BPN: Land Case Management

Overview

The National Land Agency (Badan Pertanahan Nasional/BPN) which functions as the Regulator and also as the Administrator of land affairs, has recently strengthened its adjudicative function. Such authority is promulgated through the issuance of the Head of National Land Agency Regulation No.3 of 2011 on Land Case Management, Reviews and Handling (“Regulation”). 

The adjudicative functions of the BPN (Agency) are authorized under the Agency umbrella regulation, Presidential Regulation No.10 of 2006 on National Land Agency (Perpres 10/2006). Where pursuant to Article 21-23 of Perpres 10/2006, the Deputy of Land Case Review and Land Case Handling Disputes and Conflicts, is authorized to handle such matters.      

The delegation of power is indeed necessary. Current conditions show that around 65-70 percent of cases handled by the Supreme Court involve a land dispute, and land dispute . It should be taken into consideration that all land disputes brought to the Agency are in the form of mediation, where unsatisfied parties may appeal by filing a lawsuit over the Agency decision. 

The Regulation, in a nutshell, consists of 11 Chapters and 85 Articles, which cover services for receiving complaints and providing information on cases; reviewing land cases; handling land cases; land case settlement; and legal assistance and protection (Article 3 of the Regulation).

Additionally, the Regulation includes appendixes, containing forms/documents on i) the Handling of Land cases (Form Code DI.500-DI.509); ii) Activities in handling Land Cases (Form Code DI.510-DI.519); iii) the Mapping of Land Cases (Form Code DI.520-DI.529); and iv) Supervision ((Form Code DI.530-DI.533).     

This edition of Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the Regulation and provide an analysis of its provisions.

 

Definition

The Regulation differentiates between the definition of land case disputes and land case conflicts, where pursuant to Article 1 (2), a land case dispute is defined as a land dispute between individuals, legal entities, or institutions which does not have a social-political impact.

A land case conflict on the other hand, as set in Article 1 (3), is defined as a land case dispute between individuals, legal entities, or institutions which has a socio-political impact.

A case briefing (gelar perkara) pursuant to Article 1 (5) is classified into 4 types, respectively:

a.

Internal case briefing, defined as a briefing attended by the Agency and its offices. 

b.

External case briefing, defined as a briefing attended by the Agency and its offices, including other institutions outside the Agency.

c.

Mediation briefing, defined as a briefing attended by the disputing parties in which the Agency facilitate a discussion to come to a settlement.

d.

Special briefing, defined as a briefing conducted by the Land Case Settlement Team established by the Head of the Agency or the Deputy in charge of handling land case disputes and conflicts.   

 

Purpose

The Regulation serves as a guide in assessing and handling land cases by the Agency, where the specific purpose is to reveal the root, the history, and the typology of land cases in order to resolve land cases reported to the Agency by disputing parties (Article 2).  

Pursuant to 84, the Regulation also serves to replace and repeal the following regulations:

a.

Minister of Agrarian Affairs / Head of National Land Affairs Agency Regulation No.3 of 1999 on the Delegation of Authority to Issue and to Annul Rights over State’s Land;

b.

Regulation No.9 of 1999 on the Procedures to Issue and to annul rights over State’s Land and Rights to Manage;

c.

Head of National Land Agency Decree No.34 of 2007 on Technical Instructions to handle and Resolve Land Disputes; and

d.

Other regulation which is in conflict with the Regulation.

 

The overall purpose of the Regulation is to set guidelines for managing, reviewing, and handling land cases in order to provide legal certainty over the control, the utilization, and also the ownership of land disputes that are filed with the Agency and Courts (District Court, and State’s Administrative Court)   

 

Applicability

As almost all human activities involve the utilization of land, whether for the purpose of cultivation, residence, business, public purposes, or other purposes, land issues effect all of us. In essence, all land owners, regardless of whether they are individuals, legal entities, or government and non-government institutions benefit from clear regulations to resolve land disputes.

 

Land Case Management to Agency

Reporting a complaint

Pursuant to Article 5 (2), a complaint may be an oral complaint, a written complaint or submitted via the Agency website at www.bpn.go.id. It should be noted, that although 5(2) provides legal grounds for the Agency to receive a complaint via the Agency website, the website for receiving complaints (Pengaduan Masyarakat) is not well developed yet. This condition suggests that the Agency has not allocated proper resources to receiving complaints via the internet.

