Overview
Equality before the law should be for everyone. Therefore, no one should be left behind. This principle also applies to disabled persons, especially in Jakarta. Approximately 45.000 citizens of Jakarta are disabled, including physically disabled persons. Disabled persons have the same rights as other citizens. These rights include the right to education and the right to work.
However, many physically disabled persons, especially those who use crutches, or even have to use a wheelchair, cannot earn their rights, since many buildings in Jakarta are not accessible to them. Even if they could, they need to rely on other people to carry them around. For instance, many buildings only have stairs to move from one floor to another. There is no elevator, or even a ramp.
This issue of accessibility for disabled persons is governed by several regulations, from the government and the regional government. This Indonesian Law Digest will elaborate on this issue based on the prevailing laws and regulations.
Purpose
Indonesia’s vision is to create a prosperous nation. Physically disabled persons are part of this vision; therefore they have the same position, rights, duties, and roles as other Indonesian citizens.
The prevailing laws and regulations need to protect them, since the number of physically disabled persons tends to increase from time to time. If physically disabled persons are not protected, i.e. they can not get a job because of their condition, there will be a social welfare problem, since they cannot be hired and earn their own income.
Physically disabled persons will have to rely on other people all their life, if they are not protected by laws and regulations.
Legal Framework
Indonesia protects disabled persons by law. Law No. 4 of 1997 on Disabled Persons (Disabled Persons Law) regulates the rights and duties of disabled persons, including accessibility. Provisions of the Disabled Persons Law are implemented by other laws and regulations.
The related laws and regulations on the issue of accessibility for physically disabled persons are:
|
-
|
Law No. 28 of 2002 on Buildings
|
|
-
|
Government Regulation No. 43 of 1998 on Social Welfare Improvement for Disabled Persons
|
|
-
|
Regional Regulation No. 7 of 2010 on Buildings
|
Definitions
The Disabled Persons Law, under Article 1 (1) defines disabled persons as those who have a physical or mental disability, which makes them unable to do some activities. Disabled persons include: physically disabled persons; mentally disabled persons; and also physically and mentally disabled persons.
Physically disabled persons are those who have a disability in their body parts. For instance: a full-body movement disability; visual impairment; hearing impairment; or speech impairment.
Additionally, pursuant to Article 1 (4), accessibility for disabled persons is defined as the accommodations provided for disabled persons to create equality in every aspect of life.
These aspects of life include, religion, health, education, social, labor, economy, public service, law, culture, politics, defense and security, sports, recreation, and information.
Accessibility
The Disabled Persons Law regulates accessibility under Article 10. Pursuant to Article 10 (1), accessibility is the way to create the equal opportunity for disabled persons in every aspect of life. Accessibility, pursuant to Article 10 (2), also aims to create a friendlier environment, so that disabled persons can socialize easily.
Additionally, Article 10 (3) states that accessibility will be provided by the government and or the public. It will be conducted in a comprehensive, integrated, and continuous way.
Furthermore, accessibility is also regulated under Government Regulation (Peraturan Pemerintah/PP) No. 43 of 1998 on Social Welfare Improvement for Disabled Persons (PP 43/1998).
Pursuant to Article 8 of the PP 43/1998, accessibility should be provided in every public facility and infrastructure that is operated by the government and or the public. This means that every building that is open to the public such as schools (public and private), offices (public and private), malls, and so forth, should provide accessibility for disabled persons.
Additionally, Article 10 of the PP 43/1998 states that accessibility can be provided physically or non-physically. Physical and non-physical accessibility are elaborated on in Article 11.
Physical accessibility, pursuant to Article 11 (1) of the PP 43/1998, includes: accessibility to public buildings (elaborated on in Article 12); accessibility on public roads (elaborated on in Article 13); accessibility in public gardens and cemeteries (elaborated on in Article 14); and accessibility on public transportation (elaborated on in Article 15).
