Overview
Since the enactment of Law No. 36 of 1999 on Telecommunications (Telecommunications Law) and Law No. 32 of 2002 on Broadcasting (Broadcasting Law), the telecommunications and broadcasting industries have been regulated separately, with the laws not being designed for the possibility of the industries converging with one another.
The rapid development of information technology has altered the shape and structure of the both industries, with internet services rendered by telecommunication service providers enabling television and radio programs that were conventionally broadcast through the licensed radio spectrum, to be broadcast over the internet in the form of Internet Protocol Television (IPTV) and net or web radio.
A similar situation is also true for telecommunication companies, where telecommunication is integrated with the internet by means of Voice over the Internet Protocol (VoIP) and Mobile Virtual Network Operator (MVNO) technologies.
The integration of telecommunication, broadcasting, and the internet, which can be more precisely called a convergence, has come to the attention of the Ministry of Communications and Information Technology, which is now is in the process of drafting the Bill of Telematics Convergence (“Bill”), in essence the Bill will accommodate the harmonization and convergence of telecommunications, broadcasting, and the internet industry.
Though the Bill has not been submitted to the House of Representatives (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat/DPR) as it is still being formulated to accommodate all of the stakeholders, should the Bill be passed by the House, pursuant to Article 64 of the Bill, Law No. 36 of 1999 on Telecommunications will be repealed and replaced by the Bill.
This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the Bill and provide analysis of the Bill’s provisions.
Purpose
Globalization and the development of information technology has changed the structure of the global society and economy. Such development shapes society’ requirements for access to vast information transmission capacity, and has resulted in the broadcasting and telecommunications industries converging organically rather than via regulation.
The government, through the issuance Law No. 17 of 2007 regarding the National Long-Term Development Plan for 2005-2025 (Development Law), pursuant to Development Law Appendix Chapter II. 2D 3 and Chapter IV.1.2, D 38, plans for the society become a knowledge-based society, so that it is able to adapt to globalization, and that in order to achieve such goal, a law that will accommodate the convergence of information technology, broadcasting, and telecommunications industries is required. Also having the involvement of the Ministry of Communications and Information Technology, the Bill is part of the prioritized legislation program of 2010.
Definitions
The telematics terminology is still being debated, as it is unpopular with the telecommunications industry and not in line with the practice in other countries. It is viewed that the term Information Communication Technology (Teknologi Informasi dan Komunikasi / TIK) would be a more appropriate term than telematics. Nonetheless, in Article 1 (2) telematics is defined as teleCommunications and Information Technology technology.
Convergence of telematics on the other hand means the unification of technology and the value chain of the technology produced for the purpose of providing and rendering telematics services, as set in Article 1 (1).
Much of the intent behind the Bill is to regulate the convergence of the telecommunications, broadcasting, and the information technology industries. In order to get an idea of the parties that are affected by the Bill, one must compare what was defined as telecommunications in Article 1 (1) of the Telecommunication Law, and as broadcasting in Article 1 (2) of the Broadcasting Law.
The Bill, pursuant to Article 1 (2), has widened the definition of telecommunications, stating that telecommunications is any act of transmitting, sending and/or receiving any information in the form of symbols, signs, writings, pictures, sounds through a wire, optical, electromagnetic and/or other system that enables the transmission, sending and/or receiving of information to occur.
With the widened definition, pretty much the entire broadcasting industry, which consists of television and radio companies, is affected by the Bill. Although, should the Bill pass, the Broadcasting Law will remain un-repealed, since the broadcasting industry, compared to the telecommunications industry, has different bodies that control it (Indonesian Broadcasting Committee / Komisi Penyiaran Indonesia pursuant to Article 7 of the Broadcasting Law, and Ministry of Communications and Information Technology pursuant to Article 4 of the Telecommunications Law). With a similar difference in the procedures to obtain a permit for a broadcasting and a telecommunications company. With the differences being due to the essentially different nature of the industries, where the broadcasting is a one way communications channel while telecommunications is a means for two way communications.
In fact, not many Articles in the Bill are dedicated to regulating the broadcasting industry, even though the broadcasting industry is becoming more and more complex, with the emergence of many new business models in the industry. Yet the Bill seems to focus more on the telecommunications and information technology industries.
In addition to the above-discussed definition, information technology must also be understood as a technique to gather, prepare, process, publish, analyze and/or distribute information, as set in Article 1 (4), where it is considered a two way as well as a one way means of communication.
Applicability
Telematics Providers
In order for information to be able to be transmitted by users and network providers, the availability of infrastructure is vital, which comes in the form of fiber optic cables, transmission towers, or base trans-receiver stations (BTS). Such infrastructure availability lies in the hands of a network communication contractors, who, pursuant to Article 8 (2) (a), will be govern by the Bill.
Since the communication network infrastructure would be funded by network service providers, whose core business is to provide connection and interconnection of telematics directly to users, they, pursuant to Article 8 (2) (b), are also governed by the Bill.
