Forestry: Legislative Framework and the Latest Developments

Overview

Indonesia has one of the largest tropical forests in the world, and substantial natural resources buried under the soil on which they stand. Given this, forestry has become one of the most promising businesses sectors Indonesia. Timber and non-timber forest production (for instance, rattan, rubber latex, and honey) have contributed large amounts to the state’s revenue.

This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight key features of the legislative framework faced by forestry businesses and provide analysis of the relevant provisions.

 

Purpose

The legislation discussed below was issued to regulate forestry businesses, and to protect the environment. However, due to a lack of law enforcement and supervision, forests in Indonesia have been faced with the issue of illegal logging, which has been a cause of substantial environmental damage.

To overcome these problems, the government has taken a number of steps, including participation in the Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD) program, adjusting the forestry business legal framework to prioritize environmental protection, and closely monitoring and sanctioning illegal logging.

 

Legal Framework

Forestry is regulated under Law No. 41 of 1999 on Forestry (‘1999 Forestry Law’), which repealed and replaced its predecessor, Law No. 5 of 1967. The 1999 Forestry Law broadly regulates various aspects of forestry, and includes a newly introduced provision that limits forestry area utilization for non-forestry purposes (Article 38). However, an issue has arisen in relation to the legal certainty of mining activities for holders of mining licenses that have been issued prior to the enactment of the 1999 Forestry Law. Thus, on 13 August 2004, Law No. 19 of 2004 was issued to amend the 1999 Forestry Law by adding provisions governing the validity of existing mining licenses. (Law No. 41 of 1999, as amended by Law No. 19 of 2004, on Forestry hereinafter referred to as ‘Forestry Law’).

A decade following its implementation, the government has issued a series of regulations and further implementing legislation related to, among others, forest management and utilization, forest rehabilitation and reclamation, and forest area utilization.

 

Classification of Forests

The Forestry Law classifies forests based on their status and function. Pursuant to status, Article 5 divides forests into:

-

State Forests (hutan negara) – a forest that is located on land that is not subject to a land title (such as a Right of Ownership, Right to Build, and Right to Utilize);

-

Rights Forests (hutan hak) – a forest that is located on land that is subject to land title.

 

Based on function, Article 6 divides forests into:

-

Conservation Forests (hutan konservasi) – a forest area whose primary function is to serve as plant and animal conservation of its ecosystem;

-

Protected Forests (hutan lindung) – a forest area whose primary function is to protect life-supporting systems, including the management of the water system, erosion and flood protection, and maintaining land fertility;

-

Production Forests (hutan produksi) – a forest area whose primary function is to produce forest products.

 

Furthermore, Government Regulation No. 6 of 2007, as amended by Regulation No. 3 of 2008, on the Preparation of Forest and Forest Management Plans and Forest Utilization, also recognizes forests that have been intentionally planted in production forests for a specific purpose, commonly known as ‘man-made forests.’ The Regulation divides this type of forest into:

-

Industrial Forests (hutan tanaman industri) – a forest area that has been planted to supply raw materials for timber industrial purposes;

-

Community Forests (hutan tanaman rakyat) – a forest area that has been planted to preserve forestry resources;

-

Rehabilitation Forests (hutan tanaman hasil rehabilitasi) – a forest area, planted under a rehabilitation program, to recover and improve the life-supporting systems.

 

Forest Utilization

For Forestry Purposes

Article 24 of the Forestry Law allows the utilization of forest areas, with the exception of nature reserve areas and certain zones (i.e. core zones and wilderness zones) within national parks. For utilization of production forests, the utilization has to be in the form of area utilization, environmental service utilization, timber and non-timber forest products utilization or timber and non-timber forest product collection. Particularly in protected forests, the utilization cannot diminish the forest’s primary function and is limited to area utilization, environmental service utilization, and non-timber forest product collection (Articles 28 (1) and 26 (1)).

