New Regulation Sets Out a Framework for the Placement and Protection of Indonesian Workers Abroad

Overview

The wage of domestic workers ranges from IDR 500 to 800 thousand per month in Indonesia, compared to the minimum wage, as set in Governor of Jakarta Regulation No. 1 of 2010, of IDR 1,173,909. This, as well as the even more substantial discrepancies with wages in foreign jurisdictions has encourage those working in the informal sector to seek employment abroad, in countries such Malaysia, Singapore, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, as well as others, that provide better remuneration.

The placement of workers for domestic positions is mostly done through a third party, an agency that specializes in placing prospective workers abroad (Pelaksana Penempatan Tenaga Kerja Indonesia Swasta / PPTKIS / Placement Agency). Such agencies’ business objectives are to help meet the demand, as indicated by requests from foreign business counterparts, for Indonesian workers to work abroad (Tenaga Kerja Indonesia / TKI).

The procedure that migrant workers, placement agencies and private companies have to undergo is regulated in broad terms under Law No. 39 of 2004 on Placement and Protection of Indonesian Workers Abroad (“Law”). However, much of what is regulated under the Law lacks any implementing regulations, such as provisions set out in Articles 26, 32, 36, 40, 58, 63, 69, 75 and 76 of the Law.

To address this gap in implementing regulations, the government has recently issued Minister of Labor and Transmigration (Minister) Regulation No. PER.14/MEN/X/2010 on Implementation of Placement and Protection of Indonesian Workers Abroad (‘Regulation’).

The Regulation has been in force since 19 October 2010, and has repealed three related regulations: Minister of Labor and Transmigration Regulation No. PER.16/MEN/VIII/2009 on Procedures of Issuing a Permit to Send Prospective TKI Abroad for the Placement of Private TKI; Regulation No. PER.17/MEN/VIII/2009 on the Final Preparation of TKI Before Placement Abroad; and Regulation No. PER.18/MEN/VIII/2009 on Form, Requirements, and Procedure of Obtaining Identification of Workers Working Abroad.

This edition of Indonesian Legal Digest will highlight key features of the Regulation and provide analysis of the Regulation’s provisions.

 

Purpose

Protection of TKI abroad has been an on-and-off national and international issue in the media. Over the past years cases of TKI facing physical and psychological abuse as well as violations of the TKI’s rights has resulted in Indonesia halting the departures of new domestic workers to countries such as Malaysia and Kuwait in mid 2009.

To permanently halt domestic worker departures is neither an option nor a solution, in light of the government’s inability to provide job opportunities with greater remuneration than that offered abroad. Consequently, the Regulation was issued in order to strike a balance between the economic needs of the migrant workers and their protection abroad.

In essence, the protection of migrant workers is achieved by means of three phases, first the pre-placement phase, second the placement phase as set out in Chapter XII, and third the post-placement phase as set out in Chapter XIII. The first phase covers the recruitment process and the preparation before placement abroad, the second phase involves the monitoring of migrant workers abroad, and the third phase ensures that the migrant worker will return safely to Indonesia.

The Regulation’s issuance serves to implement Articles 26, 32, 36, 40, 58, 63, 69, 75 and 76 of the Law, which aims to minimize the harm to, and the violations of rights of, Indonesian migrant workers abroad by their employers and by third parties. For this purpose, the Regulation serves to ensure that the three phases are complied with, so as to ensure the protection of migrant workers abroad.

 

Applicability

A large part of the Regulation’s provisions deals with Placement Agencies, Private Companies, and migrant workers. With migrant workers being categorized as those who are placed by Placement Agencies, and, pursuant to Article 52, those who are not.

The affected parties upon recruitment, assessment, and placement are required to obtain a permit or license. Under Articles 2 and 3 of the Regulation, in conjunction with Article 32 of the Law, Placement Agencies, before being able to recruit prospective migrant workers, are required to obtain a Mobilization License (Surat Izin Pengerahan / SIP) which is issued by the Minister of Labor and Transmigration.

As for Private Companies, which are defined as state owned enterprises, regional owned enterprises, or privately owned companies, under Articles 49 and 50, in conjunction with Article 26 of the Law, are obliged to secure a permit from the Minister of Labor and Transmigration in order to place their employees in positions abroad.

Migrant workers, under Chapter V of the Regulation, in conjunction with Article 63 of the Law, are required to obtain a migrant worker identification card upon placement (Kartu Tenaga Kerja Luar Negeri / KTKLN) which will be issued by the National Agency for Placement and Protection of Indonesian Migrant Workers (Badan Nasional Penempatan dan Perlindungan Tenaga Kerja Indonesia /BNP2TKI).

