Government Regulation on the Conversion of Agricultural Land as Part of a the Conversion of Agricultural Land

Overview

Extreme weather, global weather anomalies, and climate change have begun to affect food- producing nations. Indonesia, who was previously self-sufficient in terms of rice production is now a net importer, and has recently halted exports of food crops to safeguard the nation’s food security.

Along with imports, a heavily criticized import duty exemption for food crops was introduced by Minister of Finance Regulation No. 13 of 2011 on the Fifth Amendment to Minister of Finance Regulation No. 110/PMK.010/2006 on the Classification System for Goods and the Determination the Rate of Duty on Imported Goods.

To anticipate long-term dependency on rice, and other food crop, imports, the government is of the view that the long-term solution is to expand production areas, whereby Law No. 41 of 2009 on the Protection of Agricultural Land for Food Security (“Law”) aims to solve the long-term food shortage problems.

Pursuant to Articles 26 and 56 of the Law, which call for further implementing regulations, the government has issued Government Regulation No. 1 of 2011 on the Designation and Conversion of Agricultural Land for Food Security (“Regulation”), which has been in force since 5 January 2011.

This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight key features of the Regulation and provide an analysis of its provisions.

 

Purpose

Early this year the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) under the United Nations had warned the world of the possibility of future food crises. The symptoms are already being felt in Indonesia, where the price of chili have increased fivefold to around IDR 100 thousand per kilogram. The price-shock was so unexpected that the Minister of Agriculture’s short-term solution to stabilizing chili prices was to call for a national campaign to encourage people to plant chilies in their backyards.

The main food crop for Indonesia is rice, for the February 2011 target, the National Food Logistics Agency (BULOG) targeted to collect 3.2 million tons to ensure national food security, however, only 1.9 million tons were acquired from domestic farmers, resulting in the government importing 1.3 million tons from Thailand and Vietnam.

Once again, the rice shortages were not anticipated, with the Minister of Agriculture calling for a “No Rice Day” campaign to reduce rice intake by the Indonesian public.

As a response, Indonesia is now conducting programs to maximize land utilization. The Minister of the Economy, the Minister of Forestry, and the National Land Board have allocated an additional 2 million hectares of land, consisting of: 1 milling hectares for soya beans, 500 thousand hectares for sugarcane, with the rest being designated for corn, beans, and other vegetation.

The Regulation aims to address the issue of food scarcity and to alleviate the national food production deficiency, and also to anticipate the possibility that Vietnam and Thailand, who are the largest rice exporters in the world, halt their rice exports to ensure their own national food security in the event that their production declines.

Technically, the Regulation further implements Articles 26 and 53 of the Law, since Articles 17 though 25 of the Law, regarding procedure, requirements, and criteria for designating protected agricultural land for food crops security require further implementing regulation pursuant to Article 26 of the Law.

Similarly, Articles 44 through Article 52 of the Law, regarding land function conversion, infrastructure investment appraisal, the criteria of land for the purpose of conversion, and monetary and substitute land compensation require further implementing regulation pursuant to Article 53 of the Law.

 

Definitions and Applicability

Land

Pursuant to Article 2 of the Regulation, land subject to the Regulation’s provisions is that which is being designated as agricultural land for food security, as well as already designated land that is being converted to other functions.

According to Article 4 (a) in conjunction with Article 6, areas that will be designated as agricultural areas for food security are classified as national, provincial, and regency/city areas. Where a national area is one that covers more than 1 province, and a provincial area is one that covers more than one regency/city. While a regency/city area is one that covers more than 1 village.

According to Articles 4 (b) and (c), such agricultural land consists of agricultural land for food security and agricultural land reserves for food security, both being located in agricultural areas for food security.

 

Parties

Pursuant to Article 3, the Regulation applies to all businesses whose revenue derives from utilizing land for any purpose, since the aim of the Regulation is to secure land for food security purposes, creating the possibility that their land will be designated as such.

Public officials at the level of central, provincial, and regency/city government, whose areas are designated as agricultural areas for food security.

Land owners of 20 hectares or more, pursuant to the elucidation of Article 8 (a), will also be subject to the Regulation’s provisions.

 

Designation of an Area

Criteria

Pursuant to Article 8, not all areas can be designated as agricultural areas for food security, the areas must have sufficient land for agricultural purposes, and be able to produce food crops fulfilling the needs at the regional/city, provincial and/or at the national level.

