Overview
The trend of Indonesians travelling abroad for medical treatment has led to public discourse over the adequacy of the Indonesian health service industry, and the lack of public trust in such.
The main reasons for Indonesians to seek medical treatment abroad include the personal reasons of: a) confidence in the doctors providing treatment, b) confidence in diagnosis accuracy, c) transparency of the diagnosis, d) desire for premium health services, and e) more advanced treatment that what is available in Indonesia.
And such external reasons as: a) hospitals / healthcare service facilities and technology that are more modern and advanced, b) better services, c) attractive health package offers, d) fast and responsive handling of patients, e) lower cost, f) medical staff hospitality, and g) referrals by Indonesian doctors.
Countries that have become a destination for medical treatment are Indonesia’s neighbors: Singapore, Malaysia, and Thailand. The numbers of those seeking medical treatment abroad are substantial, with 1.5 million Indonesians from Java alone traveling abroad for medical treatment in 2007.
Advertising by foreign hospitals and clinics in Indonesia undoubtedly contributed to such numbers, however, since December 2010, foreign health facilities can no longer advertise in Indonesia, due to Article 5 (g) of Minister of Health Regulation No. 1787/MENKES/PER/XII/2010 on Advertisement and Publication of Health Services (“Advertisement Regulation”).
In order to restore public trust in the Indonesian health service industry Minister of Health Regulation No. 659/MENKES/PER/VIII/2009 on Indonesian World Class Hospitals (“World Class Hospital Regulation”) was issued. However, since its issuance there are only 2 hospitals that have been accredited as world class: Siloam Gleneagles Hospital in Karawaci, Banten and Santosa Hospital in Bandung, West Java.
The facilities providing medical services are governed by Law No. 44 of 2009 on Hospitals (“Hospital Law”) and Minister of Health Regulation No. 028/MENKES/PER/I/2011 on Clinics (“Clinic Regulation”). The medical professionals providing the services are governed by Law No. 29 of 2004 on Medical Practice (“Medical Practice Law”).
This edition of Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the legislative framework governing the health service provider industry and provide an analysis of the relevant provisions.
Purpose
Health Service Facilities
Health service facilities are classified as either Hospitals or Clinics, with both having the purpose to promote and provide health services that are preventive, curative, and rehabilitative (Article 4 (1) of the Clinic Regulation).
Hospitals, due to their larger scale, pursuant to Article 1 of the Hospital Law, provide more comprehensive health services than those offered by Clinics. This includes providing in-patient, out-patient, and emergency facilities, although some clinics, pursuant to Article 4 (2) of the Clinic Regulation, may also provide in-patient services.
Additionally, pursuant to Article 5 of the Hospital Law, Hospitals, in addition to providing healthcare services, also have a training and education purpose, as well as engaging in research and development of health science and technology.
Healthcare Providers
Medical Doctors and Dentists are classified as healthcare providers under the Medical Practice Law, which, pursuant to Article 3 governs healthcare provides with the aim to provide protection to patients, maintain and improve the quality of medical services, provide legal certainty for society, doctors, and dentists.
Hospitals
Hospitals are legal entities that can be established by the central government, regional government, or private entities (Article 7 of the Hospital Law). The current health services industry consists of both state-owned hospitals and private hospitals, with the industry no longer being a state monopoly.
Classification
Hospitals in Indonesia are classified as either General Hospitals or as Limited Practice (Specialist) Hospitals. General Hospitals are further subdivided into four types: Class A, Class B, Class C, and Class D. Limited Practice (Specialist) Hospitals are limited in classification to classes A, B and C.
Pursuant to Article 24 of the Hospital Law, General Hospitals of Class A are defined as hospitals that provide health services of at least 4 basic specialists, 5 supporting specialists, 12 other specialists, and 13 subspecialists.
General Hospitals of Class B, of at least 4 basic specialists, 4 supporting specialists, 8 other specialists, and 2 subspecialists.
General Hospitals of Class C, of at least 4 basic specialists and 4 supporting specialists.
General Hospitals of Class D, at least 2 basic specialists.
Limited Practice (Specialist) Hospitals are further discussed in the elucidation of the Article 24 of the Hospital Law.