 

Placement Agency

Placement Agencies are considered to have the biggest role in preventing migrant workers’ rights violations, and act as the first safety net for the protection of migrant workers. Under the Regulation, Placement Agencies are responsible for the migrant worker from the time they are recruited until the migrant worker has completed the duration of their employment contract and has returned to Indonesia.

 

Mobilization License

To obtain a Mobilization License (Surat Izin Pengerahan / SIP) pursuant to Articles 3 and 4, the Placement Agency must submit a request to the Minister of Labor and Transmigration, with copies to the provincial and regional government of the locality of the recruitment.

Documents that must be submitted to secure an SIP consist of: copies of placement agreement between the Placement Agency and its business counterpart abroad, a migrant worker request letter from the prospective employer, a draft of the employment agreement, and a draft of the placement agreement. These documents, except for the placement agreement, are subject to approval by an Indonesian Embassy located in the country where the migrant workers are to be placed, and have to be provided bilingually in Indonesian and  in English (or the language of the placement country).

Under Article 7, the validity of an SIP is for a period of 6 months, and may be extended for another 3 months, on the condition that the submitted request letter for migrant workers has not expired.

 

Migrant Workers

The minimum age to be employed abroad is 18 years, as set in Article 8, with a higher minimum age for household workers of 21 years. In seeking employment abroad, prospective migrant workers are required to register themselves with labor agencies in the region or city of their domicile. Under Article 8 (1) in registering a as jobseeker, prospective migrant workers can not be charged a fee, this provides legal certainty in an area where many unofficial fees were previously being collected.

The self registration process requires the prospective migrant workers to submit the documents listed in Article 8 (2) before being recruited by a Placement Agency. The self registration procedure exists to prevent human trafficking by illegal Placement Agencies.

The requirements under Article 8 are also designed to help Placement Agencies search for prospective migrant workers since regional or city labor agencies are able to provide data on prospective placement agencies, on the condition that the recruitment approval letter from the Placement and Protection of Migrant Workers Service Office (Balai Pelayanan Penempatan dan Perlindungan Tenaga Kerja / BP3TKI) has been acquired, as set out in Articles 9 and 12.

 

Recruitment

In the recruitment process, under Article 11, prospective migrant workers are briefed by Placement Agency and Labor Agency in the regional/city of their recruitment area regarding the job description, the placement countries, and also about the rights and obligations of the prospective migrant workers. Since Article 34 of the Law did not address the types of information to be provided in great detail, Article 10 of the Regulation provides a more comprehensive list of issues that must be addressed.

The required minimum is: the description of the job; the location and working conditions; protection procedure and risks that may be faced by migrant workers; the time place and requirement to register for the position; the recruitment procedure; requirements of the prospective migrant workers; condition and requirements of the job covering the salary, working hours, leave, overtime, protection guarantee, and facility obtained; prevailing law in the placement country, social cultural condition of the placement country; the documents needed to be placed as a migrant worker abroad; fees that will be imposed to migrant workers and the payment mechanism; and also the rights and obligations of the prospective workers.

In accordance with Article 11 (1) the briefing will take one day. This procedure is considered to be of utmost importance, since it will serve as the basis for the decision by prospective migrant workers on whether to continue with the recruitment process or not.

 

Selection

To ensure the suitability of the prospective migrant worker, migrant workers are to undergo administrative and skills selection through documentation verification and interviews pursuant to Articles 14 to 18. Where upon passing the selection phase the placement agreement will be signed with the Placement Agency, which must be acknowledged by the regional/city labor agency following a submission of proof of an insurance payment that is made prior to placement. The placement agreement is to be given to prospective migrant workers, the regional/city labor agency, and BP3TKI pursuant to Article 19 (3).

In order to acquire passports for the migrant workers, a recommendation letter from the regional/city labor agency is required, with the minutes of the meeting of the selection phase provided by the Placement Agency serving as a basis for the regional/city labor agency to issue a recommendation letter under Article 19 (5) in conjunction with Article 51 (f) of the Law.

 

Preparation

In preparing the selected prospective migrant workers before placement abroad, health and psychological evaluation and vocational training are required under Articles 24 and 22 in conjunction with Articles 42 to 47, 48 to 50, and 51 of the Law.  Placement Agency may accommodate the prospective migrant workers for these purposes pursuant Article 21.

The condition of the accommodation must comply with Minster of Labor and Transmigration Regulation No. Per-07/MEN/IV/2005 regarding standards of accommodation for prospective migrant workers (Regulation 7/2005). Pursuant to Article 2 of Regulation 7/2005, the Placement Agency has to acquire a permit from the regional/city officials. And the condition of the accommodation must meet the criteria in Articles 4, 5, and 6 of Regulation 7/2005.

It should be noted that, based on a Ministry of Labor and Transmigration research, it was found that many migrant workers did not acquire a full understanding of the training during the preparation that they received.

