Overview
Bankruptcy and suspension of payment in Indonesia are regulated under Law No. 37 of 2004 on Bankruptcy and Suspension of Payment (‘Bankruptcy Law’), which revokes the previous bankruptcy regulations (i.e. Faillissements-verordening Staatsblad 1905:217 juncto Staatsblad 1906:348 and Law No. 4 of 1998). The general purpose of the bankruptcy law is to provide legal certainty and fairness, for both the debtor and creditor, in debt repayment of the debtor.
Bankruptcy is defined as a general statutory attachment upon all of the debtor’s assets, in which the assets are controlled and settled by a receiver under the supervision of the supervisory judge (Article 1 (1)). The debtor's assets are liquidated in order to pay the creditors, and creditors are paid according to the rank of their claims. It should be noted that under Bankruptcy Law, the debtor has no capacity to control his assets following a bankruptcy declaration, however, the personal status of the debtor will not be affected by the bankruptcy (personal debtor’s are not placed under guardianship, and if the debtor is a legal entity, it will still be able to run its business).
Beside settlement through bankruptcy proceedings, the debt repayment could also be settled through the mechanism of suspension of payment (penundaan kewajiban pembayaran utang). The purpose of a suspension of payment is to avoid liquidating the debtor’s assets by rearranging debt repayment through a composition plan or to a certain extent, a debt restructuring. Through this mechanism, the debtor still has another chance to earn a profit in order to pay its debt as well as recover its financial standing.
This ILD will explain the Commercial Court’s (‘Court’) bankruptcy and suspension of payment proceedings and provide details about conducting each of these proceedings in Indonesia.
Bankruptcy Proceeding
Requirements for Bankruptcy Declaration
The Court may declare a debtor bankrupt if there are at least 2 (two) creditors and the debtor has not paid at least 1 (one) debt that is due and payable (Article 2(1)).
Bankruptcy Petition Filing
The bankruptcy petition may be submitted by: (i) a debtor, (ii) a public prosecutor (for the purpose of public interest), (iii) Bank Indonesia (if the debtor is a bank), (iv) the Capital Market and Financial Institutions Supervisory Body (Bapepam-LK) (if the debtor is a securities company, stock exchange, Clearing and Securities Institution, or Depository and Settlement Agency) and (v) the Minister of Finance (if the debtor is an insurance company, reinsurance company, pension fund, or state owned company that engage its business for the public interest) (Article 2).
The bankruptcy petition is submitted to the Head of Court that covers the jurisdiction of the legal domicile of the debtor. The registrar will provide a written receipt when the petition is registered on the date of submission.
The bankruptcy petition must be submitted along with the following documents:
|
-
|
a bankruptcy petition signed by the petitioner and its advocate;
|
|
-
|
a copy of the advocate’s license;
|
|
-
|
a special power of attorney that authorizes the advocate to file the bankruptcy petition on behalf of the petitioner;
|
|
-
|
a copy of the petitioner’s articles of association(should the petitioner be a legal entity);
|
|
-
|
a copy of the debtor’s corporate documents (including the debtor’s articles of association and other supporting documents);
|
|
-
|
an original document that provides evidence of the petitioner’s claim on the debtor.
|
The hearing must be conducted within 20 days of the latest date of submission. To a certain extent, the Court may suspend the hearing up to 25 days from the date the petition is submitted, at the debtor’s request (Articles 6(6) and (7)).
To protect the creditor’s interest, each creditor, public prosecutor, Bank Indonesia, Bapepam-LK, or Minister of Finance may submit a request for a conservatory attachment and appoint an interim receiver, as long as the court has not rendered a declaration. (Article 10 (1)).
Bankruptcy Declaration
A bankruptcy declaration must be rendered within 60 days of the petition’s submission and read out in a court hearing open to public. It should be noted that a bankruptcy declaration has an immediate effect, which means the decision is enforceable without being subject to any decision of a higher court related to legal remedy (i.e. cassation or petition for reconsideration).
In the bankruptcy declaration, the Court will appoint a receiver and supervisory judge. The receiver is authorized to control and/or manage the settlement of the debtor’s assets on the date the bankruptcy declaration is rendered (Article 16 (1)).
