DPR Passes the Fund Transfer Bill

Overview

Due to cross border businesses and technology development, methods of fund transfer are no longer dependent on conventional wire transfers using banks and postal remittance services (pos wesel).

According to 2010 data from the Central Bank (Bank Indonesia / BI), the average daily fund transfer volume through BI – Real Time Gross Settlement / BI-RTGS (electronic fund transfer system for IDR 100 million and above) reaches the value of IDR 170 trillion, with 150 thousands transactions.

Meanwhile, fund transfers through documented clearing is estimated to be on an average of IDR 5 – 6 trillion daily, with 300 thousand transactions.

Due to the high volume of fund transfers in Indonesia, since 2006 Bank Indonesia and the Ministry of Law and Human Rights have been drafting a bill to regulate fund transfer, where after 5 years in the making, on 23 February 2011, the House of Representative finally passed the Fund Transfer Bill (“Bill”).

Currently the Bill is awaiting signatory approval from the President as required under Article 38 of Law No. 10 of 2004 on the Drafting of Legislation. The President will have 30 days to sign the Bill into Law, with the Bill automatically becoming a Law after 30 days in the event that the Presidential signature is not forthcoming.

This edition of the Indonesian Legal Digest will highlight the key features of the Bill and provide analysis of Bill’s provisions.

 

Purpose

Public discourse surrounding the drafting of the Bill centered around the fact that current legislation on fund transfer activities governed under Bank Indonesia Regulation, provides legal loopholes for money laundering and the funding of terrorism to occur. Resulting in Indonesia potentially being included in other countries’ negative investment lists. In order to prevent this, a Law on Fund Transfers was seen as being necessary.

Furthermore, the Bill aims to regulate parties to a fund transfer due to the rising numbers of fund transfers, nominal amount, and also the development of transfer methods, as noted in the preamble of the Bill. The Bill is drafted to ensure the reliability of fund transfers, and to provide certainty for parties to a fund transfer.

 

Definitions

Fund transfer

As defined under Article 1 (1) a fund transfer is a series of activities that begins once a Sender orders a fund transfer to a fund transfer provider (“Provider”) to transfer its funds to a Beneficiary, whose credentials are included in the transfer order.

A further definition of ‘funds’ is contained in Article 1 (4) which includes: cash rendered to a Provider, or an amount of cash deposited in a bank account in the Provider’s institution, or an overdraft facility given by a Provider to the Sender.

 

Fund Service Provider

Since the series of activities of a fund transfer from the Sender to the Beneficiary may involve more than one intermediary institution, Articles 1 (8) though (12) subdivide the intermediaries into those who serve as the fund transfer provider (“Provider”) as Sender’s Provider, Beneficiary’s Provider, and Intermediary Provider between the Sender’s Provider and the Beneficiary’s Provider (“Intermediary Provider”).

 

Applicability

Jurisdiction

Pursuant to Article 2, the Bill governs fund transfer activities in Indonesian Rupiah as well as in foreign currency from Indonesia or to Indonesia involving an Indonesian Provider.

 

Indonesian Legal Entity and Permit

Providers, such as banks or non-bank financial institutions, pursuant to Article 69 (1), have to be in the form of an Indonesian legal entity.

Previously, pursuant to Article 1 (3) of the Bank Indonesia Regulation No.8/28/PBI/2006 on Remittance Activity, individuals and foreign legal entities could be a Provider. With the passage of the Bill only Indonesian legal entities can render services, implying that foreign entities who currently place an agent to offer their services, must now establish themselves as an Indonesian legal entity.

However, due to jurisdiction and physical presence issues, internet based, e-wallet type, Providers are unlikely to be immediately affected due to enforceability issues.

 

Fund Transfer Principles

Article 3 sets out the principles that apply to the parties in a fund transfer, which, among others, are:

a)

the same Provider used by a Sender and a Beneficiary will be treated as separate parties in a fund transfer, which will not apply in terms of corporate responsibility.

b)

it is stipulated that the zero hour rules principle does not apply to fund transfers, suggesting that should a Provider be declared insolvent by a court or its operations suspended, or its permit revoked, a fund transfer that occurred on the day of the decision, cannot be canceled or retrieved.

c)

provisioned the finality of payment principle, where funds that have moved from one Provider to another Provider cannot be retrieved unilaterally, unless a cancellation request from a Sender Provider is present.

d)

application of the delivery versus payment principle, where it is elucidated that in the case that a fund transfer is an obligation deriving from an agreement between a Sender and it’s Beneficiary, that at the time that the Beneficiary Provider has accepted the transfer order, the Sender’s obligation to make payment is fulfilled, resulting in the Sender’s legal rights over the agreed object.

e)

the netting mechanism is recognized under the Bill, as explained in the elucidation, providers would calculate the rights and obligations of a fund transfer activity (the final calculation of rights and obligation).