During training, the Placement Agency is forbidden to employ prospective migrant workers according to Article 46 of the Law.

Under Article 24, the Placement Agency has to facilitate the health and psychological evaluation, with a more thorough regulation under Articles 48 to 50 of the Law. Health and Psychological evaluation basically serves to determine whether the prospective migrant worker’s physical and psychological condition is fit to carry out the job abroad.

Expenses for the education and training and also the health and psychological evaluation, can be charged to prospective migrant workers pursuant to Article 45. And in the event that the prospective worker fails to meet the requirement or complete the training, the fees will be covered by the insurance, which the Placement Agency has to arrange prior to the training being commenced.

 

Final Preparation

A Placement Agency is required to enlist prospective migrant workers under their supervision to attend a final preparation program (Pembekalan Akhir Pemberangkatan/PAP). PAP serves as a final briefing to prospective migrant workers to cover issues that are listed in Article 35 regarding laws and regulation on immigration, labor, and criminal law in the country of placement. It also serve to provide information regarding the employment agreement on types of jobs; rights and obligations of migrant workers and their employers; salary, working hours, holidays, insurance, duration of the employment agreement and extension procedure; as well as methods of dispute settlement.

In registering the prospective migrant workers, the Placement Agency has to submit a draft of the employment agreement, the passport of the prospective migrant worker, and the visas. Upon a completion of PAP, a PAP certificate will be issued to the migrant worker, and will remain valid for 4 years (the maximum duration of an employment contract, post extension). In the event that a migrant worker has returned to Indonesia upon completion of employment, he/she will not be required to take an another PAP if the stay in Indonesia does not exceed 2 years, pursuant to Article 37 (2).

 

Employment Agreement

After passing the educational and training requirement and also the health and psychological evaluation, the prospective migrant workers may sign an employment agreement pursuant to Article 27. The parties to the agreement, as per Article 25, being be the migrant worker and the employer, rather than the Placement Agency.

The final requirement is that the prospective migrant worker has to attend a final briefing (Persiapan Akhir Penempatan/PAP) held by the regional/city labor agency, where the employment agreement must be signed in the presence of the officials of the regional/city labor agency.

The duration of the employment agreement, under Article 28, may only be for a period of 2 years, but may be extended for another 2 years in the event that the conditions of Article 29 (1) are met and the employer bears the additional expenses of the migrant worker insurance, legalization at an Indonesian Embassy of the extended employment agreement, commission fee to the Placement Agency responsible sending the migrant worker and its counterpart in the placement country, and a return airplane ticket. In addition to this, the employment agreement is subject to approval by an appointed official from the Indonesian Embassy where the migrant worker is placed.

The minimum contents of the employment agreement are set out in Article 26 (1). It is further stated in Article 26 (2) that the employment agreement must be based on a draft agreement that has the approval of an Indonesian Embassy in the placement country. This additional check is required since any issues regarding migrant workers will arise in the foreign jurisdiction, and it will be the Indonesian Embassy that will have to deal with any such issues.

 

Applied Charges

As set in Article 45, the Placement Agency may charge fees to prospective migrant workers for: identification verification, health and psychological evaluation, education and training, working visa, accommodation and meals, airline tickets and airport tax, transportation during accommodation for the purpose of trainings, Placement Agency fee, and insurance.

Insurance for migrant workers mentioned in Article 45 (1) (i) is further regulated under Article 7 of the Minister of Labor and Transmigration Regulation No. Per-23/MEN/XII/2008 on Migrant Worker Insurance (Regulation 23/08), which states that the insurance coverage of migrant workers should cover the time prior to placement, time of placement, and time after placement.

The part of commission that is paid by the employer can not be charged by the Placement Agency to the prospective worker, pursuant to Article 45 (2).

Placement fees vary from one country to another, with the Minister of Labor and Transmigration due to issue further regulation setting out such fees. Under Article 47, such fees have to be stated in the placement agreement, and cannot exceed those set by the Minister.

 

Private Company

Under Article 49, state owned companies, regional government owned companies, or private companies that are not Placement Agencies may employ their own workers to work abroad for the purpose of the company business.

Grounds to employ their workers in such a way are set out in Article 50 (1), and are that: the company has a direct ownership with a company abroad, or the company has been awarded a project abroad, or as part of a business expansion plan, or to improve its human resource development.

In employing their workers, a company is obliged to acquire a permit, pursuant to Article 50 (2), where upon a complete submission the application, the Minister of Labor and Transmigration, or its appointed official, has to issue the permit within 5 working days.

 

Working Identification

Although the process to obtain a migrant worker identification card (Kartu Tenaga Kerja Luar Negeri/KTKLN) are different for migrant workers processed by placement agency, private companies, or those who find employment abroad individually. It is nonetheless necessity, pursuant to Article 38, to acquire a KTKLN, so that if anything should happen to the migrant worker abroad, the identification will provide the needed information for officials to address the problems faced by an Indonesian migrant workers.

