Overview
Following the Money Laundering Bill’s introduction to the House of Representatives (“DPR”) in October 2006, the DPR has finally passed the Bill last Monday (5/10), as the Law on the Prevention and Eradication of Money Laundering (Law). The Law replaces Law No. 15 of 2002, as amended by Law No. 25 of 2003.
Although the Bill has not yet been signed by the President, it is more than likely that it will be signed and become a law within the next 30 days. However, the signatory approval by the President is merely a formality, with Article 38 of Law No. 10 of 2004 on the Formation of Laws and Regulations stating that, if not signed within 30 days, the Bill will automatically become a law regardless.
The Law grants greater powers to the Financial Transaction Reports Analysis Center (“PPATK”), the main player in preventing and eradicating money laundering. Under the Law, involvement of a wider arrays of state officials is provided for, as well as new authority for such officials to assist with their endeavors to combat and eradicate money laundering. The Law contains severe sanctions for perpetrators and aiding parties, while expanding the number of parties obliged to report suspicious transactions, as well as introducing an extraterritorial aspect.
This edition of Indonesian Legal Digest will highlight the key features of the Law and provide an analysis of the Law’s provisions.
Purpose
Based on PPATK data covering the period from its establishment in 2004 to the present, PPATK has detected 2442 suspicious transactions, with 92 percent of such being referred to the National Police (Polri) and the rest to the Attorney General’s Office (AGO). However, only 26 cases resulted in convictions (The Jakarta Globe, 06/10/2010).
Such figures provide an indication of the low effectiveness of the previous legislation in addressing money laundering in Indonesia. Consequently the Law is expected to ensure higher prosecution and conviction rates, as well as higher asset recuperation, by providing PPATK with greater powers to combat money laundering.
The Law aims to establish a legal framework that involves a wider array of officials in order to comprehensively work on preventing and eradicating money laundering. This is shown by the involvement of the Corruption Eradication Commission (“KPK”), the National Narcotics Agency (“BNN”), the Directorate General of Tax, and the Directorate General of Customs and Excise, in preventing and eradicating money laundering by means of cooperating directly with PPATK.
It should be noted that the Law is a secondary legislative mechanism designed to combat a wider spectrum of crimes, as enumerated under Article 2. The funds derived from the commission of which are legitimized by disguising them as proceeds from a legitimate business in order prevent officials from linking the funds to the criminal activity, which would result in confiscation and conviction for the predicate crime.
Stakeholders
Perpetrators and aiding parties
The Law defines money laundering perpetrators as individuals as well as corporations, and sets out the definition of the offence and the potential penalties in Articles 3, 4, 5 and 7. This is in contrast to the previous legislation, which provided ample room for argument as to whether it could actually be applied to corporations. It was even stipulated under the previous legislation, Article 4 (3) of Law No. 15 of 2002, that if a corporation was involved in money laundering due to its board’s actions on behalf of the corporation, while its articles of association did not include such activity within the scope of its business, that the corporation would not be criminally liable.
The new provisions are set out in Article 6, which requires the participation in money laundering activities to provide a benefit to the corporation and to be ordered by a person having control over the corporation. Such a revised approach indicates that the DPR is becoming more serious at targeting corporations involved in money laundering.
PPATK
Under the Law, PPATK, an institution whose main role is to prevent and eradicate money laundering, which was formed under Law No. 15 of 2002 on the Criminal Act of Money Laundering, is now provided with increased authority to carry out its functions.
This involves being able to examine and analyze a wider range of documents, as set out under Article 44, and also an ability, under Article 65 (1), to temporarily freeze accounts involved in suspicious financial transactions, something that was not possible under the previous legislation.
The ability to freeze accounts is seen as being crucial to PPATK’s effectiveness, since having to coordinate with an investigator, the prosecutor and the court to obtain an order to freeze a bank account, can often lead to a slow response that risks jeopardizing the successful recovery of the laundered funds. Pursuant to Article 71 (3), upon a request from an investigator, a prosecutor or a court, the bank is given up to 30 days to freeze an account. Consequently, the ability of PPATK to freeze accounts is a crucial part of preventing the dissipation of funds from the suspicious accounts.
Another piece of authority given to PPATK is the ability, under Article 44 (1) (h), to recommend that investigators tap communications. It should be noted that under a previous draft of the Bill, PPATK would have had the ability to intercept communications, instead of merely submitting a recommendation to investigators, this, however, did not survive the DPR’s debates. Had such authority been granted to PPATK, it could be argued that PPATK’s new role would be that of a semi-investigator.
The functions of PPATK, pursuant to Article 40, are broader than merely preventing and eradicating money laundering, and also include the management of data and information concerning suspicious transactions that are reported by financial institutions. This involves supervising financial institutions with regard to their reporting requirements, and the eventual analysis of the reports for indications of money laundering or any of the crimes listed in Article 2 (1).
Investigators and prosecutors
Investigators and prosecutors will now receive reports from PPATK, enabling them to pursue suspected money laundering, whereas, under previous legislation, Polri and the AGO were the sole recipients of PPATK reports. The change is contained in Article 74 and its elucidation, which enables other state bodies, such as the KPK, BNN, the Directorate General of Tax, and the Directorate General of Customs and Excise, who are involved in investigating and prosecuting crimes listed in Article 2, to receive the same reports as the Polri and the AGO.