 

Pursuant to Article 43, Prudence principle is to be applied relating to a cancellation of a transfer orders, and Syariah principles apply to Providers whose business is based on Syariah principles in terms of payment of fees and interest from fund transfer activity (Article 71).

 

Fund Transfers

Transfer Order

Pursuant to Article 5 (1), a transfer order that has acquired an acceptance from a Provider is, by law, an Agreement.

Whereas in order to receive an acceptance from a Provider, Article 8 (1) stipulates the requirement that a transfer order must have, among others:

a.

The Sender’s credentials;

b.

The Beneficiary’s credentials;

c.

The Beneficiary’s Provider’s credential;

d.

The amount of funds and currency that is requested to be transferred;

e.

Date of the transfer order;

f.

Other information that is required by law to be included the in the transfer order.

 

Acceptance

Pursuant to Article 15, a Provider may only accept a transfers order if the below condition are met:

a.

The transfer order includes information listed in Article 8 (1), except for credentials of the Beneficiary’s Provider if the funds were rendered in cash by the Sender;

b.

The Sender has sufficient funds available in its account;

c.

The Sender’s Provider has authenticated the transfer order; and

d.

The transfer order complies with the prevailing law and regulation on fund transfers;

 

Should the above condition be met and the order accepted, a Provider, pursuant to Article 17 (4), must execute the transfer stated in the transfer order. Failing to do so, pursuant to Article 19 (3), a Provider is obliged to pay interest or compensation to the Sender starting from the date of the acceptance until the funds are returned.

Pursuant to Article 27, the procedure and the amount to be paid in compensation to the sender will be further regulated by a Bank Indonesia Regulation. As such, Providers’ that delay fund transfers with a view of financial gain will be faced with  legal consequences.

 

Intermediary Provider

Pursuant to Article 29, should an Intermediary Provider be used, the Intermediary Provider can only execute the fund transfer should sufficient fund be available in:

a.

The Intermediary Provider’s account at the Sender’s Provider institution;

b.

The Sender’s Provider’s account at the Intermediary Provider institution;

c.

The Intermediary Provider’s account at other Provider institution; or

d.

The Intermediary Provider’s account at the Central Bank.

 

Acceptance by Beneficiary’s Provider

Pursuant to Article 36 (2) the Beneficiary’s Provider is considered to have accepted the transfer order terms should the following conditions exist:

a.

Notify the acceptance to the sending Provider;

b.

Debit the sending Provider’s account at its institution;

c.

Allocate the funds to the Beneficiary;

d.

Credit the Beneficiary’s account at its institution, or

e.

Notify the Beneficiary that the transferred funds are available to be collected.

 

The Acceptance procedures, pursuant to Article 39, will be further regulated in a Bank Indonesia Regulation.

Pursuant to Article 33, the Beneficiary’s Provider can only execute a fund transfer should sufficient fund be available in:

a.

The Beneficiary’s Provider’s account at the Sender’s Provider institution;

b.

The Sender’s Provider’s account at the Beneficiary’s Provider institution;

c.

The Beneficiary’s Provider’s account at other Provider institution; or

d.

The Beneficiary’s Provider’s account at the Central Bank.

 

Collection

Pursuant to Article 37, for fund transfers that are to be collected in cash, the Beneficiary’s Provider is obliged to notify the Beneficiary of the availability of funds for collection. Should the Beneficiary fail to collect after 3 times of being notified in a timely manner, the funds have to be returned to the Sender.

If within 90 days the Sender’s whereabouts are unknown after an attempt being made to return the funds, the fund will be given by the Sender Provider to a state chancery institution.

Pursuant to Article 40, the process of a fund transfer is considered completed if the Beneficiary has received/collected the funds.

 

Refusal

Pursuant to Article 19 (1), a Provider can refuse to accept a transfer order with reasonable excuse, in which case the Provider has to notify of its’ refusal 1 day after receiving a transfer order, by informing the Sender of the grounds for the refusal.

