Overview
Transfer pricing is defined as a transaction with an affiliated entity, and, if seen from a business perspective, is often considered profitable due to the inherent certainty of such arrangements, but also due to the potential tax savings that can be attained.
Such tax savings can be taken advantage of by shifting profits from one affiliated company to another by artificially lowering or raising a transaction value. Thereby reducing value added tax and the tax on luxury goods, as well as gaining the ability to shift profits so as to minimize the aggregate income tax payments.
In order to prevent such manipulation in affiliated transactions, Director General of Tax Regulation No. PER-43/PJ/2010 on the Implementation of Reasonable and Acceptable (arm’s length) Principles Between Taxpayers and Other Parties Having a Special Relationship (“Regulation 43”) has been issued, and has been in force since 6 September 2010.
In part to complement Regulation 43, in instances where an Indonesian tax subject engages in transfer pricing with their affiliate in another jurisdiction, Director General of Tax Regulation No. PER-48/PJ/2010 on Procedures in Implementing the Mutual Agreement Procedure Based on Avoidance of Double Taxation Agreement (“Regulation 48”) has been issued, and has been in force since 3 November 2010.
This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of Regulation 43, and Regulation 48 as relevant, and provide an analysis of the related legislative framework.
Purpose
Regulation 43
Based on Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) data, over 60% of world trade consists of affiliated transactions, giving rise to a substantial volume of transfer pricing, and ample opportunity for manipulation.
Since transfer pricing in itself does not necessarily constitute inappropriate business conduct, even though the manipulation of transfer pricing often does, Regulation 43 aims to provide guidelines to parties to affiliated transactions for determining a proper and reasonable method of valuing the transaction. This will save time and money by preventing the parties from being subject to adjustments by the Directorate General of Tax, as per the authority granted under Article 18 (3) of Law No. 7 of 1983, as amended by Law No. 36 of 2008, on Income Tax (Income Tax Law), in conjunction with Article 2 (1) of Law No. 8 of 1983, as amended by law No. 42 of 2009, on Value Added Tax for Goods and Services and Sales Tax for Luxury Goods (VAT Law).
In essence, Regulation 43 aims to set out how the value of a transfer pricing transaction should be determined. With the affiliated parties essentially being obliged to treat the transaction as if the transaction was done with a non-affiliated counterpart, i.e. to apply the arm’s length principle.
Regulation 48
Affiliated transactions may involve parties that are tax subjects of different jurisdictions, with the possibility of double taxation emerging as a consequence, in the absence of a double taxation treaty.
In order to prevent double taxation, since 1971 Indonesia has entered into dozens of bilateral tax treaties, now totaling 59 countries.
Article 32 A in conjunction with Article 18 (3) of the Income Tax Law allow for adjustments to transfer pricing. Regulation 48 serves as guidelines for the implementation of Mutual Agreement Procedures of double taxation treaties, setting out the process for making any adjustments, including how to handle transfer pricing in the context of double taxation.
Applicability
Regulation 43 applies to, as per Article 1 (5), affiliated parties, as defined in Article 18 (4) of the Income Tax Law and Article 2 (2) of the VAT Law.
Based on these articles, affiliation can be segmented into:
|
1.
|
Direct or indirect ownership of a company by the same legal entity;
|
|
2.
|
Ownership of 25% or more;
|
|
3.
|
Familial relationships; and
|
|
4.
|
As further set out by the Minister of Finance.
|
Definitions
Transfer pricing transactions may involve goods, both tangible and intangible, movable and immovable, or services.
Pursuant to Article 1 (9) in conjunction with Article 2 (2) of Regulation 43, transfer pricing is defined as price determination in a transaction between parties who have a special relationship. With transactions subject to Regulation 43 including:
|
a.
|
Sales, transfer, purchase or acquisition of tangible or intangible goods;
|
|
b.
|
Lease, royalty, or other honorarium acquired from rendering or for utilizing tangible or intangible goods;
|
|
c.
|
Income or expenses for rendering or utilizing certain services;
|
|
d.
|
Fund allocation; and
|
|
e.
|
Rendering or acquiring property in the form of financial instruments, and income or expenses that arise from rendering or acquiring goods in the form of financial instruments.
|
Example
Director General of Tax Circular Letter No. SE-04/PJ/7/1993 on the Guidelines for Handling Transfer Pricing Cases provides examples of unreasonable price determination in transfer pricing transactions. The following is one such example:
Company A has 25% ownership in company B. During a sale and purchase transaction between company A and B, company A determined that each unit sold to company B is priced at IDR 160/unit, while in reality the price would be different if company A entered into a transaction with a non-affiliated company, for instance company X at IDR 200/unit.