As set in Article 6, the complaint must consist of the complainant’s identity, the object of dispute, the case position, and the purpose of the complaint. Additionally, supporting documents must be included in the complaint.

Each complaint submitted via the complaint counter will receive a receipt (Article 7 (1)). 

 

Land Case Information

Article 8(2) grants rights to stakeholders to access information about land cases handled by the Agency, with requirements set in Article 9. Pursuant to Article 9 (1) Land case information is categorized as:

1.

Confidential information (such as information categorized as a state secret, documents classified by the law as a state secret);

2.

Limited information (such as information on the progress of a land case, the settlement result of a land case, and other information determined by the Agency officials); and 

3.

Information open to the public (such as laws and regulations on land affairs, procedures to file a complaint and the settlement of land cases, number-types-and typology of land cases).

 

The complainant and defendant of a land case, pursuant to Article 12, may request information on the progress of their case. The case progress by the Agency will be rendered in writing.

 

Timeline

The Agency is obliged to render information on the land case progress no more than 30 days after the date of the request (Article 13(1)). As set in Article 13 (3), the Agency is obliged to inform parties of the land case progress, and the progress report must include:

a.

The point of the case (pokok perkara) and the dispute, and

b.

A complete explanation that is supported with data from the Agency and its regent office.

 

Land Case Review

Pursuant to Article 14, in conjunction with Article 15, the Head of Agency Regional Office and/or the Deputy which heads Land Case Disputes and Conflicts Management may individually or jointly, systematically review the case over the root and the history of land cases.

The objects of analysis as set in Article 19 are:

a.

Electronic data,

b.

Panel data in the control room, 

c.

The case position of the complaint,

d.

Related complaints to Agency officials.

 

Land Case Dispute

The objective of a land case dispute review under Article 21 is to review and analyze the root and history of the dispute, to discover variables that cause the dispute, and to find solutions to resolve the dispute. 

Legal research will be conducted before rendering a recommendation in handling the land case dispute, where pursuant to Article 21 (1), the data analyzed includes juridical data, physical data and/or other supporting data.

Pursuant to Article 27, a land case dispute will be handled with the following steps:

a.

Research / processing data submitted by the complainant;

b.

Field research;

c.

Holding a case briefing (gelar perkara);

d.

Organizing Minutes of data processing;

e.

Preparation of meeting minutes/letter/decree; and/or

f.

Monitoring and evaluating results of land case disputes.

 

Set in Article 27 (2), for certain types of land case disputes, a special team will be established to handle the case. The establishment of a special team will be authorized by the Head of the Agency.

 

Processing complainant’s data

Pursuant to Article 29, the research and processing of the complainant’s data consists of:

a.

Reviewing the completeness and the validity of the submitted data;

b.

Reviewing the complainant’s data;

c.

Matching juridical data and physical data and other supporting data;

d.

Studying the chronology of the dispute;

e.

Analyzing juridical aspects, physical aspects, and administrative aspects.

 

Field Research

As set in Article 29 (3), if found necessary to complete the juridical data, physical data and other supporting data, field research may be conducted. Pursuant to Article 30, field research consists of:

a.

Research of the validity of the data and its source;

b.

Searching for additional information or explanations from witnesses related to the case;

c.

Visiting the object of dispute (land);

d.

Research on the land boundaries, the situation, the field map or measuring documents; and

e.

Other activities deemed necessary.

 

Case Briefing (gelar perkara)

The case briefing, pursuant to Article 34 (1), is held by the order of the Deputy in charge the land case dispute/conflict. Parties involved in the case briefing are further stipulated under Article 34, where minutes of the meeting must be produced pursuant to a provision of Article 35.

The type of case briefing is stipulated in Article 36, where in essence there are 4 types of case briefings. These are:

a.

Internal briefing à this type of briefing serves to gather input from Agency officials to identify the dispute/conflict and come up with a plan to resolve the problem (stipulated further in Article 37); 

b.

External briefing à  this type of briefing serves to acquire information and opinions from organs of the Agency and institutions outside the Agency, this brief serves to sharpen the analysis of the case and findings  (stipulated further in Article 38)

c.