The suggestion is that a refusal would occur in the event that a fund transfer is suspicious and may form a part of a money laundering activity or the funding of terrorism.

Article 39 further sets out the procedures for a Beneficiary Provider to reject a transfer.

 

Unsuccessful Fund Transfers

Pursuant to Article 20, the Sender’s Provider is accountable for the fund transfer until the Beneficiary’s Provider has accepted the transfer.

It is further stipulated that a force majeure condition, as set out in Article 21, does not relieve a Provider’s obligation to perform the fund transfer. Suggesting that Article 1596 of the Indonesian Civil Code, on force majeure, is superseded by the Bill.

Pursuant to Article 23, in the event of a situation where an equivalent to a court decision prohibits the execution of a fund transfer, the Provider must inform the Sender of this within 1 working day.

Pursuant to Article 26, where an Intermediary Provider is used, and the Intermediary Provider’s business is suspended or its permit revoked, or it becomes insolvent, the Sender’s Provider is accountable to execute the transfer using other means at its own cost without waiting for the funds to be returned by the Intermediary Provider.

 

Cancellation and Modification

Cancellation

Pursuant to Article 42 in conjunction with Article 45, a cancellation may be done due to a Sender request or a court decision.

If requested by the Sender, it can only be done if an acceptance has not been made by the Beneficiary Provider, as per Article 36 (2), additionally Article 42 (2) requires an a prior agreement between the Sender and the Sender Provider on cancellation. The costs incurred will be borne by the Sender (Article 42 (4))

Pursuant to Article 42 (5) the Sender Provider will be relieved from any legal liability to the Sender deriving from the cancellation.

Pursuant to Article 45 (2) in a cancellation due to a court decision, the Beneficiary Provider will be relieved from any legal liability for not performing the fund transfer.

 

Modification

Pursuant to Article 46, a modification of a transfer order can only be done if the Beneficiary Provider has sufficient time to make the changes, and has not completed the steps stipulated in Article 36 (2).

 

Correction

Article 56 stipulates that should a Sender Provider make a mistake in performing a fund transfer, the institution is obliged make a correction by cancelling or modifying the transfer.

Pursuant to Article 57, should a Beneficiary Provider have made a mistake on the acceptance of the transfer order that results in an unintended Beneficiary collecting the funds, then the Provider is obliged to make the necessary corrections so that the rightful Beneficiary will be able to collect the funds.

Pursuant to Article 59, the Beneficiary Provider is obliged to assist other Providers should a cancellation, modification or correction occur.

 

Recovery of Funds

Pursuant to Article 47, as stipulated in Article 21 (1), if a condition that resembles a force majeure occurs, preventing a transfer, and the Sender requests a cancellation of an order, the Provider is obliged to return the funds without delay, with any delay leading to the payment of interest or compensation to the Sender.

Pursuant to Article 48 if an Intermediary Provider is selected by the Sender, the Sender Provider can return the funds once the Intermediary Provider has returned the funds. However, if an Intermediary Provider is chosen by the Sender Provider, then the Sender Provider is obliged to promptly return the fund without waiting for the funds from the Intermediary Provider.

Pursuant to Articles 50 and 51, the zero hour principle does not apply to fund transfers, therefore a Provider is not justified in stopping the execution of an accepted transfer order. And insolvency, business suspension, or permit revocation does not relieve the Provider from returning the funds to the Sender.

Pursuant to Article 53, in a cancellation of a fund transfer due to a court decision, the Beneficiary Provider is obliged to withhold the funds, and return the fund the rightful party as determined by the court.

 

Debit Transfers

Pursuant to Article 61, a debit transfer is commenced through a debit transfer order, which a Provider can only accept if the conditions set out in Article 62 (1) are met:

a.

Debit transfer order includes all of the information listed in Article 8, except for the Sender’s information;

b.

Sender Provider has made authentication (if necessary);

c.

The debit transfer order has fulfilled the internal policy of the Sender Provider;

d.

The debit transfer order complies with prevailing regulations.

 

The Sender Provider has accepted the Debit transfer order if any of the events enumerated in Article 62 (2) have taken place.

Articles 64 and 65 provide the grounds for refusing to accept a debit transfer order.