Within 3 days of the bankruptcy judgment, the Court shall deliver a copy of the judgment (which contains the legal consideration and dissenting opinion) to the debtor, petitioner, receiver, and supervisory judge (Article 9). At the latest, 5 days after the receiver and supervisory judge receive the bankruptcy judgment, the receiver shall announce, in at least in 2 daily newspapers, matters related to the bankruptcy judgment, including:
|
-
|
the name, address, and occupation of the debtor;
|
|
-
|
the name of the supervisory judge;
|
|
-
|
the name, address, and occupation of the receiver;
|
|
-
|
the names, addresses, and occupations of members of the interim creditors’ committee (if already appointed); and
|
|
-
|
the time and venue of the first creditor’s meeting (Article 15 (4)).
|
Legal Remedies
The legal remedies available upon a declaration of bankruptcy are cassation and petition for reconsideration. The petition of cassation must be submitted to the Court within 8 days of the declaration of bankruptcy. The petition of cassation can be submitted by (i) the debtor, (ii) creditors who are a party in the lower court proceeding, or (iii) un-satisfied creditors who are not parties to the lower court proceeding.
The losing party must submit a notice of cassation on the date the cassation is registered. The registrar will deliver the petition of cassation together with the notice of cassation to the defendant within 2 days of registering the petition. After receiving the notice of cassation, the defendant has 7 days to submit a counter notice of cassation, and the registrar will deliver such notice to the claimant within 2 days of receiving the counter notice of cassation (Article 12).
The registrar will submit the petition of cassation, notice of cassation and counter notice of cassation together with the brief of the case to the Supreme Court at the latest 14 days after the petition of cassation is registered.
The hearing of the cassation must be conducted at the latest 20 days after the Supreme Court receives the petition of cassation and the decision of the cassation shall be rendered within 60 (sixty) days of the Supreme Court’s receipt of the petition of cassation.
A petition for reconsideration may be submitted upon the decision of a petition of declaration of bankruptcy, which has become final and binding. The procedures for cassation shall be applied in the same manner as the procedures of civil review (Article 14 (2)).
Post Bankruptcy Declaration
Claim Submission and Creditors’ Meeting
Within 14 days of the bankruptcy declaration, the supervisory judge shall stipulate:
|
-
|
a deadline for claim submission;
|
|
-
|
a deadline for tax verification to determine tax amounts pursuant to the prevailing tax laws and regulations;
|
|
-
|
schedules for the first creditors’ meeting to verify claims.
|
At least 5 days after the supervisory judge determines the matters above, the receiver shall notify known creditors of the schedule for the creditors meeting’, by registered mail or courier, and publish such notification in at least 2 daily newspapers (Article 114). Bankruptcy Law requires the first creditors’ meeting to be held within 30 days of the bankruptcy declaration (Article 86 (1)).
The receiver shall provide a copy of the list of claims to the Court’s registrar for public access at least 7 days prior to the first creditors’ meeting. (Article 119). This list of claims is subject to verification to determine the value of the claim and discussion of any objection related to the claim. To a certain extent, the supervisory judge may suspend the meeting and continue the meeting within 8 days of the first creditor’s meeting without issuing a summons.
Submission of Composition Plan (if any)
The debtor is entitled to propose a composition plan to the creditors. The offered composition could be submitted to the Court’s registrar and shall be available for 8 days prior the creditors’ meeting. To a certain extent, the creditors’ meeting could be suspended for a period of 21 days to further discuss the offered composition plan (Article 147).
The offered composition plan shall be approved if the stipulated quorum is reached. If the offered composition plan is approved, the supervisory judge shall stipulate the hearing date. The hearing shall be held at least 8 days, and 14 days at the latest, after the composition plan is approved. The Court shall render its decision to grant or reject the ratification of the approved composition plan with its legal opinion within 7 days of the hearing date.
If the Court approves the ratification, the bankruptcy is terminated and the receiver shall announce the bankruptcy in the State Gazette and at least 2 daily newspapers. On the other hand, if the Court rejects the ratification of the approved composition plan, the bankrupt estate is in a state of insolvency (the debtor is no longer able to offer another composition plan).
State of Insolvency and Settlement of Assets
The assets of the debtor, by law, will be in a state of insolvency if: (i) no composition plan is offered, (ii) the offered composition plan has not been approved, or (iii) ratification of the approved composition plan is rejected by the Court and such decision is final and binding (Article 178 (1)).
