Development of Multimodal Transport in Indonesia in Anticipation of the ASEAN Single Market

Overview

The development of the logistics sector is inseparable from role of multimodal transport, which serves as an integral component of the logistic business that commonly utilizes more than one transportation mode. Government Regulation No. 8 of 2011 on Multimodal Transport (‘Regulation’) has been issued to set out the legal framework for multimodal transport in Indonesia, provisions relating to which have previously been scattered throughout various transport laws and regulations.

The Regulation contains 11 chapters and 31 articles, which set out the provisions on, among others: multimodal transport activities, multimodal transport documents, rights, obligations, and liability of multimodal transport operator and service users, as well as insurance, and tariffs. The Regulation was issued on 8 February 2011 and will come into force 1 year from its enactment, on 8 February 2012.

The significant role played by multimodal transport has also attracted the attention of international organizations (for instance, the United Nations, ASEAN, and the World Trade Organization), who have provided legal frameworks for the multimodal transport at the international level. Particularly in ASEAN, the role of multimodal transport has become one of the main agendas in relation to ASEAN logistics liberalization currently expected to take place around 2019. The Regulation is intended to improve the quality of national multimodal transport operators and prepare them to compete on the international stage.

This edition of Indonesian Law Digest will highlight key features of the Regulation and provide analysis of its provisions.

 

Purpose

The Regulation has been issued to govern the operation of multimodal transport, and specifically to implement Article 148 of Law No. 34 of 2007 on Railways, Article 55 of Law No. 17 of 2008 on Shipping, Article 191 of Law No. 1 of 2009 on Aviation, and Article 165 (4) of Law No. 22 of 2009 on Traffic and Road Transport.

Moreover, by providing a legal framework for the operation of multimodal transport in Indonesia, the ultimate goal is to prepare the Indonesian logistics sector for the liberalization of multimodal transport within the context of the ASEAN single market.

 

Definitions

Article 1 (1) defines multimodal transport as the transportation of goods, under an agreement to deliver from the dispatch site to the collection site, by utilizing at least 2 different transportation modes, such as land, sea, air transportation and/or railway.

Multimodal transport is operated by: (1) domestic legal entities, defined as a state or regional owned company, or an Indonesian legal entity that is specifically established to engage in multimodal transport; or (2) foreign legal entity, defined as a legal entity engaging in multimodal transport, which is established under the laws of another country (Articles 2 (1) and (2)).

In addition to multimodal transport operators, the Regulation also introduces the concept of an agent, which is defined as an Indonesian legal entity appointed by a multimodal transport business entity pursuant to a cooperation agreement (Article 1 (5)).

 

Applicability

The Regulation applies to multimodal transport operators (domestic and foreign legal entities), agents, associations of multimodal operators, freight forwarders, and logistic services providers, as well as to services users and the recipients of the transported goods.

All multimodal transport activities within the jurisdiction of Indonesia, as well as the transport of goods (following their arrival at a terminal/station/port/airport in Indonesia) has to comply with the provisions of the Regulation.

 

Key Features of the Regulation

Multimodal Transport Operators

Multimodal transport business activities can only be conducted by domestic or foreign legal entities that are established with the purpose of engaging in multimodal transport. Multimodal transport operators undertake to arrange for the transport of goods by means of more than one mode of transport, and issue a single multimodal transport document for the entire journey of the cargo (door-to-door service).

In conducting its activities, multimodal transport operators can cooperate, by means of a cooperation agreement, with land, sea, air transportation and/or railway service providers (Articles 10 (1) and (2)).

 

Licensing

To engage in multimodal transportation business activities, domestic legal entities have to hold a multimodal transport business license, which is issued by the Minister of Transportation (Article 7 (1)). The domestic legal entity has to meet administrative and technical requirements stipulated in Articles 7 (3) and (4) of the Regulation, which consist of:

-

deed of establishment of the company;

-

taxpayer registration number (NPWP);

-

letter of business domicile;

-

capital requirement in the amount of at least 80,000 Special Drawing Rights (a unit of account stipulated by the International Monetary Fund); and

-

working equipment, such as a permanent office, loading and unloading equipment, and have sufficient human resources that are competent in the area of multimodal transport, as evidenced by competency certificates.