The utilization mentioned above can only be carried out after obtaining the respective licenses, as follows:

-

Area Utilization Business License (Izin Usaha Pemanfaatan Kawasan / IUPK);

-

Environmental Service Utilization Business License (Izin Usaha Pemanfaatan Jasa Lingkungan / IUPJL);

-

Timber Forest Products Utilization Business License (Izin Usaha Pemanfaatan Hasil Hutan Kayu / IUPHHK);

-

Non-timber Forest Products Utilization Business License (Izin Usaha Pemanfaatan Hasil Hutan Bukan Kayu / IUPHHBK);

-

Timber Forest Products Collection Business License (Izin Usaha Pemungutan Hasil Hutan Kayu / IPHHK); and

-

Non-timber Forest Products Collection Business License (Izin Usaha Pemungutan Hasil Hutan Bukan Kayu / IPHHBK).

 

Generally, IUPK, IUPJL, and IPHHBK in protected forests can only be granted to an individual or a cooperative. However, particularly for an IUPJL, it can also be granted to an private Indonesian business entity or a state or regional-owned enterprise (Article 27). A similar approach applies to IUPK, IUPJL, IUPHHK, IUPHHBK, IPHHK and IPHHBK in production forests, generally they can only be granted to an individual or a cooperative. However, for IUPJL, IUPHHK, and IUPHHBK, they can also be granted to a private Indonesian business entity or a state or regional-owned enterprise (Article 29).

 

For Non-Forestry Purposes

Article 38 of the Forestry Law, as further implemented by Government Regulation No. 24 of 2010 on Forest Area Utilization, allows forest utilization for the purpose of certain strategic non-forestry development, which includes, among others, religious purposes, mining, telecommunication networks, public and toll roads, and temporary shelter for natural disaster victims.

In order to utilize the forest area for these purposes, a ‘borrow and use’ license must be obtained from the Minister of Forestry by means of an application by another minister, governor, regent/mayor, corporate executive, or foundation executive. The technical details of the application procedure remain to be elaborated by subsequent Minister of Forestry regulation.

It should be noted that, particularly for mining, if the mining activities are carried out in a production forest, they can be conducted by means of underground as well as open-cut mining. In protected forests however, the mining activities can only be conducted by means of underground mining pursuant to Article 5 (1) of the Regulation.

 

License Requirements and Procedures

Timber Forest Products Utilization Business License (“IUPHHK”)

The utilization of timber forest products from a man-made forest can be performed in industrial, community or rehabilitation forests (Article 37 of Government Regulation No. 6 of 2007, as amended by Regulation No. 3 of 2008).

Pursuant to Articles 5 and 6 of the amended Minister of Forestry Regulation No. P.19/Menhut-II/2007, to acquire an IUPHHK for an industrial forest, the applicant has to submit, to the Minister of Forestry with copies to the Director General, Head of Forestry Planology Agency, Head of the Provincial Agency, and Head of the District/City Agency, the following:

-

corporate documents of the company (including deed of incorporation, business license, and the Taxpayer Registration Number (NPWP));

-

statement of willingness to open a branch office in the province and/or district/city;

-

the proposed location plan including a satellite image with a minimum resolution of 30 meters and map with a scale of 1:100,000;

-

the governor’s recommendation, after obtaining a recommendation from the regent/mayor based on technical considerations of the head of the forestry agency in the district/city, that states that the requested location does not encumber other rights as  supported by a location map with a minimum scale of 1:100,000; and

-

technical requirements in the form of a technical proposal that consists of: (i) general condition of the proposed location and condition of the company; and (ii) technical suggestions, including objectives and purpose, utilization plan, silviculture system, organization, financing and cash flow, and forest protection.

 

Following the submission of completed application, the Directorate General of Production Forestry Development will review the administrative documents (within 10 working days) and, if the application is completed, the Head of the Forestry Planology Agency will issue a confirmation on, among others, the designated forest area and its irrigation, demarcation, and vegetation of the proposed location (within 30 working days). The Head of the Forestry Planology Agency will then review the technical proposal (within 7 working days).