After the debtor’s assets are in a state of insolvency, the supervisory judge may hold a creditors’ meeting to discuss the settlement of assets and the verification process for a creditor who submits their claim after a period of time stipulated by the supervisory judge (Article 187). All assets of the debtor shall be sold through a public auction or, to a certain extent, through a private sale (by prior approval from the supervisory judge).
The receiver shall prepare a distribution list, subject to prior approval from the supervisory judge, which contains details about income and expenses, including the receiver’s fee, names of creditors, verified amounts of claims, and the portion received by the creditors. The supervisory judge determines the portion received by unsecured creditors (Article 189 (3)).
It should be noted that a secured creditor (who holds in rem security rights) is obliged to enforce his rights against the debtor’s collateral within the 2 month period following the commencement of insolvency. If the secured creditor does not exercise his rights within the given period of time, the receiver shall make a request to sell the collateral pursuant to provisions of the Bankruptcy Law. The secured creditor will lose his preferred status, but may submit a claim for any underpayment from the sale proceeds, and will have the same position as unsecured creditors.
Suspension of Payment (‘SOP’)
SOP Petition Submission and Provisional SOP Declaration
In the event that the debtor cannot repay or foresees (or the creditor(s) foresee) that the debtor will not be able to repay its due and payable debt, the debtor or its creditor(s) may submit a SOP petition to the Court. In a SOP proceeding, the debtor shall submit a composition plan, which offers payment of all or part of its debt to creditors (secured and unsecured creditors).
As in a bankruptcy proceeding, the SOP petition is submitted to the Head of Court that covers the jurisdiction of the legal domicile of the debtor, and shall be signed by the petitioner and his advocates. The registrar will provide a written receipt when the petition is registered on the date of submission.
If the debtor initiates the petition, the SOP petition shall be submitted along with a list of debts, receivables (including their nature) of the debtor, and other supporting documents as evidence. Within 3 days of registering the petition, the Court shall grant a provisional SOP and appoint a supervisory judge and 1 or more administrators to manage assets of the debtor (Article 225 (2)).
On the other hand, if the creditors initiate the petition, the debtor shall prepare a similar list of debts, receivables, and composition plan (if any) in the hearing, after being summoned (at least 7 days before the hearing date) by the Court. Within 20 days of registering the petition, the Court shall grant the provisional SOP and appoint a supervisory judge and 1 or more administrators to manage assets of the debtor (Article 225 (3)).
Following the grant of a provisional SOP, the administrator shall announce the decision in the State Gazette and at least 2 daily newspapers determined by the supervisory judge. The announcement shall also contain an invitation to attend the hearing, name of the supervisory judge, and address of the administrator (Article 226 (1). The administrator shall also notify all creditors known to him in writing by registered mail or by courier. The composition plan, if it has already been submitted when the provisional SOP is granted, shall also be mentioned in such announcement at least 21 days before the scheduled hearing (Article 226 (2)).
The provisional SOP will be valid for 45 days or an earlier date subject to a subsequent hearing held by the Court. In the event that the debtor is not present at the hearing, the Court will declare the debtor bankrupt (Article 225 (4) and (5)).
It should be noted that in the event that the SOP petition and the bankruptcy petition are both pending before the Court at the same time, the Bankruptcy Law requires the SOP petition to be decided first.
Prior to Judge’s Deliberation Meeting
Before the scheduled hearing is held, the supervisory judge shall determine:
|
-
|
a deadline for the creditors to submit their claims to the administrator; and
|
|
-
|
a meeting to discuss and vote on the proposed composition plan.
|
It should be noted that there is at least a 14 day period between the deadline to submit the creditor’s claims and the said meeting. As mentioned above, judges may take up to 45 days to deliberate, between granting the provisional SOP and the hearing, to determine whether to grant a permanent SOP.
The administrator shall review the submitted claims and prepare a list of claims that includes the names and addresses of the creditors, the amount of claims, a brief explanation of the claim, and whether it is disputable by the administrators. This list of claims shall be available at Court’s registrar for public inspection 7 days prior to the meeting of creditors (Article 276).
During the creditor’s meeting, the creditors may be present themselves or represented by a proxy (authorized by a written power of attorney). The agenda of this meeting is to discuss and vote on the composition plan proposed by the debtor. A copy of minutes of the meeting shall be available within 3 days of the creditor’s meeting.