Foreign Ownership
As provided under Article 26 of the Hospital Law, foreign ownership of Limited Practice (Specialist) Hospitals of Class A is permitted. However, pursuant to Presidential Regulation No. 36 of 2010 on the List of Business Fields Closed to Investment and Business Fields Open, With Conditions, to Investment (“Negative Investment List”), Limited Practice (Specialist) Hospitals are limited in the amount of foreign ownership to a maximum of 67%, while General Hospitals have to have 100% local capital.
Pursuant to Article 21 of the Hospital Law, to establish a private hospital, the hospital must be in the form of a limited liability company, having the company’s objective as set out in Article 7 (4), as a health service facility. Furthermore it must comply with Law. No. 40 of 2007 on Limited Liability Companies, and, in the event that it involves foreign investment, Law No. 25 of 2007 on Investment.
Infrastructure and Human Resources
A hospital must be supported with the necessary infrastructure as set out in Article 11 of the Hospital Law, and with qualified human resources (health service providers and support staff) pursuant to Articles 12 through 14. It must also have a pharmacy (Article 15), and possess reliable medical apparatus (Article 16).
Permits
When establishing a hospital a permit to establish a hospital has to be secured (Article 25 (3) of the Hospital Law), which will be valid for 2 years with a possibility of a 1 year extension. In securing the permit a feasibility study and an environmental assessment have to be carried out (Article 8).
Once the hospital’s premises are established, a hospital has to secure an operating permit pursuant to Article 25, The operating permit is valid for 5 years, where its permit’s issuance process being dependant on the hospital class applied for. The institutions having the authority to issue the permits are stipulated in Article 26.
Furthermore, when applying for a permit, it is necessary to comply with Minister of Health Regulation No. 147/MENKES/PER/I/2010 on Hospital Permits.
Organizational Structure
A hospital, pursuant to Article 33 of the Hospital Law, is required to be an organization that is effective, efficient, and accountable. The organization must consist of a Hospital Director, health service providers, who consist of doctors, nurses, and supporting medical staff. It must also have a medical committee, an internal examiner, and general and financial administrators.
Hospital Director
Pursuant Article 34 of the Hospital Law, the position of a Hospital Director cannot be filled by a foreign citizen or the hospital owner.
World Class Hospitals
The preamble of the World Class Hospital Regulation states that its purpose is to enhance Indonesian health services through supervision, accreditation, and certification of hospitals. With the certification being conducted by an independent international evaluator, such as the International Society for Quality in Healthcare (ISQua) pursuant to Minister of Health Regulation No. 1195/MENKES/SK/VIII/2010 on International Standard Hospital Accreditation Agencies.
Pursuant to Article 3 of the World Class Hospital Regulation, hospitals that have been in operation for 2 years are eligible to apply for accreditation.
Application
The application procedure for being accredited as a world class hospital, as set out in Article 10 of the World Class Hospital Regulation, can be initiated by the hospital owner or the Hospital Director. During the application, as well as after obtaining the world class hospital accreditation, the hospital will be supervised by a supervisory team that is established by the Minister of Health (Article 7 in conjunction with Article 13).
The criteria that an applicant must fulfill to acquire the world class hospital accreditation are set out in the Appendix of the World Class Hospital Regulation.
Clinics
Classification
Under Article 2 of the Clinic Regulation, clinic’s is classified into Primary (Pratama) Clinics and Main (Utama) Clinics. The difference is that Primary Clinics provides basic medical services, whereas Main Clinics provide specialist health services or both specialist and basic medical services.
Facilities
As required by Articles 9 and 10 of the Clinic Regulation, a Clinic must possess the minimum infrastructure listed, and, as required by Articles 11 through 13, it must be equipped with the listed medical equipment.
Human resources requirements are set out in Articles 15 through 17, whereas a Primary Clinic must have a minimum of 2 doctors, while a Main Clinic only requires 1 doctor for every specialist practice area.
Permit
Permits for clinics are given for 5 years pursuant to Article 21 of the Clinic Regulation. An application for the permit has to be submitted to the local regency/city government after receiving a recommendation from a health agency at the regency/city level. The documentary application requirements are further stipulated in Article 21 (3).