 

To engage in multimodal transport business activities in Indonesia, foreign legal entities have to register with the Minister of Transportation (Articles 9 (2) and (3)). Such registration remains effective for the duration of the validity of the business license issued by the authorized body from their country of origin (Article 9 (4)).

It should be noted that in engaging in multimodal transport business activities in Indonesia, the registered foreign legal entity has to appoint a domestic multimodal transport legal entity as its agent, due to the implementation of the cabotage principle, which requires cooperation with a national legal entity (as its agent) in transporting goods following their arrival at a terminal/station/port/airport in Indonesia (Article 9 (1)). However, the Regulation does not provide for sanctions for noncompliance with these provisions.

Further details on the registration of foreign legal entities engaging in multimodal transport will be set out by future ministerial regulation.

 

Rights and Obligation of Multimodal Transport Operators

Licensed multimodal transport operators are subject to certain obligations, among others, to comply with all provisions stipulated under the license and to commence operations within 6 months from the issuance of the license. Following the commencement of operations such multimodal transport operators have to report on their activities semi-annually to the Minister of Transportation (Article 11).

Additionally, Article 12 (1) requires multimodal transport operators, in performing their business activities, to:

-

issue multimodal transport documents;

-

transport goods pursuant to the agreed contract;

-

maintain safety and security in its implementation;

-

handle dangerous and special materials in accordance with legislative requirements;

-

resolve submitted claims by service users (if any); and

-

insure their liabilities pursuant to the prevailing laws and regulations.

 

Multimodal transport operators are entitled to, among other things: to open and/or examine the goods (evidenced by service users) for the purpose of verifying the information provided regarding the transported goods, refuse to transport goods that are suspected to pose a danger to the safety and security of the transport activities, and reject any unproven claims (Article 13). On the other hand, service users are not entitled to submit a claim to multimodal transport operators, who open or examine the transported goods, refuse to transport, or in the event that the transported goods contain unreported dangerous materials (Article 18).

 

Liability of Multimodal Transport Operators

Multimodal transport operators are liable for the transported goods after the goods are received from the service users and until they are delivered to the recipient (in accordance with the agreed contract). The liability includes damage to the goods, partial or entire loss of the goods, and/or late delivery to the recipient (Article 14 (2)).

For any damaged or lost goods, the liability of the multimodal transport operator is in the form of compensation. Such compensation is pursuant to the rates set out in Article 23 (2). In the event the damage or loss is caused by a failure and/or negligence of the multimodal transport operator, compensation is possible up to the value of the goods (Article 24).

By using multimodal transport services, the interests of the service users are protected, since they can claim against the multimodal transport operator with whom they have entered into the transport contract (in contrast to non-multimodal transport, where the service users often have to claim against the responsible sub-carrier). The multimodal transport operator takes over the full responsibility for the transportation of the goods, with service users no longer having to concern themselves with each sub-contracting carrier.

 

Insurance

The Regulation obliges multimodal transport operators to insure their liabilities pursuant to the prevailing laws and regulations. Service users can request cargo insurance, with its cost being borne by the service users.

 

Tariffs

Tariffs of multimodal transport services are as stipulated in the written contract between multimodal transport operator and the services user (Article 27 (1)). The multimodal transport tariff consists of a tariff for each transportation mode and of the tariff for other services provided by the multimodal transport operator.

 

International Framework and its Implementation

On 17 November 2005, members of ASEAN, including Indonesia, signed the ASEAN Framework Agreement on Multimodal Transport, as the agreement on the provisions for regulating multimodal transport between ASEAN countries. The framework agreement consists of 42 articles, which are divided into 11 chapters, and provides provisions on, among others: multimodal transport operators, liability of multimodal transport operators, liability of consignors, and jurisdiction and competence (including settlement of disputes). The framework agreement is part of the action plan for the ASEAN single market that allows multimodal transport operators coming from ASEAN member countries to operate in their jurisdictions.

