work contract renegotiations is to protect state and public interests. Many countries in other regions are doing the same thing. He emphasized that mining companies have always denied renegotiations based on the duration of work contracts.
Marwan also criticized Article 169 of the Mining Law. Under Article 169 (a), work contracts that were made before the current Mining Law are still applicable until they expire. However, Article 169 (b) states that existing work contracts have to comply with the Mining Law's provisions, excluding state income-related issues.
"The existing contractsare still applicable, but they must comply with the Mining Law for the duration of the contract period. It's ambiguous," he said.
Still related to renegotiation, Marwan further asserted the importance of putting a government representative on the boards of directors of foreign mining companies. "So that Indonesia will not always experience great losses," he said.
(M. Vareno Tarnes / Pirhot Nababan)
The government wants to renegotiate mining contracts immediately, since many of them are about to expire soon. The Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) has confirmed the renegotiations of 118 mining contracts due to the potential for state losses. The renegotiations will emphasize land and royalty issues.
"We have to renegotiate the contracts to fix royalty payments. The contracts are about to end, and there is an opportunity for extensions," said Hatta Rajasa, Coordinating Minister for Economic Affairs, in Jakarta, Tuesday (26/7).
Further, Hatta asserted, there will be no problems with there negotiations as long as the government still complies with the contracts. "I'm sure that the companies are willing to renegotiate," he asserted.
Work contracts under Law No. 4 of 2009 on Mining and Coal, have been heavily criticized. Many argue that the Mining Law gives too many privileges to mining investors, and needs to be amended.
"The work contracts neglect public interests, and give too many privileges to investors instead," said Pramono Anung, Deputy Speaker of the House of Representative, last week.
Pramono further criticized unfair royalty sharing in the mining industry. He questioned government royalties, which should be used to develop communities in mining areas.
"There is no other way but to renegotiate the existing work contracts," he asserted.
Mining royalties are currently regulated under Government Regulation No. 45 of 2003 on Non-Tax State Income within the Ministry of ESDM (PP 45/2003). Under this regulation, the royalty for gold is set at 3,75 percent of the selling price times the tonnage. In practice, however, some exceptions occur, such as an exception for PT Freeport Indonesia (Affiliate of Freeport McMoRan Copper & Gold). Freeport's royalty is set at 1 percent of the selling price times the tonnage.
In comparison, African countries such as South Africa, Namibia, Tanzania, require significantly higher royalties. These countries set royalties at 3-8 percent of a mining company’s gross income.
The renegotiation with Freeport, however, has not happened yet. "We are still processing it, and there is no progress, yet," Pramono said.
Marwan Batubara, Executive Director at the IRESS (Indonesian Resources Studies), said that the main goal of the work contract renegotiations is to protect state and public interests. Many countries in other regions are doing the same thing. He emphasized that mining companies have always denied renegotiations based on the duration of work contracts.
Marwan also criticized Article 169 of the Mining Law. Under Article 169 (a), work contracts that were made before the current Mining Law are still applicable until they expire. However, Article 169 (b) states that existing work contracts have to comply with the Mining Law's provisions, excluding state income-related issues.
"The existing contractsare still applicable, but they must comply with the Mining Law for the duration of the contract period. It's ambiguous," he said.
Still related to renegotiation, Marwan further asserted the importance of putting a government representative on the boards of directors of foreign mining companies. "So that Indonesia will not always experience great losses," he said.
(M. Vareno Tarnes / Pirhot Nababan)