 

Fund Transfer Fee

Pursuant to Article 68, Providers are obliged to be transparent to the Sender with regards to the fees imposed for fund transfers. The procedure for charging the fee and the obligation to provide the information will be regulated in a Bank Indonesia Regulation.

 

Provider Permit

As provided under Article 69, Provider that operates in Indonesia must be in the form of an Indonesian legal entity, and has to secure a license, currently in the form of obtaining a License for a Remittance Business as regulated under Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 8/28/PBI/2006 on Remittance Businesses, and Bank Indonesia Circular Letter No. 8/32/DASP of 2006 on the Registration of Remittance Businesses.

Individuals and foreign entities can no longer render fund transfer services, and will have to be incorporated as Indonesian legal entities, pursuant to Article 89 (1), within the course of the next 2 years.

 

Supervision

Pursuant to Article 72, the supervision of fund transfer activity will be under the purview of Bank Indonesia. And, pursuant to Article 73, Providers must report their activities to Bank Indonesia.

 

Evidence and Burden of Proof

Article 76 introduces new types of evidence into the Indonesian legal system. Under Article 164 of the Indonesian Civil Procedure Law, which is the prevailing regulation on evidence, the only acknowledged evidence is:

a.

Documents;

b.

Eyewitnesses;

c.

Suspicion;

d.

Confession;

e.

Testimony under oath.

 

Article 76 states that electronic information, electronic documents, and/or printouts of fund transfer activity are also accepted as legally valid evidence. Additionally, Article 77 recognizes electronic signatures as a valid instrument of fund transfer activity.

The burden of proof with respect to delays and/or errors lays with the Provider, according to Article 78, if a delay of a fund transfer results in loss to the Sender or the Beneficiary.

 

Sanction

Administrative

Pursuant to Article 74, Bank Indonesia can impose administrative sanction towards a Provider failing to submit reports, information, and clarification (as per Articles 72 and 73). The sanctions can take the form of:

a.

Warning letters;

b.

Administrative fines;

c.

Business suspension;

d.

Permit revocation.

 

Pursuant to Article 75, the procedure for imposing sanction towards Providers will be regulated by further Bank Indonesia Regulation.

 

Criminal

Pursuant to Article 79, Providers operating without the necessary license (Article 69 (1)) will face 3 year imprisonment or a fine of up to IDR 3 billion.

Article 81 provides for a 5 year imprisonment or a fine of up to IDR 5 billion for anybody who moves funds illegally by means of a counterfeit transfer order. This also applies to any party claiming to have lawful rights towards funds, whereas in fact the person does not (Article 85).

Pursuant to Article 82, an accomplice who receives funds deriving from a counterfeit transfer order will face 4 year imprisonment and/or a fine of up to IDR 1 billion.

Pursuant to Article 83, any party that alters or erases any part of information contained in a transfer order with the goal of enriching themselves or a third party, will be subject to imprisonment of 2 years or a fine of IDR 1 billion. And where such an act causes damage to the Sender and/or the Beneficiary, the penalties will be doubled.

Article 84 provides for up to 20 year imprisonment and a fine of up to IDR 20 billion for damaging the fund transfer system.

Article 86 and Article 87 stipulate additional prison time for individuals who are employees of a Provider and for corporate perpetrators, where such individuals are subject to an additional 1/3 of the imposed sentence, and corporations are subject to an addition 2/3 of the imposed fine.

 

Conclusion

With the Bill passing the House, Indonesia now finally has a regulatory framework on fund transfers. However, this is a long overdue development, considering that in 1987 the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNICITRAL) has issued a Legal Guide on Electronic Funds Transfers, followed by the issuance of a Model Law on International Credit Transfers in 1992.

Following this, it took around 20 years for Indonesia to finally pass a law on fund transfers. With the perception being that the fear of being included in negative foreign investment lists had ultimately galvanized the political will for the Bill to be passed.

The Introduction of new principles of fund transfers provides more certainty to the parties conducting a fund transfer, emphasizing that force majeure conditions are not an excuse for non-performance.

With the introduction of electronic evidence and the allocation of the burden of proof to the Provider, the Bill enriches the legislative framework and fills the previously unregulated legal gaps.

The criminal sanctions provide for long imprisonment terms and substantial fines, and as such can be expected to deter illegal fund transfer activity and to prevent money laundering and the funding of terrorist groups.