The issuance of a KTKLN is done by the BNP2TKI. Prior to receiving a KTKLN, a prospective migrant worker being placed by a Placement Agency has, under Article 40, to submit their placement document, proof of attending a PAP, proof of insurance coverage, the employment agreement, and proof of payment for the training.

Individual applicants, pursuant to Article 52, are only required to submit proof of a visa invitation from the employer and a signed employment agreement. Excluding the PAP and insurance coverage, the lower requirements for individual applicants are due to the likely higher level of education of individual applicants, and that the employer provides insurance in the placement country. Private companies sending their workers abroad, pursuant to Article 51, are required to submit a placement agreement, and proof of insurance.

Obtaining a KTKLN, pursuant to Articles 41 (2) and 52 (2), upon complete submission of the required documents, will take no longer than 1 working day.

 

Placement

Under Article 34 a prospective migrant worker has to attend a PAP at least 2 days prior to the departure to the placement abroad. And the Placement Agency, following the placement, is obliged to monitor the migrant workers that they have sent abroad.

The monitoring, as elaborated on in Article 55, has to be carried out by the Placement Agency directly and/or with coordination with their business counterpart in the country of placement. Under Article 55 (2) the Placement Agency has to monitor the condition of the migrant workers by acquiring such details as the name and address of the employer, the suitability of the position and workplace to which the migrant workers are deployed, the fulfillment of the migrant workers’ rights, as well as the condition and any problems faced by the migrant workers.

Pursuant to Article 55 (4) the Placement Agency then has to report their findings every 6 months to the Minister of Labor and Transmigration and the Head of BNP2TKI.

 

Data and Information

Pursuant to Article 53, information on migrant workers abroad has to be provided via the internet by BNP2TKI, so that it can be accessed by public, as appropriate. The type of data that must be provided by BNP2TKI is further set out under Article 54. However, as of the date of this Indonesian Legal Digest, such information was not available on the BNP2TKI website. Where the Regulation is lacking, is that there are no articles addressing how the information is to be provided and by when BNP2TKI has to start providing the information. 

 

Post-Placement

Estimates by the Ministry of Labor and Transmigration indicate that from 2005 to 2009 there are around 3.5 million migrant workers deployed to Middle East, Asia Pacific, as well as other continents. This has made protection of migrant workers after their placement a difficult task for officials, as well as the parties receiving and processing them upon their return to Indonesia.

The return of migrant workers to Indonesia takes place through Soerkarno-Hatta International Airport, where, instead of exiting Terminal 2 (international arrivals) like other international passengers, the migrant workers are directed to the Selapajang terminal just outside Soekarno-Hatta, which is intended for the arrival of migrant workers. 

The separate terminal for migrant workers has become an item of debate in early 2010. Cases have arisen in the special terminal where the uneducated migrant workers who bring their earnings in foreign currency are taken advantage of. This has contributed to calls to discontinue the use of a separate terminal, the aim of which was initially to increase efficiency.

As mentioned in Article 75 of the Law in conjunction with Article 56 of the Regulation, the return of migrant workers is also the responsibility of Placement Agency. With Articles 56 to 59 of the Regulation being complementary to Articles 73 to 75 of the Law.

The Placement Agency, upon the return of a migrant worker from their placement abroad, is requires to carry out the tasks as set out in Article 58.

 

Sanctions

The Regulation is an implementing regulation of the Law, and as such elaborates on the Law’s provisions but does not provide criminal or explicit administrative sanctions. The only sanctions that are contained are in Article 6, which states that the SIP of a Placement Agency can be denied or annulled should they fail to resolve their past issues.

Administrative sanctions are imposed on those who violate requirements such as the SIP, as set out in Article 2, employment agreement as set out in Articles 25 and 26, PAP as set out in Article 31, and charges to migrant workers set out in Article 45, pursuant to Article 100 of the Law. The administrative sanctions may be in the form of warning letter, suspension of business activities, revocation of licenses, cancellation of migrant workers placements, and/or the recalling of migrant workers at their own expense. 

 

Conclusion

The legal framework for the protection of migrant workers working abroad is considered to be sufficient considering that domestic workers in Indonesia are currently struggling to gain recognition and protection. In Indonesia domestic workers are often denied leave, paid below minimum wage, and are not covered by any form of insurance.

