Overview
The Bill on Geospatial Information (“Law”) was passed by the House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR) on 5 April 2011, a little over a year after being submitted to the DPR (16/2/2010). Although the Law has now been passed, it can take up to a further 2 years before it is fully implemented (Article 70).
In accordance with Law No. 10 of 2004 on the Formation of Laws and Regulations, the date of enactment will be within 30 days of the Law’s passage, or when signed by the President, whichever is the earliest. At that time the Law will be assigned a number.
It should be noted that geospatial information in Indonesia has never been subject to a regulatory framework at the level of a law. Historically, basic geospatial information and thematic geospatial information are based on information collected during the Dutch colonial era, which has over time been updated by different institutions, both government and private, for their own purposes.
It is evident that geospatial information in Indonesia is often inaccurate, with multiple cases of the government issuing mining concessions as well as oil and gas drilling permits relying on inaccurate geospatial information. Notably, Freeport was granted a mining concession for copper, but was later alleged to be mining more of gold than copper, a mineral that is significantly higher in value.
A similar case is Exxon Mobil and the Cepu Blok, where it was reported that Exxon utilized high-tech geospatial satellite information to locate a large quantity of oil reserves in the Cepu Blok, while Indonesia relied on a different set of geospatial information. Resulting in bargaining over different quantity of oil reserves in the production sharing agreement.
The Law itself provides more than a legal framework in acquiring accurate geospatial data for decision and policy making, it also stipulates the establishment of a government institution that will ensure the administration of national geospatial information, and the process of how geospatial information is acquired and distributed.
This edition of Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the Law and provide analysis of its provisions.
Purpose
Geospatial Information is essential for Indonesia as a supporting system, where it serves to ensure that decision making on the development of the economy, social, culture and national defense will be accurate.
Specifically, geospatial information enables more accurate decision making regarding the management of natural resources, planning development areas, planning investment locations, determining land boundaries and developing the tourism industry, assisting disaster mitigation, and ensuring environmental sustainability.
With the passage of the Law, a single reference for geospatial information would be established for the geospatial information industry.
Definitions
Geospatial information is often misperceived by laymen as merely being Geographic information and mapping of the earth’s surface, where in fact the term is wider than this.
The Law defines Geospatial Information as data on geographical information, dimensions or size, and/or the characteristics of natural resources and/or man-made objects, which exist under, on, or above the land surface (Article 1 (3)).
Pursuant to Article 4, Geospatial Information is classified as:
|
1.
|
Basic Geospatial Information (Informasi Geospasial Dasar / IGD), defined in Article 1 (5) as Geospatial Information that consists of objects that can be seen directly or measured from the physical appearance on the earth’s surface and which are unchangeable in the long run; and
|
|
2.
|
Thematic Geospatial Information (Informasi Geospasial Tematik / IGT), defined in Article 1 (6) as Geospatial Information that focuses on one or more specific themes and refers to the IGD.
|
A common example of geospatial information is Google Earth/Maps and auto vehicle navigation systems (GPS). Google Earth/Maps provides 3 dimensional visual information to users, and additional information of certain location of streets, business districts, forest areas, housing areas and streets. Auto vehicle navigation systems provide direction information to drivers from the point of departure to the destination using the Global Positioning System (GPS).
Applicability
Geospatial Information is classified as Basic Geospatial Information (IGD), which can only be provided by the Government (Article 22), and Thematic Geospatial Information (IGT), which can be provided by the Government or by private entities (Article 23), pursuant to Article 4.
End users of Geospatial Information, pursuant to Article 49, are protected with regards to the supplied information, whereas they have the right to refuse the provided geospatial information if the result is of poor quality and does not meet the metadata and/or history data formats determined by the Head of the soon to be established Geospatial Information Agency.
Providing Geospatial Information
Pursuant to Article 55, private persons or groups of people wishing to provide Geospatial Information, are required to poses the required competency to provide geospatial information, in accordance with the prevailing laws and regulations.
