Overview
To accelerate infrastructure development, as well as to encourage investors to participate in state-procured infrastructure projects in Indonesia, the government has introduced a range of cooperation initiatives with business entities, through Public-Private Partnerships (‘PPP’). Such infrastructure development includes infrastructure for, among others, transportation, road, telecommunication and informatics, oil and gas, and electricity.
Following such PPP initiatives, in December 2010, the government issued a presidential regulation, which addresses infrastructure guarantees designed to improve the creditworthiness of infrastructure projects and to encourage private sector participation. The infrastructure guarantees are implemented by the Minister of Finance through PT Penjaminan Infrastruktur Indonesia (Persero) (Indonesia Infrastructure Guarantee Fund / ‘IIGF’). IIGF has insured the risks of private contractors in 3 large state-procured infrastructure projects, namely an airport railway project, 2 x 1000 Megawatt power plants in Central Java, and a Garbage Generated Power Plant in Bandung. Currently, there are at least 9 projects in line such guarantees, including construction of Port Tanah Ampo in Bali, the Jakarta City Airport Railway, and a drinking-water project in Sekampung Bandar Lampung.
This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the legislative framework of PPP projects in the context of the IIGF, and provide analysis of the relevant regulations.
Purpose
PPP projects and the infrastructure guarantees are designated to foster infrastructure development in Indonesia by engaging financial involvement from private investors. The government also aims to improve the quality of management and maintenance of infrastructure procurement by selecting the potential private partners through a tender process.
Legislative Framework
The government initially introduced public–private partnership projects in November 2005, through Presidential Regulation No. 67 of 2005, as amended by Presidential Regulation No. 13 of 2010 on Cooperation Between Government and Business Entities in the Procurement of Infrastructure Projects (‘Regulation No. 67’). And followed up with the issuance of Government Regulation No. 35 of 2009, which authorized the government to inject capital, in the amount of IDR 1 trillion (and a further IDR 1 trillion under Government Regulation No. 88 of 2010), for the purpose of establishing the IIGF.
Recently, the government has issued Presidential Regulation No. 78 of 2010 on Infrastructure Guarantees for PPP under the IIGF (‘Regulation No. 78’) and its further implementing regulation, in the form of Minister of Finance Regulation No. 260/PMK.011/2010 on Implementation Guidelines for the IIGF in PPP Projects (‘Regulation No. 260’), which serve as the basic framework to implement the IIGF for PPP projects in Indonesia.
Applicability
The aforementioned regulations apply to:
|
(i)
|
the government (minister/heads of institutions/heads of regional, or state-owned/regional-owned companies) as the party in charge of the project;
|
|
(ii)
|
business entities, in the form of limited liability companies, state-owned/regional-owned companies, or cooperatives as the partner and infrastructure project recipient; and
|
|
(iii)
|
the IIGF, as the infrastructure project guarantee provider.
|
PPP Projects
A PPP project is carried out in order to provide state-procured infrastructure, including construction works to develop, improve, manage, and/or maintain the infrastructure facilities. A PPP project could be performed through: (i) a cooperation agreement, or (ii) business permits (Article 5 of Regulation No. 67). The PPP project has to be conducted with due observance of the principles of, among others: fairness, transparency, competition, mutually beneficial partnership and support.
To determine projects that will be conducted by means of a cooperation agreement, the government evaluates the proposed projects by considering: the suitability of the infrastructure development plan in accordance to the national/regional development plan, location of the project, inter-regional infrastructure connections, budget analysis, and social benefit (Article 7 (1) of Regulation No. 67). Following this process, the government stipulates a project priority list, which is accessible for a public tender process.
Alternatively, a business entity may propose an infrastructure procurement project to the government. Such a proposed project not being part of the master project in the related sector, but technically integrated with the master project, economically and financially feasible, and not requiring any government support in the form of fiscal contributions (Article 10 of Regulation No. 67). In the event that the government approves such a proposed project, the implementation still has be conducted by means of a public tender process.
Cooperation Agreements and Business Permits
Cooperation Agreements
A cooperation agreement is the written consent for the infrastructure project, entered into by the government and the private partner. Article 23 (1) of Regulation No. 67 provides that the cooperation agreement has to include, among other matters:
|
-
|
scope of works;
|
|
-
|
work duration;
|
|
-
|
rights and obligations, including the allocation of risks;
|
|
-
|
termination of agreement;
|
|
-
|
dispute settlement; and
|
|
-
|
force majeure.
|
The cooperation agreement has to be governed by Indonesian law and written in Indonesian. In the event that the agreement is executed in bilingual form, Indonesian serves as the governing language of the agreement.
Further, it should be noted that any transfer of shares prior the commencement of commercial operation of the infrastructure project, can only be conducted following the approval from the government (minister/head of institution/head of region). And with due consideration that such transfer of shares will not postpone the operational schedule of the infrastructure project (Article 23 (4) of Regulation No. 67).
It also notable that, within 12 months after the cooperation agreement is executed, the private partner has to secure a loan for the infrastructure project (evidenced by the execution of a financing agreement and having a part of the loan is available for disbursement) (Article 24 (1) of Regulation No. 67). In the event that the private partner cannot fulfill its obligation within this period of time, the cooperation agreement is considered to be terminated and the government can release the implementation guarantee accordingly.
Business Permits
Infrastructure procurement based on business permits is carried out through a permit auction mechanism (Article 27 of Regulation No. 67). The exact procedures of the permit auction will be further regulated by the minister/head of institution/head of region, with due consideration of the principles of PPP.
