Overview
The Bill on Immigration (“Law”) has been passed by the House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat / DPR) on 7 April 2011, serving to repeal and replace Law No. 9 of 1992 on the same subject matter (“Previous Law”).
Considering that it has been 19 years since the enactment of the Previous Law, a number of laws that are directly related to immigration matters have changed and evolved to deal with a number of otherwise unaddressed issues relating to immigration.
In 2006, Law No. 62 of 1958 on Indonesian Citizenship was replaced by Law No. 12 of 2006 on the same subject matter, regulating the possibility to acquire temporary dual citizenship for children of mixed marriages, relieving mixed marriage children from the requirement to secure a residence permit.
Later, Law No. 25 of 1997 on Labor replaced Law No.14 of 1969 on General Provisions on Manpower, and was, in 2003, replaced by Law No. 13 of 2003 on Labor. Under the 2003 Labor Law, new provisions were introduced for both Indonesian and foreign workers (expatriates), involving the Directorate General of Immigration, the authority which issues stay permits and exit permits, and travel documents.
There is also the enactment of Law No. 1 of 2009 on Aviation, which repealed and replaced Law No. 15 of 1992 on the same subject matter, and also the issuance of Law No. 17 of 2008 on Shipping, both of which address the movement of people from one country to another.
Additionally, the crime of human trafficking which involves international crime syndicates that know no borders was regulated under Law No. 21 of 2007 on the Eradication of Human Trafficking Crimes. This made human trafficking a special crime, which the 1992 Immigration Law did not address, and considering that the involvement of the Directorate General of Immigration is crucial in its prevention and prosecution.
Other immigration issues such as that spouses in mixed marriages were not well accommodated by the 1992 Immigration Law in acquiring Permanent Resident Permits (Izin Tinggal Tetap / ITAP). And foreign workers and investors that have been residing for over a decade in Indonesia continued to face difficulties in securing an ITAP, as well as the infamous fictitious marriage cases.
The issues mentioned above drove the government and the DPR to view the passage of a new immigration law to replace Law No.12 of 1992 on Immigration Law (“Previous Law”) as a necessity.
This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will provide analysis and highlight the key features of the Law.
Purpose
Fahri Hamzah the head of the committee on the Immigration Bill at the DPR is of the view that the Law was passed for 5 philosophical and sociological reasons:
First, to prevent the misuse of authority. Second, bureaucracy reformation and the development of an effective, efficient, and certain public service. Third, organizational reforms of immigration functions based on information systems and immigration management. Fourth, to modernize the security approach towards respecting basic human rights. Fifth, to advance peoples’ welfare by supporting investment, tourism and encouraging Indonesia’s socio-cultural relationship with the international community.
Applicability
The Law in essence applies to any individual who enters and departs Indonesian territory, both for Indonesian and foreign citizens, regardless of the stay or departure reasons, whether for diplomatic, state, business, work, leisure, or family visit purposes.
The Law also applies to visa sponsors. And transportation operators, pursuant to Article 17, whereby they are required to prevent violations of immigration procedures.
Entry Permits
To enter Indonesian territory, a foreigner must secure a valid travel document and a visa from an appointed Indonesian immigration official in Indonesia and/or abroad (Articles 8 and 9). And, upon providing a complete document when entering Indonesia, an entry permit will be issued (Article 10).
Reasons for denial
Those providing travel documents (Passport and Visa) can still be denied entry under the Article 13 reasons:
|
a.
|
Their name is blacklisted to enter Indonesia
|
|
b.
|
Absence of a valid travelling document (elaborated further in Article 24)
|
|
c.
|
Holding a counterfeit passport
|
|
d.
|
Providing incorrect/fabricated information when acquiring a Visa
|
|
e.
|
Suffering from an infectious decease which threatens public health
|
|
f.
|
Involved in transnational/international crime or organized crime
|
|
g.
|
Listed on the wanted list of another country
|
|
h.
|
Involved in an activity to overthrow the Indonesian government
|
|
i.
|
Involved in a prostitution or a human trafficking network
|
It is worth to note that the Previous Law (Article 8 of the Previous Law) did not include reasons in points f, g, h, and i, above.
Blacklist (Daftar Penangkalan)
Defined in Article 1 (29), blacklisitng (Daftar Penangkalan) is defined as a restriction to enter Indonesian territory for immigration reasons. A request to include a foreigner is stipulated in Article 100, where a request will be granted 3 days after a submission.
A black list would be valid for 6 months and may be extended for the same period of time (Article 102), it is expected that a further implementation regulation on Black list procedure will be issued (Article 103).