Mediation briefing à this type of briefing serves to gather information/opinions from disputing parties, serving also to explain the weaknesses and strengths of the parties’ legal positions, facilitate resolution of the land case, and also to decide a method for resolving the dispute (stipulated further in Article 39), and

d.

Special briefing à this type of briefing is held to resolve complex land cases, and also to resolve different decisions about handling land cases between Agency officials and other institution officials, to correct a previous Agency official decision found to be troubling (stipulated further in Article 40).

 

Land Case Conflict

The objective of a land case conflict review under Article 23 (1) is to review and analyze the root and history of the conflict, to discover variables that caused the conflict and potential impacts of the conflict.

Pursuant to Article 23, data deriving from the complainant and related institutions, and the department Agency will be researched and analyzed to determine present an explanation of the root causes of the conflict.

It should be noted that the provisions on handling a Land Case Dispute also apply to a Land Case Conflict (mutatis mutandis) pursuant to Article 47.

 

Alternative Dispute Resolution

Pursuant to Article 61, a land case dispute that is resolved outside the court revolves around:

a.

Annulling a certificate which rights/ownership that are legally invalid (cacat hukum);

b.

Registering ownership/a rights’ certificate of land including other general lists; and

c.

Issuance of a certificate or administrative decision on land that is found to be legally invalid.  

 

Administration of a legally defective certificate

Pursuant to Article 71,  if several certificates exist that overlap on the same land object, the Agency in principle will annul and/or issue a land certificate, with the expectation that there will only be 1 certificate for 1 land object.

Administratively legally defective land certificates pursuant to Article 62 (2) are classified as follows:

a.

Procedural mistake in the process of determining and/or registering land rights;

b.

Procedural mistake in the process of registering the transfer of rights and/or a substitute certificate;

c.

Procedural mistake in the process of confirming and/or recognizing land rights over a previous customary land right;

d.

Procedural mistake in measuring, mapping and/or calculating the width of an object;

e.

Overlapping right or certificate over the same land object;

f.

Mistake over the rights of the subject and/or object; and

g.

Other mistakes in implementing prevailing laws and regulations.

 

Parties of interest, whether represented by an attorney or directly by the parties, pursuant to Article 64 (1) may file an application over an administratively legally defective certificate/rights.

The application as set in Article 64 (3) must be supported by supporting documents, which are:

a.

The certificate that is believed to be administratively legally defective;

b.

A result of processed data that proves the existence of an administratively legally defective certificate;

c.

Copy of a court decision/judge’s opinion that states that counterfeit documents were used in the process of issuing a land certificate.

d.

Other documents which support the grounds for the application

 

Timeline

As set in Article 66, the Agency is obliged within 6 months after the discovery of a legally defective certificate, to correct the  certificate. However, Article 66 (2) gives grounds to extend the 6 month time limitation, the grounds are as follows:

a.

The certificate which will be annulled, is in a blocked status, confiscated by authorized officials (conservatoir-beslag);

b.

The Land is the subject of a different case being tried in court (stipulated further in Article 66 (3);

c.

Annulling the rights/certificate is predicted to cause a mass social impact/conflict.         

 

The extension, pursuant to Article 66 (4), by the Head of the Agency Regional office or lower office to the Head of the Agency must be no later than 3 months after the decision to extend the execution of a legally defective certificate/rights.

 

Handling Lawsuits

Commonly, land cases processed by courts include the Agency as party in a lawsuit, whether as co-defendant in a civil case at the district court level, or as a defendant in a state administrative case in the state’s administrative court, pursuant to Article 25. However, Article 25 only states the district court and state’s administrative court, while in practice, the Agency may also become a co-defendant in inheritance or family cases in the religious court, if land is the object of dispute in the case.

As Chapter 6 part 6 of the Regulation is dedicated to regulating land cases, Article 50 (4) stipulates that should the Agency be a co-defendant/defendant and a losing party to the case, in principle the Agency will appeal the court’s decision.

 

Phases as a co-defendant/defendant

Pursuant to Article 50 (3), the Regulation re-confirms the civil case procedure of a defendant, that is provisioned in the Indonesian Civil Procedural Law (Herziene Inlandsch Reglement/ H.I.R), where the procedure consists of:

a.

Receiving a court’s summons;

b.

Preparing a letter of assignment and Power of Attorney Letter;

c.

Preparing an answer to the lawsuit/complaint;

d.

