Overview
The banking industry is considered to be one of the most highly regulated, with much of the reason for this being the importance of banks to the welfare and stability of society. This is due to the banks’ activities in the form of holding and distributing a wide range of depositors’ funds, through savings, deposits, rendering credit and buying commercial paper.
The activities of rendering credit and buying commercial paper hold a degree of risk, and in case of mismanagement may result in disturbing a bank’s business continuity and consequentially the stability of the financial system, as transpired in the case of the Asian Financial Crisis which affected the Indonesian banking industry.
To prevent the reoccurrence of such events, the Central Bank (Bank Indonesia / BI), pursuant to Article 29 of Law No. 7 of 1992 as amended by Law No. 10 of 1998 on the Banking Industry (“Law”), has supervisory power over banks. As set out in Article 30 of the Law, banks have an obligation to report to BI regarding their business activities, with one of the reports being a Business Plan.
Bank Indonesia Regulation No.12/21/PBI/2010 on Bank Business Plans (“Regulation”) was recently issued to restate the bank Business Plan requirements. With the issuance of the Regulation, previous BI regulation on the same issue, namely BI Regulation No.6/25/PBI/2004 has been revoked. The Regulation has been in force since 19 October 2010.
This edition of the Indonesian Legal Digest will highlight key features of the Regulation and provide analysis of the Regulation’s provisions.
Purpose
Banks exist in different legal forms, such as limited companies, regional government owned companies, or as cooperatives, as regulated under Law No. 40 of 2007 on Limited Liability Companies (Law 40/2007), Law No. 5 of 1962 on Regional Government Owned Companies (Law 5/1962), and Law No. 25 of 1992 on Cooperatives (Law 25/1992), respectively.
The banks, as established under the laws mentioned above, are obliged under Article 62 of Law 40/2007, Article 15 of Law 5/1962, and Article 30 of Law 25/1992 to set out their Business Plans, this serves as an internal supervisory mechanism and provides a general vision of how the banks will be managed by their Directors.
Banks, due to their role within the economy, are subject to the supervision of BI pursuant to Article 30 of Law No. 7 of 1992, by means of reporting their business conduct and plans, in the form of a Business Plan, as set out under Article 2 of the Regulation.
The Business Plan serves as a control mechanism for BI to supervise banks in conducting their businesses, to get an overview of the banks’ business objectives and their realization, and their compliance with the application of good corporate governance principles.
Banks, through the issuance of the Regulation, are given a new sets of guidelines for producing their Business Plans. Compared to the Regulation’s predecessor, BI Regulation No.6/25/PBI/2004, Sharia Banks and Sharia Business Units of other banks, which previously lacked an implementing regulation for setting their Business Plan, are now covered by the Regulation, which aims to fill this, as well as other, gaps.
It should be noted that since 2008, Sharia Banks are no longer regulated under Law No. 10 of 1998 on the Amendment of Banking Law No. 7 of 1992, instead being specifically regulated under Law No. 21 of 2008 on Sharia Banking. Since then, there has been no regulation that has been issued to address Business Plans of Sharia banks.
Definitions
Pursuant to Article 1 (3) in conjunction with Article 2, a Business Plan is described as a document that must be provided by banks to BI, as the bank supervisory body. Such a document must consist of the bank’s short term plan in the form of a one year plan, and a medium term plan in the form of a three year plan, and must also include a plan to improve the performance of its business units, and its strategy in realizing the plan according to the time and targets, while keeping in mind the compliance with prudential and risk management principles.
As provided under Article 2, in preparing a Business Plan, banks are to consider internal factors that can affect the realization of their plans, such as their financial condition, as indicated by liquid assets and receivables, debts to any third parties, capacity to manage the bank’s business units and human resources, and also the infrastructure, such as the bank branches and agents.
External factors are also to be considered, such as the condition of the global economy, the regional economy, and the Indonesian economy, as well as social and political developments in Indonesia are all factors that need to be considered. Additionally, the development of technology that is needed to improve services to depositors should also be taken into account.
Applicability
Indonesia has a universal banking system, where banks may provide commercial and investment services from within a single legal entity. With a restriction being the limits on investment activity under Articles 6 and 7 of the Law.
A notable characteristic of the banking system in Indonesia, if compared to western countries, is that Indonesia has a third type of banking entity in the form of the Sharia Bank. In essence a Sharia Bank is an entity resulting from the application of Islamic Law, which is not allowed to impose interest and is forbidden from engaging in speculative transactions, based on Sharia principles. However, in order to maintain its business, it may pay dividends to its depositors and collect a profit.
The types of banks that are affected by the Regulation do not include investment banks, while, as set out in Article 1 (1), banks that have to provide a Business Plan to BI are: Sharia banks, commercial banks, and branches of foreign commercial banks that operate in Indonesia.
The Board of Directors, pursuant to Article 2 (4), have to prepare the Business Plan, which the Commissioners have to then approve, prior to submitting it to BI. The Business Plan also has to be communicated to the shareholders and to all levels of the bank’s organization, according to Article 3.
Business Plan
A Business Plan consists of a short-term plan and a medium-term plan, as defined in Article 1 (3). The contents of the Business Plan as stipulated in Article 2, in conjunction with Article 5, at first glance do not appear significantly different from the Regulation’s predecessor, namely Article 5 of BI Regulation No.6/25/PBI/2004. However, new requirements, as further discussed below, now apply to commercial banks, Sharia Banks, and foreign bank branches.