Advertising
Health service advertisements, pursuant to Article 7 of the Advertisement Regulation, may be done through any type of media, such as: news, banners, articles or features. The advertiser, pursuant to Article 4, must ensure that the content of the advertisement in the form of data/facts is accurate, based on proof, informative, educative, and accountable.
Prohibition of certain advertisements is stipulated in Article 5, which includes the prohibition on foreign health services advertising in Indonesia if the medical practice does not take place in Indonesia (Article 5 (g)).
Pursuant to Article 41 of the Medical Practice Law in conjunction with Article 26 of the Clinic Regulation, Medical practitioners working in a clinic or a hospital are obligated to post the name of the practicing doctor.
Pursuant to Article 11 of the World Class Hospital Regulation those hospitals that have been accredited as such cannot use this fact as part of their advertising.
Healthcare Providers
In order to practice medicine in Indonesia, a doctor must secure a Letter of Registration (Surat Tanda Registrasi / STR) pursuant to Article 29 of the Medical Practice Law. The institution that is responsible for issuing an STR is the Indonesian Medical Council (Article 7).
According to Article 7, the Indonesian Medical Council has the authority, besides accepting a doctor’s registration with the issuance of an STR, to validate the standards of the doctors’ and dentists’ profession education, and to supervise medical education institutions.
Obtaining an STR
Pursuant to Article 29 of the Medical Practice Law, an STR is valid for 5 years, and in order to obtain one, an applicant must fulfill the requirement of:
|
a.
|
degree certificate in medicine, as a doctor specialist, dentist, or dental specialist
|
|
b.
|
statement of doctor’s or dentist oath.
|
|
c.
|
health certificate of physical and mental condition.
|
|
d.
|
competency certificate; and
|
|
e.
|
statement to comply and uphold professional ethics.
|
Additionally, Article 2 of Minister of Health Regulation No.161/MENKES/PER/I/2010 on Registration of Healthcare Providers (Healthcare Provider Regulation) stipulates further details of the requirements.
Details of the Competency Test to acquire the Competency Certificate are further stipulated in Article 4 of the Healthcare Provider Regulation.
License to Practice
After securing an STR, in order for a doctor to practice medicine, they must obtain a License to Practice Medicine (Surat Ijin Praktik / SIP), pursuant to Article 2 of the Minister of Health Regulation No.512/MENKES/PER/IV/2007 on Licenses to Practice Medicine (“License Regulation”). The issuing institution of an SIP is the health agency at the regency/city government level (Article 1(3)).
Pursuant to Article 4 of the License Regulation in conjunction with Article 36 of the Medical Practice Law, a doctor can obtain a maximum of 3 SIPs (limiting the number of locations where they can practice to 3, from a previous 5).
Foreign Doctors
Based on Article 5 of the Minister of Health Regulation No.317/MENKES/PER/III/2010 on Utilization of Foreign Healthcare Providers in Indonesia (Foreign Doctor Regulation), foreign doctors may be employed for the purpose of training, transfer of technology and knowledge, as well as for the provision of a health service.
However, the number of foreign doctors formally practicing in Indonesia is comparatively low due to the stringent permit requirements that are in place. In practice, foreign doctors often do not secure the necessary permits before commencing medical practice in Indonesia, something that has resulted in deportations in the past.
Restrictions
Pursuant to Article 20 of the Clinic Regulation, Foreign Doctors are not permitted to practice in Clinics. And, based on Article 11 of the Foreign Doctor Regulation, foreign doctors are only permitted to be employed in a Class A and B hospitals.
In additional to that, based on Article 3 of the Foreign Doctor Regulation, a foreign doctor is not permitted to practice medicine independently.
When practicing medicine, a foreign doctor, pursuant to Article 25 of the Foreign Doctor Regulation, must be assisted by 2 Indonesian healthcare workers.
Employing Foreign Doctors
Pursuant to Article 15 of the Foreign Doctor Regulation, institutions that can employ foreign doctors are:
|
a.
|
Accredited health facilities / hospitals;
|
|
b.
|
Education Hospitals;
|
|
c.
|
Professional Organizations; and
|
|
d.
|
Non-education health facilities, which, however, are obliged to cooperate with an Education Hospital.
|
Classification
Foreign doctors are classified as those who provide health services and those who provide health training, pursuant to Article 10 of the Foreign Doctor Regulation. Those providing healthcare services can obtain a 1 year permit which can be extended for another year, those providing training can obtain a 6 months permit which can be extended for another 6 months.