Under these circumstances the Directorate General of Tax, under Article 18 (3) of the Income Tax Law, can adjust the determined transfer price. It will use the comparable uncontrolled price method, under which the IDR 200/unit price will be used to recalculate the income and the tax imposed as a result of the transaction. Resulting in Company B having to pay the reminder of the outstanding Value Added Tax or Luxury Goods Sales Tax, if applicable. Also as a consequence, Company A’s income tax would be readjusted due to a different sale price being used.
Arm’s Length Principle
In order to determine an acceptable transfer price, affiliated parties are obliged to conduct a comparative analysis using internal and external data for comparison, and documentation of the transaction as set out in Article 4 (2) of Regulation 43.
Pursuant to Article 5 (1) of Regulation 43, the following variables have to be analyzed:
|
a)
|
Object being transacted; (further stipulated in Article 6 of Regulation 43);
|
|
b)
|
Function of each party in the transaction; (further stipulated in Article 7 of Regulation 43);
|
|
c)
|
Provisions of the contract; (further stipulated in Article 8 of Regulation 43);
|
|
d)
|
Economic condition; (further stipulated in Article 9 of Regulation 43); and
|
|
e)
|
Business strategy (further stipulated in Article 10 of Regulation 43).
|
Method
Pursuant to Article 11 of Regulation 43, in addition to the comparative analysis obligation, affiliated parties having to determine a reasonable and fair price of an affiliated transaction must also use the most appropriate method, out of:
|
a.
|
Comparable uncontrolled price - CUP (as defined in Article 1 (12));
|
|
b.
|
Resale price method - RPM, or the cost plus method - CPM (as defined in Articles 1 (13) and (14)); or
|
|
c.
|
Profit split method - PSM, or the transactional net margin method - TNMM (as defined in Articles 1 (15) and (16)).
|
Article 11 (3) requires that, in determining the most appropriate transfer pricing method, the abovementioned methods should be applied sequentially. The CUP is to be used first, and should CUP not be the most proper method, the RPM or CPM is to be considered, followed by the PSM or TNMM.
Exception
As per Article 3 (3) of Regulation 43, if an affiliated transaction results in income or expenses from the transaction of less than IDR 10 million, the parties are not obliged to apply the arm’s length principle nor use the abovementioned methods. Nonetheless, the parties to the transaction are still obliged to comply with Article 28 of Law No. 6 of 1983, as amended by Law No. 28 of 2007, on General Provisions and Tax Procedures (Tax Procedures Law), as it pertains to bookkeeping and tax reporting.
Documentation and Tax Reporting
Tax subjects who engage in transfer pricing, pursuant to Article 18 of Regulation 43, are obliged to comply with Article 28 of the Tax Procedures Law regarding bookkeeping and tax reporting. As set out in Article 18 (3), the documents that have to be submitted to the Directorate General of Tax include:
|
a.
|
General structure of the company including details such as the structure of the business group, ownership structure, organizational structure, business operational structure, list of competitors, and a description of the business environment;
|
|
b.
|
The policy used in determining the price and/or cost allocation determination;
|
|
c.
|
The results of analysis of the object being transacted, the functionality analysis, the economic condition, provisions of the agreed contract, and the business strategy (see the discussion of Article 5 (1) of Regulation 43 above).
|
|
d.
|
The selected price determination method;
|
|
e.
|
Documentation on the application of methods used in determining a proper and reasonable price or profit, which are chosen by the taxpayer.
|
Sanctions
Pursuant to Article 20 of Regulation 43, transfer pricing transactions that are found by the Directorate General of Tax to be improper can be adjusted. Whereby the methods and all of the supporting documentation for the transfer pricing in applying the arm’s length principle by the affiliated companies will be re-considered.
In the event that a reasonable explanation that clarifies the chosen method and the supporting documentation of the transfer pricing transaction is absent, the Directorate General of Tax can determine the proper and reasonable price and profit, using the most appropriate method as per its discretion.
Criminal
Although Regulation 43 does not provide for any criminal sanctions for inappropriate transfer pricing practices, pursuant to Article 20 (5), it is stipulated that a criminal investigation may be conducted if an indication of tax fraud is present. Further stipulation of how the investigation will take place are contained in Article 44 of the Tax Procedures Law.
Double Taxation
Double taxation in the context of transfer pricing transactions may occur in cross border transactions. Pursuant to Article 2 (1) of Regulation 48, an Indonesian tax subject or a treaty partner tax subject may apply for a Mutual Agreement Procedure (MAP) - an administrative procedure agreed by parties of a tax treaty to resolve problems arising in implementing a double taxation avoidance agreement, as per Article 1 (2) of Regulation 48.