Indonesia, as one of the signature countries, has committed to implementing the framework agreement into its national legislation (in accordance with which the Regulation was finally issued on 8 February 2011). Following Indonesia, in the near future, Thailand is planning to enact legislation addressing multimodal transport, which will apply to both domestic and international multimodal transports. In Singapore, in order to develop the multimodal transport business, various customs formalities have been standardized and the ‘Singapore Registry of Accredited Multimodal Transport Operators’ has been established in order to promote the interests of the freight forwarding industry in Singapore.

 

Sanctions

Failure to comply with Articles 11 and 12 (1), on operational obligations of multimodal transport operators, is subject to administrative sanctions (written notice, temporary cessation of operations, and/or revocation of license).

The revocation of license sanction is intended for multimodal transport operators who: endangered state security and human safety, obtain the business license illegally, are declared bankrupt, or commit a criminal offence (as evidenced by a binding court decision) (Article 12 (5)).

It is of note that the Regulation does not contain any further stipulations on sanctions for non-registered or unlicensed multimodal transport operators, who conduct their activities within Indonesia.

Further details on sanctions will be set out by future ministerial regulation.

 

Conclusion

Multimodal transport plays an important role in providing an integrated service for the transportation of goods. To improve and enhance the multimodal transport business in Indonesia, the Regulation has been issued to provide a somewhat comprehensive legal framework. The Regulation covers both domestic and foreign multimodal transport operators that operate within Indonesia. Prior to the Regulation coming into force in 2012, the government still has to improve the supporting infrastructure (railways, ports, airports, and roads), the development of human resources, and monitoring and supervision of the transportation of goods, so as to improve the performance of multimodal transport businesses. In the face of international competition, the government has been urged to streamline regulations, improve infrastructure and the transportation system, and simplify customs procedures so as to support further liberalization within the context of the ASEAN single market.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

The development of the logistics sector is inseparable from role of multimodal transport, which serves as an integral component of the logistic business that commonly utilizes more than one transportation mode. Government Regulation No. 8 of 2011 on Multimodal Transport (‘Regulation’) has been issued to set out the legal framework for multimodal transport in Indonesia, provisions relating to which have previously been scattered throughout various transport laws and regulations.

The Regulation contains 11 chapters and 31 articles, which set out the provisions on, among others: multimodal transport activities, multimodal transport documents, rights, obligations, and liability of multimodal transport operator and service users, as well as insurance, and tariffs. The Regulation was issued on 8 February 2011 and will come into force 1 year from its enactment, on 8 February 2012.

The significant role played by multimodal transport has also attracted the attention of international organizations (for instance, the United Nations, ASEAN, and the World Trade Organization), who have provided legal frameworks for the multimodal transport at the international level. Particularly in ASEAN, the role of multimodal transport has become one of the main agendas in relation to ASEAN logistics liberalization currently expected to take place around 2019. The Regulation is intended to improve the quality of national multimodal transport operators and prepare them to compete on the international stage.

This edition of Indonesian Law Digest will highlight key features of the Regulation and provide analysis of its provisions.

 

Purpose

The Regulation has been issued to govern the operation of multimodal transport, and specifically to implement Article 148 of Law No. 34 of 2007 on Railways, Article 55 of Law No. 17 of 2008 on Shipping, Article 191 of Law No. 1 of 2009 on Aviation, and Article 165 (4) of Law No. 22 of 2009 on Traffic and Road Transport.

Moreover, by providing a legal framework for the operation of multimodal transport in Indonesia, the ultimate goal is to prepare the Indonesian logistics sector for the liberalization of multimodal transport within the context of the ASEAN single market.

 

Definitions

Article 1 (1) defines multimodal transport as the transportation of goods, under an agreement to deliver from the dispatch site to the collection site, by utilizing at least 2 different transportation modes, such as land, sea, air transportation and/or railway.

