Overview
Bank Indonesia Circular Letter No. 13/8/DPNP on Fit and Proper Tests (“Circular Letter”) has been issued on 28 March 2011 to implement Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 12/23/PBI/2010 on Fit and Proper Tests (“Regulation”).
With the banking industry being one of the most heavily regulated, the regulatory requirements apply not only to best practices in engaging with external parties to which prudential principles must be applied, but also to best practices at the internal level of bank decision makers and controlling organs.
The case of Bank Indonesia Liquidity Support (BLBI), and the more recent Bank Century case – now Bank Mutiara, have resulted a trust crisis in the pillar on which a bank bases its business foundation, resulting in the possibility of systemic implications for the entire industry.
In order to maintain public trust in the industry, a fit and proper test is an obligatory requirement for bank decision makers and controlling organs, serving also to ensure that bank management is in accordance with good corporate governance principles, with the expectation that trust in the banking industry will be sustained.
This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the Circular Letter and the Regulation and provide an analysis of the relevant provisions.
Purpose
Circular Letter
With the issuance of Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 12/23/PBI/2010 on Fit and Proper Tests, Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 5/25/PBI 2003 on the same issue (“Previous Regulation”) has been revoked and replaced.
The revocation had resulted in the Bank Indonesia Circular Letter No. 6/15/DPNP/2004 on Fit and Proper Test Evaluation (“Previous Circular Letter”) to be no longer relevant, as its purpose was to implement the Previous Regulation.
The Circular Letter, in addition to implementing the Regulation, also serves repeal and replace the Previous Circular Letter.
Fit and Proper Test
The purpose of the fit and proper test is to evaluate the integrity and financial feasibility of controlling prospective and/or incumbent shareholders (PSP, as defined in Article 1 (5) of the Regulation); and the integrity, reputation and financial competence of the prospective and/or incumbent commissioners, directors, heads of foreign bank branch offices (Kantor Bank Cabang Asing / KCBA) and representative offices, as well as of executive officers.
Applicability
Commercial Banks
The Circular Letter applies the fit and proper test to commercial banks specifically, whereas Sharia Banks and Rural Credit Banks (Bank Perkreditan Rakyat) are regulated by a different Bank Indonesia regulation and circular letter, respectively:
|
a.
|
Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 11/31/PBI/2009 on the same issue for Sharia Banks and Sharia Business Units, as implemented by Bank Indonesia Circular Letter No. 12/6/DPBS dated 8 March 2010.
|
|
b.
|
Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 6/23/PBI/2004 on the same issue for Rural Credit Banks, as implemented by Bank Indonesia Circular Letter No. 6/35/DPBPR dated 16 August 2004.
|
Parties
Under the Circular Letter, pursuant to Section I, commercial bank decision makers and organs that are subject to the fit and proper test by Bank Indonesia are:
|
i)
|
Controlling Shareholders (prospective and incumbent), as further elaborated on in Section II (A 2 a);
|
|
ii)
|
Board of Commissioners (candidate and incumbent), as further elaborated on in Section II (A 2 b); and
|
|
iii)
|
Board of Directors (candidate and incumbent), as also further elaborated on in Section II (A 2 b).
|
The Circular Letter applies not only to local commercial banks, but also for foreign banks and bank branch offices (Kantor Bank Cabang Asing / KCBA) pursuant to Section I (3) in conjunction with Section I (2), where the mentioned parties and also the banks’ executives are subject to a re-evaluation under the fit and proper test.
Exception
Pursuant to Section II (A 2 last paragraph) members of the Board of Commissioners and Directors whose positions are being extended are not subject to the fit and proper test.
New Entry: Prospective/Candidate Fit and Proper Tests
Controlling Shareholders
Controlling Shareholders (Pemegang Saham Pengendali / PSP) pursuant to Article 6 of the Regulation have to undergo a fit and proper test, where the object of the test is:
|
i)
|
Integrity (as elaborated further in Article 7 of the Regulation), and
|
|
ii)
|
Financial feasibility (as elaborated further in Article 8 of the Regulation).
|
Pursuant to Section II (A 1), a PSP is required to a have commitment to advancing the bank’s operations, to which it must submit a 3 years plan, comprising of the bank’s operational strategy and capital strengthening plan.
A PSP may be requested by Bank Indonesia to make a written statement committing to not transferring its shares for a certain period of time, with the non-transfer period being agreed between Bank Indonesia and the PSP.