Preparing a rebuttal (duplik);

e.

Preparing evidence;

f.

Preparing witnesses;

g.

Site Examination;

h.

Conclusion;

i.

Appeals process

 

1)

Appeal to the high court;

 

2)

Cassation;

 

3)

Case review (Peninjauan Kembali/PK);

 

4)

Other legal attempts to appeal a court decision (Verzet/Derden Verzet).   

 

Grounds for Appealing

Article 50 (5), gives grounds to stop an appeal to the highest venue, on the condition that it is supported by datum which reveals that an appeal is not necessary, though an exception is rendered in Article 50 (5) where the Agency is obliged to exhaust all avenues of appeals, should the land object relate to state property or regional government property.

 

Reconciliation

Article 51 (1) establishes the conditions for reconciliation where the Agency is a co-defendant/defendant. The conditions are as follows:

a.

Does not involve State/ Regional Government property;

b.

Does not result in an Agency loss;

c.

Agreed by the disputing parties;  

d.

Is not in regard to the same subject and object in another case;

e.

Received a written approval issued by an authorized Agency official.  

 

Enforcing Court’s Decision 

Article 54 provisions that the Agency will enforce a final legal court decision, however, exceptions are justified for the following reasons:

a.

The object of the court’s decision is in conflict with another court decision;

b.

The object of the court’s decision has been sequested (conservatoir beslag);

c.

The object of a court’s decision is an object in a different case; and

d.

Other reasons as provisioned by the prevailing laws and regulations.

 

In essence, a court’s decision for the Agency would only lead to 3 types of orders, respectively, to issue, to transfer and/or to annul land ownership rights (Article 56).         

 

Timeline

The Agency, pursuant to Article 57 (1), is obliged to enforce a court decision no more than 2 months after it receives a copy of the court decision.

 

Institution

Since the Regulation is issued by the National Land Agency, the authority of the Agency is provisioned in Presidential Regulation No.10 of 2006 on the National Land Agency. Additionally, Chapter 8 of the Regulation addresses the rights of the Agency to annul and to register land rights deriving from the conversion of rights.

The Head of the Agency may delegate land rights annulment or registration to the Deputy of Land Case Dispute/Conflict Management and Head of Agency Regional Office (Article 73). However, decisions by the mentioned officials must mention that the decision is for and on behalf of the Head of the Agency.  

 

Sanctions 

The Regulation does not include any criminal and administrative sanctions for Agency officials. This is common, as this Regulation is issued by a government institution at the Ministry level. However, Article 41 (4) and Article 80 (3) states administrative sanctions that refer to a different regulation.

 

One of the many regulations referred to in referred by Article 41 (4) and Article 80 (3) of the Regulation is the Government Regulation No. 30 of 1980 on Civil Servants.

 

Conclusion

The Regulation’s provisions condition where the Agency is a co-defendant / defendant at a District Court / State’s Administrative Court, however, it fails to regulate provisions should the Agency be a party in the Religious Court. This suggest that the Agency was not careful in drafting the Regulation. This conclusion is supported by Religious court practices, where family and inheritance cases often involve land as the object in dispute.

When Law No.5 of 1960 on Principle Provisions of Agrarian Affairs was still in the form of a bill, there were intentions to establish a Land Court along with its enactment. However, this opinion did not pass the majority of the parliament at that time. Though that idea is not entirely wrong. Some parliament members back in the 1950s saw into the future and saw that land issues would result in a large number of cases. The prediction has been proven to be right, where currently around 65 – 70 percent cases in the Supreme Court are land cases.

The National Land Agency which functions as the regulator and also administrator of Land Affairs, has a function that resembles a Legislative and also an Executive function. With the issuance of the Regulation, it has been re-enforced with additional power, which is the Judicative function, however this judicative power is limited only to mediating parties of a land case dispute/conflict.

Such authority resembles an alternative dispute resolution called mediation, provisioned with Law No.30 of 1999 on Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution, this suggests that any outcome from the mediation process at the Agency would not be final and legally binding, and may be appealed to a court of justice. 