Finally, it should be noted that a number of implementing regulations are necessary before the Bill will effectively come into force.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

Due to cross border businesses and technology development, methods of fund transfer are no longer dependent on conventional wire transfers using banks and postal remittance services (pos wesel).

According to 2010 data from the Central Bank (Bank Indonesia / BI), the average daily fund transfer volume through BI – Real Time Gross Settlement / BI-RTGS (electronic fund transfer system for IDR 100 million and above) reaches the value of IDR 170 trillion, with 150 thousands transactions.

Meanwhile, fund transfers through documented clearing is estimated to be on an average of IDR 5 – 6 trillion daily, with 300 thousand transactions.

Due to the high volume of fund transfers in Indonesia, since 2006 Bank Indonesia and the Ministry of Law and Human Rights have been drafting a bill to regulate fund transfer, where after 5 years in the making, on 23 February 2011, the House of Representative finally passed the Fund Transfer Bill (“Bill”).

Currently the Bill is awaiting signatory approval from the President as required under Article 38 of Law No. 10 of 2004 on the Drafting of Legislation. The President will have 30 days to sign the Bill into Law, with the Bill automatically becoming a Law after 30 days in the event that the Presidential signature is not forthcoming.

This edition of the Indonesian Legal Digest will highlight the key features of the Bill and provide analysis of Bill’s provisions.

 

Purpose

Public discourse surrounding the drafting of the Bill centered around the fact that current legislation on fund transfer activities governed under Bank Indonesia Regulation, provides legal loopholes for money laundering and the funding of terrorism to occur. Resulting in Indonesia potentially being included in other countries’ negative investment lists. In order to prevent this, a Law on Fund Transfers was seen as being necessary.

Furthermore, the Bill aims to regulate parties to a fund transfer due to the rising numbers of fund transfers, nominal amount, and also the development of transfer methods, as noted in the preamble of the Bill. The Bill is drafted to ensure the reliability of fund transfers, and to provide certainty for parties to a fund transfer.

 

Definitions

Fund transfer

As defined under Article 1 (1) a fund transfer is a series of activities that begins once a Sender orders a fund transfer to a fund transfer provider (“Provider”) to transfer its funds to a Beneficiary, whose credentials are included in the transfer order.

A further definition of ‘funds’ is contained in Article 1 (4) which includes: cash rendered to a Provider, or an amount of cash deposited in a bank account in the Provider’s institution, or an overdraft facility given by a Provider to the Sender.

 

Fund Service Provider

Since the series of activities of a fund transfer from the Sender to the Beneficiary may involve more than one intermediary institution, Articles 1 (8) though (12) subdivide the intermediaries into those who serve as the fund transfer provider (“Provider”) as Sender’s Provider, Beneficiary’s Provider, and Intermediary Provider between the Sender’s Provider and the Beneficiary’s Provider (“Intermediary Provider”).

 

Applicability

Jurisdiction

Pursuant to Article 2, the Bill governs fund transfer activities in Indonesian Rupiah as well as in foreign currency from Indonesia or to Indonesia involving an Indonesian Provider.

 

Indonesian Legal Entity and Permit

Providers, such as banks or non-bank financial institutions, pursuant to Article 69 (1), have to be in the form of an Indonesian legal entity.

Previously, pursuant to Article 1 (3) of the Bank Indonesia Regulation No.8/28/PBI/2006 on Remittance Activity, individuals and foreign legal entities could be a Provider. With the passage of the Bill only Indonesian legal entities can render services, implying that foreign entities who currently place an agent to offer their services, must now establish themselves as an Indonesian legal entity.

However, due to jurisdiction and physical presence issues, internet based, e-wallet type, Providers are unlikely to be immediately affected due to enforceability issues.

 

Fund Transfer Principles

Article 3 sets out the principles that apply to the parties in a fund transfer, which, among others, are:

a)

the same Provider used by a Sender and a Beneficiary will be treated as separate parties in a fund transfer, which will not apply in terms of corporate responsibility.

b)

it is stipulated that the zero hour rules principle does not apply to fund transfers, suggesting that should a Provider be declared insolvent by a court or its operations suspended, or its permit revoked, a fund transfer that occurred on the day of the decision, cannot be canceled or retrieved.

c)

provisioned the finality of payment principle, where funds that have moved from one Provider to another Provider cannot be retrieved unilaterally, unless a cancellation request from a Sender Provider is present.

d)

application of the delivery versus payment principle, where it is elucidated that in the case that a fund transfer is an obligation deriving from an agreement between a Sender and it’s Beneficiary, that at the time that the Beneficiary Provider has accepted the transfer order, the Sender’s obligation to make payment is fulfilled, resulting in the Sender’s legal rights over the agreed object.

e)

the netting mechanism is recognized under the Bill, as explained in the elucidation, providers would calculate the rights and obligations of a fund transfer activity (the final calculation of rights and obligation).