Board of Commissioners and Directors
Pursuant to Section II (A 1 b) in conjunction with Article 17 of the Regulation, candidate Board of Commissioners and Directors are subject to evaluation of their:
|
i)
|
Integrity (as elaborated further in Article 18 of the Regulation),
|
|
ii)
|
Competency (as elaborated further in Article 19 of the Regulation), and
|
|
iii)
|
Financial feasibility (as elaborated further in Article 20 of the Regulation).
|
Administrative Requirements
Controlling Shareholders
Administrative requirements for a PSP refer not only to the provisions of the Circular Letter, with the PSP also having to comply with other Bank Indonesia regulations’ and circular letters’ provisions, as set out in Section II 1 of the Circular Letter, which, among others, relate to:
|
i)
|
Requirements and procedures for opening branch offices and supporting branch offices, as well as representative offices abroad,
|
|
ii)
|
Requirements and procedures for purchasing commercial bank shares,
|
|
iii)
|
Requirements and procedures for mergers, consolidations, and acquisitions of commercial banks, and
|
|
iv)
|
Commercial banks.
|
Administrative documents that needs to be submitted by a PSP in order to acquire an approval from Bank Indonesia are listed in the Circular Letter Appendixes 1 a and 1 b.
Additionally, 3 years of financial reports have to be submitted, if the PSP is a bank or a legal entity (Section II 2), as further elaborated in Appendix 1 (A 2 c), along with a filled form as provided in Appendixes 1 c and 1 d.
Board of Commissioners and Directors
Administrative requirements, as set out in Section II C, require candidates for the board of commissioners and directors to submit the forms contained in Appendixes 2 a through f. And, in addition to submitting the mentioned documents, the candidate also has to comply with provisions of Bank Indonesia regulations and circular letters on:
|
i)
|
Requirements and procedures for opening branch offices and supporting branch offices, as well as representative offices abroad,
|
|
ii)
|
Implementation compliance of commercial bank functions,
|
|
iii)
|
Commercial banks, and
|
|
iv)
|
Implementation of good corporate governance for commercial banks.
|
Procedure
Pursuant to Article 10 in conjunction with Article 22 of the Regulation, the fit and proper tests carried out for prospective PSPs and candidates for the board of commissioners and directors comprise of:
|
i)
|
Administrative evaluation, and
|
|
ii)
|
Interview (if deemed necessary).
|
Administrative evaluation
For prospective PSPs the administrative evaluation is directed towards the submitted administrative documents that comprise of Appendix 1 a through d (Section II E 2 a). For candidates for the board of commissioners and directors, administrative documents that are evaluated comprise of Appendix 2 a through f (Section II E 2 b).
Additionally both prospective PSP and candidate directors and commissioners will also be reviewed based on other data, respectively, the Bank Indonesia Administrative Notes on track records (jejak rekam), the disqualification list (daftar tidak lulus), and the bad credit list (kredit macet), which functions to ensure the integrity and financial feasibility of the prospective PSPs and candidate directors and commissioners.
Interview
Pursuant to Section II.3.a, an interview is mandatory for prospective PSPs, whereas candidate directors and commissioners are only required to undergo an interview if they will hold the following positions (Section II.3.b):
|
i)
|
Directors who will have a compliance function,
|
|
ii)
|
Commissioners who will be holding an independent commissioner position.
|
As provisioned under Section II.3.b.3, Bank Indonesia can also require an interview for other than the abovementioned reasons, should further clarification or explanation be required.
Results
The results of a fit and proper test can either be a ‘pass’ or ‘fail’ (Article 14 of the Regulation), if the test subject passes the test, it may hold the proposed position (Section II.E.4.a), if not, then it may not hold the proposed position (Section II.E.4.b).
The test results will be informed not only to the test subject, but also to related institutions such as the Government, the Deposit Assurance Company (Lembaga Penjamin Simpanan), and other shareholders and interested parties (Section II.E.4.c).
Incumbent Shareholders failing the test
Pursuant to Section II.E.4.d, if a prospective PSP fails the fit and proper test, as meant in Article 14 (2), then the procedure set out in Articles 36, 37, and 38 of the Regulation will be applied.
Where, among others, they may not (Article 36 of the Regulation):
|
i)
|
Conduct activities as a PSP,
|
|
ii)
|
Vote in shareholder meetings, and
|
|
iii)
|
Must transfer its shares within 6 months.
|
Additionally, pursuant to Article 37 of the Regulation, a PSP must render a Power of Attorney letter for the purpose of selling the shares to Bank Indonesia or to a third party that is approved by Bank Indonesia. And, as set out in Article 37 (b) of the Regulation, a 20 year restriction will be imposed on the PSP.
Moreover, the Supervisory board of Capital Markets will be informed of the PSP, and dividend payments will be suspended until the shares are transferred (Articles 37 (c) and (d) of the Regulation).
Directors/Commissioners failing the test
The position of a commissioner or a director in a bank is party decided by the shareholders meeting, with the other part of the decision being left to Bank Indonesia through the Fit and Proper Test. As stipulated in Section II.E.4.e), commissioners or directors that fail the fit and proper test fall under the procedure set out in Article 40 of the Regulation, which among other, provides that they:
|
i)
|
Prohibited to act as a commissioner, director, or executive officer,
|
|
ii)
|
Must immediately give up their position.
|
Additionally, the bank that proposed the mentioned parties, must execute the consequence of failing the fit and proper test, no later than 3 months from Bank Indonesia informing it of the fit and proper test results.