The protection for migrant workers is needed during the pre-placement phase, the placement phase, and the post-placement phase. However, the bulk of the Regulation’s provisions address the pre-placement phase, since it takes place in Indonesia and consequently is easier to assure the enforcement of. This results in arguably somewhat lacking protection of migrant workers during their placement abroad. As such, it is reasonable to expect that there will be further legislation to regulate the placement phase, and post-placement phase.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

The wage of domestic workers ranges from IDR 500 to 800 thousand per month in Indonesia, compared to the minimum wage, as set in Governor of Jakarta Regulation No. 1 of 2010, of IDR 1,173,909. This, as well as the even more substantial discrepancies with wages in foreign jurisdictions has encourage those working in the informal sector to seek employment abroad, in countries such Malaysia, Singapore, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, as well as others, that provide better remuneration.

The placement of workers for domestic positions is mostly done through a third party, an agency that specializes in placing prospective workers abroad (Pelaksana Penempatan Tenaga Kerja Indonesia Swasta / PPTKIS / Placement Agency). Such agencies’ business objectives are to help meet the demand, as indicated by requests from foreign business counterparts, for Indonesian workers to work abroad (Tenaga Kerja Indonesia / TKI).

The procedure that migrant workers, placement agencies and private companies have to undergo is regulated in broad terms under Law No. 39 of 2004 on Placement and Protection of Indonesian Workers Abroad (“Law”). However, much of what is regulated under the Law lacks any implementing regulations, such as provisions set out in Articles 26, 32, 36, 40, 58, 63, 69, 75 and 76 of the Law.

To address this gap in implementing regulations, the government has recently issued Minister of Labor and Transmigration (Minister) Regulation No. PER.14/MEN/X/2010 on Implementation of Placement and Protection of Indonesian Workers Abroad (‘Regulation’).

The Regulation has been in force since 19 October 2010, and has repealed three related regulations: Minister of Labor and Transmigration Regulation No. PER.16/MEN/VIII/2009 on Procedures of Issuing a Permit to Send Prospective TKI Abroad for the Placement of Private TKI; Regulation No. PER.17/MEN/VIII/2009 on the Final Preparation of TKI Before Placement Abroad; and Regulation No. PER.18/MEN/VIII/2009 on Form, Requirements, and Procedure of Obtaining Identification of Workers Working Abroad.

This edition of Indonesian Legal Digest will highlight key features of the Regulation and provide analysis of the Regulation’s provisions.

 

Purpose

Protection of TKI abroad has been an on-and-off national and international issue in the media. Over the past years cases of TKI facing physical and psychological abuse as well as violations of the TKI’s rights has resulted in Indonesia halting the departures of new domestic workers to countries such as Malaysia and Kuwait in mid 2009.

To permanently halt domestic worker departures is neither an option nor a solution, in light of the government’s inability to provide job opportunities with greater remuneration than that offered abroad. Consequently, the Regulation was issued in order to strike a balance between the economic needs of the migrant workers and their protection abroad.

In essence, the protection of migrant workers is achieved by means of three phases, first the pre-placement phase, second the placement phase as set out in Chapter XII, and third the post-placement phase as set out in Chapter XIII. The first phase covers the recruitment process and the preparation before placement abroad, the second phase involves the monitoring of migrant workers abroad, and the third phase ensures that the migrant worker will return safely to Indonesia.

The Regulation’s issuance serves to implement Articles 26, 32, 36, 40, 58, 63, 69, 75 and 76 of the Law, which aims to minimize the harm to, and the violations of rights of, Indonesian migrant workers abroad by their employers and by third parties. For this purpose, the Regulation serves to ensure that the three phases are complied with, so as to ensure the protection of migrant workers abroad.

 

Applicability

A large part of the Regulation’s provisions deals with Placement Agencies, Private Companies, and migrant workers. With migrant workers being categorized as those who are placed by Placement Agencies, and, pursuant to Article 52, those who are not.

The affected parties upon recruitment, assessment, and placement are required to obtain a permit or license. Under Articles 2 and 3 of the Regulation, in conjunction with Article 32 of the Law, Placement Agencies, before being able to recruit prospective migrant workers, are required to obtain a Mobilization License (Surat Izin Pengerahan / SIP) which is issued by the Minister of Labor and Transmigration.

As for Private Companies, which are defined as state owned enterprises, regional owned enterprises, or privately owned companies, under Articles 49 and 50, in conjunction with Article 26 of the Law, are obliged to secure a permit from the Minister of Labor and Transmigration in order to place their employees in positions abroad.

Migrant workers, under Chapter V of the Regulation, in conjunction with Article 63 of the Law, are required to obtain a migrant worker identification card upon placement (Kartu Tenaga Kerja Luar Negeri / KTKLN) which will be issued by the National Agency for Placement and Protection of Indonesian Migrant Workers (Badan Nasional Penempatan dan Perlindungan Tenaga Kerja Indonesia /BNP2TKI).

 

Placement Agency

Placement Agencies are considered to have the biggest role in preventing migrant workers’ rights violations, and act as the first safety net for the protection of migrant workers. Under the Regulation, Placement Agencies are responsible for the migrant worker from the time they are recruited until the migrant worker has completed the duration of their employment contract and has returned to Indonesia.