As further stipulated in Article 9, areas that can be designated as agricultural areas for food security include both already designated agricultural areas as well as other areas. The areas are also subject to inclusion in the National Plan for the Protection of Agricultural Land for Food Security.

Pursuant to Article 10 the exact procedure and criteria for designation will be further stipulated by future ministerial regulation.

 

Proposal

Should the criteria set out in Article 8 in conjunction with Article 9 be met, a stakeholder having an interest in the designation of an area as an agricultural area for food security, will make a proposal to the relevant level of government pursuant to Article 11.

The proposal has to consist of textual, numeric and spatial data/information, providing a broad indication of the proposed area (national, provincial, regency/city), and must discuss self-reliance and food security.

 

Designation

The proposal will eventually lead to a determination by the relevant level of government. For the national level this is further stipulated in Article 12, for the provincial level in Article 15, and for the regency/city level in Article 16.

 

Designation of Land

Criteria

Land that is located in designated agricultural areas for food security can be designated as agricultural land for food security. Pursuant to Article 22 (1), in order to be designated as such, the land must fulfill the criteria of:

a.

being located in an integrated area which supports productivity and efficiency of the production of the needed food crops,

b.

having the technical potential and suitability as agricultural land for food security,

c.

being supported by basic infrastructure; and/or

d.

having been utilized for the production of food crops.

 

Further details of the above criteria are set out in Articles 22 (2), (3), and (4).

Pursuant to Article 24 the exact procedure and criteria for designation will be further stipulated by future ministerial regulation.

 

Proposal

To secure the designation of land as agricultural land for food security, interested parties must submit a proposal to the regency/city official pursuant to Article 25.

The proposal has to consist of textual, numeric and spatial data/information, providing a broad indication of the proposed land, and must discuss self-reliance and food security.

 

Designation

Pursuant to Article 26, the proposal must undergo scrutiny by the regency/city official. Whereby it will be verified and coordinated with officials in charge of the regency/city zoning policy and the local land agency. It is of note, however, that the Regulation lacks a timeline for the officials to render a decision on the designation of land.

 

Designation as Reserve Land

Agricultural land reserves for food security, pursuant to Article 27, derive from abandoned land or former forest land. The criteria for agricultural land reserves for food security are similar to the criteria of agricultural land for food security (Article 30), and will be further stipulated by future ministerial regulation according to Article 32.

Additionally, pursuant to Article 31, the proposed reserve land must not be in dispute.

The proposal for the designation of land as agricultural land reserves for food security is subject to scrutiny, same as agricultural land for food security, with the procedure being set out in Article 34.

 

Conversion of Agricultural Land for Food Security

Pursuant to Article 35 (1), the conversion of designated agricultural land for food security is prohibited, except in the event that one of the enumerated exceptions can be made out, with the land being procured for:

a.

public purpose, or

b.

in the event of natural disaster (such as lands in the Aceh province that were affected by the tsunami, or lands affected by the Merapi volcanic eruption).

 

Article 36 limits public purpose conversion, to: public roads, reservoirs, dams, irrigation, clean/drinking water pipelines, drainage and sanitation, irrigation buildings, ports, airports, tail track and stations, terminals, public safety facilities, conversation areas, and power plants and their networks. Notably this list does not include retail or residential developments.

 

Requirements to Convert

Pursuant to Article 39, in order to convert agricultural land for food security for public purposes, the following requirements have to be fulfilled:

a.

a strategic feasibility study (further stipulated in Article 40);

b.

a plan to convert the function of the land (further stipulated in Article 41);

c.

compensation plan for the owner/rights holder of the land (further stipulated in Article 42); and

d.

availability of replacement land for the land that is converted (further stipulated in Article 43)

 

Procedure

The relevant government institution that will make the re-designation depends on the location of the land. Where it involves more than a single province, it will be the central government, where it involves more than a single regency/city it will be the provincial government, and the regency/city government otherwise (Article 46).

Pursuant to Article 47, a verification team will be formed before a re-designation is made. The team will consist of individuals in the field of agriculture, development plan, infrastructure development, and land specialists. Pursuant to Article 48 the re-designation will be integrated with changes in zoning.