The term “public buildings”, defined in Article 11 (1), does not only mean government-owned buildings. It also includes buildings that are built and opened for the public/citizens. Therefore, privately owned buildings, such as malls, offices, and private schools (except for houses), should also provide accessibility for disabled persons.
Meanwhile, non-physical accessibilities are stated in Article 11 (2), including information services (elaborated on in Article 16) and special services (elaborated on in Article 17).
Accessibility in Public Buildings
Indonesia’s Law No. 28 of 2002 on Buildings (Buildings Law) regulates the provision to establish a building. Article 7 (3) of the Buildings Law states that every building should comply with reliability requirements. These reliability requirements are regulated under Article 16 (1), and include safety, health, comfort and ease of access requirements.
Accessibility for disabled persons is regulated under Article 27 (2) of the Buildings Law. This article states that every building should have an easy, secure, and comfortable facility in order for disabled persons to have easy access from, to, and inside the building.
Pursuant to Article 29 (1) of the Buildings Law, every building should provide stairs, ramps, and elevators inside the building for disabled persons. The Buildings Law pursuant to Article 31, however, excludes houses (dwellings) from these requirements.
Moreover, under PP 43/1998, every building should provide facilities for disabled persons, such as:
|
a.
|
access to, from, and inside the building;
|
|
b.
|
special doors, stairs, and elevators for multi-story buildings;
|
|
c.
|
parking lot and passenger drop-off;
|
|
d.
|
restrooms;
|
|
e.
|
public phones;
|
|
f.
|
emergency warnings;
|
|
g.
|
signage.
|
At the lower level of regulations, accessibility for disabled persons is regulated by the Special Capital Territory of Jakarta Regulation (Peraturan Daerah/Perda) No. 7 of 2010 on Buildings (Perda 7/2010).
Article 100 of the Perda 7/2010 states that, every building intended for public interests should comply with the facility and accessibility requirements for disabled persons.
The facilities for disabled persons, pursuant to Article 107 of the Perda 7/2010, are quite similar to the PP 43/1998:
|
a.
|
restrooms;
|
|
b.
|
public phones;
|
|
c.
|
parking lot;
|
|
d.
|
guidelines;
|
|
e.
|
signs and markers;
|
|
f.
|
doors;
|
|
g.
|
ramps;
|
|
h.
|
stairs;
|
|
i.
|
elevators.
|
Article 107 of the Perda 7/2010 also excludes houses (dwellings) from these requirements.
Sanctions
The requirements stated in the Disabled Persons Law, Building Law, PP 43/1998, and Perda 7/2010, are mandatory. Therefore, sanctions could be given to those that do not comply with the prevailing laws and regulations.
Pursuant to Article 29 of the Disabled Persons Law, every party that does not provide accessibility for disabled persons will be subject to administrative sanctions.
Under Article 45 (1) of the Buildings Law, administrative sanctions that could be given are, for instance:
|
a.
|
a written warning;
|
|
b.
|
restrictions on the activities;
|
|
c.
|
a revocation of the certificate of worthiness of the building structure;
|
|
d.
|
building demolition orders.
|
Perda 7/2010 also includes similar sanctions as the Buildings Law. For example:
|
a.
|
a written warning;
|
|
b.
|
restrictions on the activities;
|
|
c.
|
revocation of the permit to establish a building (izin mendirikan bangunan/IMB);
|
|
d.
|
imposition of fines.
|
Conclusion
The prevailing laws and regulations mandate every owner of the building to provide accessibility for disabled persons. Sanctions could be given for violations of the prevailing laws and regulations.
However, the enforcement of these laws and regulations is weak. Many buildings, especially in Jakarta do not comply with the requirements. Offices, malls, and schools are not friendly to disabled persons. There are no proper stairs, elevators, and ramps to allow disabled persons to access buildings.
The sanctions permitted under the laws and regulations should be implemented by officials against buildings that do not comply with the prevailing laws and regulations. Subsequently, disabled persons could also enjoy the same facilities as any other citizens.
......