Telematics application service provider are also to be affected by the Bill, such companies may take the form of server applications for e-commerce, e-news, e-magazine, web television, social networking, and those that are categorized in Article 1 (9) as provider of application and content in conjunction with Article 8 (2) (c).
For the purpose of simplicity, network communication contractors, network service providers, and telematics application service providers will be referred to as telematics providers.
In summary, the Bill will affect government institutions, and companies and individuals whose activities involve the provision of infrastructure and network services and the use telematics.
Foreign Carriers and Diplomatic Envoys
Pursuant to Articles 19 and 20 of the Bill, ships under a foreign flag and airplanes are not permitted to use radio spectrum frequency while in Indonesia, except for navigation or humanitarian purposes. Additionally, ships and airplanes using the radio spectrum are to channeled their communications through a telematic provider, or use satellite communication systems available for shipping and aviation.
Diplomatic envoys, under Article 27 of the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, are to be allowed and protected by receiving countries in relations to freedom of communication. Pursuant to Article 21, diplomatic envoys are permitted the use of communication hardware and applications that enable the diplomatic envoy to make use of the radio spectrum. The use of radio spectrum will be in accordance with the reciprocity principle, whereby Indonesian diplomatic envoys abroad would enjoy the same privileges in the receiving countries.
Compared to Articles 35, 36, and 37 of the Telecommunications Law regarding the rights of foreign flagged ships, airplanes, and diplomatic envoys, the Bill, in Articles 19, 20, 21, essentially re-regulates such rights, without any significant changes to the rights and obligations.
Telematics Forms
Article 8 provides that telematics may have commercial purposes and non-commercial purposes, where the commercial purposes are self explanatory, while the non-commercial telematics serve national defense, security, and universal services obligation purposes, as well as special services such as search and rescue, navigation, and individual services such as amateur radio and radio communication between citizens through the use of handheld transceivers.
Much of Article 8 has been regulated in Article 9 of the Telecommunications Law, though Article 9 of the Telecommunication Law did not explicitly emphasize non-commercial purposes, leaving them to be implied.
Permits
Though, under Article 13, the procedure in acquiring a permit is somewhat vague, compared with Article 11 of the Telecommunications Law, no changes have been introduced to the procedure. There will also be further implementation regulation on this matter.
If the Bill passes, it can be expected that the procedure in obtaining a permit would follow the existing regulation for the telecommunications and broadcasting industries, unless new regulations are also issued. With regard to telematics providers in the information technology industry, which is less regulated compared to telecommunications and broadcasting industries, the Bill appears to be lacking in formulating a convergence of the three industries.
Radio Frequency Spectrum
Since the radio frequency spectrum is a limited resource, pursuant to Article 16, the Minister of Communications and Information Technology would have power to regulate, supervise, and control the use of the radio frequency spectrum. Such power has previously been mandated in Article 33 of the Telecommunications Law.
To acquire rights to use such resources, a telematics provider must obtain a permit from the government, through the process of a radio frequency auction. A previous example of such being the 3G radio spectrum auction, where in 2006 major telecommunication companies (telematics providers) invested substantial amounts to acquire parts of the 3G radio spectrum (PT. Telkomsel IDR 218 billion, PT. Indosat IDR 160 billion, and PT. Excelcomindo IDR 188 Billion).
Such amounts may appear substantial for ten year usage rights, however, they are merely a fraction compared to early 2000, when English and German 3G auctions raised GBP 22.5 and 33 billion, respectively, ultimately overstraining the telecommunications companies and causing the 2001 telecoms crisis.
Satellite Orbits
The use of satellite orbits is currently regulated under Articles 33 and 34 of the Telecommunications Law, the Bill, under Article 23, also requires a permit to use satellite orbits. The current implementing regulation on the usage of satellite orbits is Government Regulation No. 53 of 2000 on the Use of Radio Spectrum Frequencies and Satellite Orbits in conjunction with Minister of Communications and Information Technology Regulation No. 13/P/M.KOMINFO/8/2005 on the Implementation of Satellite Communications.
Numbering
In providing telematics services, telematics provider are numbered by means of a telephone, internet protocol, or electronic number in accordance with Article 24 (3). Such numbering is also regulated under Articles 23 and 24 of the Telecommunication Law. The corresponding implementing regulation is currently still Minister of Communications and Information Technology Regulation No. 20 of 2001 on the Implementation of Telecommunications Networks.
If the Bill passes, there will be a regulation regarding the numbering of telematics providers, whereas of now, the regulation does not cover the convergence of telemactis.
Hardware
Pursuant to Article 25, all tools and/or telematics hardware made and is distributed in Indonesia has to comply with technical requirements set by the government by means of the Indonesian National Standards (SNI). As of the date of this Indonesian Legal Digest, the Ministry of Communications and Information Technology makes 59 types of telematics hardware subject to SNI certification.
With the convergence of telematics, hardware as defined in Article 25 will expand to include potentially unintended equipment, such as personal computers, such broadening of applicability may in turn complicate the future implementation of the Bill.