 

Compensation

Pursuant to Article 50, agricultural land for food security cannot be converted without providing compensation to the land owner / land right user. In addition to monetary compensation, compensation for the infrastructure located on the converted land has to be provided. The compensation will derive from the state budget, the provincial budget, or regency/city budget. A special team will decide the value of compensation for the infrastructure.

 

Sanctions

The Regulation does not contain specific sanctions for violations of its provisions, instead, one must refer to the umbrella law, respectively Law No. 41 of 2009 on the Protection of Agricultural Land for Food Security.

 

Administrative Sanctions

Since the Regulation is a further stipulation of Articles 17 though 26 and 44 though 52 of the Law, parties who fail to provide compensation for the existing infrastructure, as per Article 50 of the Regulation, will face administrative sanctions in accordance with Article 70 of the Law, consisting of:

a.

temporary suspension of activities;

b.

temporary suspension of the provision of public services;

c.

shutdown of the lcoation;

d.

permit revocation;

e.

permit cancellation;

f.

infrastructure demolition;

g.

land restoration;

h.

removal of incentives; and/or

i.

administrative fines.

 

Criminal Sanctions

A conversion of agricultural land for food security that does not comply with the Articles contained in Chapter III of the Regulation, the perpetrator may be subject to criminal sanction pursuant to Article 72 of the Law. The perpetrator will face 5 years imprisonment and a criminal fine of a maximum of IDR 1 billion. In the event that the criminal act is committed by a public official, the imposed imprisonment will be further extended by 1/3.

 

Conclusion

The Regulation, as mentioned in the preamble, is designed to further stipulate Articles 26 and 53 of the Law, which in essence refers to Articles 17 though 25 and 44 though 53. Unfortunately, the Regulation fails to explicitly set out what kind of protection the land owners can expect, following a designation as agricultural land for food security.

In essence, the Regulation’s articles are heavily focused on the designation of land as agricultural land for food security and the procedure for conversion to other purposes. Providing less attention to private individuals whose land is affected by the Regulation. However, in the grand scheme of the Regulation, it is designed to secure national food security, and as such can be expected to heavily focus on securing land for such purpose.

Therefore the affected private entities/individuals are left to refer to other regulations on compensation payments.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

Extreme weather, global weather anomalies, and climate change have begun to affect food- producing nations. Indonesia, who was previously self-sufficient in terms of rice production is now a net importer, and has recently halted exports of food crops to safeguard the nation’s food security.

Along with imports, a heavily criticized import duty exemption for food crops was introduced by Minister of Finance Regulation No. 13 of 2011 on the Fifth Amendment to Minister of Finance Regulation No. 110/PMK.010/2006 on the Classification System for Goods and the Determination the Rate of Duty on Imported Goods.

To anticipate long-term dependency on rice, and other food crop, imports, the government is of the view that the long-term solution is to expand production areas, whereby Law No. 41 of 2009 on the Protection of Agricultural Land for Food Security (“Law”) aims to solve the long-term food shortage problems.

Pursuant to Articles 26 and 56 of the Law, which call for further implementing regulations, the government has issued Government Regulation No. 1 of 2011 on the Designation and Conversion of Agricultural Land for Food Security (“Regulation”), which has been in force since 5 January 2011.

This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight key features of the Regulation and provide an analysis of its provisions.

 

Purpose

Early this year the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) under the United Nations had warned the world of the possibility of future food crises. The symptoms are already being felt in Indonesia, where the price of chili have increased fivefold to around IDR 100 thousand per kilogram. The price-shock was so unexpected that the Minister of Agriculture’s short-term solution to stabilizing chili prices was to call for a national campaign to encourage people to plant chilies in their backyards.

The main food crop for Indonesia is rice, for the February 2011 target, the National Food Logistics Agency (BULOG) targeted to collect 3.2 million tons to ensure national food security, however, only 1.9 million tons were acquired from domestic farmers, resulting in the government importing 1.3 million tons from Thailand and Vietnam.

Once again, the rice shortages were not anticipated, with the Minister of Agriculture calling for a “No Rice Day” campaign to reduce rice intake by the Indonesian public.

As a response, Indonesia is now conducting programs to maximize land utilization. The Minister of the Economy, the Minister of Forestry, and the National Land Board have allocated an additional 2 million hectares of land, consisting of: 1 milling hectares for soya beans, 500 thousand hectares for sugarcane, with the rest being designated for corn, beans, and other vegetation.

