Overview
As an archipelagic state, shipping plays a significant role in the Indonesian economy. Shipping is governed by Law No. 17 of 2008 on Shipping (‘Shipping Law’), which was issued on 7 May 2008 and revoked the previous shipping law (Law No. 21 of 1992), which was considered to be no longer suitable for the development of the shipping industry.
By 2009 the government was meant issue a number of implementing regulations, as required by Article 347. Fewer than half of the implementing regulations required by the Shipping Law have been issued so far, those that have been issued are:
|
(i)
|
Government Regulation No. 61 of 2009 on Ports,
|
|
(ii)
|
Government Regulation No. 5 of 2010 on Navigation,
|
|
(iii)
|
Government Regulation No. 20 of 2010 on Water Transportation, and
|
|
(iv)
|
Government Regulation No. 21 of 2010 on Maritime Environmental Protection.
|
Pending government regulations include, among others, those governing the Coast Guard (which is awaiting presidential approval), Port Business Entities, Multimode Transportation, and Search and Rescue.
Although it was enacted in 2008, the Shipping Law provides for a 3 year transitional period before certain provisions come into force, in 2011. Such provisions include the implementation of the cabotage principle and the removal of regulatory and port management functions of PT Pelabuhan Indonesia (Persero) (“PT Pelindo”), making PT Pelindo just another player in the shipping market that is open to competition.
This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will address the key features of the Shipping Law and provide an analysis of its provisions as well as the issues that have arisen since its enactment.
Purpose
The purpose of the Shipping Law is to provide a comprehensive regulatory framework for the shipping industry. The Shipping Law is based on, according to Article 2, the principles of, among others: mutual benefit, joint enterprise, fair competition, non-discrimination, public interest, integration, supremacy of law, independence, and state sovereignty. Furthermore, the objectives of the Shipping Law, as elaborated in Article 3, consist of: expediting the movement of people and goods, improving competition in the shipping business, strengthening state unity and the realization of a strong archipelagic nation, and the improvement of national defence.
Definitions
Among the 64 definitions in Article 1, of note are those relating to the newly introduced port administration system, i.e. the Port Authority and the Port Administrator Unit, which are defined as government entities that conduct regulatory, control and supervisory functions in relation to port activities. A Port Authority is established for ports that are commercially operated, on the other hand, a Port Administrator Unit is established for ports that are not yet commercially operated. Furthermore, there is a new definition of Port Business Entities, which allows for the participation of private entities as port operators.
Applicability
The Shipping Law applies to:
|
•
|
shipping and port activities, including the safety, security, and maritime protection within Indonesian waters;
|
|
•
|
foreign vessels within Indonesian waters; and
|
|
•
|
Indonesian-flagged vessel located outside Indonesian waters.
|
Main Features of the Shipping Law
Participation of Private Investors as Port Business Entities
Port business activities consist of supplying and/or providing port services and other services related to port activities (including vessels, passengers and goods), such as, for instance, the provision of dock services, fuel stations, loading and unloading of passengers and/or vehicles. Pursuant to the Shipping Law, these activities may be conducted commercially by private entities through the establishment of a Port Business Entity.
The main role of a Port Business Entity is to operate terminals and other port facilities. These activities may be conducted based on a concession from, or another form of agreement with a Port Authority. In conducting its activities, a Port Business Entity is obliged to, among other matters, provide and maintain port facilities, maintain security of the operated port and provide port services to port users.
Port Business Entities will be further governed by an upcoming government regulation.
Port Operator Competition
The Shipping Law revised the authority of PT Pelindo, which previously administered port activities as both port regulator and port operator. By separating the abovementioned functions and allowing for private entity participation, PT Pelindo will cease to enjoy monopoly benefits as a port regulator and port operator and transition into being merely another one of the port operators.
This change is introduced in order to foster investment in the port sector, particularly in Makassar, Kalimantan and Papua, by opening the possibility of private investment participation instead of exclusively relying on the government and PT Pelindo. The aim is to create competition, with the expectation that this will bring about port development by engaging private investment in the sector.
Article 344 provides for a 3 year transitional period (ending on 7 May 2011) for PT Pelindo to adjust so as to be in compliance with the changes introduced by the Shipping Law.
Port Authority
The Shipping Law separates authorities in administering governmental port activities, into:
|
(i)
|
regulating, supervising and the development of port activities (which is conducted by the Port Authority (for commercial ports) or by the Port Administrator Unit (for ports that are not yet commercially operated); and
|
|
(ii)
|
navigation safety and security (which is conducted by the Harbourmaster (syahbandar)), and/or customs and excise, immigration and quarantine (which are the responsibility of the agencies designated by the prevailing laws and regulations).
|
At present, the government has prepared the establishment of 4 Port Authorities and Harbourmasters, located at the main ports of Indonesia: Tanjung Priok Port (Jakarta), Tanjung Perak Port (Surabaya), Belawan Port (Medan) and Makassar Port (Makassar). By establishing the Port Authorities, there is a clear separation of the government’s role as the regulator from that of a port operator (in the form of Port Business Entities or PT Pelindo). As such, even for privately operated ports, the regulatory and control roles remain with the government.
Foreign Investment in the Shipping Business
Foreign investors can engage in the shipping business, in cooperation with Indonesian citizens or local companies, by establishing a joint venture company. The limitation on foreign ownership, as stipulated under Presidential Regulation No. 36 of 2010 (the Negative Investment List), is set at a maximum of 49%. Further, the joint venture company has to possess at least one Indonesian-flagged vessel with a gross tonnage of at least 5,000 and a crew of Indonesian citizens (Article 29 (2) of the Shipping Law and Article 96 (1) of Government Regulation No. 20 of 2010).