 

Pursuant to Article 43, Prudence principle is to be applied relating to a cancellation of a transfer orders, and Syariah principles apply to Providers whose business is based on Syariah principles in terms of payment of fees and interest from fund transfer activity (Article 71).

 

Fund Transfers

Transfer Order

Pursuant to Article 5 (1), a transfer order that has acquired an acceptance from a Provider is, by law, an Agreement.

Whereas in order to receive an acceptance from a Provider, Article 8 (1) stipulates the requirement that a transfer order must have, among others:

a.

The Sender’s credentials;

b.

The Beneficiary’s credentials;

c.

The Beneficiary’s Provider’s credential;

d.

The amount of funds and currency that is requested to be transferred;

e.

Date of the transfer order;

f.

Other information that is required by law to be included the in the transfer order.

 

Acceptance

Pursuant to Article 15, a Provider may only accept a transfers order if the below condition are met:

a.

The transfer order includes information listed in Article 8 (1), except for credentials of the Beneficiary’s Provider if the funds were rendered in cash by the Sender;

b.

The Sender has sufficient funds available in its account;

c.

The Sender’s Provider has authenticated the transfer order; and

d.

The transfer order complies with the prevailing law and regulation on fund transfers;

 

Should the above condition be met and the order accepted, a Provider, pursuant to Article 17 (4), must execute the transfer stated in the transfer order. Failing to do so, pursuant to Article 19 (3), a Provider is obliged to pay interest or compensation to the Sender starting from the date of the acceptance until the funds are returned.

Pursuant to Article 27, the procedure and the amount to be paid in compensation to the sender will be further regulated by a Bank Indonesia Regulation. As such, Providers’ that delay fund transfers with a view of financial gain will be faced with  legal consequences.

 

Intermediary Provider

Pursuant to Article 29, should an Intermediary Provider be used, the Intermediary Provider can only execute the fund transfer should sufficient fund be available in:

a.

The Intermediary Provider’s account at the Sender’s Provider institution;

b.

The Sender’s Provider’s account at the Intermediary Provider institution;

c.

The Intermediary Provider’s account at other Provider institution; or

d.

The Intermediary Provider’s account at the Central Bank.

 

Acceptance by Beneficiary’s Provider

Pursuant to Article 36 (2) the Beneficiary’s Provider is considered to have accepted the transfer order terms should the following conditions exist:

a.

Notify the acceptance to the sending Provider;

b.

Debit the sending Provider’s account at its institution;

c.

Allocate the funds to the Beneficiary;

d.

Credit the Beneficiary’s account at its institution, or

e.

Notify the Beneficiary that the transferred funds are available to be collected.

 

The Acceptance procedures, pursuant to Article 39, will be further regulated in a Bank Indonesia Regulation.

Pursuant to Article 33, the Beneficiary’s Provider can only execute a fund transfer should sufficient fund be available in:

a.

The Beneficiary’s Provider’s account at the Sender’s Provider institution;

b.

The Sender’s Provider’s account at the Beneficiary’s Provider institution;

c.

The Beneficiary’s Provider’s account at other Provider institution; or

d.

The Beneficiary’s Provider’s account at the Central Bank.

 

Collection

Pursuant to Article 37, for fund transfers that are to be collected in cash, the Beneficiary’s Provider is obliged to notify the Beneficiary of the availability of funds for collection. Should the Beneficiary fail to collect after 3 times of being notified in a timely manner, the funds have to be returned to the Sender.

If within 90 days the Sender’s whereabouts are unknown after an attempt being made to return the funds, the fund will be given by the Sender Provider to a state chancery institution.

Pursuant to Article 40, the process of a fund transfer is considered completed if the Beneficiary has received/collected the funds.

 

Refusal

Pursuant to Article 19 (1), a Provider can refuse to accept a transfer order with reasonable excuse, in which case the Provider has to notify of its’ refusal 1 day after receiving a transfer order, by informing the Sender of the grounds for the refusal.