Permits
To secure a permit for a foreign doctor, an applicant must acquire a Minister of Health Decree after acquiring a recommendation letter from the Indonesian Medical Council (Article 6 of Foreign Doctor Regulation), additionally they must obtain a recommendation letter from the collegium of doctors from their country of origin (Article 6 (2)).
The educational requirement for medical doctors, pursuant to Article 7 of the Foreign Doctor Regulation, is that of a specialist or equivalent with a Masters degree in medicine. Moreover, a foreign doctor applicant must secure an STR and an SIP issued by the Indonesian Medical Council. Additionally, foreign doctors must also comply with the Health Provider Regulation.
Following compliance with the abovementioned Articles, a foreign doctor needs to also secure a work permit from the Directorate of Immigration and to comply with Government Regulation No. 32 of 1994 on Visas, Entry Permits, and Immigration Permits.
Pursuant to Article 12 of the Foreign Doctor Regulation, to employ a foreign doctor, the employing health service facility / medical facility is obliged to secure a Utilization Plan to Use Foreign Doctors (Rencana Pengguna Tenaga Kerja Asing / RPTKA as further stipulated in Article 13) and a Permit to Employ a Foreign Doctor (Izin Mempekerjakan Tenaga Kerja Asing / IMTA as further stipulated in Article 14).
Disciplinary Actions
Patients, pursuant to Article 52 of the Medical Practice Law, have the right to:
|
a.
|
Acquire a comprehensive explanation regarding any medical treatment;
|
|
b.
|
Asks for a doctor’s/dentist’s opinion;
|
|
c.
|
Acquire health services according to their medical condition;
|
|
d.
|
Reject a medical treatment; and
|
|
e.
|
Acquire their medical records.
|
Pursuant to Article 55 in conjunction with Article 64 of the Medical Practice Law, patients can file a complaint seeking disciplinary action to the Medical Honorary Council. The Council has the authority to receive reports, examine and process the reports, and decide on the disciplinary action towards the reported health provider.
The Council’s decision, pursuant to Article 69 (3) of the Medical Practice Law, may be in the form of a written warning, recommendation to revoke the STR or SIP, and/or an order to undertake education or training at a medical education institution.
Pursuant to Article 66 (3) of the Medical Practice Law, a decision by the Council does not prevent the patient party from filing a lawsuit or making a criminal complaint.
Sanctions
Pursuant to Article 62 of the Hospital Law, parties who operate a hospital without securing an operating license may face up to 2 years imprisonment and a maximum fine of IDR 5 billion. Should the perpetrator be a company, it can be subject to 3 times heavier penalties than a natural person (Article 63).
As set out in Article 41 of the Medical Practice Law, an obligation exists to display the name of the medical practitioner including their SIP and STR, should this requirement not be complied with, pursuant to Article 79 (a) of the Medical Practice Law, the responsible party can face 1 year imprisonment or a fine of IDR 50 million.
Health service facilities that employ doctors who do not have an SIP and STR, pursuant to Article 80 of the Medical Practice Law, may face imprisonment of 10 years or a fine of up to IDR 300 million.
Doctors who practice medicine without securing the appropriate registration (Article 29 (1) for domestic doctors, and Article 31 (1) and 32 (1) for foreign doctors), pursuant to Article 75 of the Medical Practice Law, may face up to 3 years imprisonment or a fines of up to IDR 100 million.
Conclusion
An effective deterrent issue in the framework for medical facilities and medical practitioners is that, compared to the stringent registration requirements, the sanctions for those violating foreign doctor employment and registration requirements are either imprisonment or the payment of a relatively inexpensive fine. Also notable is that the Advertisement Regulation prevents the promotion of foreign medical services, but lacks sanctions towards the foreign advertiser, admittedly domiciled in another jurisdiction, or the party who publishes the foreign medical service advertisement domestically.
Finally, in all of the government’s attempts to improve Indonesian medical services, the limits on competition, in the form of only allowing foreign investment in Limited Practice (Specialist) Hospitals, remain in place.
......