It is of note that there are exception to the technical hardware requirements for military telecommunications hardware and ships under foreign flags.
Interconnection and Utilization of Shared Infrastructure
Pursuant to Article 31, every telematics provider has the right to acquire connectivity from other telematics providers, and in rendering such, a telematics provider is obliged to assure interoperability with the other telematics provider. This interconnection obligation follows from the obligation to publish interconnection offers in a way that may be accessed by any interested party. The regulation on interconnection concerning fees, method of calculation, and dispute settlement procedures is Minister of Communications and Information Technology Regulation No. 08/PER/M.KOMIFO/02/2006. In the event that the Bill passes, there will likely be a new regulation on interconnection to address the convergence of telematics.
The current practice for telecommunications companies (telematics providers) is to depend on themselves for establishing BTS’ as widely as possible, making telecommunication coverage a strong selling point in attracting customers, similarly to the practice of banks widely installing automatic teller machines (ATM) to gain a competitive edge.
Article 32, requires every telematics provider to allow it telecommunication network be used by other telematics providers. This will allow providers to expand their network coverage without additional capital investment, instead paying other telecommunication network owners based on its usage. There will be a further Government Regulation on the utilization of shared infrastructure.
Business Competition
In every industry, unfair business competition may occur, with the telematics industry being no exception. Pursuant to Articles 29 and 30, any mergers, acquisitions or other transactions are subject to the approval from the Minister of Communications and Information Technology, in accordance with the applicable government laws and regulations.
Corporate restructuring will also be supervised by the Business Competition Supervisory Commission (KPPU) pursuant to with Articles 28 and 29 of Law No. 5 of 1999 on Antimonopoly and Unfair Business Practices in conjunction with Government Regulation No. 57 of 2010 on Mergers and Acquisitions that Might Result in Monopolistic Practices and Unfair Business Competition.
Consumer Protection
Users of telematics under the Bill receives a substantial amount of protection, although they are also covered by the Consumer Protection Law (Law No. 8 of 1999). Articles 33 to 35 specify the rights of users in acquiring telematics services, which come in the form of receiving the services as promised by the telematics provider, with a right to complain with regards to telematics services and for such complaints to be resolved by the telematics provider.
Additionally, users have a right to obtain a list detailing any usage, and bring an action for indemnification for any loss caused by using the services of a telematics provider. On these issues a Government Regulation will be issued to further regulate the implementation.
Security
As provided in Article 41, destruction and/or interference in the form of physical or electromagnetic disturbances, that includes the act of hacking any telematics services, is prohibited. In relation to hacking, Chapter VI and Articles 30 to 32 of the Information and Electronic Transactions Law (Law No. 11 of 2008) elaborate further on this matter.
Though, under Article 43, telematics providers are subject to confidentiality requirements in relation to the services provided to their users, in the event of a request from a law enforcement agency as set in Article 44, they are obliged to accommodate the interception of communications.
Universal Service Obligation
An issue faced by many countries is providing telecommunication coverage throughout their territory, especially in secluded areas with low population density where the cost of establishing telecommunications infrastructure would not be recovered through the operation of the services. Pursuant to Article 38, telematics providers are obliged to contribute funds for a universal service obligation (USO) in order to realize universal telecommunications coverage. The USO is currently regulated in Article 16 of the Telecommunication Law in conjunction with Articles 26 to 28 of Government Regulation No. 52 of 2000.
The method of obtaining funds for the USO can take different forms, for example, in the United States a monthly contribution from existing telephone customers is imposed, while, in Indonesia, USO funds are obtained by imposing contributions to telecommunications companies rather than customers.
It can be expected that if the Bill passes, provisions along the lines of Government Regulation No. 52 of 2000 on USO will apply to information technology and broadcasting companies, forcing them to contribute to a USO fund. In the debates regarding the Bill, there has not been any discussion of USO fund collection being shifted from telematics providers to the users.
Regulatory Body
A new regulatory body will be established pursuant to Article 39, to regulate, supervise and control the convergence of telemactis, there will be an implementing regulation issued to further regulate the new body.
Sanctions
The Bill imposes administrative sanction for certain enumerated violations pursuant to Articles 47 and 48, in the form of administrative fines and/or license revocation. A Government Regulation will be issued to set out the administrative sanctions.
Articles 49 through 60 impose the set out criminal sanctions in the form of imprisonment and monetary penalties. With the investigatory powers being set out in Article 46.
Conclusion
Much of what is covered in the Bill does not necessarily accommodate the convergence of telematics. In fact, most of the articles contained in the Bill address the telecommunications industry, and do not proportionately address the broadcasting and information technology industries.
The only plausible provision that accommodates the true convergence of telematics, with regards to the utilization of shared infrastructure, is contained in Article 32. With half of the contents of the Bill reemphasizing what was already regulated in the Telecommunications Law. It is of note, that if passed in its current form, the Bill would require a substantial number of further implementing regulations.
......