The suggestion is that a refusal would occur in the event that a fund transfer is suspicious and may form a part of a money laundering activity or the funding of terrorism.

Article 39 further sets out the procedures for a Beneficiary Provider to reject a transfer.

 

Unsuccessful Fund Transfers

Pursuant to Article 20, the Sender’s Provider is accountable for the fund transfer until the Beneficiary’s Provider has accepted the transfer.

It is further stipulated that a force majeure condition, as set out in Article 21, does not relieve a Provider’s obligation to perform the fund transfer. Suggesting that Article 1596 of the Indonesian Civil Code, on force majeure, is superseded by the Bill.

Pursuant to Article 23, in the event of a situation where an equivalent to a court decision prohibits the execution of a fund transfer, the Provider must inform the Sender of this within 1 working day.

Pursuant to Article 26, where an Intermediary Provider is used, and the Intermediary Provider’s business is suspended or its permit revoked, or it becomes insolvent, the Sender’s Provider is accountable to execute the transfer using other means at its own cost without waiting for the funds to be returned by the Intermediary Provider.

 

Cancellation and Modification

Cancellation

Pursuant to Article 42 in conjunction with Article 45, a cancellation may be done due to a Sender request or a court decision.

If requested by the Sender, it can only be done if an acceptance has not been made by the Beneficiary Provider, as per Article 36 (2), additionally Article 42 (2) requires an a prior agreement between the Sender and the Sender Provider on cancellation. The costs incurred will be borne by the Sender (Article 42 (4))

Pursuant to Article 42 (5) the Sender Provider will be relieved from any legal liability to the Sender deriving from the cancellation.

Pursuant to Article 45 (2) in a cancellation due to a court decision, the Beneficiary Provider will be relieved from any legal liability for not performing the fund transfer.

 

Modification

Pursuant to Article 46, a modification of a transfer order can only be done if the Beneficiary Provider has sufficient time to make the changes, and has not completed the steps stipulated in Article 36 (2).

 

Correction

Article 56 stipulates that should a Sender Provider make a mistake in performing a fund transfer, the institution is obliged make a correction by cancelling or modifying the transfer.

Pursuant to Article 57, should a Beneficiary Provider have made a mistake on the acceptance of the transfer order that results in an unintended Beneficiary collecting the funds, then the Provider is obliged to make the necessary corrections so that the rightful Beneficiary will be able to collect the funds.

Pursuant to Article 59, the Beneficiary Provider is obliged to assist other Providers should a cancellation, modification or correction occur.

 

Recovery of Funds

Pursuant to Article 47, as stipulated in Article 21 (1), if a condition that resembles a force majeure occurs, preventing a transfer, and the Sender requests a cancellation of an order, the Provider is obliged to return the funds without delay, with any delay leading to the payment of interest or compensation to the Sender.

Pursuant to Article 48 if an Intermediary Provider is selected by the Sender, the Sender Provider can return the funds once the Intermediary Provider has returned the funds. However, if an Intermediary Provider is chosen by the Sender Provider, then the Sender Provider is obliged to promptly return the fund without waiting for the funds from the Intermediary Provider.

Pursuant to Articles 50 and 51, the zero hour principle does not apply to fund transfers, therefore a Provider is not justified in stopping the execution of an accepted transfer order. And insolvency, business suspension, or permit revocation does not relieve the Provider from returning the funds to the Sender.

Pursuant to Article 53, in a cancellation of a fund transfer due to a court decision, the Beneficiary Provider is obliged to withhold the funds, and return the fund the rightful party as determined by the court.

 

Debit Transfers

Pursuant to Article 61, a debit transfer is commenced through a debit transfer order, which a Provider can only accept if the conditions set out in Article 62 (1) are met:

a.

Debit transfer order includes all of the information listed in Article 8, except for the Sender’s information;

b.

Sender Provider has made authentication (if necessary);

c.

The debit transfer order has fulfilled the internal policy of the Sender Provider;

d.

The debit transfer order complies with prevailing regulations.

 

The Sender Provider has accepted the Debit transfer order if any of the events enumerated in Article 62 (2) have taken place.

Articles 64 and 65 provide the grounds for refusing to accept a debit transfer order.