The Regulation aims to address the issue of food scarcity and to alleviate the national food production deficiency, and also to anticipate the possibility that Vietnam and Thailand, who are the largest rice exporters in the world, halt their rice exports to ensure their own national food security in the event that their production declines.

Technically, the Regulation further implements Articles 26 and 53 of the Law, since Articles 17 though 25 of the Law, regarding procedure, requirements, and criteria for designating protected agricultural land for food crops security require further implementing regulation pursuant to Article 26 of the Law.

Similarly, Articles 44 through Article 52 of the Law, regarding land function conversion, infrastructure investment appraisal, the criteria of land for the purpose of conversion, and monetary and substitute land compensation require further implementing regulation pursuant to Article 53 of the Law.

 

Definitions and Applicability

Land

Pursuant to Article 2 of the Regulation, land subject to the Regulation’s provisions is that which is being designated as agricultural land for food security, as well as already designated land that is being converted to other functions.

According to Article 4 (a) in conjunction with Article 6, areas that will be designated as agricultural areas for food security are classified as national, provincial, and regency/city areas. Where a national area is one that covers more than 1 province, and a provincial area is one that covers more than one regency/city. While a regency/city area is one that covers more than 1 village.

According to Articles 4 (b) and (c), such agricultural land consists of agricultural land for food security and agricultural land reserves for food security, both being located in agricultural areas for food security.

 

Parties

Pursuant to Article 3, the Regulation applies to all businesses whose revenue derives from utilizing land for any purpose, since the aim of the Regulation is to secure land for food security purposes, creating the possibility that their land will be designated as such.

Public officials at the level of central, provincial, and regency/city government, whose areas are designated as agricultural areas for food security.

Land owners of 20 hectares or more, pursuant to the elucidation of Article 8 (a), will also be subject to the Regulation’s provisions.

 

Designation of an Area

Criteria

Pursuant to Article 8, not all areas can be designated as agricultural areas for food security, the areas must have sufficient land for agricultural purposes, and be able to produce food crops fulfilling the needs at the regional/city, provincial and/or at the national level.

As further stipulated in Article 9, areas that can be designated as agricultural areas for food security include both already designated agricultural areas as well as other areas. The areas are also subject to inclusion in the National Plan for the Protection of Agricultural Land for Food Security.

Pursuant to Article 10 the exact procedure and criteria for designation will be further stipulated by future ministerial regulation.

 

Proposal

Should the criteria set out in Article 8 in conjunction with Article 9 be met, a stakeholder having an interest in the designation of an area as an agricultural area for food security, will make a proposal to the relevant level of government pursuant to Article 11.

The proposal has to consist of textual, numeric and spatial data/information, providing a broad indication of the proposed area (national, provincial, regency/city), and must discuss self-reliance and food security.

 

Designation

The proposal will eventually lead to a determination by the relevant level of government. For the national level this is further stipulated in Article 12, for the provincial level in Article 15, and for the regency/city level in Article 16.

 

Designation of Land

Criteria

Land that is located in designated agricultural areas for food security can be designated as agricultural land for food security. Pursuant to Article 22 (1), in order to be designated as such, the land must fulfill the criteria of:

a.

being located in an integrated area which supports productivity and efficiency of the production of the needed food crops,

b.

having the technical potential and suitability as agricultural land for food security,

c.

being supported by basic infrastructure; and/or

d.

having been utilized for the production of food crops.

 

Further details of the above criteria are set out in Articles 22 (2), (3), and (4).

Pursuant to Article 24 the exact procedure and criteria for designation will be further stipulated by future ministerial regulation.

 

Proposal

To secure the designation of land as agricultural land for food security, interested parties must submit a proposal to the regency/city official pursuant to Article 25.

The proposal has to consist of textual, numeric and spatial data/information, providing a broad indication of the proposed land, and must discuss self-reliance and food security.

 

Designation

Pursuant to Article 26, the proposal must undergo scrutiny by the regency/city official. Whereby it will be verified and coordinated with officials in charge of the regency/city zoning policy and the local land agency. It is of note, however, that the Regulation lacks a timeline for the officials to render a decision on the designation of land.

