The Central Jakarta District Court granted the petition of five Jakarta citizens in a citizen lawsuit against Governor’s Regulation No. 88 of 2010 on the Amendment of Governor’s Regulation No. 75 of 2005 on No Smoking Areas. The five citizens filed a petition to become involved as a third party in the lawsuit. This process is known as an intervention in the Indonesian legal system.
After the judges granted their petition, the five citizens gave an immediate response to the plaintiff’s lawsuit, via their legal counsel. One of the counselors, Azas Tigor Nainggolan, memberof Solidarity of Public Advocates for Tobacco Control (Solidaritas Advokat Publik Untuk Pengendalian Tembakau/SAPTA), argued that the plaintiff's lawsuit has failed to fulfill the requirementsfor a citizen lawsuit.
According to Tigor, the citizen lawsuit is a mechanism for suinga public apparatus that fails to comply withthe rights of citizen. "What kind of failure has resulted from the Jakarta Governor’sissuance of the Regulation? And who is harmed by this regulation?"
Tigor further added that Madon, the plaintiff, cannot verify the Jakarta citizens that are being harmed because of the Regulation. Moreover, Tigor also thought that the lawsuit was not supposed to request for an annulment of a public apparatus' decision.
He explained that the lawsuit should be filed in the Supreme Court, since the Governor’s Regulation is below the level of a law. "The Central Jakarta District Courtdoes not have jurisdiction to handle this dispute," he asserted.
Pursuant to these issues, Tigor asked the judges to refuse the lawsuit, since it is an unclear lawsuit (obscuur libel).
Leo Wisnu Susapto / Pirhot Nababan
The Central Jakarta District Court granted the petition of five Jakarta citizens in a citizen lawsuit against Governor’s Regulation No. 88 of 2010 on the Amendment of Governor’s Regulation No. 75 of 2005 on No Smoking Areas. The five citizens filed a petition to become involved as a third party in the lawsuit. This process is known as an intervention in the Indonesian legal system.
After the judges granted their petition, the five citizens gave an immediate response to the plaintiff’s lawsuit, via their legal counsel. One of the counselors, Azas Tigor Nainggolan, memberof Solidarity of Public Advocates for Tobacco Control (Solidaritas Advokat Publik Untuk Pengendalian Tembakau/SAPTA), argued that the plaintiff's lawsuit has failed to fulfill the requirementsfor a citizen lawsuit.
According to Tigor, the citizen lawsuit is a mechanism for suinga public apparatus that fails to comply withthe rights of citizen. "What kind of failure has resulted from the Jakarta Governor’sissuance of the Regulation? And who is harmed by this regulation?"
Tigor further added that Madon, the plaintiff, cannot verify the Jakarta citizens that are being harmed because of the Regulation. Moreover, Tigor also thought that the lawsuit was not supposed to request for an annulment of a public apparatus' decision.
He explained that the lawsuit should be filed in the Supreme Court, since the Governor’s Regulation is below the level of a law. "The Central Jakarta District Courtdoes not have jurisdiction to handle this dispute," he asserted.
Pursuant to these issues, Tigor asked the judges to refuse the lawsuit, since it is an unclear lawsuit (obscuur libel).
Leo Wisnu Susapto / Pirhot Nababan