If the submitted application is in order, the Minister of Forestry will issue an approval letter for the applicant to proceed with the arrangement of environmental documents. At this stage, the applicant will have to prepare its environmental documents and submit them to the Minister of Forestry (within 150 working days for AMDAL and 60 working days for UKL/UPL, otherwise the approval letter could be annulled). The Minister will issue an IUPHHK following a review of the environmental documents and the arrangement of the working area map by the Head of the Forestry Planology Agency. Following the issuance of the IUPHHK by the Minister, the Director General will issue a Payment Instruction - Forest Utilization Business License Retribution Letter (SPP-IIUPH) (within 6 working days). Finally, the applicant can obtain the IUPHHK after paying the amount stipulated in the SPP-IIUPH.

Although timelines are set out for the completion of each stage of the procedures, there is no provision stating what will occur in the event the state agencies do not respond within the allotted periods of time.

 

Non-timber Forest Products Utilization Business License (“IUPHHBK”)

Based on Article 5 of Minister of Forestry Regulation No. P.36/Menhut-II/2008, the IUPHHBK for a natural forest is granted by the regent/mayor (if the proposed area is within a single district/city), governor (if the proposed area covers multiple districts/cities), or minister (if the proposed area covers multiple provinces). The IUPHHBK for a production forest is granted by the regent (for an individual, with a maximum area of 10 hectares, and a cooperative/state/regional-owned enterprise/ private Indonesian business entity, with maximum area of 30 or 50 hectares (for sago palm plants) or by the Minister (for larger areas).

To secure a IUPHHBK for a natural or a production forest, the applicant has to submit the required documents, to the regent/mayor, governor or minister (with a copy to, as relevant, the Minister of Forestry, governor, head of the provincial agency, head of the district/city agency and head of BP2HP), as follows:

-

copy of identity card (if the applicant is an individual) or deed of incorporation (if the applicant is a company or cooperative);

-

Taxpayer Registration Number (NPWP);

-

recommendation from the governor (if the IUPHHBK is granted by the Minister) or regent/mayor (if the IUPHHBK is granted by the governor), or the head of the agency in the district/city (if the IUPHHBK is granted by the regent/mayor); and

-

the proposed project.

 

The IUPHHBK for natural and production forests will be granted for a period of 25 years and can be extended based on an annual evaluation by the regent/mayor, governor or Minister as the grantor of the IUPHHBK pursuant to Article 9 of the Regulation.

 

Timber Forest Products Collection Business License (“IPHHK”) and Non-timber Forest Products Collection Business License (“IPHHBK”)

The procedures for obtaining an IPHHK or an IPHHBK for production forests are governed by Minister of Forestry Regulation No. P.46/Menhut-II/2009. To obtain an IPHHK and/or an IPHHBK in natural or a production forest, the applicant has to submit an application and the required documents to the Head of the District/City Agency (the application form is contained in Attachment I of the Regulation), as follows:

-

recommendation from the village head or a similar official;

-

copy of identity card (if the applicant is an individual) or deed of incorporation (if the applicant is a cooperative);

-

sketch of the proposed area location;

-

list of names, types and kinds of equipment that will be used in collecting the timber products.

 

Based on the completion of the required documents above, the Head of the District/City Agency will conduct an evaluation and issue an approval or a rejection letter.

 

Borrow and Use License

Borrow and use licenses are governed by Minister of Forestry Regulation No. P.43/Menhut-II/2008. Article 9 (4) of the Regulation stipulates that to acquire a borrow and use license, the applicant has to submit an application along with the following supporting documents:

-

working plan of forest utilization including a location map with scale of 1:50,000;

-

recommendation from the regent/mayor (for licenses issued by the governor) or governor (for licenses issued by the regent/mayor);

-

approved environmental documents;

-

technical recommendation from the president director of the State-Owned Public Forestry Corporation (Perum Perhutani);

-

the related non-forestry licenses and agreements;

-

statement of willingness to complete all of the obligations and cover all of the required payments;

-

recommendation from Director General of Mineral, Coal and Geothermal in relation to mining activities.

