A draft Guidelines on the implementation of Article 19(d) of Law No. 5 of 1999 on the Prohibition of Monopolistic Practices and Unfair Competition (“Draft Guidelines) was released by the Commission for the Supervision of Business Competition (KPPU).
Article 19(d) of Competition Law addresses discrimanatory practices, in which the issuance of the Draft Guidelines serves to promote fair competition by providing businesses and other stakeholders with a clear understanding of prohibited discriminatory practices, so that they can adapt their practices to conform with the Competition Law.
Chapter III Section 3.2(6) defines unfair competition as competition among enterprises in the production and or marketing of goods and services, which is done in a dishonest or unlawful manner or inhibits competition. Section 3.2(7) defines discriminatory practice as a different act or treatment performed by one business against certain business actors.
Chapter III also distinguishes Article 19(d) from other similar provisions in the Law. Articles 17 and 18 of the Law address similar issues with respect to Monopoly and Monophonic practices. However, there are two main distinctions. First, Article 19 addresses domination of the relevant market to obtain influence over business competitors, while activities in Articles 17 and 18 are not necessarily intended to dominate the market. Second, Article 19 does not require a business to possess a certain market share, while Articles 17 and 18 specifically require a certain share of the relevent market.
Item 3.3.2 stipulates more detailed different paragraphs in Article 19, where distinction is as follow:
|
(a)
|
Hindering and/or blocking certain businesses from conducting the same business activities in the relevant market (elaborated by picture 1) ;
|
|
(b)
|
Activities that bar competitor’s or customers from doing buisness with the competitor (elaborated by picture 2);
|
|
(c)
|
Restricting the circulation and/or sale of goods or services in the relevent market (elaborated by picture 3).
|
Chapter IV explains the analytical process used to determine whether a business entity is engaging in discriminatory practices and provides examples of how the Law will be applied. To prove that an act/treatment is discriminatory, the Commission must first determine the relevent market. Next, the Commission must show that the business has market control/market power in the relevent market. In addition to showing that an act show that there is no reasonable motive for the discriminatory treatment and discriminatory impact/ that an act results in unhealthy competition.
Chapter V addresses sanctions under the Law.KPPU has the authority to impose administrative sanctions against busineses that violate provisions of Article 19. Sanctions can include a order to stop harmful activities, a deterination and payment of compensation, and fines.
The Draft Guidelines is awaiting inputs and critics from stakeholders where it is most likely to receive changes.
......