According to Article 5, the Business Plan must consist of, at least, an Executive Summary as further elaborated on in Article 6; a Policy and Management Strategy as further elaborated on in Article 7; an Application of Risk Management and Bank Performance as further elaborated on in Article 8; a Financial Report Projection including Assumptions as further elaborated on in Article 9; Projection of Capital Ratios and Certain Other Items as further elaborated on in Article 10; Funding Plan as further elaborated on in Article 11; Investment Fund Plan as further elaborated on in Article 12; Capital Plan as further elaborated on in Article 13; Organization and Human Resources Development plan as further elaborated on in Article 14; the Issuance of New Products and/or New Activities as further elaborated on in Article 15; and the Development and/or Changes of the Office Network as further elaborated on in Article 16.
New Requirements
A difference from the previous regulation is contained in Article 14, which requires plans to use outsourcing and expatriate labor to be reported in the Business Plan. Previously such a requirement was not imposed, with the prior regulation, pursuant to its Article 15, requiring only an organization development plan and a human resource development plan to be provided.
Pursuant to Article 6, the Executive Summary is required to, at a minimum, contain the bank’s vision and mission, its policy direction, and the strategic steps that will be taken. In the prior regulation such requirements were no imposed.
The success of credit distribution programs such as Simpedes and Kupedes in which Bank Rakyat Indonesia (BRI) had successfully reached farmers living in secluded areas throughout Indonesia, appears to have come to the attention of BI. Whereby, according to Article 8 (d), banks are required to have a plan for the provision of credit to micro, small and medium enterprises.
Risk management was already required by the previous regulation, but compliance policies were not. Now, as set out in Article 7, risk management and compliance policies are required, in conjunction with the Article 8 (e) requirement that Sharia Banks, and Sharia Business Units of other banks, comply with Sharia principles.
Risk Management
As defined in Article 1 (3) of BI Regulation No. 5/8/PBI/2003 on the Application of Risk Management for Commercial Banks, risk management is a set of procedures and a methodology used to identify measure, observe, and control risks that arise during the course of the bank’s business activities.
Managing risk is a complex process for banks, requiring a bank to take into account its competition, its corporate culture, the economy in general, technology, expertise, human resources, and the bank’s financial strength in designing and implementing its risk management methodologies.
Submission and Amendment
A Business Plan, prior to being submitted by the Board of Directors, has to first be approved by the Commissioners, in accordance with Article 2 (4). The submission of the Plan for the following year, pursuant to Article 18 (1), must be made by the end of November, with an exception for 2011 Business Plans, in Article 18 (2), which can be submitted at any time before the end of December 2010.
In the event of noncompliance of the submitted Business Plan with the provisions of the Regulation, banks have 15 days from being notified of such by BI, to revise the Business Plan.
Pursuant to Article 19, a bank may amend its Business Plan in the event of significant external or internal factors that affect the bank’s operations, or following an event that significantly affects the bank’s performance (subject to BI’s considerations).
Banks are only given an opportunity to amend their Business Plan once, which may be done until the end of June. Such amendments must be submitted 30 working days prior to the modified Business Plan being implemented, allowing BI time to request further adjustments to be made.
Realization Report
Considering that the main goal of the Regulation is for banks to set a realistic Business Plan, under Article 20, banks are to required to report on the realization of the Business Plan each quarter.
Banks have one month after the end of the quarter, or 45 days for banks that do no have an online system while having over 100 branches, to submit their realization report.
Pursuant to Article 20 (3), the realization report must consist of: descriptions of achievement, and explanations of deviations in realizing the Business Plan, the follow up on the achievement of the Business Plan, capital ratios and certain other items, and other information, such as a realization report on changing the office network and reports on the realization of a linkage program.
Supervision Report
As required by Article 4, Commissioners have to supervise the realization of the Business Plan. And, under Article 21, the Commissioners are required to submit their supervision report on a semi-annual basis. The report must be submitted no later than two months after the end of the 6 month reporting period.
The report must consist an evaluation by the Commissioners of: the realization of the Business Plan quantitatively and qualitatively, factors that affect business performance, and efforts to improve the bank’s performance.
Sanctions
Late submission of a Business Plan, a Business Plan Realization Report, or a Business Plan Supervision Report, to BI or one of its branches (as set out in Article 25) will attract sanctions. Pursuant to Article 27 (1) this will lead to the bank being fined IDR 1 million for every working day that it fails to submit the required report. It is further set out in Articles 22 (1) and 23 (1) and (2) how such lateness is defined.
In the event that a bank fails to submit the reports, with failure to submit being defined in Articles 22 (3) and 23 (3), the bank will be subject to a fine of IDR 50 million for each report that is not submitted.
Banks submitting adjustments to the Business Plan, following a request from BI, are subject to a fine of IDR 50 million under Article 27 (4) if the needed information or documents are not provided. However, pursuant to Article 27 (5), a bank would given 21 working days before being fined for such omissions.
Other administrative sanctions are also available if banks are found to be in violation of the Regulation. Pursuant to Article 28 such sanctions can take the form of: warning letters, temporarily halting the operation of certain business activities, the downgrading of the bank’s level, and the inclusion of company management and shareholder names in the list of individuals who fail the BI fit and proper test.
Conclusion
BI has a wide range of powers over banks, such as the ability to license, regulate, control and to impose sanctions. In exercising its powers BI seeks to ensure the stability of Indonesia’s banking system, and, with the issuance of the Regulation, specifically to address the oversight of the banks that is done by means of the Business Plan requirements.
The issuance of the Regulation serves to subject Syariah Banks and Syariah Banking Units to the obligation of providing a Business Plan. While previous regulation on Business Plans did not explicitly address Syariah Banking, leaving potential regulatory gaps, the issuance of the Regulation ensures that commercial banks, Syariah Banks, and foreign banks are all subject to the same obligations.
......