Multimodal transport is operated by: (1) domestic legal entities, defined as a state or regional owned company, or an Indonesian legal entity that is specifically established to engage in multimodal transport; or (2) foreign legal entity, defined as a legal entity engaging in multimodal transport, which is established under the laws of another country (Articles 2 (1) and (2)).

In addition to multimodal transport operators, the Regulation also introduces the concept of an agent, which is defined as an Indonesian legal entity appointed by a multimodal transport business entity pursuant to a cooperation agreement (Article 1 (5)).

 

Applicability

The Regulation applies to multimodal transport operators (domestic and foreign legal entities), agents, associations of multimodal operators, freight forwarders, and logistic services providers, as well as to services users and the recipients of the transported goods.

All multimodal transport activities within the jurisdiction of Indonesia, as well as the transport of goods (following their arrival at a terminal/station/port/airport in Indonesia) has to comply with the provisions of the Regulation.

 

Key Features of the Regulation

Multimodal Transport Operators

Multimodal transport business activities can only be conducted by domestic or foreign legal entities that are established with the purpose of engaging in multimodal transport. Multimodal transport operators undertake to arrange for the transport of goods by means of more than one mode of transport, and issue a single multimodal transport document for the entire journey of the cargo (door-to-door service).

In conducting its activities, multimodal transport operators can cooperate, by means of a cooperation agreement, with land, sea, air transportation and/or railway service providers (Articles 10 (1) and (2)).

 

Licensing

To engage in multimodal transportation business activities, domestic legal entities have to hold a multimodal transport business license, which is issued by the Minister of Transportation (Article 7 (1)). The domestic legal entity has to meet administrative and technical requirements stipulated in Articles 7 (3) and (4) of the Regulation, which consist of:

-

deed of establishment of the company;

-

taxpayer registration number (NPWP);

-

letter of business domicile;

-

capital requirement in the amount of at least 80,000 Special Drawing Rights (a unit of account stipulated by the International Monetary Fund); and

-

working equipment, such as a permanent office, loading and unloading equipment, and have sufficient human resources that are competent in the area of multimodal transport, as evidenced by competency certificates.

 

To engage in multimodal transport business activities in Indonesia, foreign legal entities have to register with the Minister of Transportation (Articles 9 (2) and (3)). Such registration remains effective for the duration of the validity of the business license issued by the authorized body from their country of origin (Article 9 (4)).

It should be noted that in engaging in multimodal transport business activities in Indonesia, the registered foreign legal entity has to appoint a domestic multimodal transport legal entity as its agent, due to the implementation of the cabotage principle, which requires cooperation with a national legal entity (as its agent) in transporting goods following their arrival at a terminal/station/port/airport in Indonesia (Article 9 (1)). However, the Regulation does not provide for sanctions for noncompliance with these provisions.

Further details on the registration of foreign legal entities engaging in multimodal transport will be set out by future ministerial regulation.

 

Rights and Obligation of Multimodal Transport Operators

Licensed multimodal transport operators are subject to certain obligations, among others, to comply with all provisions stipulated under the license and to commence operations within 6 months from the issuance of the license. Following the commencement of operations such multimodal transport operators have to report on their activities semi-annually to the Minister of Transportation (Article 11).

Additionally, Article 12 (1) requires multimodal transport operators, in performing their business activities, to:

-

issue multimodal transport documents;

-

transport goods pursuant to the agreed contract;

-

maintain safety and security in its implementation;

-

handle dangerous and special materials in accordance with legislative requirements;

-

resolve submitted claims by service users (if any); and

-

insure their liabilities pursuant to the prevailing laws and regulations.

 

Multimodal transport operators are entitled to, among other things: to open and/or examine the goods (evidenced by service users) for the purpose of verifying the information provided regarding the transported goods, refuse to transport goods that are suspected to pose a danger to the safety and security of the transport activities, and reject any unproven claims (Article 13). On the other hand, service users are not entitled to submit a claim to multimodal transport operators, who open or examine the transported goods, refuse to transport, or in the event that the transported goods contain unreported dangerous materials (Article 18).

