The ASEAN Charter's applicability to Indonesia is not merely based on Law No. 38 of 2008 on the ASEAN Charter Ratification. The ASEAN Charter is a legally binding convention for Indonesia since Indonesia has already submitted a ratification document to the ASEAN Secretariat, in accordance with Article 14 of Law No. 24 of 2000 on International Treaties.
"Therefore, the applicability of the ASEAN Charter to Indonesia and the rest of ASEAN's members is based on articles in the ASEAN Charter. It is not based on ratification under one national law," said Linggawaty Hakim, Director General of Law and International Treaties at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, at a judicial review trial regarding Article 1 (5) and 2 (2) (n) of the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law, in Jakarta, Wednesday (20/7).
The petition for judicial review was filed by a civil society organization called Alliance for Global Justice, which consists ofthe Institute for Global Justice, People's Farmer United, INFID Association, Indonesian Farmers Alliance, FNPBI, People’s Coalition for Fisheries Justice, Migrant Care, Petisi 28 activists, Small Enterprise Women Defenders Association, Anti-Debt Coalition, Salamuddin, Dani Setiawan, and Haris Rusli.
Under Article 1 (5), the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law stipulates the single market principle with a basis of single production. This means that trade agreement implementation within the ASEAN countries should be similar to one another. This article became the ASEAN's legal basis for making free trade agreements (FTAs) with many parties outside ASEAN, such as the ASEAN-China FTA; ASEAN-Korea FTA; and ASEAN-Australia and New Zealand FTA.
The Alliance for Global Justice argues that ASEAN Charter implementation regarding free trade has harmed national industries and trade, since Indonesia has to comply with ASEAN's decisions. Therefore, the Alliance requested that the Constitutional Court revoke Articles 1 (5) and 2 (2) (n), since they contradict Articles 27 (2) and 33 (4) of the 1945 Constitution.
However, Linggawaty underlined that the ASEAN Charter Ratification law only functions as an approval from the executive and legislature that binds Indonesia is to the ASEAN Charter. "The substance itself does not change the form of the ASEAN Charter as an international law," Linggawaty said.
Linggawaty also denied that the FTAs were based on the ASEAN Charter, since those documents were made based on a specific international treaty, before the ASEAN Charter entered into force.
If the Constitutional Court annulls the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law, the FTAs will remain legally binding documents. Article 27 of the 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties also asserted that, "A party may not invoke the provisions of its internal law as a justification for its failure to perform a treaty".
"If the Constitutional Court revokes it, Indonesia will face a difficult situation," she asserted.
Linggawaty further asserted that the single market under ASEAN Charter was meant to implement Article 27 (2) of the 1945 Constitution, in order to improve trade, investment, business, professionals, and workers. "It is also aimed at eradicatingpoverty and the development gap. Therefore Article 1 (5) of the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law does not contradict the Constitution," she added.
Meanwhile, economist Sri Edi Swarsono explained that under free trade, the market will control the economy. Therefore, he said, the government is supposed to control the national market and protect its citizens in the economic field.
"A market-controlled economy has caused an economic downturn for this nation. The market has pushed aside the public's sovereignty," Edi emphasized.
Edi also asserted that under Article 33 of the Constitution, the government should prioritize the public, not the market. He further criticized several international treaties that have been carelessly ratified into national laws.
"Any policy should comply with the 1945 Constitution," he asserted.
(Agus Sahbani / Pirhot Nababan)
The ASEAN Charter's applicability to Indonesia is not merely based on Law No. 38 of 2008 on the ASEAN Charter Ratification. The ASEAN Charter is a legally binding convention for Indonesia since Indonesia has already submitted a ratification document to the ASEAN Secretariat, in accordance with Article 14 of Law No. 24 of 2000 on International Treaties.
"Therefore, the applicability of the ASEAN Charter to Indonesia and the rest of ASEAN's members is based on articles in the ASEAN Charter. It is not based on ratification under one national law," said Linggawaty Hakim, Director General of Law and International Treaties at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, at a judicial review trial regarding Article 1 (5) and 2 (2) (n) of the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law, in Jakarta, Wednesday (20/7).
The petition for judicial review was filed by a civil society organization called Alliance for Global Justice, which consists ofthe Institute for Global Justice, People's Farmer United, INFID Association, Indonesian Farmers Alliance, FNPBI, People’s Coalition for Fisheries Justice, Migrant Care, Petisi 28 activists, Small Enterprise Women Defenders Association, Anti-Debt Coalition, Salamuddin, Dani Setiawan, and Haris Rusli.
Under Article 1 (5), the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law stipulates the single market principle with a basis of single production. This means that trade agreement implementation within the ASEAN countries should be similar to one another. This article became the ASEAN's legal basis for making free trade agreements (FTAs) with many parties outside ASEAN, such as the ASEAN-China FTA; ASEAN-Korea FTA; and ASEAN-Australia and New Zealand FTA.
The Alliance for Global Justice argues that ASEAN Charter implementation regarding free trade has harmed national industries and trade, since Indonesia has to comply with ASEAN's decisions. Therefore, the Alliance requested that the Constitutional Court revoke Articles 1 (5) and 2 (2) (n), since they contradict Articles 27 (2) and 33 (4) of the 1945 Constitution.
However, Linggawaty underlined that the ASEAN Charter Ratification law only functions as an approval from the executive and legislature that binds Indonesia is to the ASEAN Charter. "The substance itself does not change the form of the ASEAN Charter as an international law," Linggawaty said.
Linggawaty also denied that the FTAs were based on the ASEAN Charter, since those documents were made based on a specific international treaty, before the ASEAN Charter entered into force.
If the Constitutional Court annulls the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law, the FTAs will remain legally binding documents. Article 27 of the 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties also asserted that, "A party may not invoke the provisions of its internal law as a justification for its failure to perform a treaty".
"If the Constitutional Court revokes it, Indonesia will face a difficult situation," she asserted.
Linggawaty further asserted that the single market under ASEAN Charter was meant to implement Article 27 (2) of the 1945 Constitution, in order to improve trade, investment, business, professionals, and workers. "It is also aimed at eradicatingpoverty and the development gap. Therefore Article 1 (5) of the ASEAN Charter Ratification Law does not contradict the Constitution," she added.
Meanwhile, economist Sri Edi Swarsono explained that under free trade, the market will control the economy. Therefore, he said, the government is supposed to control the national market and protect its citizens in the economic field.
"A market-controlled economy has caused an economic downturn for this nation. The market has pushed aside the public's sovereignty," Edi emphasized.
Edi also asserted that under Article 33 of the Constitution, the government should prioritize the public, not the market. He further criticized several international treaties that have been carelessly ratified into national laws.
"Any policy should comply with the 1945 Constitution," he asserted.
(Agus Sahbani / Pirhot Nababan)