Law No. 7 of 2011 on Currency ("Currency Law") mandated the establishment of an agency to coordinate the eradication of counterfeit money, since counterfeiting can lead to other criminal actions such as terrorism, money laundering, illegal logging, and human trafficking.
Many believe that the existing Counterfeit Money Eradication Coordination Agency (Badan Koordinasi Pemberantasan Uang Palsu/Botasupal) which is under the National Intelligence Agency (BIN) isinsufficient.
"The agency mandatedbythe Currency Law, will actually be a transformation of Botasupal," said Achsanul Qosasi, Chairman of the Currency Bill Special Committee, last week.
The new agency will includethe State Intelligence Agency, Indonesian National Police, Attorney General's Office, Ministry of Finance, and Bank Indonesia, pursuant to Article 28 (2) of the Currency Law,.
On the other hand, Difi Johansyah, Head of the Public Relations Bureau at Bank Indonesia, said that Bank Indonesia has not been informed about the implementation of Article 28 (2). However, Difi asserted that Bank Indonesia will not have any problem with the plan, since Bank Indonesia and Botasupal have cooperated on several occasions.
Commissioner Agung Setya, Director II of Special Economic Crimes at the National Police Criminal Investigation Agency (Bareskrim Polri), echoed Difi's position. He asserted that the police already has officials to eradicate counterfeit money.
"We have a Sub-directorate on Counterfeit Money and Documents (Subdirektorat Uang dan Dokumen Palsu/Udpal), which is under the National Police Special Crime Directorate. Moreover, every Regional Police Office (Kepolisian Daerah/Polda) in Indonesia has a monetary and fiscal investigation unit," he said.
However, the Currency Law does not clearly stipulatehow the agency should be established. The Law mandated an implementing regulation, at the presidential regulation level, to specify the details. "The who, how, and when, will be set by a presidential regulation," he added.
The soon-to-be agency, however,has already received criticism. Sony Maulana Sikumbang, a law lecturer at Universitas Indonesia, explained that the Currency Law should state the rules regarding the new institution. The Law should explain the form, status and budget of the institution, just to mention a fewissues.
Sony also questioned the urgency of the new institution. "Is the current agency (Botasupal) not good enough?The [new agency’s] status must be clear, about whether itis a permanent or an ad hoc institution," he emphasized.
A new institution, he further added, will become a burden on the state budget. "There will be a new budget, new secretariat, and so forth. Whilst, we already have many non-ministerial agencies," he asserted.
Based on a study prepared by the Research and Advocacy Institution for Judicial Independency (Lembaga Kajian dan Advokasi untuk Independensi Peradilan/LeIP), Indonesia has, at least, 53 non-structural institutions; government-controlled or independent.
Ronal Rofiandri, a researcher at the Centre for Indonesian Law & Policy Studies (Pusat Studi Hukum & Kebijakan Indonesia/PSHK), said many of these institutions do not have a clear job description. Even more, some of them overlap.
"We just know that Indonesia has a National Sugar Board, a National Book Board, and a Civic Life Development Agency. Whilst the State Civil Service Commission, which was mandated by Law No. 43 of 1999 on Civil Service Principles, has not been established,” he explained. Ronal also mentioned the existence of the Indonesia Science Academy, which is not as popular as the Indonesian Institute of Sciences (LIPI).
Theexistence of these extraneous institutionsis ironic, since the government always says the budgetis too small to fulfill basic needs.
(M. Vareno Tarnes / Pirhot Nababan)
Law No. 7 of 2011 on Currency ("Currency Law") mandated the establishment of an agency to coordinate the eradication of counterfeit money, since counterfeiting can lead to other criminal actions such as terrorism, money laundering, illegal logging, and human trafficking.
Many believe that the existing Counterfeit Money Eradication Coordination Agency (Badan Koordinasi Pemberantasan Uang Palsu/Botasupal) which is under the National Intelligence Agency (BIN) isinsufficient.
"The agency mandatedbythe Currency Law, will actually be a transformation of Botasupal," said Achsanul Qosasi, Chairman of the Currency Bill Special Committee, last week.
The new agency will includethe State Intelligence Agency, Indonesian National Police, Attorney General's Office, Ministry of Finance, and Bank Indonesia, pursuant to Article 28 (2) of the Currency Law,.
On the other hand, Difi Johansyah, Head of the Public Relations Bureau at Bank Indonesia, said that Bank Indonesia has not been informed about the implementation of Article 28 (2). However, Difi asserted that Bank Indonesia will not have any problem with the plan, since Bank Indonesia and Botasupal have cooperated on several occasions.
Commissioner Agung Setya, Director II of Special Economic Crimes at the National Police Criminal Investigation Agency (Bareskrim Polri), echoed Difi's position. He asserted that the police already has officials to eradicate counterfeit money.
"We have a Sub-directorate on Counterfeit Money and Documents (Subdirektorat Uang dan Dokumen Palsu/Udpal), which is under the National Police Special Crime Directorate. Moreover, every Regional Police Office (Kepolisian Daerah/Polda) in Indonesia has a monetary and fiscal investigation unit," he said.
However, the Currency Law does not clearly stipulatehow the agency should be established. The Law mandated an implementing regulation, at the presidential regulation level, to specify the details. "The who, how, and when, will be set by a presidential regulation," he added.
The soon-to-be agency, however,has already received criticism. Sony Maulana Sikumbang, a law lecturer at Universitas Indonesia, explained that the Currency Law should state the rules regarding the new institution. The Law should explain the form, status and budget of the institution, just to mention a fewissues.
Sony also questioned the urgency of the new institution. "Is the current agency (Botasupal) not good enough?The [new agency’s] status must be clear, about whether itis a permanent or an ad hoc institution," he emphasized.
A new institution, he further added, will become a burden on the state budget. "There will be a new budget, new secretariat, and so forth. Whilst, we already have many non-ministerial agencies," he asserted.
Based on a study prepared by the Research and Advocacy Institution for Judicial Independency (Lembaga Kajian dan Advokasi untuk Independensi Peradilan/LeIP), Indonesia has, at least, 53 non-structural institutions; government-controlled or independent.
Ronal Rofiandri, a researcher at the Centre for Indonesian Law & Policy Studies (Pusat Studi Hukum & Kebijakan Indonesia/PSHK), said many of these institutions do not have a clear job description. Even more, some of them overlap.
"We just know that Indonesia has a National Sugar Board, a National Book Board, and a Civic Life Development Agency. Whilst the State Civil Service Commission, which was mandated by Law No. 43 of 1999 on Civil Service Principles, has not been established,” he explained. Ronal also mentioned the existence of the Indonesia Science Academy, which is not as popular as the Indonesian Institute of Sciences (LIPI).
Theexistence of these extraneous institutionsis ironic, since the government always says the budgetis too small to fulfill basic needs.
(M. Vareno Tarnes / Pirhot Nababan)