The Regulation also lacks a method to determine the cost of using the Agency to resolve cases, where in using any venue to resolve a dispute the cost incurred is inevitable. It is expected that the Agency will issue a specific regulation on using the Agency as a venue to resolve land cases.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

The National Land Agency (Badan Pertanahan Nasional/BPN) which functions as the Regulator and also as the Administrator of land affairs, has recently strengthened its adjudicative function. Such authority is promulgated through the issuance of the Head of National Land Agency Regulation No.3 of 2011 on Land Case Management, Reviews and Handling (“Regulation”). 

The adjudicative functions of the BPN (Agency) are authorized under the Agency umbrella regulation, Presidential Regulation No.10 of 2006 on National Land Agency (Perpres 10/2006). Where pursuant to Article 21-23 of Perpres 10/2006, the Deputy of Land Case Review and Land Case Handling Disputes and Conflicts, is authorized to handle such matters.      

The delegation of power is indeed necessary. Current conditions show that around 65-70 percent of cases handled by the Supreme Court involve a land dispute, and land dispute . It should be taken into consideration that all land disputes brought to the Agency are in the form of mediation, where unsatisfied parties may appeal by filing a lawsuit over the Agency decision. 

The Regulation, in a nutshell, consists of 11 Chapters and 85 Articles, which cover services for receiving complaints and providing information on cases; reviewing land cases; handling land cases; land case settlement; and legal assistance and protection (Article 3 of the Regulation).

Additionally, the Regulation includes appendixes, containing forms/documents on i) the Handling of Land cases (Form Code DI.500-DI.509); ii) Activities in handling Land Cases (Form Code DI.510-DI.519); iii) the Mapping of Land Cases (Form Code DI.520-DI.529); and iv) Supervision ((Form Code DI.530-DI.533).     

This edition of Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the Regulation and provide an analysis of its provisions.

 

Definition

The Regulation differentiates between the definition of land case disputes and land case conflicts, where pursuant to Article 1 (2), a land case dispute is defined as a land dispute between individuals, legal entities, or institutions which does not have a social-political impact.

A land case conflict on the other hand, as set in Article 1 (3), is defined as a land case dispute between individuals, legal entities, or institutions which has a socio-political impact.

A case briefing (gelar perkara) pursuant to Article 1 (5) is classified into 4 types, respectively:

a.

Internal case briefing, defined as a briefing attended by the Agency and its offices. 

b.

External case briefing, defined as a briefing attended by the Agency and its offices, including other institutions outside the Agency.

c.

Mediation briefing, defined as a briefing attended by the disputing parties in which the Agency facilitate a discussion to come to a settlement.

d.

Special briefing, defined as a briefing conducted by the Land Case Settlement Team established by the Head of the Agency or the Deputy in charge of handling land case disputes and conflicts.   

 

Purpose

The Regulation serves as a guide in assessing and handling land cases by the Agency, where the specific purpose is to reveal the root, the history, and the typology of land cases in order to resolve land cases reported to the Agency by disputing parties (Article 2).  

Pursuant to 84, the Regulation also serves to replace and repeal the following regulations:

a.

Minister of Agrarian Affairs / Head of National Land Affairs Agency Regulation No.3 of 1999 on the Delegation of Authority to Issue and to Annul Rights over State’s Land;

b.

Regulation No.9 of 1999 on the Procedures to Issue and to annul rights over State’s Land and Rights to Manage;

c.

Head of National Land Agency Decree No.34 of 2007 on Technical Instructions to handle and Resolve Land Disputes; and

d.

Other regulation which is in conflict with the Regulation.

 

The overall purpose of the Regulation is to set guidelines for managing, reviewing, and handling land cases in order to provide legal certainty over the control, the utilization, and also the ownership of land disputes that are filed with the Agency and Courts (District Court, and State’s Administrative Court)   

 

Applicability

As almost all human activities involve the utilization of land, whether for the purpose of cultivation, residence, business, public purposes, or other purposes, land issues effect all of us. In essence, all land owners, regardless of whether they are individuals, legal entities, or government and non-government institutions benefit from clear regulations to resolve land disputes.

 

Land Case Management to Agency

Reporting a complaint

Pursuant to Article 5 (2), a complaint may be an oral complaint, a written complaint or submitted via the Agency website at www.bpn.go.id. It should be noted, that although 5(2) provides legal grounds for the Agency to receive a complaint via the Agency website, the website for receiving complaints (Pengaduan Masyarakat) is not well developed yet. This condition suggests that the Agency has not allocated proper resources to receiving complaints via the internet.