 

Designation as Reserve Land

Agricultural land reserves for food security, pursuant to Article 27, derive from abandoned land or former forest land. The criteria for agricultural land reserves for food security are similar to the criteria of agricultural land for food security (Article 30), and will be further stipulated by future ministerial regulation according to Article 32.

Additionally, pursuant to Article 31, the proposed reserve land must not be in dispute.

The proposal for the designation of land as agricultural land reserves for food security is subject to scrutiny, same as agricultural land for food security, with the procedure being set out in Article 34.

 

Conversion of Agricultural Land for Food Security

Pursuant to Article 35 (1), the conversion of designated agricultural land for food security is prohibited, except in the event that one of the enumerated exceptions can be made out, with the land being procured for:

a.

public purpose, or

b.

in the event of natural disaster (such as lands in the Aceh province that were affected by the tsunami, or lands affected by the Merapi volcanic eruption).

 

Article 36 limits public purpose conversion, to: public roads, reservoirs, dams, irrigation, clean/drinking water pipelines, drainage and sanitation, irrigation buildings, ports, airports, tail track and stations, terminals, public safety facilities, conversation areas, and power plants and their networks. Notably this list does not include retail or residential developments.

 

Requirements to Convert

Pursuant to Article 39, in order to convert agricultural land for food security for public purposes, the following requirements have to be fulfilled:

a.

a strategic feasibility study (further stipulated in Article 40);

b.

a plan to convert the function of the land (further stipulated in Article 41);

c.

compensation plan for the owner/rights holder of the land (further stipulated in Article 42); and

d.

availability of replacement land for the land that is converted (further stipulated in Article 43)

 

Procedure

The relevant government institution that will make the re-designation depends on the location of the land. Where it involves more than a single province, it will be the central government, where it involves more than a single regency/city it will be the provincial government, and the regency/city government otherwise (Article 46).

Pursuant to Article 47, a verification team will be formed before a re-designation is made. The team will consist of individuals in the field of agriculture, development plan, infrastructure development, and land specialists. Pursuant to Article 48 the re-designation will be integrated with changes in zoning.

 

Compensation

Pursuant to Article 50, agricultural land for food security cannot be converted without providing compensation to the land owner / land right user. In addition to monetary compensation, compensation for the infrastructure located on the converted land has to be provided. The compensation will derive from the state budget, the provincial budget, or regency/city budget. A special team will decide the value of compensation for the infrastructure.

 

Sanctions

The Regulation does not contain specific sanctions for violations of its provisions, instead, one must refer to the umbrella law, respectively Law No. 41 of 2009 on the Protection of Agricultural Land for Food Security.

 

Administrative Sanctions

Since the Regulation is a further stipulation of Articles 17 though 26 and 44 though 52 of the Law, parties who fail to provide compensation for the existing infrastructure, as per Article 50 of the Regulation, will face administrative sanctions in accordance with Article 70 of the Law, consisting of:

a.

temporary suspension of activities;

b.

temporary suspension of the provision of public services;

c.

shutdown of the lcoation;

d.

permit revocation;

e.

permit cancellation;

f.

infrastructure demolition;

g.

land restoration;

h.

removal of incentives; and/or

i.

administrative fines.

 

Criminal Sanctions

A conversion of agricultural land for food security that does not comply with the Articles contained in Chapter III of the Regulation, the perpetrator may be subject to criminal sanction pursuant to Article 72 of the Law. The perpetrator will face 5 years imprisonment and a criminal fine of a maximum of IDR 1 billion. In the event that the criminal act is committed by a public official, the imposed imprisonment will be further extended by 1/3.

 

Conclusion

The Regulation, as mentioned in the preamble, is designed to further stipulate Articles 26 and 53 of the Law, which in essence refers to Articles 17 though 25 and 44 though 53. Unfortunately, the Regulation fails to explicitly set out what kind of protection the land owners can expect, following a designation as agricultural land for food security.

In essence, the Regulation’s articles are heavily focused on the designation of land as agricultural land for food security and the procedure for conversion to other purposes. Providing less attention to private individuals whose land is affected by the Regulation. However, in the grand scheme of the Regulation, it is designed to secure national food security, and as such can be expected to heavily focus on securing land for such purpose.

Therefore the affected private entities/individuals are left to refer to other regulations on compensation payments.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info