Licensing
To engage in water transportation, an individual or business entity must obtain a water transportation license, a water transportation service license, and/or a water transportation operation license, pursuant to Article 27. A license to conduct water transportation (sea transportation, traditional shipment, river and lake transportation, and ferry transportation) is issued by the regent/major, the governor, or the Minister of Transportation, depending on the legal domicile and operational location. To obtain the required license, a business entity must posses at least one Indonesian-flagged vessel with a gross tonnage of at least 175; or 5,000, and a crew of Indonesian citizens, for joint venture company, in accordance with Article 29.
Implementation of the Cabotage Principle
The cabotage principle is set out in Article 8, which stipulates that domestic sea-transportation can only be conducted by domestic sea-transportation companies, using Indonesian-flagged vessels, crewed by Indonesian citizens. Foreign-flagged vessels are prohibited from engaging in intra-Indonesian transport of passengers and/or goods. Article 341 provides for a 3 year transitional period (until 7 May 2011) before these restrictions have to come into force.
In relation to this matter, Minister of Transportation released Regulation No. KM 22 of 2010 to address the implementation of the cabotage principle. This regulation provides for an exception (extended to downstream and upstream oil and natural gas activities by Minister of Transportation Regulation No. PM 73 of 2010), in contrast to an earlier Minister of Transportation Regulation No. KM 71 of 2005, which set a deadline of 1 January 2011, for the utilization of foreign-flagged vessels within Indonesian waters under certain conditions:
|
(i)
|
in the event no Indonesian-flagged vessel can transport the shipment, and
|
|
(ii)
|
the shipment contract was entered into before 7 May 2008.
|
However, if there is an Indonesian-flagged vessel available and able to transport the shipment, it must be given first priority. This exception remains available until 7 May 2011.
Based on research conducted by hukumonline, due to the lack of Indonesian vessels to accommodate offshore oil extraction, the government is planning to revise Article 341 so as to secure national oil production. This will create a long-term exception to the cabotage principle for offshore oil and gas activities.
Ship Mortgages and Financing
Government provides financing and tax facilities in order to foster the development of the Indonesian shipping fleet and to encourage procurement of domestic vessels by the national shipping sector. These financing and tax facilities will be implemented by means of:
|
(i)
|
developing special non-bank financial institutions to finance the procurement of domestic vessels,
|
|
(ii)
|
stimulating financing facilities from bank and non-bank financial institution, and
|
|
(iii)
|
providing fiscal incentives.
|
Furthermore, the government also allows for foreign financing under Article 57 (2) (g), with due consideration for domestic utilization and transfer of technology.
To provide legal certainty to creditors, the Shipping Law sets out a mortgage security mechanism. A vessel that has been registered in the Indonesian Ship Register (Daftar Kapal Indonesia) can be encumbered by a mortgage to become a security for a debt in accordance with Article 60. A vessel can be encumbered by multiple mortgages, with priorities based on the dates and sequence of the mortgage deeds.
A super-priority exists under Article 65, which prioritizes:
|
(i)
|
salary payment and other payment to the ship captain and crew, including their repatriation and social insurance contributions,
|
|
(ii)
|
payments for injury or death,
|
|
(iii)
|
salvage expenses,
|
|
(iv)
|
port and navigation expenses, and
|
|
(v)
|
other expenses incurred due to physical or operating damage.
|
These payments have to be made before the secured creditors can collect on their security.
Special Terminals and Own Use Terminals
The Shipping Law introduces a new concept of Special Terminals and Own Use Terminals. In accordance with Article 104 such terminals can be built in order to support activities related to certain main businesses that cannot be accommodated by nearby ports. Such main businesses include: mining, energy, forestry, agriculture, fishery, industry, and docks and shipyards. Special Terminals can be built to support activities outside the Work Environment Area or the Interest Environment Area, while Own Use Terminals can be built to support activities within the Work Environment Area or the Interest Environment Area.
Own Use Terminals can only be utilized for certain activities, including: ship transportation, loading and unloading of passengers, goods, raw materials or manufactured products, education, research and development, training and social purposes.
The license to operate a Special Terminal is granted for a maximum of 5 years, and can be extended upon certain requirements being met. Special Terminals cannot be operated for public purposes except in the event of an emergency, with prior approval from the Minister of Transportation.
Sanctions
Administrative sanctions consist of warnings, administrative penalties, suspension of licenses and certificates, and revocation of licenses and certificates.
Criminal sanctions, under Articles 284 through 337, include, among others, for violation of the cabotage principle, 5 years imprisonment and a maximum penalty in the amount of IDR 600 million.
Conclusion
In order to improve the national shipping industry, the government has amended the previous shipping law, which was considered to be no longer sufficient to support the much-needed development of the Indonesian shipping industry. The Shipping Law introduced several major changes regarding ports and the shipping industry, among others, it opened up the possibility of private investor participation and transformed the authority structure previously monopolized by PT Pelindo.
However, the government has faced difficulties in implementing the cabotage principle, particularly in the offshore oil and gas sector. As we head towards the full implementation of the Shipping Law in May 2011 (following the conclusion of the 3 year transitional period since its enactment), a lot of work remains to be done, including the issuance of the pending government regulations to further implement the Shipping Law, which should have been completed in 2009.
......