As set in Article 6, the complaint must consist of the complainant’s identity, the object of dispute, the case position, and the purpose of the complaint. Additionally, supporting documents must be included in the complaint.

Each complaint submitted via the complaint counter will receive a receipt (Article 7 (1)). 

 

Land Case Information

Article 8(2) grants rights to stakeholders to access information about land cases handled by the Agency, with requirements set in Article 9. Pursuant to Article 9 (1) Land case information is categorized as:

1.

Confidential information (such as information categorized as a state secret, documents classified by the law as a state secret);

2.

Limited information (such as information on the progress of a land case, the settlement result of a land case, and other information determined by the Agency officials); and 

3.

Information open to the public (such as laws and regulations on land affairs, procedures to file a complaint and the settlement of land cases, number-types-and typology of land cases).

 

The complainant and defendant of a land case, pursuant to Article 12, may request information on the progress of their case. The case progress by the Agency will be rendered in writing.

 

Timeline

The Agency is obliged to render information on the land case progress no more than 30 days after the date of the request (Article 13(1)). As set in Article 13 (3), the Agency is obliged to inform parties of the land case progress, and the progress report must include:

a.

The point of the case (pokok perkara) and the dispute, and

b.

A complete explanation that is supported with data from the Agency and its regent office.

 

Land Case Review

Pursuant to Article 14, in conjunction with Article 15, the Head of Agency Regional Office and/or the Deputy which heads Land Case Disputes and Conflicts Management may individually or jointly, systematically review the case over the root and the history of land cases.

The objects of analysis as set in Article 19 are:

a.

Electronic data,

b.

Panel data in the control room, 

c.

The case position of the complaint,

d.

Related complaints to Agency officials.

 

Land Case Dispute

The objective of a land case dispute review under Article 21 is to review and analyze the root and history of the dispute, to discover variables that cause the dispute, and to find solutions to resolve the dispute. 

Legal research will be conducted before rendering a recommendation in handling the land case dispute, where pursuant to Article 21 (1), the data analyzed includes juridical data, physical data and/or other supporting data.

Pursuant to Article 27, a land case dispute will be handled with the following steps:

a.

Research / processing data submitted by the complainant;

b.

Field research;

c.

Holding a case briefing (gelar perkara);

d.

Organizing Minutes of data processing;

e.

Preparation of meeting minutes/letter/decree; and/or

f.

Monitoring and evaluating results of land case disputes.

 

Set in Article 27 (2), for certain types of land case disputes, a special team will be established to handle the case. The establishment of a special team will be authorized by the Head of the Agency.

 

Processing complainant’s data

Pursuant to Article 29, the research and processing of the complainant’s data consists of:

a.

Reviewing the completeness and the validity of the submitted data;

b.

Reviewing the complainant’s data;

c.

Matching juridical data and physical data and other supporting data;

d.

Studying the chronology of the dispute;

e.

Analyzing juridical aspects, physical aspects, and administrative aspects.

 

Field Research

As set in Article 29 (3), if found necessary to complete the juridical data, physical data and other supporting data, field research may be conducted. Pursuant to Article 30, field research consists of:

a.

Research of the validity of the data and its source;

b.

Searching for additional information or explanations from witnesses related to the case;

c.

Visiting the object of dispute (land);

d.

Research on the land boundaries, the situation, the field map or measuring documents; and

e.

Other activities deemed necessary.

 

Case Briefing (gelar perkara)

The case briefing, pursuant to Article 34 (1), is held by the order of the Deputy in charge the land case dispute/conflict. Parties involved in the case briefing are further stipulated under Article 34, where minutes of the meeting must be produced pursuant to a provision of Article 35.

The type of case briefing is stipulated in Article 36, where in essence there are 4 types of case briefings. These are:

a.

Internal briefing à this type of briefing serves to gather input from Agency officials to identify the dispute/conflict and come up with a plan to resolve the problem (stipulated further in Article 37); 

b.

External briefing à  this type of briefing serves to acquire information and opinions from organs of the Agency and institutions outside the Agency, this brief serves to sharpen the analysis of the case and findings  (stipulated further in Article 38)

c.