 

The Head of the Forestry Planology Agency will coordinate to issue a technical opinion to the Minister of Forestry with regards to the submitted application. If the application is approved, the Minister of Forestry will issue a borrow and use principal license for a period of 2 years. The applicant will then have to fulfill the obligations stipulated in the principal license, pursuant to Article 14 (2) of the Regulation. Borrow and use licenses will be granted for the maximum period of 20 years and can be extended, pursuant to Article 27 (1) of the Regulation.

 

Current Forestry Issues in Indonesia

REDD and Its Implementation Concerns

To reduce domestic and global greenhouse gas emissions, Indonesia has begun to implement the REDD program, which seeks to organize and finance a concerted international effort to reduce carbon emissions caused by deforestation. Indonesia’s latest move towards REDD implementation was by way of an initial bilateral agreement with Norway, signing a Letter of Intent to collaborate so as to help Indonesia implement forest-conscious reforms, and to reduce emissions accordingly.

In brief, the REDD scheme between Indonesia and Norway will be carried out in 3 stages, as follows:

-

Stage 1: Preparation from 2010 to January 2011

 

In this initial stage Indonesia will, among other things, put forth a viable national strategy to address deforestation, forest degradation and peat land-related emissions, coordinate REDD implementation and policy strategy as well as its report to the President, and establish a funding framework.

-

Stage 2: Preparation from January 2011 to December 2013

 

At this stage, the government will focus on policy and legal development, law enforcement, and capacity building.

-

Stage 3: January 2014 onwards

 

By this stage, Indonesia will be ready to implement the REDD plan and targets to pledge emissions cuts of at least 26% by 2020.

 

As part of the REDD scheme agenda, the government has set 2012 as the last year for the pulp and paper industry to utilize timber from natural forests. This moratorium is part of the bilateral agreement between Indonesia and Norway, under which Indonesia will receive USD 1 billion, as funding for REDD schemes.

In the future, all timber raw materials for the pulp and paper industry will be derived from man-made forests and there will no longer be any conversion of natural forests. Thus, during this 2-years moratorium, the pulp and paper industries have to prepare the land area designated for their timber supplies. It should be noted that the government will stipulate sanctions, in the form of revocation of licenses, in the event the industries do not carry out the planting activities.

 

Illegal Logging

Illegal logging and the trade in illegal timber have been, and continue to be, a serious problem in Indonesia. Illegal logging is a violation by a person or legal entity of the forestry legislative scheme, including illegal cutting and collecting of timber forest products, and the receipt or purchase of timber forest products that are not supported by valid legal documents. Being one of the most lucrative sources of income, the forestry business has a tendency for illegal logging practices that are caused by legal framework loopholes between central and regional implementing regulations.

The effort to create definitive legislation on illegal logging dates back to the 2005 discussion of a Bill on the Protection and Eradication of Illegal Logging. However, at present, the discussion of this bill has faded away along with a decrease in illegal logging cases. Leaving the industry to rely on provisions, that lack enforcement and certainty, of the Forestry Law.

 

Sanctions

Administrative sanctions consist of penalties, revocation of licenses, suspension of activities, and/or areal reduction.

Criminal sanctions, under Article 78 of the Forestry Law, include, among others, for illegal logging (Article 50 (3)), imprisonment and penalties of up to IDR 10 billion.

 

Conclusion

Indonesia, with its strategic location, is endowed with substantial quantities of natural resources within its forestry areas. Indonesia is also one of biggest suppliers of international market with its timber and non-timber production forest resources. This is accompanied with the consequences that the government has to prepare an adequate legal framework for the development of the forestry industry, as well as for the protection of Indonesian forest areas. Having said this, in terms of the legal framework, the government needs to address the issues of illegal logging and environmental damage, which have led to a series of natural disasters in Indonesia. Moreover, the government also needs to improve the welfare of the surrounding communities that are affected by forestry activities.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

Indonesia has one of the largest tropical forests in the world, and substantial natural resources buried under the soil on which they stand. Given this, forestry has become one of the most promising businesses sectors Indonesia. Timber and non-timber forest production (for instance, rattan, rubber latex, and honey) have contributed large amounts to the state’s revenue.

