Mining Contracts Should Be Renegotiated

 

Since its issuance in 2009, Law no. 4 of 2009 on Mining and Coal (Mining Law) has received a lot of criticism. Many think the law is too "pro-investor", particularly in relationship to mining work contracts. There was a recommendation to amend this law, just two years after its enactment.

Pramono Anung, Deputy Speaker of the House of Representatives (DPR), said that the Mining Law has given too many privileges to investors. "It is not profitable for the Indonesian people," he said at a discussion regarding Mining Work Contract Regenotiation, held by the National Law Commission, in Jakarta, Wednesday (13/7).

He also criticized unfair royalty sharing withmining businesses. Pramono questioned the funds that have been received by the government, which should be used to build the communities around mining areas.

"There is no other way, except to renegotiate the mining work contracts," he asserted.

As a reminder, mining royaltiesare regulated by Government Regulation No. 45 of 2003 on Non-Tax State Income Tariff, which is applicable to the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM). Under the Regulation, the royalty for gold was set at 3.75 percent of the selling price multiplied by the tonnage. However, Freeport only paid 1 percent of its selling price multiplied by the tonnage.

Compared to other countries that produce gold, such as South Africa, Namibia, and Tanzania,the 3.75 figure is too low, since it is calculated from the net income. The aforementioned countries received three to eight percent royalties on gross income.

Moreover, at the same occasion, Ichsanuddin Noorsy, an economics expert, emphasized that Indonesia has failed to protect its energy sovereignty,even though Indonesia has a large oil reserve. "Only a foolish country voluntarily gives away its energy sovereignty toa foreign party. We have a large reserve, yet we can't do much about it," he said.

Ichsan argued that the current condition is caused by the pressure from foreign parties. It is because of Indonesia's dependency on the World Bank, IMF, and other monetary institutions. He took the case of PT Newmont Nusa Tenggara as an example. Ichsan believes that the divestment, which the government purchased, is part of the Newmont's strategy to keep its positionin the company.

Meanwhile, Marwan Batubara, Executive Director of Indonesian Resources Studies (IRESS), said that the point of work contract negotiation is to protect the state and public interest. Many other countries have renegotiatied, even thoughthe mining companiesargued that the contract period should be finished first.

Marwan also provided an explanation regarding Article 169 of the Mining Law. Under Article 169 (a), the prevailing work contract and Coal Mining Business Work Agreement (Perjanjian Karya Pengusahaan Pertambangan Batubara/PKP2B) will stay in force until the end of the contract's period.

Moreover, Article 169 (b) stated that the rules in the work contract and PKP2B have to be adjusted one year after the Mining Law has came into force. However, the article excluded contracts that relate to state income. He believes that these articles are confusing.

He said that the Mining Law allowsthe work contract and PKP2B to be continued until its end period, whilst the rules in it have to be adjusted according to the law.

Marwan asserted the importance of putting a government representative on the board of directors in a foreign mining company. "To protect Indonesia's interests," he asserted.

As a reminder, the government has responded to the recommendation regarding the regenotiation. Evita Herawati Legowo, Director General of Oil and Gas at the ESDM asserted that the renegotiation will be focused on contracts that do not result in any profit for Indonesia.

She explained that profitable contracts and investments will be continued, and the government is making progress on identifying the existing oil and gas contracts.

Evita further said that the government will only renegotiate the selling aspect of the contracts, particularly the export price of liquified natural gas (LNG). She asserted that if LNG export has harmed the state income, it should be renegotiated.

She also asked every stakeholder to respect the prevailing contracts, since the oil and gas contract renegotiation needs a well-made policy, in order to maintaina positive investment climate in Indonesia.

(M. Agus Yozami / Pirhot Nababan)

 

Since its issuance in 2009, Law no. 4 of 2009 on Mining and Coal (Mining Law) has received a lot of criticism. Many think the law is too "pro-investor", particularly in relationship to mining work contracts. There was a recommendation to amend this law, just two years after its enactment.

Pramono Anung, Deputy Speaker of the House of Representatives (DPR), said that the Mining Law has given too many privileges to investors. "It is not profitable for the Indonesian people," he said at a discussion regarding Mining Work Contract Regenotiation, held by the National Law Commission, in Jakarta, Wednesday (13/7).

He also criticized unfair royalty sharing withmining businesses. Pramono questioned the funds that have been received by the government, which should be used to build the communities around mining areas.

"There is no other way, except to renegotiate the mining work contracts," he asserted.

As a reminder, mining royaltiesare regulated by Government Regulation No. 45 of 2003 on Non-Tax State Income Tariff, which is applicable to the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM). Under the Regulation, the royalty for gold was set at 3.75 percent of the selling price multiplied by the tonnage. However, Freeport only paid 1 percent of its selling price multiplied by the tonnage.

Compared to other countries that produce gold, such as South Africa, Namibia, and Tanzania,the 3.75 figure is too low, since it is calculated from the net income. The aforementioned countries received three to eight percent royalties on gross income.

Moreover, at the same occasion, Ichsanuddin Noorsy, an economics expert, emphasized that Indonesia has failed to protect its energy sovereignty,even though Indonesia has a large oil reserve. "Only a foolish country voluntarily gives away its energy sovereignty toa foreign party. We have a large reserve, yet we can't do much about it," he said.

Ichsan argued that the current condition is caused by the pressure from foreign parties. It is because of Indonesia's dependency on the World Bank, IMF, and other monetary institutions. He took the case of PT Newmont Nusa Tenggara as an example. Ichsan believes that the divestment, which the government purchased, is part of the Newmont's strategy to keep its positionin the company.

Meanwhile, Marwan Batubara, Executive Director of Indonesian Resources Studies (IRESS), said that the point of work contract negotiation is to protect the state and public interest. Many other countries have renegotiatied, even thoughthe mining companiesargued that the contract period should be finished first.

Marwan also provided an explanation regarding Article 169 of the Mining Law. Under Article 169 (a), the prevailing work contract and Coal Mining Business Work Agreement (Perjanjian Karya Pengusahaan Pertambangan Batubara/PKP2B) will stay in force until the end of the contract's period.

Moreover, Article 169 (b) stated that the rules in the work contract and PKP2B have to be adjusted one year after the Mining Law has came into force. However, the article excluded contracts that relate to state income. He believes that these articles are confusing.

He said that the Mining Law allowsthe work contract and PKP2B to be continued until its end period, whilst the rules in it have to be adjusted according to the law.

Marwan asserted the importance of putting a government representative on the board of directors in a foreign mining company. "To protect Indonesia's interests," he asserted.

As a reminder, the government has responded to the recommendation regarding the regenotiation. Evita Herawati Legowo, Director General of Oil and Gas at the ESDM asserted that the renegotiation will be focused on contracts that do not result in any profit for Indonesia.

She explained that profitable contracts and investments will be continued, and the government is making progress on identifying the existing oil and gas contracts.

Evita further said that the government will only renegotiate the selling aspect of the contracts, particularly the export price of liquified natural gas (LNG). She asserted that if LNG export has harmed the state income, it should be renegotiated.

She also asked every stakeholder to respect the prevailing contracts, since the oil and gas contract renegotiation needs a well-made policy, in order to maintaina positive investment climate in Indonesia.

(M. Agus Yozami / Pirhot Nababan)

2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info