Mediation briefing à this type of briefing serves to gather information/opinions from disputing parties, serving also to explain the weaknesses and strengths of the parties’ legal positions, facilitate resolution of the land case, and also to decide a method for resolving the dispute (stipulated further in Article 39), and

d.

Special briefing à this type of briefing is held to resolve complex land cases, and also to resolve different decisions about handling land cases between Agency officials and other institution officials, to correct a previous Agency official decision found to be troubling (stipulated further in Article 40).

 

Land Case Conflict

The objective of a land case conflict review under Article 23 (1) is to review and analyze the root and history of the conflict, to discover variables that caused the conflict and potential impacts of the conflict.

Pursuant to Article 23, data deriving from the complainant and related institutions, and the department Agency will be researched and analyzed to determine present an explanation of the root causes of the conflict.

It should be noted that the provisions on handling a Land Case Dispute also apply to a Land Case Conflict (mutatis mutandis) pursuant to Article 47.

 

Alternative Dispute Resolution

Pursuant to Article 61, a land case dispute that is resolved outside the court revolves around:

a.

Annulling a certificate which rights/ownership that are legally invalid (cacat hukum);

b.

Registering ownership/a rights’ certificate of land including other general lists; and

c.

Issuance of a certificate or administrative decision on land that is found to be legally invalid.  

 

Administration of a legally defective certificate

Pursuant to Article 71,  if several certificates exist that overlap on the same land object, the Agency in principle will annul and/or issue a land certificate, with the expectation that there will only be 1 certificate for 1 land object.

Administratively legally defective land certificates pursuant to Article 62 (2) are classified as follows:

a.

Procedural mistake in the process of determining and/or registering land rights;

b.

Procedural mistake in the process of registering the transfer of rights and/or a substitute certificate;

c.

Procedural mistake in the process of confirming and/or recognizing land rights over a previous customary land right;

d.

Procedural mistake in measuring, mapping and/or calculating the width of an object;

e.

Overlapping right or certificate over the same land object;

f.

Mistake over the rights of the subject and/or object; and

g.

Other mistakes in implementing prevailing laws and regulations.

 

Parties of interest, whether represented by an attorney or directly by the parties, pursuant to Article 64 (1) may file an application over an administratively legally defective certificate/rights.

The application as set in Article 64 (3) must be supported by supporting documents, which are:

a.

The certificate that is believed to be administratively legally defective;

b.

A result of processed data that proves the existence of an administratively legally defective certificate;

c.

Copy of a court decision/judge’s opinion that states that counterfeit documents were used in the process of issuing a land certificate.

d.

Other documents which support the grounds for the application

 

Timeline

As set in Article 66, the Agency is obliged within 6 months after the discovery of a legally defective certificate, to correct the  certificate. However, Article 66 (2) gives grounds to extend the 6 month time limitation, the grounds are as follows:

a.

The certificate which will be annulled, is in a blocked status, confiscated by authorized officials (conservatoir-beslag);

b.

The Land is the subject of a different case being tried in court (stipulated further in Article 66 (3);

c.

Annulling the rights/certificate is predicted to cause a mass social impact/conflict.         

 

The extension, pursuant to Article 66 (4), by the Head of the Agency Regional office or lower office to the Head of the Agency must be no later than 3 months after the decision to extend the execution of a legally defective certificate/rights.

 

Handling Lawsuits

Commonly, land cases processed by courts include the Agency as party in a lawsuit, whether as co-defendant in a civil case at the district court level, or as a defendant in a state administrative case in the state’s administrative court, pursuant to Article 25. However, Article 25 only states the district court and state’s administrative court, while in practice, the Agency may also become a co-defendant in inheritance or family cases in the religious court, if land is the object of dispute in the case.

As Chapter 6 part 6 of the Regulation is dedicated to regulating land cases, Article 50 (4) stipulates that should the Agency be a co-defendant/defendant and a losing party to the case, in principle the Agency will appeal the court’s decision.

 

Phases as a co-defendant/defendant

Pursuant to Article 50 (3), the Regulation re-confirms the civil case procedure of a defendant, that is provisioned in the Indonesian Civil Procedural Law (Herziene Inlandsch Reglement/ H.I.R), where the procedure consists of:

a.

Receiving a court’s summons;

b.

Preparing a letter of assignment and Power of Attorney Letter;

c.

Preparing an answer to the lawsuit/complaint;

d.