This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight key features of the legislative framework faced by forestry businesses and provide analysis of the relevant provisions.

 

Purpose

The legislation discussed below was issued to regulate forestry businesses, and to protect the environment. However, due to a lack of law enforcement and supervision, forests in Indonesia have been faced with the issue of illegal logging, which has been a cause of substantial environmental damage.

To overcome these problems, the government has taken a number of steps, including participation in the Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD) program, adjusting the forestry business legal framework to prioritize environmental protection, and closely monitoring and sanctioning illegal logging.

 

Legal Framework

Forestry is regulated under Law No. 41 of 1999 on Forestry (‘1999 Forestry Law’), which repealed and replaced its predecessor, Law No. 5 of 1967. The 1999 Forestry Law broadly regulates various aspects of forestry, and includes a newly introduced provision that limits forestry area utilization for non-forestry purposes (Article 38). However, an issue has arisen in relation to the legal certainty of mining activities for holders of mining licenses that have been issued prior to the enactment of the 1999 Forestry Law. Thus, on 13 August 2004, Law No. 19 of 2004 was issued to amend the 1999 Forestry Law by adding provisions governing the validity of existing mining licenses. (Law No. 41 of 1999, as amended by Law No. 19 of 2004, on Forestry hereinafter referred to as ‘Forestry Law’).

A decade following its implementation, the government has issued a series of regulations and further implementing legislation related to, among others, forest management and utilization, forest rehabilitation and reclamation, and forest area utilization.

 

Classification of Forests

The Forestry Law classifies forests based on their status and function. Pursuant to status, Article 5 divides forests into:

-

State Forests (hutan negara) – a forest that is located on land that is not subject to a land title (such as a Right of Ownership, Right to Build, and Right to Utilize);

-

Rights Forests (hutan hak) – a forest that is located on land that is subject to land title.

 

Based on function, Article 6 divides forests into:

-

Conservation Forests (hutan konservasi) – a forest area whose primary function is to serve as plant and animal conservation of its ecosystem;

-

Protected Forests (hutan lindung) – a forest area whose primary function is to protect life-supporting systems, including the management of the water system, erosion and flood protection, and maintaining land fertility;

-

Production Forests (hutan produksi) – a forest area whose primary function is to produce forest products.

 

Furthermore, Government Regulation No. 6 of 2007, as amended by Regulation No. 3 of 2008, on the Preparation of Forest and Forest Management Plans and Forest Utilization, also recognizes forests that have been intentionally planted in production forests for a specific purpose, commonly known as ‘man-made forests.’ The Regulation divides this type of forest into:

-

Industrial Forests (hutan tanaman industri) – a forest area that has been planted to supply raw materials for timber industrial purposes;

-

Community Forests (hutan tanaman rakyat) – a forest area that has been planted to preserve forestry resources;

-

Rehabilitation Forests (hutan tanaman hasil rehabilitasi) – a forest area, planted under a rehabilitation program, to recover and improve the life-supporting systems.

 

Forest Utilization

For Forestry Purposes

Article 24 of the Forestry Law allows the utilization of forest areas, with the exception of nature reserve areas and certain zones (i.e. core zones and wilderness zones) within national parks. For utilization of production forests, the utilization has to be in the form of area utilization, environmental service utilization, timber and non-timber forest products utilization or timber and non-timber forest product collection. Particularly in protected forests, the utilization cannot diminish the forest’s primary function and is limited to area utilization, environmental service utilization, and non-timber forest product collection (Articles 28 (1) and 26 (1)).