Request
In resolving double taxation issues involving a transfer pricing scheme, an applicant must file a written request to the Directorate General of Tax, through the head of the tax office where the tax subject is registered. Pursuant to Article 4 (1) the applicant must submit information consisting of:
|
a.
|
Identity of the tax subject requesting the MAP;
|
|
b.
|
Identity of the affiliated party who is a treaty partner tax subject engaging in the transfer pricing scheme.
|
|
c.
|
Report of the action taken by the treaty partner that is not in line with the agreed tax treaty.
|
|
d.
|
Report of an objection to a treaty partner tax administration office, or an appeal to a tax court at the partner’s venue, which requested a correction and adjustment over the decided tax letter.
|
|
e.
|
Fiscal year of the matter in dispute.
|
|
f.
|
Explanation of the adjustment made to the transfer pricing by the treaty partner, consisting of the substance of the transaction, the value of the adjustment, and the basis for the adjustment.
|
|
g.
|
Opinion of the Indonesian tax subject regarding the correction.
|
|
h.
|
Parties that can be contacted by the Directorate General of Tax to follow up on the MAP request.
|
|
i.
|
Name of the relevant tax office, and, if possible, the specific unit name.
|
|
j.
|
Provisions of the tax treaty, which are seen by the tax subject as not being applied correctly.
|
In addition to the abovementioned documents, pursuant to Article 9 of Regulation 48, MAP applicants have to comply with Appendix I of Regulation 48.
Parties who apply for MAP, if represented by an attorney pursuant to Article 4 (2), are obliged to submit a power of attorney letter.
Time Limits
In applying for MAP, an applicant must consider the relevant time limits, since the time limits vary from one tax treaty to another.
Treaty partners who do not have a MAP time limit are the United Kingdom and Saudi Arabia, while the typical time limit for most partner countries is 2 to 3 years (United States, Japan, Netherlands, Philippines). Failing to abide by the time limits will result in a rejection by the Directorate General of Tax pursuant to Article 4 (8) (a) of Regulation 48.
Timeframe
Upon submission of the documents as set out in Article 4 (1), the Head of the Tax Office will have 30 calendar days to process the application before forwarding it to Director II of Tax Regulation.
Director II of Tax Regulation will then have 15 calendar days to determine whether the MAP application is complete or incomplete (Article 4(5)). Following the submission of the completed documents, Director II of Tax Regulation will further process the MAP request via a written consultation with the tax officials of the treaty partner (Article 4 (7)).
An issue with Regulation 48 is that, although a timeframe is provided for Indonesian tax officials, any kind of timing certainty from partner countries is absent from Regulation 48, leaving the applicant to refer to the MAP in the partner country or be subject to the whims of the partner country tax officials.
Pursuant to Article 7 of Regulation 48, the Directorate General of Tax, in the course of following up on a MAP request, can meet for consultation with the tax officials from the partner country, so as to come up with a Mutual Agreement Draft, which will affect the determination of the partner country’s tax officials with regards to the objection by the MAP applicant.
Pursuant to Articles 7 (3) and (4) of Regulation 48, the Mutual Agreement Draft will be communicated to the MAP applicant, who has to approve or disapprove of the Mutual Agreement Draft within 30 days from being notified by the Directorate General of Tax. Following an approval, should there be adjustment of the tax payable, pursuant to Article 7 (6) of Regulation 48 the Director General of Tax will inform the Mutual Agreement to the MAP applicant.
MAP process stoppage
Pursuant to Article 8 of Regulation 48, the Directorate General of Tax can stop the implementation of MAP in the event that:
|
1)
|
MAP applicant submits a cancellation request letter;
|
|
2)
|
Mutual Agreement Draft is not agreed to by the MAP applicant;
|
|
3)
|
MAP applicant does not provide all of the requested data, information and documents needed by the Directorate General of Tax; or
|
|
4)
|
Submission of incorrect/false information to the Directorate General of Tax.
|
Conclusion
Transfer pricing is not necessarily inappropriate, as is often perceived by the public. However, due to such transactions at times being used by multinational as well as local affiliated companies to reduce their tax liabilities, the issuance of Regulation 43 is intended to serve as a guideline for affiliated parties to apply the arm’s length principle and select the most appropriate method of determining the price. Parties failing to comply with Regulation 43 may face tax adjustment and recalculation, or even criminal prosecution.
Transfer pricing often involves cross border transactions, and as such raises issues of double taxation. Regulation 48 provides a guide for MAP applicants on how to take advantage of their rights under the tax treaties within a government to government framework, and, as such serves to complement Regulation 43.
......