 

Fund Transfer Fee

Pursuant to Article 68, Providers are obliged to be transparent to the Sender with regards to the fees imposed for fund transfers. The procedure for charging the fee and the obligation to provide the information will be regulated in a Bank Indonesia Regulation.

 

Provider Permit

As provided under Article 69, Provider that operates in Indonesia must be in the form of an Indonesian legal entity, and has to secure a license, currently in the form of obtaining a License for a Remittance Business as regulated under Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 8/28/PBI/2006 on Remittance Businesses, and Bank Indonesia Circular Letter No. 8/32/DASP of 2006 on the Registration of Remittance Businesses.

Individuals and foreign entities can no longer render fund transfer services, and will have to be incorporated as Indonesian legal entities, pursuant to Article 89 (1), within the course of the next 2 years.

 

Supervision

Pursuant to Article 72, the supervision of fund transfer activity will be under the purview of Bank Indonesia. And, pursuant to Article 73, Providers must report their activities to Bank Indonesia.

 

Evidence and Burden of Proof

Article 76 introduces new types of evidence into the Indonesian legal system. Under Article 164 of the Indonesian Civil Procedure Law, which is the prevailing regulation on evidence, the only acknowledged evidence is:

a.

Documents;

b.

Eyewitnesses;

c.

Suspicion;

d.

Confession;

e.

Testimony under oath.

 

Article 76 states that electronic information, electronic documents, and/or printouts of fund transfer activity are also accepted as legally valid evidence. Additionally, Article 77 recognizes electronic signatures as a valid instrument of fund transfer activity.

The burden of proof with respect to delays and/or errors lays with the Provider, according to Article 78, if a delay of a fund transfer results in loss to the Sender or the Beneficiary.

 

Sanction

Administrative

Pursuant to Article 74, Bank Indonesia can impose administrative sanction towards a Provider failing to submit reports, information, and clarification (as per Articles 72 and 73). The sanctions can take the form of:

a.

Warning letters;

b.

Administrative fines;

c.

Business suspension;

d.

Permit revocation.

 

Pursuant to Article 75, the procedure for imposing sanction towards Providers will be regulated by further Bank Indonesia Regulation.

 

Criminal

Pursuant to Article 79, Providers operating without the necessary license (Article 69 (1)) will face 3 year imprisonment or a fine of up to IDR 3 billion.

Article 81 provides for a 5 year imprisonment or a fine of up to IDR 5 billion for anybody who moves funds illegally by means of a counterfeit transfer order. This also applies to any party claiming to have lawful rights towards funds, whereas in fact the person does not (Article 85).

Pursuant to Article 82, an accomplice who receives funds deriving from a counterfeit transfer order will face 4 year imprisonment and/or a fine of up to IDR 1 billion.

Pursuant to Article 83, any party that alters or erases any part of information contained in a transfer order with the goal of enriching themselves or a third party, will be subject to imprisonment of 2 years or a fine of IDR 1 billion. And where such an act causes damage to the Sender and/or the Beneficiary, the penalties will be doubled.

Article 84 provides for up to 20 year imprisonment and a fine of up to IDR 20 billion for damaging the fund transfer system.

Article 86 and Article 87 stipulate additional prison time for individuals who are employees of a Provider and for corporate perpetrators, where such individuals are subject to an additional 1/3 of the imposed sentence, and corporations are subject to an addition 2/3 of the imposed fine.

 

Conclusion

With the Bill passing the House, Indonesia now finally has a regulatory framework on fund transfers. However, this is a long overdue development, considering that in 1987 the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (UNICITRAL) has issued a Legal Guide on Electronic Funds Transfers, followed by the issuance of a Model Law on International Credit Transfers in 1992.

Following this, it took around 20 years for Indonesia to finally pass a law on fund transfers. With the perception being that the fear of being included in negative foreign investment lists had ultimately galvanized the political will for the Bill to be passed.

The Introduction of new principles of fund transfers provides more certainty to the parties conducting a fund transfer, emphasizing that force majeure conditions are not an excuse for non-performance.

With the introduction of electronic evidence and the allocation of the burden of proof to the Provider, the Bill enriches the legislative framework and fills the previously unregulated legal gaps.

The criminal sanctions provide for long imprisonment terms and substantial fines, and as such can be expected to deter illegal fund transfer activity and to prevent money laundering and the funding of terrorist groups.

Finally, it should be noted that a number of implementing regulations are necessary before the Bill will effectively come into force.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info