The utilization mentioned above can only be carried out after obtaining the respective licenses, as follows:

-

Area Utilization Business License (Izin Usaha Pemanfaatan Kawasan / IUPK);

-

Environmental Service Utilization Business License (Izin Usaha Pemanfaatan Jasa Lingkungan / IUPJL);

-

Timber Forest Products Utilization Business License (Izin Usaha Pemanfaatan Hasil Hutan Kayu / IUPHHK);

-

Non-timber Forest Products Utilization Business License (Izin Usaha Pemanfaatan Hasil Hutan Bukan Kayu / IUPHHBK);

-

Timber Forest Products Collection Business License (Izin Usaha Pemungutan Hasil Hutan Kayu / IPHHK); and

-

Non-timber Forest Products Collection Business License (Izin Usaha Pemungutan Hasil Hutan Bukan Kayu / IPHHBK).

 

Generally, IUPK, IUPJL, and IPHHBK in protected forests can only be granted to an individual or a cooperative. However, particularly for an IUPJL, it can also be granted to an private Indonesian business entity or a state or regional-owned enterprise (Article 27). A similar approach applies to IUPK, IUPJL, IUPHHK, IUPHHBK, IPHHK and IPHHBK in production forests, generally they can only be granted to an individual or a cooperative. However, for IUPJL, IUPHHK, and IUPHHBK, they can also be granted to a private Indonesian business entity or a state or regional-owned enterprise (Article 29).

 

For Non-Forestry Purposes

Article 38 of the Forestry Law, as further implemented by Government Regulation No. 24 of 2010 on Forest Area Utilization, allows forest utilization for the purpose of certain strategic non-forestry development, which includes, among others, religious purposes, mining, telecommunication networks, public and toll roads, and temporary shelter for natural disaster victims.

In order to utilize the forest area for these purposes, a ‘borrow and use’ license must be obtained from the Minister of Forestry by means of an application by another minister, governor, regent/mayor, corporate executive, or foundation executive. The technical details of the application procedure remain to be elaborated by subsequent Minister of Forestry regulation.

It should be noted that, particularly for mining, if the mining activities are carried out in a production forest, they can be conducted by means of underground as well as open-cut mining. In protected forests however, the mining activities can only be conducted by means of underground mining pursuant to Article 5 (1) of the Regulation.

 

License Requirements and Procedures

Timber Forest Products Utilization Business License (“IUPHHK”)

The utilization of timber forest products from a man-made forest can be performed in industrial, community or rehabilitation forests (Article 37 of Government Regulation No. 6 of 2007, as amended by Regulation No. 3 of 2008).

Pursuant to Articles 5 and 6 of the amended Minister of Forestry Regulation No. P.19/Menhut-II/2007, to acquire an IUPHHK for an industrial forest, the applicant has to submit, to the Minister of Forestry with copies to the Director General, Head of Forestry Planology Agency, Head of the Provincial Agency, and Head of the District/City Agency, the following:

-

corporate documents of the company (including deed of incorporation, business license, and the Taxpayer Registration Number (NPWP));

-

statement of willingness to open a branch office in the province and/or district/city;

-

the proposed location plan including a satellite image with a minimum resolution of 30 meters and map with a scale of 1:100,000;

-

the governor’s recommendation, after obtaining a recommendation from the regent/mayor based on technical considerations of the head of the forestry agency in the district/city, that states that the requested location does not encumber other rights as  supported by a location map with a minimum scale of 1:100,000; and

-

technical requirements in the form of a technical proposal that consists of: (i) general condition of the proposed location and condition of the company; and (ii) technical suggestions, including objectives and purpose, utilization plan, silviculture system, organization, financing and cash flow, and forest protection.

 

Following the submission of completed application, the Directorate General of Production Forestry Development will review the administrative documents (within 10 working days) and, if the application is completed, the Head of the Forestry Planology Agency will issue a confirmation on, among others, the designated forest area and its irrigation, demarcation, and vegetation of the proposed location (within 30 working days). The Head of the Forestry Planology Agency will then review the technical proposal (within 7 working days).