 

Mobilization License

To obtain a Mobilization License (Surat Izin Pengerahan / SIP) pursuant to Articles 3 and 4, the Placement Agency must submit a request to the Minister of Labor and Transmigration, with copies to the provincial and regional government of the locality of the recruitment.

Documents that must be submitted to secure an SIP consist of: copies of placement agreement between the Placement Agency and its business counterpart abroad, a migrant worker request letter from the prospective employer, a draft of the employment agreement, and a draft of the placement agreement. These documents, except for the placement agreement, are subject to approval by an Indonesian Embassy located in the country where the migrant workers are to be placed, and have to be provided bilingually in Indonesian and  in English (or the language of the placement country).

Under Article 7, the validity of an SIP is for a period of 6 months, and may be extended for another 3 months, on the condition that the submitted request letter for migrant workers has not expired.

 

Migrant Workers

The minimum age to be employed abroad is 18 years, as set in Article 8, with a higher minimum age for household workers of 21 years. In seeking employment abroad, prospective migrant workers are required to register themselves with labor agencies in the region or city of their domicile. Under Article 8 (1) in registering a as jobseeker, prospective migrant workers can not be charged a fee, this provides legal certainty in an area where many unofficial fees were previously being collected.

The self registration process requires the prospective migrant workers to submit the documents listed in Article 8 (2) before being recruited by a Placement Agency. The self registration procedure exists to prevent human trafficking by illegal Placement Agencies.

The requirements under Article 8 are also designed to help Placement Agencies search for prospective migrant workers since regional or city labor agencies are able to provide data on prospective placement agencies, on the condition that the recruitment approval letter from the Placement and Protection of Migrant Workers Service Office (Balai Pelayanan Penempatan dan Perlindungan Tenaga Kerja / BP3TKI) has been acquired, as set out in Articles 9 and 12.

 

Recruitment

In the recruitment process, under Article 11, prospective migrant workers are briefed by Placement Agency and Labor Agency in the regional/city of their recruitment area regarding the job description, the placement countries, and also about the rights and obligations of the prospective migrant workers. Since Article 34 of the Law did not address the types of information to be provided in great detail, Article 10 of the Regulation provides a more comprehensive list of issues that must be addressed.

The required minimum is: the description of the job; the location and working conditions; protection procedure and risks that may be faced by migrant workers; the time place and requirement to register for the position; the recruitment procedure; requirements of the prospective migrant workers; condition and requirements of the job covering the salary, working hours, leave, overtime, protection guarantee, and facility obtained; prevailing law in the placement country, social cultural condition of the placement country; the documents needed to be placed as a migrant worker abroad; fees that will be imposed to migrant workers and the payment mechanism; and also the rights and obligations of the prospective workers.

In accordance with Article 11 (1) the briefing will take one day. This procedure is considered to be of utmost importance, since it will serve as the basis for the decision by prospective migrant workers on whether to continue with the recruitment process or not.

 

Selection

To ensure the suitability of the prospective migrant worker, migrant workers are to undergo administrative and skills selection through documentation verification and interviews pursuant to Articles 14 to 18. Where upon passing the selection phase the placement agreement will be signed with the Placement Agency, which must be acknowledged by the regional/city labor agency following a submission of proof of an insurance payment that is made prior to placement. The placement agreement is to be given to prospective migrant workers, the regional/city labor agency, and BP3TKI pursuant to Article 19 (3).

In order to acquire passports for the migrant workers, a recommendation letter from the regional/city labor agency is required, with the minutes of the meeting of the selection phase provided by the Placement Agency serving as a basis for the regional/city labor agency to issue a recommendation letter under Article 19 (5) in conjunction with Article 51 (f) of the Law.

 

Preparation

In preparing the selected prospective migrant workers before placement abroad, health and psychological evaluation and vocational training are required under Articles 24 and 22 in conjunction with Articles 42 to 47, 48 to 50, and 51 of the Law.  Placement Agency may accommodate the prospective migrant workers for these purposes pursuant Article 21.

The condition of the accommodation must comply with Minster of Labor and Transmigration Regulation No. Per-07/MEN/IV/2005 regarding standards of accommodation for prospective migrant workers (Regulation 7/2005). Pursuant to Article 2 of Regulation 7/2005, the Placement Agency has to acquire a permit from the regional/city officials. And the condition of the accommodation must meet the criteria in Articles 4, 5, and 6 of Regulation 7/2005.

It should be noted that, based on a Ministry of Labor and Transmigration research, it was found that many migrant workers did not acquire a full understanding of the training during the preparation that they received.

During training, the Placement Agency is forbidden to employ prospective migrant workers according to Article 46 of the Law.