If private persons or a group of people are embodied in a legal entity, the legal entity must comply with both the Administrative and the Technical requirements (Article 56 (1)). As set out in Article 56 (2), the administrative requirements are:
|
a.
|
Deed of establishment, and
|
|
b.
|
Business license.
|
Technical requirements, pursuant to Article 56 (2), are:
|
a.
|
Certificate that meets the classification and qualification as a geospatial information provider, and
|
|
b.
|
Employs certified professionals in the field of geospatial information.
|
Since the Law is a regulatory framework for Geospatial Information, further implementing regulations on administrative and technical requirements will be issued at a later date.
Organizing Geospatial Information
In order to ensure that a single reference set of geospatial information is established so as to ensure that end users will acquire accurate, credible, and accountable for information, organizing of geospatial information, pursuant to Article 25, is divided into the following phases:
|
a.
|
Collection of Geospatial Data (further stipulated in Chapter V Part Two),
|
|
b.
|
Processing of Geospatial Data and Geospatial Information (further stipulated in Chapter V Part Three),
|
|
c.
|
Storing and Securing Geospatial Data and Geospatial Information (further stipulated in Chapter V Part Four),
|
|
d.
|
Dissemination of Geospatial Data and Geospatial Information (further stipulated in Chapter V Part Five),
|
|
e.
|
The use of Geospatial Information (further stipulated in Chapter V Part Six).
|
Collection
Since geospatial databases are gathered from variety of sources, such as previously available Basic Geospatial Information or data that derives from images taken from airplanes, satellites, or surveyors directly in the field.
Article 27 (2) sets a standard for acquiring information. Which includes complying with the standards of the geospatial reference system, types, criteria, and data formats that will be later determined by the Head of the soon to be established Geospatial Information Agency.
Article 28 sets out permission that must be obtained for collecting data, if the area where the data is being collected is located in a prohibited area, or if the act of collection of the data/information can have a hazardous effect on the collector (stipulated further in Article 29), or if collected by foreign owned vehicles (airplane and vessels, but not satellites).
Processing
Article 31 contains an Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) protection provision, where the processing of geospatial data and geospatial information must be by means of licensed and/or open source software.
Acquired geospatial data is prioritized to be processed in Indonesia (Article 32 (1)), with the possibility of processing abroad only being available after receiving approval from the soon to be established Geospatial Information Agency.
The standard for the processed data/information must meet the criteria of the soon to be established Geospatial Information Agency (Article 34), where it must comprise of:
|
a.
|
A projection system and coordinate system that is clear and is able to be converted to the national coordinate standard system (Article 34 (1) (a),
|
|
b.
|
A format, database, and metadata that are easily integrated with other geospatial information (Article 34 (1) (b)).
|
Storing and Securing
To ensure that the acquired geospatial data and information is available to the users and is not lost or damaged, Article 38 requires that geospatial information be archived electronically or in print.
Dissemination
Pursuant to Article 41 and Article 42, geospatial information is classified as i) open information and ii) restricted information. In essence both Basic and Thematic Geospatial Information that is produced by government is categorized as open information, although certain Thematic Geospatial Information may be categorized as being restricted information should the prevailing laws and regulations so require (Article 43 (2)).
For example, Article 43 (2) suggests that Thematic Geospatial Information produced by military institutions for military purposes is categorized as restricted information.
Usage of Geospatial Information
Gathering geospatial information requires substantial investment, manpower, and the use of advanced technology to ensure its availability and accuracy. Although Basic Geospatial Information is categorized as open information, Article 48 stipulates that a fee can be charged to the user.
Specific provisions regarding privately provided geospatial information do not exist under the Law, with Article 48 suggesting that private providers can decide their fees based on mutual consent with the user as provisioned under Article 1338 of the Civil Code. Except in the case where the user is the government and the purpose is for disaster mitigation (Article 52).
Article 49 stipulates the rights of the users over the requested geospatial information.