If the submitted application is in order, the Minister of Forestry will issue an approval letter for the applicant to proceed with the arrangement of environmental documents. At this stage, the applicant will have to prepare its environmental documents and submit them to the Minister of Forestry (within 150 working days for AMDAL and 60 working days for UKL/UPL, otherwise the approval letter could be annulled). The Minister will issue an IUPHHK following a review of the environmental documents and the arrangement of the working area map by the Head of the Forestry Planology Agency. Following the issuance of the IUPHHK by the Minister, the Director General will issue a Payment Instruction - Forest Utilization Business License Retribution Letter (SPP-IIUPH) (within 6 working days). Finally, the applicant can obtain the IUPHHK after paying the amount stipulated in the SPP-IIUPH.

Although timelines are set out for the completion of each stage of the procedures, there is no provision stating what will occur in the event the state agencies do not respond within the allotted periods of time.

 

Non-timber Forest Products Utilization Business License (“IUPHHBK”)

Based on Article 5 of Minister of Forestry Regulation No. P.36/Menhut-II/2008, the IUPHHBK for a natural forest is granted by the regent/mayor (if the proposed area is within a single district/city), governor (if the proposed area covers multiple districts/cities), or minister (if the proposed area covers multiple provinces). The IUPHHBK for a production forest is granted by the regent (for an individual, with a maximum area of 10 hectares, and a cooperative/state/regional-owned enterprise/ private Indonesian business entity, with maximum area of 30 or 50 hectares (for sago palm plants) or by the Minister (for larger areas).

To secure a IUPHHBK for a natural or a production forest, the applicant has to submit the required documents, to the regent/mayor, governor or minister (with a copy to, as relevant, the Minister of Forestry, governor, head of the provincial agency, head of the district/city agency and head of BP2HP), as follows:

-

copy of identity card (if the applicant is an individual) or deed of incorporation (if the applicant is a company or cooperative);

-

Taxpayer Registration Number (NPWP);

-

recommendation from the governor (if the IUPHHBK is granted by the Minister) or regent/mayor (if the IUPHHBK is granted by the governor), or the head of the agency in the district/city (if the IUPHHBK is granted by the regent/mayor); and

-

the proposed project.

 

The IUPHHBK for natural and production forests will be granted for a period of 25 years and can be extended based on an annual evaluation by the regent/mayor, governor or Minister as the grantor of the IUPHHBK pursuant to Article 9 of the Regulation.

 

Timber Forest Products Collection Business License (“IPHHK”) and Non-timber Forest Products Collection Business License (“IPHHBK”)

The procedures for obtaining an IPHHK or an IPHHBK for production forests are governed by Minister of Forestry Regulation No. P.46/Menhut-II/2009. To obtain an IPHHK and/or an IPHHBK in natural or a production forest, the applicant has to submit an application and the required documents to the Head of the District/City Agency (the application form is contained in Attachment I of the Regulation), as follows:

-

recommendation from the village head or a similar official;

-

copy of identity card (if the applicant is an individual) or deed of incorporation (if the applicant is a cooperative);

-

sketch of the proposed area location;

-

list of names, types and kinds of equipment that will be used in collecting the timber products.

 

Based on the completion of the required documents above, the Head of the District/City Agency will conduct an evaluation and issue an approval or a rejection letter.

 

Borrow and Use License

Borrow and use licenses are governed by Minister of Forestry Regulation No. P.43/Menhut-II/2008. Article 9 (4) of the Regulation stipulates that to acquire a borrow and use license, the applicant has to submit an application along with the following supporting documents:

-

working plan of forest utilization including a location map with scale of 1:50,000;

-

recommendation from the regent/mayor (for licenses issued by the governor) or governor (for licenses issued by the regent/mayor);

-

approved environmental documents;

-

technical recommendation from the president director of the State-Owned Public Forestry Corporation (Perum Perhutani);

-

the related non-forestry licenses and agreements;

-

statement of willingness to complete all of the obligations and cover all of the required payments;

-

recommendation from Director General of Mineral, Coal and Geothermal in relation to mining activities.