Exiting Indonesia
In order to depart from Indonesia, an exit permit is required under Article 14, with the reasons to deny the issuance of an exit permit being:
|
a.
|
Not carrying a valid travelling document (passport)
|
|
b.
|
Required (both foreign and Indonesian citizens) for a criminal investigation if requested by law enforcement officials.
|
|
c.
|
Listed in the prevention list (daftar pencegahan)
|
A notable new provision on foreigners exiting Indonesia is contained in Article 16 (2), stating that foreigners are prohibited from departing from Indonesia should legal obligations in accordance with the prevailing laws and regulations remain unsettled at the time of departure.
Article 16 (2) of the Law allows for an interpretation that foreigners who are parties in a civil lawsuit may be prevented from exiting Indonesia. Chapter III of the Previous Law prevented departure from Indonesia only if legal obligations deriving from public law were unsettled (e.g. immigration, criminal, tax, and national security issues).
Pursuant to Article 75 (1) an immigration officer will administer administrative sanctions, having the provided grounds to deny departure from Indonesia, in Article 91. Pursuant to Article 97 a denial to depart from Indonesia would be valid for 6 months and may be extended for the same period of time without limitation, with the procedure for requesting an exit denial being stipulated in Article 94.
Transportation
Provisioned under Article 17 (3) In conjunction with Article 19 (3), transportation air/sea/land companies are given the authority to deny transport to passengers who do not posses valid travel documents. Failure to do so will result in the the imposition of the transportation costs for the passenger to depart Indonesia (Article 19 (4)).
Visas
Types of visas granted to foreigners are stipulated in Article 34, and include:
|
i)
|
Diplomatic and Official Visas, which are given to diplomatic passport holders or Official Passport holders, whose visits are for foreign government/International organization work or diplomatic work (Articles 36 and 37)
|
|
ii)
|
Visiting Visa, given for purposes of governmental visits, study, social and cultural purposes, tourism, business, family visits, and press related work (Article 38)
|
|
iii)
|
Limited Stay Visa, given to clergy, experts, research workers, students, investors, retirees, and family members (Article 39 (1)). Pursuant to Article 39 (2) a Limited Stay Visa can be granted for cooperation purposes that take place on vessels in Indonesian waters, territorial sea, continental shelf, and the Indonesian Exclusive Economic Zone.
|
Reason for denial of a visa are stipulated in Article 42.
Restrictions on travel to conflict areas
Based on Article 12 in conjunction with Article 48 (4), it is provisioned that foreigners can be prohibited from travelling to certain areas in Indonesia for safety reasons, when an area is considered to be a conflict hotspot.
Article 125 suggests that those that travel to such areas, who commonly include journalists, missionaries, and humanitarian workers, would face imprisonment of up to 3 years and/or an IDR 300 million criminal fine.
Stay Permits
Every foreigner wishing to stay in Indonesia is required to secure a Stay Permit (Izin Tinggal) pursuant to Article 48 (1), with the exception of the Diplomatic and Official Passport holders. The types of Stay Permits are classified into 3 groups:
|
a.
|
Stay Permit for Visiting purposes (Izin Tinggal Kunjungan / ITAK), reasons to grant ITAK are stipulated in Article 50.
|
|
b.
|
Limited Stay Permit (Izin Tinggal Terbatas / ITAS), reasons to grant ITAS are stipulated in Article 52.
|
|
c.
|
Permanent Residence Permit (Izin Tinggal Tetap / ITAP), reasons to grant ITAP are stipulated in Article 54.
|
Limited Stay Permits (ITAS)
A limited stay Permit can be granted for up to a maximum of 2 years (Article 1 of Minister of Law and Human Rights Regulation No. M.01-IZ.01.10 of 2007 on the Second Amendment of Minister of Law and Human Rights Decree No. M.02-IZ.O1.10 of 1995 on Transit Visas, Visiting Visas, Limited Stay Visas, Entry Visas, and Immigration Permits (“Minister Regulation”).
Parties that can acquire an ITAS are set out under Article 52, and include:
|
a.
|
ITAK holders
|
|
b.
|
A child born in Indonesia from an ITAS holder
|
|
c.
|
A foreigner whose ITAK is altered to an ITAS
|
|
d.
|
Vessel crews operating in Indonesian territory
|
|
e.
|
Spouse of an Indonesian citizen
|
|
f.
|
Child from a mixed marriage
|
Permanent Residence (ITAP)
The number of foreigners domiciled in Indonesia is far below that of neighboring countries such as Singapore, Thailand, and Malaysia. One of the potential reasons for this is due to the Previous Law being un-accommodative to foreigners in acquiring an ITAP whether for work, investment, or mixed marriages reasons.