Under Article 24, the Placement Agency has to facilitate the health and psychological evaluation, with a more thorough regulation under Articles 48 to 50 of the Law. Health and Psychological evaluation basically serves to determine whether the prospective migrant worker’s physical and psychological condition is fit to carry out the job abroad.

Expenses for the education and training and also the health and psychological evaluation, can be charged to prospective migrant workers pursuant to Article 45. And in the event that the prospective worker fails to meet the requirement or complete the training, the fees will be covered by the insurance, which the Placement Agency has to arrange prior to the training being commenced.

 

Final Preparation

A Placement Agency is required to enlist prospective migrant workers under their supervision to attend a final preparation program (Pembekalan Akhir Pemberangkatan/PAP). PAP serves as a final briefing to prospective migrant workers to cover issues that are listed in Article 35 regarding laws and regulation on immigration, labor, and criminal law in the country of placement. It also serve to provide information regarding the employment agreement on types of jobs; rights and obligations of migrant workers and their employers; salary, working hours, holidays, insurance, duration of the employment agreement and extension procedure; as well as methods of dispute settlement.

In registering the prospective migrant workers, the Placement Agency has to submit a draft of the employment agreement, the passport of the prospective migrant worker, and the visas. Upon a completion of PAP, a PAP certificate will be issued to the migrant worker, and will remain valid for 4 years (the maximum duration of an employment contract, post extension). In the event that a migrant worker has returned to Indonesia upon completion of employment, he/she will not be required to take an another PAP if the stay in Indonesia does not exceed 2 years, pursuant to Article 37 (2).

 

Employment Agreement

After passing the educational and training requirement and also the health and psychological evaluation, the prospective migrant workers may sign an employment agreement pursuant to Article 27. The parties to the agreement, as per Article 25, being be the migrant worker and the employer, rather than the Placement Agency.

The final requirement is that the prospective migrant worker has to attend a final briefing (Persiapan Akhir Penempatan/PAP) held by the regional/city labor agency, where the employment agreement must be signed in the presence of the officials of the regional/city labor agency.

The duration of the employment agreement, under Article 28, may only be for a period of 2 years, but may be extended for another 2 years in the event that the conditions of Article 29 (1) are met and the employer bears the additional expenses of the migrant worker insurance, legalization at an Indonesian Embassy of the extended employment agreement, commission fee to the Placement Agency responsible sending the migrant worker and its counterpart in the placement country, and a return airplane ticket. In addition to this, the employment agreement is subject to approval by an appointed official from the Indonesian Embassy where the migrant worker is placed.

The minimum contents of the employment agreement are set out in Article 26 (1). It is further stated in Article 26 (2) that the employment agreement must be based on a draft agreement that has the approval of an Indonesian Embassy in the placement country. This additional check is required since any issues regarding migrant workers will arise in the foreign jurisdiction, and it will be the Indonesian Embassy that will have to deal with any such issues.

 

Applied Charges

As set in Article 45, the Placement Agency may charge fees to prospective migrant workers for: identification verification, health and psychological evaluation, education and training, working visa, accommodation and meals, airline tickets and airport tax, transportation during accommodation for the purpose of trainings, Placement Agency fee, and insurance.

Insurance for migrant workers mentioned in Article 45 (1) (i) is further regulated under Article 7 of the Minister of Labor and Transmigration Regulation No. Per-23/MEN/XII/2008 on Migrant Worker Insurance (Regulation 23/08), which states that the insurance coverage of migrant workers should cover the time prior to placement, time of placement, and time after placement.

The part of commission that is paid by the employer can not be charged by the Placement Agency to the prospective worker, pursuant to Article 45 (2).

Placement fees vary from one country to another, with the Minister of Labor and Transmigration due to issue further regulation setting out such fees. Under Article 47, such fees have to be stated in the placement agreement, and cannot exceed those set by the Minister.

 

Private Company

Under Article 49, state owned companies, regional government owned companies, or private companies that are not Placement Agencies may employ their own workers to work abroad for the purpose of the company business.

Grounds to employ their workers in such a way are set out in Article 50 (1), and are that: the company has a direct ownership with a company abroad, or the company has been awarded a project abroad, or as part of a business expansion plan, or to improve its human resource development.

In employing their workers, a company is obliged to acquire a permit, pursuant to Article 50 (2), where upon a complete submission the application, the Minister of Labor and Transmigration, or its appointed official, has to issue the permit within 5 working days.

 

Working Identification

Although the process to obtain a migrant worker identification card (Kartu Tenaga Kerja Luar Negeri/KTKLN) are different for migrant workers processed by placement agency, private companies, or those who find employment abroad individually. It is nonetheless necessity, pursuant to Article 38, to acquire a KTKLN, so that if anything should happen to the migrant worker abroad, the identification will provide the needed information for officials to address the problems faced by an Indonesian migrant workers.