Government Support
Article 1 (8) of Regulation No. 67 defines government support as fiscal or non-fiscal contributions, which are granted in order to improve the financial worthiness of the infrastructure project. The fiscal support being included in the state/regional expenditure budget. Non-fiscal support may be granted in the form of licenses, land procurement, construction support, and/or other forms, as pursuant to the prevailing laws and regulations (Article 17A (3) of Regulation No. 67). Such government support will be stipulated in the public tender documents.
Infrastructure Guarantee Fund for PPP Projects
Types and Forms of the Guarantee Fund
Infrastructure guarantees, according to Article 2 of Regulation No. 260, can take the of:
|
(i)
|
Government Guarantees - granted by the Minister of Finance to the private partner after receiving a guarantee proposal from the IIGF, and
|
|
(ii)
|
IIGF Guarantees - granted by IIGF as the guarantee provider to the private partner as the guarantee recipient.
|
Article 3 of Regulation No. 260 states that the infrastructure guarantees can be carried out through an IIGF Guarantee (which covers entire or partial infrastructure risks of a single infrastructure project) or jointly, via an IIGF Guarantee and a Government Guarantee (as based on infrastructure risks allocation between the IIGF and the Minister of Finance). This joint guarantee is only possible in the event that there are insufficient assets within the IIGF to provide a guarantee, there is no possibility of cooperation with multilateral financial institutions to provide a guarantee, and there is no capital injection from the government, and the implementation of the project can not be further delayed (Article 5 (1) of Regulation No. 260).
Infrastructure guarantees are granted as long as the party in charge of the project can issue a statement letter, which evidences the validity of the cooperation agreement, and a written commitment letter to the IIGF to make the best endeavors to control, manage, prevent, an mitigate infrastructure risks and to undertake to fulfill its regress, right to recover, obligation (Article 5 (2) of Regulation No. 78).
Claim Submission
Article 11 of Regulation No. 78 stipulates that the private partner may submit a claim to the IIGF, in the event that:
|
-
|
the private partner has received a notification that the party in charge of the project admits its incapability to fulfill its obligation prior the termination of the cooperation agreement;
|
|
-
|
within the determined period of time, the party in charge of the project does not fulfill its payment obligation upon receivables submitted by the private partner.
|
IIGF will then evaluate the submitted claim in order to ensure that the claim is in accordance with the coverage stipulated under the infrastructure guarantee agreement and there is no dispute upon the outstanding receivables submitted by the private partner (Article 12 of Regulation No. 78). The IIGF will then fulfill its obligation towards the private partner following a verification process (that concludes that the claim requirements have been fulfilled).
Indonesia Infrastructure Guarantee Fund (IIGF)
Establishment of IIGF
IIGF was formally established on 30 December 2009, following the issuance of Government Regulation No. 35 of 2009. The IIGF was established to ensure that the risks of a contracting state agency are accountable to the state, and not the private business entity partner. In the past, private partners have been reticent to participate in PPPs with the Indonesian state due in part to the large uninsurable risks that often have to be assumed in such engagements.
Assets of IIGF
The infrastructure guarantees are derived from the assets of IIGF. Besides government capital injection, in conducting its activities, the IIGF may obtain funds from business income, grants, loans, and third party capital participation. Currently, the IIGF has received financial support from the World Bank and is looking at the possibility of participation of other multilateral institutions.
Mechanism of Single Window Policy
In order to implement control and manage state-budge risk, all activities of the IIGF will be carried out through a mechanism of a single window policy, including the evaluation of projects, guarantee structuring, and the claim process. In the beginning, activities of IIGF include, among others: receiving and evaluating the guarantee proposal documents; referring the proposed guarantee to the Minister of Finance for further review; and preparing, discussing, and executing agreements. In terms of claims and payment, activities of IIGF include, among others: supervision of the potential materialization of infrastructure risks; mitigation processes; processing claims based on IIGF Guarantee agreements and Government Guarantee agreements; and conducting payments under IIGF Guarantee agreements (Article 6 (2) of Regulation No. 260).
Risk Coverage
In carrying out infrastructure projects, there is a possibility of the occurrence of unexpected events, which may negatively affect the private partner’s investment. Article 10 (1) of Regulation No. 260 states that infrastructure guarantees are granted for the following risks, as caused by:
|
-
|
an act or omission of an act by the party in charge of the project or by the government, which, pursuant to the prevailing laws and regulations, they are authorized to perform;
|
|
-
|
policy of the party in charge of the project or of the government;
|
|
-
|
unilateral decision of party in charge of the project or of the government;
|
|
-
|
incapability of the party in charge of the project in fulfilling its obligations under the cooperation agreement (breach of contract).
|
In the future, the IIGF will issue a guidelines on risk infrastructure categorization based on the aforementioned causalities. These guidelines will serve as a reference for the party in charge of the project in preparing the cooperation agreement, the infrastructure guarantee proposal, and for the private partners investing in public-private partnership projects (Articles 11 (1) and (2) of Regulation No. 260).
Conclusion
In order to address the insufficient level of investment in Indonesian infrastructure development, the government has taken major steps in fostering private investor participation in infrastructure projects. These steps include the provision of a series of regulatory frameworks, governing financial participation in public-private partnership projects and establishing the IIGF to provide infrastructure guarantees for such projects. The government intends these facilities to attract private investors by reducing the private investors’ prior concerns over certain legal, financial, and political risks. In 2011, the government has received a lot of infrastructure project proposals as well as interest in IIGF Guarantees. Although this is an initial step, there are high hopes from the public for such partnership projects and their contribution to developing the Indonesian infrastructure sector.
......