Preparing a rebuttal (duplik);

e.

Preparing evidence;

f.

Preparing witnesses;

g.

Site Examination;

h.

Conclusion;

i.

Appeals process

 

1)

Appeal to the high court;

 

2)

Cassation;

 

3)

Case review (Peninjauan Kembali/PK);

 

4)

Other legal attempts to appeal a court decision (Verzet/Derden Verzet).   

 

Grounds for Appealing

Article 50 (5), gives grounds to stop an appeal to the highest venue, on the condition that it is supported by datum which reveals that an appeal is not necessary, though an exception is rendered in Article 50 (5) where the Agency is obliged to exhaust all avenues of appeals, should the land object relate to state property or regional government property.

 

Reconciliation

Article 51 (1) establishes the conditions for reconciliation where the Agency is a co-defendant/defendant. The conditions are as follows:

a.

Does not involve State/ Regional Government property;

b.

Does not result in an Agency loss;

c.

Agreed by the disputing parties;  

d.

Is not in regard to the same subject and object in another case;

e.

Received a written approval issued by an authorized Agency official.  

 

Enforcing Court’s Decision 

Article 54 provisions that the Agency will enforce a final legal court decision, however, exceptions are justified for the following reasons:

a.

The object of the court’s decision is in conflict with another court decision;

b.

The object of the court’s decision has been sequested (conservatoir beslag);

c.

The object of a court’s decision is an object in a different case; and

d.

Other reasons as provisioned by the prevailing laws and regulations.

 

In essence, a court’s decision for the Agency would only lead to 3 types of orders, respectively, to issue, to transfer and/or to annul land ownership rights (Article 56).         

 

Timeline

The Agency, pursuant to Article 57 (1), is obliged to enforce a court decision no more than 2 months after it receives a copy of the court decision.

 

Institution

Since the Regulation is issued by the National Land Agency, the authority of the Agency is provisioned in Presidential Regulation No.10 of 2006 on the National Land Agency. Additionally, Chapter 8 of the Regulation addresses the rights of the Agency to annul and to register land rights deriving from the conversion of rights.

The Head of the Agency may delegate land rights annulment or registration to the Deputy of Land Case Dispute/Conflict Management and Head of Agency Regional Office (Article 73). However, decisions by the mentioned officials must mention that the decision is for and on behalf of the Head of the Agency.  

 

Sanctions 

The Regulation does not include any criminal and administrative sanctions for Agency officials. This is common, as this Regulation is issued by a government institution at the Ministry level. However, Article 41 (4) and Article 80 (3) states administrative sanctions that refer to a different regulation.

 

One of the many regulations referred to in referred by Article 41 (4) and Article 80 (3) of the Regulation is the Government Regulation No. 30 of 1980 on Civil Servants.

 

Conclusion

The Regulation’s provisions condition where the Agency is a co-defendant / defendant at a District Court / State’s Administrative Court, however, it fails to regulate provisions should the Agency be a party in the Religious Court. This suggest that the Agency was not careful in drafting the Regulation. This conclusion is supported by Religious court practices, where family and inheritance cases often involve land as the object in dispute.

When Law No.5 of 1960 on Principle Provisions of Agrarian Affairs was still in the form of a bill, there were intentions to establish a Land Court along with its enactment. However, this opinion did not pass the majority of the parliament at that time. Though that idea is not entirely wrong. Some parliament members back in the 1950s saw into the future and saw that land issues would result in a large number of cases. The prediction has been proven to be right, where currently around 65 – 70 percent cases in the Supreme Court are land cases.

The National Land Agency which functions as the regulator and also administrator of Land Affairs, has a function that resembles a Legislative and also an Executive function. With the issuance of the Regulation, it has been re-enforced with additional power, which is the Judicative function, however this judicative power is limited only to mediating parties of a land case dispute/conflict.

Such authority resembles an alternative dispute resolution called mediation, provisioned with Law No.30 of 1999 on Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution, this suggests that any outcome from the mediation process at the Agency would not be final and legally binding, and may be appealed to a court of justice. 

The Regulation also lacks a method to determine the cost of using the Agency to resolve cases, where in using any venue to resolve a dispute the cost incurred is inevitable. It is expected that the Agency will issue a specific regulation on using the Agency as a venue to resolve land cases.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info