Copyrights
Article 50 prohibits outright extraction and reutilization of the whole or substantial part of the contents of the geospatial information/data. In order to be able to do so, the extractor or the re-utilizor, must first obtain permission from the information owner before commencing its intention to produce a derivate product that contains geospatial information/data that is not lawfully theirs.
Although intellectual property rights in Indonesia are considered not to be well developed, especially when it comes to databases that are categorized as copyright, as meant in Article 12 (1 L) Of Law No. 19 of 2002. The sui generis rights over a database have been assumingly taken into consideration when formulating Article 50.
Sui generis rights over a database are defined as those of the maker of the database (the party that provided the investment necessary to compile the database) and comprise of the exclusive right to prevent unauthorized extraction and reutilization of the whole or a substantial part of the content of the database (the sui generis rights), which can be licensed or sold to third parties. Further discussion regarding sui generis rights can be found in a paper by Charlotte Waelde titled Databases and lawful users: the chink in the armour, published by Intellectual Property Quarterly, 2006.
Although it can be expected that there will be legal issues arising regarding whether data that has been extracted and reutilized becomes the property of the original acquirer, or the parties who have modified the data for their own purposes. Leaving also a question as to what extent can the data owner limit the extraction and reutilization of their acquired geospatial information that is categorized as database, since the law on Intellectual Property Rights does not contain provisions of such specificity, leaving it at a requirement for permission from the database owner to be present.
Nonetheless, restrictions on alteration of certain information under Article 58 exists, where data that can not be altered is the National Horizontal Net Control (Jaring Kontrol Horizontal Nasional/JKHN), the National Vertical Net Control (Jaring Kontrol Vertikal Nasional/JKVN), and National Gravity Net Control (Jaring Kontrol Gaya berat Nasional/JKGN) and other survey instruments.
Supervision
Supervision of the providers and users of geospatial information will be under the authority of the soon to be established Geospatial Information Agency (Article 69 (2)). During the transition period (3 years) supervision will be the responsibility of the National Agency for Surveys and Mapping (Badan Koordinasi Survei dan Pemetaan Nasional / Bakosurtanal).
Supervision of geospatial information providers and users is stipulated in Article 57, whereby a further Government Regulation will address such supervision.
Sanctions
The law provides administrative (Chapter 9) and criminal (Chapter 10) sanctions. Of most concern to information providers are the provisions contained in Article 61 in conjunction with Article 67.
Where inaccuracies in supplied geospatial information result in damages to the users, the provider will be subject to imprisonment of up to 3 years, or a fine of up to IDR 750 million. Supporting this, a provider, pursuant to Article 8 (1) of Law No.8 of 1999 on Consumer Protection is prohibited, as a producer, from producing products and/or services that do not comply with the standards that are required by the prevailing laws and regulations
Article 61 would appear to apply to such cases as where a driver relies on their in-car navigation system leading to an accident, such as driving into a body of water, or a wall. As well as cellular users who subscribe to geospatial information for location of medical facilities for emergency purposes, but fail to locate a hospital or clinic due to the inaccuracy of the provided geospatial information.
The provisions contained in Article 61 are a double edged sword, where they serve to ensure that accurate and high quality information is provided to users, but at the same time add to the cost of providing geospatial information.
Conclusion
A widely known use of geospatial information by a wide range of people is “Google Maps” and Wikimapia, both of which are classified as open information and are free to be accessed. A wider range of geospatial information, such as more detailed topographic maps or natural resource surveys, is available at a cost and is commonly classified as restricted information.
The accuracy of such freely available sources as Google Maps and Wikimapia is far from reliable, since it is often acquired from satellite imagery that does not contain geometric information and requires geo correction. Nonetheless, if a party were to rely on this type of geospatial information and incur damages, regardless of whether the information was acquired without cost, the provider would be criminally liable.
Since it will take up to 2 years for the Law to be fully implemented, it is expected that during this time the Geospatial Information Agency will be established, and a number of implementing regulations will be issued to ensure the execution of the Law’s provisions.
......