Pursuant to Article 54 (1), Permanent Residence Permits (Izin Tinggal Tetap / ITAP) are granted to:
|
a)
|
Clergy, workers, investors, elderly (ITAP granted after residing for 3 consecutive years, Article 60 (1)),
|
|
b)
|
Spouse in a mixed marriage (ITAP granted after residing for 2 consecutive years, Article 60 (2)),
|
|
c)
|
Spouse and/or children of a foreigner holding an ITAP (ITAP granted promptly, Article 60 (3)), and
|
|
d)
|
Former Indonesian citizens and former children holding dual citizenship (ITAP granted promptly, Article 60 (3)).
|
A change under the Law is that an initial ITAP is granted for a 5 years period, where upon expiry an extension can be granted for an unlimited time (Article 59). Previously ITAP was granted for 5 years with an obligation to extend every 5 years (Article 38 of Government Regulation No. 32 of 1994 on Visas, Entry Permits, and Immigration Permits).
Article 59 provides legal certainty to spouses and family member from mixed marriages, and has been welcomed by the Mixed Marriage Community (Komunitas Perkawinan Campuran / KomPerca).
Working Rights and Remuneration
Under Article 61, ITAS and ITAP holders (spouses and children of mixed marriages) are permitted to work and/or have a business in Indonesia, although the Article is largely self explanatory, it still leaves a question whether a working permit is required, with the elucidation failing to clarify this issue.
Furthermore, this also leaves another question on how much is an ITAS and ITAP holders are supposed to be remunerated, as the Director General of Taxation Decree No. Kep-173/PJ/2002 on Guideline for Expatriate Salary Standards (“Decree”) sets high rates compared to Indonesian standards.
The Decree sets the guideline salaries to be paid being, ranging from USD 1,729 per month for Korean citizen holding a staff level in a company engaged in Trading, to USD 37,967 per month for Australian citizens holding a consultant managerial position for working in a government project with foreign funding.
Although there are no prevailing regulations on this issue, it could be presumed that foreign workers can be classified as:
|
i)
|
Expatriates, defined as foreigners securing employment abroad to later be posted in Indonesia, and
|
|
ii)
|
Foreign locals, defined as foreigners who secured employment directly in Indonesia.
|
Human Trafficking
Provisions on human trafficking are a new addition under the Law. Under the Previous Law, victims were treated in the same way as any deportee. Now, pursuant to Article 86 in conjunction with Article 87, victims will receive special treatment, whereby the government will use its best efforts (but notably is not obliged to do so) to enable the return of the victims to their country of origin (Article 88).
Establishment of a New Immigration Institution
Currently, immigration offices are established at the district and city levels, pursuant to Article 4 (1), immigration services can be conducted at a sub-district (kecamatan) level. This Article ensures accessibility for citizen and non-citizens in relation to immigration matters, and also serves as a reform of the immigration bureaucracy.
This additional establishment of offices is made possible by the immigration office’s advances in their information systems and immigration management.
Although it will take some time for immigration offices to be established at the sub-district level, since a Minister of Law and Human Rights Decree will first have to further implement any such establishment (Article 4 (3)), and also due to a dependency on the state budget to cover the cost of establishing immigration offices at the sub-district level.
Sanctions
The Law imposes administrative sanctions, as set out in Chapter VII, and criminal sanctions, as set out in Chapter XI.
Transportation operators who enter and exit Indonesia without going through a designated immigration checkpoint, will face 1 year imprisonment and/or a fine of IDR 100 million, and if transporting passengers will be subject to double the sanctions (Article 114).
Possession of invalid, expired or counterfeit travel documents, will lead to foreigner facing a maximum of 5 years imprisonment and a maximum criminal fine of IDR 500 million (Article 119).
Holding a counterfeit Indonesian travel document will lead to a maximum of 5 years imprisonment and an IDR 500 million criminal fine (Article 127).
Fictitious marriages with Indonesian citizens, as utilized by some to acquire an ITAP, pursuant to Article 135 are now a criminal act, with the foreign perpetrator facing 5 year imprisonment and an IDR 500 million fine. The Previous Law did not provision for such a sanction.
Human trafficking crimes, pursuant to Article 120, can lead to a maximum of 15 years imprisonment and a fine of IDR 1.5 billion.
Conclusion
Going through the provisions of the Law, it can certainly be considered friendlier to foreigners than the Previous Law. Considering that spouses in mixed marriages, investors, workers, clergy, as well as children of mixed marriages can more easily acquire an ITAP.
Although sanctions imposed under the law are greater than those under the Previous Law, such provisions are considered necessary to eradicate the transnational crime of human trafficking.
With the passage of the Law, a regulatory framework to reform and advance immigration services has been created, with multiple implementing regulation expected to follow, ranging from the level of government regulation to ministerial decrees.
......