Judge’s Deliberation Meeting and Permanent SOP
In the judge’s deliberation meeting, the Court shall hear the debtor, supervisory judge, administrator, and the creditors present at the meeting (or represented by proxy with an authorized power of attorney). If the debtor has submitted a proposed composition plan along with the submission of a SOP petition, voting may be conducted (Article 228 (3)).
If the composition plan has not been submitted or if the creditors are not able to cast their vote, upon a request of the debtor, the creditors shall decide whether to grant a permanent SOP or reject the permanent SOP (Article 228 (4)). If the creditors agree to convert the provisional SOP to a permanent SOP, such postponement shall not elapse from 270 days since the provisional SOP was granted, otherwise the debtor will be declared bankrupt (Article 228 (6) and 230 (1)). On the other hand, if the creditors reject the petition for a permanent SOP, the debtor will be declared bankrupt (Article 230 (1)).
Approval of the Composition Plan and Ratification by the Court
Pursuant to Article 281 (1), the composition plan is accepted by a proper vote, if:
|
-
|
approved by (i) more than half of the unsecured creditors, who are present or represented at the meeting, and whose rights are acknowledged or temporarily acknowledged and (ii) unsecured creditors, representing two-thirds of the total amount of unsecured claims, who are present or represented at the meeting, and whose rights are acknowledged or temporarily acknowledged; and
|
|
-
|
approved by (i) more than half of the secured creditors, who are present or represented at the meeting and represent at least two-thirds of the total amount of the claims of such secured creditors who are present or represented at the meeting.
|
Secured creditors who do not approve the composition plan, will be given compensation equal to the secured amounts or the actual amount of the loans that are directly secured by in rem rights, whichever is less (Article 281 (2).
If the composition plan is approved, the supervisory judge must submit a written report to the Court and schedule a hearing to ratify the composition plan (Article 284 (1)). Subject to any postponement, the hearing must be conducted within 14 days of scheduling the hearing (Article 284 (3)).
The Court shall render its decision to grant or reject ratification of the approved composition plan. If the Court grants the ratification, the composition plan shall bind all creditors (except for creditors that do not approve the composition plan). The SOP is terminated when the decision on the ratification of the approved composition plan has binding legal force and the administrator shall announce this termination in the State Gazette and at least 2 daily newspapers.
However, if the Court rejects the ratification, in the same hearing, the Court shall also declare the debtor bankrupt and such decision must be announced in the State Gazette and at least 2 daily newspapers not more than 5 days after the decision is received by the supervisory judge and receiver (Article 285 (3)).
The settlement process following a bankruptcy declaration shall also apply in the same manner in this SOP proceeding.
Legal Remedy
Except for a petition for reconsideration, no legal remedy is available against the decision of the Court in a SOP proceeding. The cassation should only be submitted by the attorney general for the purpose of legal interest (Article 293 (2)).
The petition for reconsideration should only be submitted if:
|
-
|
there is new evidence following the decision of the Court, and such new evidence is determinative in nature and already existed during the examination of the case but was unknown at the time; or
|
|
-
|
there is an absolute failure in the judge’s decision.
|
If new evidence is the ground to submit a petition for reconsideration, the petition shall be submitted within 180 days of the latest lower court decision that has binding legal force. However, if an absolute failure in the judge’s decision is the ground for submitting a petition for reconsideration, the petition shall be submitted within 30 days of a lower court decision that has binding legal force (Article 296 (1) and (2)).
The petition for reconsideration shall be submitted to the Court’s registrar and the registrar will provide a written receipt when the petition is registered on the date of submission. The Court’s registrar will deliver the petition for reconsideration within 2 days of registering the petition.
The losing party/claimant must submit evidence that supports its petition to the Court’s registrar, and has 2 days to deliver with the evidence and the petition of civil review to the defendant after the petition is registered. The defendant could submit a response to the civil review petition up to 10 days after the civil review petition is registered. Subsequently, the Court’s registrar shall deliver the response of the defendant to the Supreme Court’s registrar within 12 days at the latest since the petition was registered.
The Supreme Court shall examine and render its decision upon the civil review petition up to 30 days after the petition is received by the Supreme Court’s registrar and deliver copy of the decision up to 32 days after the petition is received by the Supreme Court’s registrar (Article 298). The decision shall be read out in a court hearing open to public.
......