 

Liability of Multimodal Transport Operators

Multimodal transport operators are liable for the transported goods after the goods are received from the service users and until they are delivered to the recipient (in accordance with the agreed contract). The liability includes damage to the goods, partial or entire loss of the goods, and/or late delivery to the recipient (Article 14 (2)).

For any damaged or lost goods, the liability of the multimodal transport operator is in the form of compensation. Such compensation is pursuant to the rates set out in Article 23 (2). In the event the damage or loss is caused by a failure and/or negligence of the multimodal transport operator, compensation is possible up to the value of the goods (Article 24).

By using multimodal transport services, the interests of the service users are protected, since they can claim against the multimodal transport operator with whom they have entered into the transport contract (in contrast to non-multimodal transport, where the service users often have to claim against the responsible sub-carrier). The multimodal transport operator takes over the full responsibility for the transportation of the goods, with service users no longer having to concern themselves with each sub-contracting carrier.

 

Insurance

The Regulation obliges multimodal transport operators to insure their liabilities pursuant to the prevailing laws and regulations. Service users can request cargo insurance, with its cost being borne by the service users.

 

Tariffs

Tariffs of multimodal transport services are as stipulated in the written contract between multimodal transport operator and the services user (Article 27 (1)). The multimodal transport tariff consists of a tariff for each transportation mode and of the tariff for other services provided by the multimodal transport operator.

 

International Framework and its Implementation

On 17 November 2005, members of ASEAN, including Indonesia, signed the ASEAN Framework Agreement on Multimodal Transport, as the agreement on the provisions for regulating multimodal transport between ASEAN countries. The framework agreement consists of 42 articles, which are divided into 11 chapters, and provides provisions on, among others: multimodal transport operators, liability of multimodal transport operators, liability of consignors, and jurisdiction and competence (including settlement of disputes). The framework agreement is part of the action plan for the ASEAN single market that allows multimodal transport operators coming from ASEAN member countries to operate in their jurisdictions.

Indonesia, as one of the signature countries, has committed to implementing the framework agreement into its national legislation (in accordance with which the Regulation was finally issued on 8 February 2011). Following Indonesia, in the near future, Thailand is planning to enact legislation addressing multimodal transport, which will apply to both domestic and international multimodal transports. In Singapore, in order to develop the multimodal transport business, various customs formalities have been standardized and the ‘Singapore Registry of Accredited Multimodal Transport Operators’ has been established in order to promote the interests of the freight forwarding industry in Singapore.

 

Sanctions

Failure to comply with Articles 11 and 12 (1), on operational obligations of multimodal transport operators, is subject to administrative sanctions (written notice, temporary cessation of operations, and/or revocation of license).

The revocation of license sanction is intended for multimodal transport operators who: endangered state security and human safety, obtain the business license illegally, are declared bankrupt, or commit a criminal offence (as evidenced by a binding court decision) (Article 12 (5)).

It is of note that the Regulation does not contain any further stipulations on sanctions for non-registered or unlicensed multimodal transport operators, who conduct their activities within Indonesia.

Further details on sanctions will be set out by future ministerial regulation.

 

Conclusion

Multimodal transport plays an important role in providing an integrated service for the transportation of goods. To improve and enhance the multimodal transport business in Indonesia, the Regulation has been issued to provide a somewhat comprehensive legal framework. The Regulation covers both domestic and foreign multimodal transport operators that operate within Indonesia. Prior to the Regulation coming into force in 2012, the government still has to improve the supporting infrastructure (railways, ports, airports, and roads), the development of human resources, and monitoring and supervision of the transportation of goods, so as to improve the performance of multimodal transport businesses. In the face of international competition, the government has been urged to streamline regulations, improve infrastructure and the transportation system, and simplify customs procedures so as to support further liberalization within the context of the ASEAN single market.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info