Moreover, pursuant to Section II.E.4.e.1, directors and commissioners who fail the fit and proper test are not eligible to be a PSP of a bank.
Exception
Candidate commissioners and directors who fail the fit and proper test resulting from a transitional position, as meant in Sections II A.2.b.4 through II A.2.b.8, such as:
|
i)
|
Commissioner changing position to a different commissioner post within the same bank,
|
|
ii)
|
Commissioner changing position to an independent commissioner within the same bank,
|
|
iii)
|
Director changing position to a director holding a compliance function within the same bank,
|
|
iv)
|
Commissioner or director who is promoted to a higher position in the same bank.
|
As long as there is no indication of failures in integrity, financial feasibility, and financial reputation and/or competency from the fit and proper test, referring also to Articles 27 and 28 of the Regulation, they can still hold their position (Section II E.4.e.2)
Existing: Prospective/Candidate Fit and Proper Tests
Incumbent PSPs and members of the board of commissioners and directors falling under the category of Sections I.2 and I.3 that are suspected to have integrity, financial feasibility, financial reputation and/or competency problems pursuant to Articles 27 and 28 of the Regulation, are subject to a fit and proper test (Section III A.1).
A fit and proper test can be conducted at any given, should information acquired from off/on-site supervision indicate that (Section III A.2):
|
i)
|
integrity of the PSP is in question,
|
|
ii)
|
the integrity and financial reputation and/or competency of the director, commissioner, or executive officer is in question,
|
|
iii)
|
violation by a head of a foreign bank representative office.
|
Section III A.3 sets out the criteria and/or factors that indicate the integrity and financial reputation and/or competency of the incumbent parties.
Fit and Proper Test Procedure
The procedure of a fit and proper test for an incumbent PSP, member of a board of directors or commissioners and executive officers is stipulated in Section III.B.
The test’s purpose is to re-evaluate the integrity and financial reputation and/or competency of an incumbent based on the information acquired by Bank Indonesia. Pursuant to Section III.B.2 the procedure of the fit and proper tests comprises of:
|
i)
|
Clarification of evidence to the test subject,
|
|
ii)
|
Determination and delivery of preliminary results of the test and of the test to the test subject,
|
|
iii)
|
Response of the test subject regarding the preliminary results of the fit and proper test,
|
|
iv)
|
Determination and delivery of the final results of the fit and proper test to the test subject.
|
Pursuant to Section III.B.3, test subjects that are found to have committed a violation will be categorized as a ‘perpetrator’ (Section III.B.3.a) or as an ‘accomplice’ (Section II.B.3.b).
Results
Incumbents that pass the fit and proper test, pursuant to Section III.C 1, are permitted to continue to hold their current position.
Those who are categorized as an accomplice, pursuant to Section II.C.2, can be found to have passed the fit and proper test, with a condition of producing a commitment statement to not repeat the similar violation in the future.
Those who are found to ‘fail’ the fit and proper test, as set in Section II.C.3, PSPs will be prohibited from owning shares in the banking industry, and/or hold the position as a commissioner, director or an executive officer in the banking industry.
Sanctions
The sanctions are set out in Section III (C) and Appendixes 3a and 3b, and include prohibition from owning commercial bank shares and holding commissioner/director/executive positions. The sanctions are based on the type and frequency of offences and the non-compliance with prior sanctions, rather than on the impact of the conduct.
Failure of the fit and proper test results in PSPs having to transfer the ownership of shares (within 6 months for commercial banks, pursuant to Section III C.5.a). While commissioners, directors, heads of foreign bank branches/representative offices, and executive officers have to depart from their positions.
Conclusion
The rationale behind the strict regime towards prospective and incumbent PSPs, members of the board of commissioners or directors and executive officers stems from the recent case of Bank Century - now Bank Mutiara. Where it was proven that not only did directors and commissioners issue orders to bank staff to engage in illegal banking practice but also that PSPs, respectively Robert Tantular, Hesham Al Warraq and Rafat Ali Rizfi, contributed to the wrongdoing.
It is expected that with heavier sanctions and a simpler procedure that are set out in the Circular Letter compared that of the Previous Circular Letter, the fit and proper tests for commercial bank decision makers and controlling organs, will be one of the instruments that will strengthen the trust in the banking industry.
Although it took seven years for the Regulation to be issued, and replace the Previous Regulation, seeing many illegal banking practices transpire during this period, the Circular Letter and the Regulation are now being put to the test, in ensuring that a legal framework that facilitates good corporate governance in the banking industry be realized.
......