 

The Head of the Forestry Planology Agency will coordinate to issue a technical opinion to the Minister of Forestry with regards to the submitted application. If the application is approved, the Minister of Forestry will issue a borrow and use principal license for a period of 2 years. The applicant will then have to fulfill the obligations stipulated in the principal license, pursuant to Article 14 (2) of the Regulation. Borrow and use licenses will be granted for the maximum period of 20 years and can be extended, pursuant to Article 27 (1) of the Regulation.

 

Current Forestry Issues in Indonesia

REDD and Its Implementation Concerns

To reduce domestic and global greenhouse gas emissions, Indonesia has begun to implement the REDD program, which seeks to organize and finance a concerted international effort to reduce carbon emissions caused by deforestation. Indonesia’s latest move towards REDD implementation was by way of an initial bilateral agreement with Norway, signing a Letter of Intent to collaborate so as to help Indonesia implement forest-conscious reforms, and to reduce emissions accordingly.

In brief, the REDD scheme between Indonesia and Norway will be carried out in 3 stages, as follows:

-

Stage 1: Preparation from 2010 to January 2011

 

In this initial stage Indonesia will, among other things, put forth a viable national strategy to address deforestation, forest degradation and peat land-related emissions, coordinate REDD implementation and policy strategy as well as its report to the President, and establish a funding framework.

-

Stage 2: Preparation from January 2011 to December 2013

 

At this stage, the government will focus on policy and legal development, law enforcement, and capacity building.

-

Stage 3: January 2014 onwards

 

By this stage, Indonesia will be ready to implement the REDD plan and targets to pledge emissions cuts of at least 26% by 2020.

 

As part of the REDD scheme agenda, the government has set 2012 as the last year for the pulp and paper industry to utilize timber from natural forests. This moratorium is part of the bilateral agreement between Indonesia and Norway, under which Indonesia will receive USD 1 billion, as funding for REDD schemes.

In the future, all timber raw materials for the pulp and paper industry will be derived from man-made forests and there will no longer be any conversion of natural forests. Thus, during this 2-years moratorium, the pulp and paper industries have to prepare the land area designated for their timber supplies. It should be noted that the government will stipulate sanctions, in the form of revocation of licenses, in the event the industries do not carry out the planting activities.

 

Illegal Logging

Illegal logging and the trade in illegal timber have been, and continue to be, a serious problem in Indonesia. Illegal logging is a violation by a person or legal entity of the forestry legislative scheme, including illegal cutting and collecting of timber forest products, and the receipt or purchase of timber forest products that are not supported by valid legal documents. Being one of the most lucrative sources of income, the forestry business has a tendency for illegal logging practices that are caused by legal framework loopholes between central and regional implementing regulations.

The effort to create definitive legislation on illegal logging dates back to the 2005 discussion of a Bill on the Protection and Eradication of Illegal Logging. However, at present, the discussion of this bill has faded away along with a decrease in illegal logging cases. Leaving the industry to rely on provisions, that lack enforcement and certainty, of the Forestry Law.

 

Sanctions

Administrative sanctions consist of penalties, revocation of licenses, suspension of activities, and/or areal reduction.

Criminal sanctions, under Article 78 of the Forestry Law, include, among others, for illegal logging (Article 50 (3)), imprisonment and penalties of up to IDR 10 billion.

 

Conclusion

Indonesia, with its strategic location, is endowed with substantial quantities of natural resources within its forestry areas. Indonesia is also one of biggest suppliers of international market with its timber and non-timber production forest resources. This is accompanied with the consequences that the government has to prepare an adequate legal framework for the development of the forestry industry, as well as for the protection of Indonesian forest areas. Having said this, in terms of the legal framework, the government needs to address the issues of illegal logging and environmental damage, which have led to a series of natural disasters in Indonesia. Moreover, the government also needs to improve the welfare of the surrounding communities that are affected by forestry activities.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info