The issuance of a KTKLN is done by the BNP2TKI. Prior to receiving a KTKLN, a prospective migrant worker being placed by a Placement Agency has, under Article 40, to submit their placement document, proof of attending a PAP, proof of insurance coverage, the employment agreement, and proof of payment for the training.

Individual applicants, pursuant to Article 52, are only required to submit proof of a visa invitation from the employer and a signed employment agreement. Excluding the PAP and insurance coverage, the lower requirements for individual applicants are due to the likely higher level of education of individual applicants, and that the employer provides insurance in the placement country. Private companies sending their workers abroad, pursuant to Article 51, are required to submit a placement agreement, and proof of insurance.

Obtaining a KTKLN, pursuant to Articles 41 (2) and 52 (2), upon complete submission of the required documents, will take no longer than 1 working day.

 

Placement

Under Article 34 a prospective migrant worker has to attend a PAP at least 2 days prior to the departure to the placement abroad. And the Placement Agency, following the placement, is obliged to monitor the migrant workers that they have sent abroad.

The monitoring, as elaborated on in Article 55, has to be carried out by the Placement Agency directly and/or with coordination with their business counterpart in the country of placement. Under Article 55 (2) the Placement Agency has to monitor the condition of the migrant workers by acquiring such details as the name and address of the employer, the suitability of the position and workplace to which the migrant workers are deployed, the fulfillment of the migrant workers’ rights, as well as the condition and any problems faced by the migrant workers.

Pursuant to Article 55 (4) the Placement Agency then has to report their findings every 6 months to the Minister of Labor and Transmigration and the Head of BNP2TKI.

 

Data and Information

Pursuant to Article 53, information on migrant workers abroad has to be provided via the internet by BNP2TKI, so that it can be accessed by public, as appropriate. The type of data that must be provided by BNP2TKI is further set out under Article 54. However, as of the date of this Indonesian Legal Digest, such information was not available on the BNP2TKI website. Where the Regulation is lacking, is that there are no articles addressing how the information is to be provided and by when BNP2TKI has to start providing the information. 

 

Post-Placement

Estimates by the Ministry of Labor and Transmigration indicate that from 2005 to 2009 there are around 3.5 million migrant workers deployed to Middle East, Asia Pacific, as well as other continents. This has made protection of migrant workers after their placement a difficult task for officials, as well as the parties receiving and processing them upon their return to Indonesia.

The return of migrant workers to Indonesia takes place through Soerkarno-Hatta International Airport, where, instead of exiting Terminal 2 (international arrivals) like other international passengers, the migrant workers are directed to the Selapajang terminal just outside Soekarno-Hatta, which is intended for the arrival of migrant workers. 

The separate terminal for migrant workers has become an item of debate in early 2010. Cases have arisen in the special terminal where the uneducated migrant workers who bring their earnings in foreign currency are taken advantage of. This has contributed to calls to discontinue the use of a separate terminal, the aim of which was initially to increase efficiency.

As mentioned in Article 75 of the Law in conjunction with Article 56 of the Regulation, the return of migrant workers is also the responsibility of Placement Agency. With Articles 56 to 59 of the Regulation being complementary to Articles 73 to 75 of the Law.

The Placement Agency, upon the return of a migrant worker from their placement abroad, is requires to carry out the tasks as set out in Article 58.

 

Sanctions

The Regulation is an implementing regulation of the Law, and as such elaborates on the Law’s provisions but does not provide criminal or explicit administrative sanctions. The only sanctions that are contained are in Article 6, which states that the SIP of a Placement Agency can be denied or annulled should they fail to resolve their past issues.

Administrative sanctions are imposed on those who violate requirements such as the SIP, as set out in Article 2, employment agreement as set out in Articles 25 and 26, PAP as set out in Article 31, and charges to migrant workers set out in Article 45, pursuant to Article 100 of the Law. The administrative sanctions may be in the form of warning letter, suspension of business activities, revocation of licenses, cancellation of migrant workers placements, and/or the recalling of migrant workers at their own expense. 

 

Conclusion

The legal framework for the protection of migrant workers working abroad is considered to be sufficient considering that domestic workers in Indonesia are currently struggling to gain recognition and protection. In Indonesia domestic workers are often denied leave, paid below minimum wage, and are not covered by any form of insurance.

The protection for migrant workers is needed during the pre-placement phase, the placement phase, and the post-placement phase. However, the bulk of the Regulation’s provisions address the pre-placement phase, since it takes place in Indonesia and consequently is easier to assure the enforcement of. This results in arguably somewhat lacking protection of migrant workers during their placement abroad. As such, it is reasonable to expect that there will be further legislation to regulate the placement phase, and post-placement phase.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info