The Upstream Oil and Gas Activity Agency (Badan Pelaksana Kegiatan Usaha Hulu Minyak dan Gas Bumi/BP Migas) denied that there are 14 contractors with partnership contracts (Kontraktor Kontrak Kerja Sama/KKKS) that have unsettled debts as revealed by the Financial and Development Supervisory Agency (Badan Pengawasan Keuangan dan Pembangunan/BPKP) report.
According to R Priyono, Head of BP Migas, only three KKKSs have a tax problem. Those companies are still on trial and no verdicts have been made regarding tax treaty disputes and royalties, which amounted to IDR 1,6 trillion between 1991-2008.
At the hearing between Commission XI of the House of Representatives (DPR) and BP Migas, Priyono said that his institution will not reveal the companies that are on trial. "We cannot announce this, yet. The three companies will pay if they are told to do so. They are waiting for a tax letter (surat ketetapan pajak)," he explained.
Priyono emphasized that KKKS have made a large contribution to Indonesia. Between 2005 and 2010, KKKS contributed IDR 35-77 trillion of profit.
"However, the tax problem has to be solved by a taxation mechanism, in accordance with the prevailing laws and regulations," he said.
A tax treaty is an agreement between two countries to avoid double taxation. Priyono explained that many KKKS in Indonesia used the British legal system to implement a tax treaty. However, this does not mean that the three KKKS on trial are using British Law.
Fuad Rahmany, Director General of Tax, said that tax disputes often occur over tax treaties between Indonesia and the oil and gas company’s home country. In this case, the three companies did not pay taxes as agreed upon in the relevant agreement.
According to Fuad, foreign oil and gas companies have to pay a larger amount of non-tax state income (pendapatan negara bukan pajak/PNBP) after they receive an oil and gas income taxbreak. Therefore, based on the amount of the equity to be split, the state's income is still set at 85 percent, and the contractor's income is set at 15 percent.
Apparently, Fuad said, the contractors are reluctant to pay a larger PNBP, so the 85-15 profit sharing scheme is not being implemented properly.
Previously, BPKP conducted an audit of the oil and gas industry in Indonesia, which was later reviewed by the Supreme Audit Agency (Badan Pemeriksa Keuangan/BPK) on 24 May 2011. The BPK review revealed that many oil and gas companies have unsettled obligations.
BPKP has submitted its audit, up to the 2008 fiscal year, to the Directorate General of Tax. The audit revealed debts equal to USD 176,117 million. Meanwhile, BPKP has not yet submitted other debt findings that amount to USD 108,099 million. For the 2008 fiscal year, oil and gas companies' outstanding debt reached USD 284,216 million.
Moreover, during the following year, there was a tax underpayment that amounted to USD 139,459. This figure was larger for the 2010 financial year, amounting to USD 159,330 million.
The ten companies with the largest debts are: CNOOC (USD 94,239 million), Conocophillips Grissik (USD 84,774 million), Petro China International Indonesia Ltd Block Jabung (USD 62,949 million), Mobil Exploration Indonesia Inc – Blok Lepas Pantai Sumatera Utara (USD 59,998 million), VICO (USD 42,987 million), ExxonMobil Oil Indonesia Inc (USD 41,763 million), Premier Oil Area Natuna Sea ‘A’ (USD 38,368 million), BP West Java Ltd (USD 35,123 million), Star Energy (USD 17,095 million), and PT Pertamina EP (USD 16,921 million).
(M. Agus Yozami / Pirhot Nababan)
The Upstream Oil and Gas Activity Agency (Badan Pelaksana Kegiatan Usaha Hulu Minyak dan Gas Bumi/BP Migas) denied that there are 14 contractors with partnership contracts (Kontraktor Kontrak Kerja Sama/KKKS) that have unsettled debts as revealed by the Financial and Development Supervisory Agency (Badan Pengawasan Keuangan dan Pembangunan/BPKP) report.
According to R Priyono, Head of BP Migas, only three KKKSs have a tax problem. Those companies are still on trial and no verdicts have been made regarding tax treaty disputes and royalties, which amounted to IDR 1,6 trillion between 1991-2008.
At the hearing between Commission XI of the House of Representatives (DPR) and BP Migas, Priyono said that his institution will not reveal the companies that are on trial. "We cannot announce this, yet. The three companies will pay if they are told to do so. They are waiting for a tax letter (surat ketetapan pajak)," he explained.
Priyono emphasized that KKKS have made a large contribution to Indonesia. Between 2005 and 2010, KKKS contributed IDR 35-77 trillion of profit.
"However, the tax problem has to be solved by a taxation mechanism, in accordance with the prevailing laws and regulations," he said.
A tax treaty is an agreement between two countries to avoid double taxation. Priyono explained that many KKKS in Indonesia used the British legal system to implement a tax treaty. However, this does not mean that the three KKKS on trial are using British Law.
Fuad Rahmany, Director General of Tax, said that tax disputes often occur over tax treaties between Indonesia and the oil and gas company’s home country. In this case, the three companies did not pay taxes as agreed upon in the relevant agreement.
According to Fuad, foreign oil and gas companies have to pay a larger amount of non-tax state income (pendapatan negara bukan pajak/PNBP) after they receive an oil and gas income taxbreak. Therefore, based on the amount of the equity to be split, the state's income is still set at 85 percent, and the contractor's income is set at 15 percent.
Apparently, Fuad said, the contractors are reluctant to pay a larger PNBP, so the 85-15 profit sharing scheme is not being implemented properly.
Previously, BPKP conducted an audit of the oil and gas industry in Indonesia, which was later reviewed by the Supreme Audit Agency (Badan Pemeriksa Keuangan/BPK) on 24 May 2011. The BPK review revealed that many oil and gas companies have unsettled obligations.
BPKP has submitted its audit, up to the 2008 fiscal year, to the Directorate General of Tax. The audit revealed debts equal to USD 176,117 million. Meanwhile, BPKP has not yet submitted other debt findings that amount to USD 108,099 million. For the 2008 fiscal year, oil and gas companies' outstanding debt reached USD 284,216 million.
Moreover, during the following year, there was a tax underpayment that amounted to USD 139,459. This figure was larger for the 2010 financial year, amounting to USD 159,330 million.
The ten companies with the largest debts are: CNOOC (USD 94,239 million), Conocophillips Grissik (USD 84,774 million), Petro China International Indonesia Ltd Block Jabung (USD 62,949 million), Mobil Exploration Indonesia Inc – Blok Lepas Pantai Sumatera Utara (USD 59,998 million), VICO (USD 42,987 million), ExxonMobil Oil Indonesia Inc (USD 41,763 million), Premier Oil Area Natuna Sea ‘A’ (USD 38,368 million), BP West Java Ltd (USD 35,123 million), Star Energy (USD 17,095 million), and PT Pertamina EP (USD 16,921 million).
(M. Agus Yozami / Pirhot Nababan)