During the debates on the Bill at the DPR, it was proposed that only if the analysis of a PPATK report on a suspicious transaction indicated that corruption had taken place, that the KPK would receive a copy of the report. This proposal was not accepted, with the DPR ultimately agreeing that every related investigator and prosecutor would receive the PPATK reports.
Such transparency is seen as being critically important, since in the efforts to combat money laundering the flow of information is essential to enabling the cooperation necessary to prosecute those involved in money laundering, and to achieve a higher conviction rate while successfully recovering the assets.
Reporting entities
PPATK acquires the financial data for its reports from the reporting entities, which are defined under Article 17 as financial institutions and institutions which provide products and services, as further enumerated. This is a change from the previous legislation, where a reporting entity was simply defined as a financial institution, without further elaboration. The extended definition provides PPATK with scope to supervise a wider range of entities.
This is in line with the reality of money laundering, whereas perpetrators do not always use financial institutions such as banks, investment companies, or equity firms to launder the funds. In fact, money laundering often involves the conversion of funds into physical goods such as houses, boats, gold, and other valuable items. As such, the expanded definition should provide assistance in combating the actual types of transactions involved in modern money laundering.
The “know your customer principle” is retained by the Law in Article 18, stating that for any transaction amounting to 100 million Indonesian Rupiah or more, the reporting entity is required to verify the customer and the transaction.
Reporting entities, both in the form of financial institutions and the providers of goods and services, are also required, under Articles 23 (1) (b) and 27 (1), to report any suspicious transactions, amounting to 500 million Indonesian Rupiah or more, to PPATK.
The exact procedure of the reporting is mostly is covered by Articles 23, 25, 26, and 27.
Finally, under Article 65 (1), the reporting entities have to obey any temporary freezing orders given by PPATK with regards to an account or a transaction.
Reverse burden of proof
Under previous legislation, the main problem faced in attempting to secure a conviction for money laundering was that investigators and prosecutors encountered often insurmountable difficulties in proving the predicate crime in order to meet the definition of money laundering.
Due to the vague nature of the previous legislation it was usually, and often with success, argued by the defense that the predicate crime had to be proven before the money laundering prosecution could proceed. Now the investigators and prosecutors, relying on Article 69, are given a green light to proceed with the indictments, without first having to prove the predicate crime. This change is predicted to significantly increase the number of prosecutions.
The Law goes even further in an attempt to increase the conviction rate by reversing the burden of proof under Article 77. Under which the party allegedly engaged in money laundering must prove that the assets did not originate as a result of a crime. This change has been long awaited by law enforcement, as it greatly reduces the workload of the prosecutor who previously had to meet the burden of proving that the assets derived from criminal activity.
Extraterritorial reach
Money laundering typically consists of a number of stages, in the form of: 1) placement (introduction of illicitly obtained funds into the money laundering process), 2) layering (undertaking transactions to obscure the source of the funds), and 3) integration (the return of the now seemingly legitimate funds for further use).
In the placement and layering stages, it is common to use international wire transfers, which involves setting up offshore accounts and shell companies to ensure that the transaction goes beyond a single country’s jurisdiction. Due to the nature of money laundering as a trans-border crime, and with the previous money laundering legislation being unable to provide a basis for the prosecution of money laundering committed outside of Indonesia, the Law, under Articles 2 (1) and 10, assumes jurisdiction over parties engaged in money laundering, whether conducted in Indonesia or abroad.
Such extraterritorial power is unconventional under the Indonesian criminal law, since, as provided under Article 2 of the Indonesian Criminal Code, a prosecution for a crime can only be commenced if the locus delicti of the crime occurred within Indonesia.
Sanctions
The most significant change in relation to sanctions is the imposition of sanctions on corporations who perpetrate or aid in money laundering. Article 7 imposes two types of sanctions, the first being the criminal fine with a maximum of 100 billion Indonesian Rupiah, and the administrative sanctions which can take the form of a revocation of business licenses, temporary suspension of the company’s operations, forced dissolution, and the confiscation of company assets.
Such sanctions are indicative of the political will to combat money laundering. However, it is doubtful, should the maximum fine be imposed, that a significant number of companies would be able to pay the criminal fine.
Reporting entities are bound to secrecy in reporting suspicious financial transactions, so as not to disclose to third parties or the suspected perpetrators the reporting of a suspicious transaction to PPATK. Violation of this is taken very seriously, with Article 12 (5) providing for 5 years imprisonment and a maximum criminal fine of 1 billion Indonesian Rupiah.
Reporting obligations can also not be neglected by the reporting entity, since failing to meet the requirements set out under Articles 23, 25, 26 and 27 will lead to the administrative sanctions set out in Article 30 (3). Given the new powers vested in PPATK by the Law, it is likely that there will be further regulation issued by PPATK relating to this particular supervising obligation and the associated sanctions.
Conclusion
Many of the provision in the Law grant additional powers to PPATK, to ensure its effectiveness in fulfilling its function of preventing and eradicating money laundering. It is likely that, with such new powers, PPATK will no longer be considered a toothless tiger, due to its newfound ability to temporarily freeze suspicious accounts.
Moreover, since the previous money laundering legislation did not provide legal certainty, address the reality on the ground, or reflect the international standards in fighting money laundering, the Law is a welcome revision of this particular area of law. Of particular interest is the attempt to address the reality that money laundering often crosses borders and jurisdictions, by introducing extraterritoriality into the law. This, however, is in sharp contrast with the Indonesian Criminal Code, under which a criminal provision can only apply to conduct that takes place within Indonesia.
The Law appears promising, as it introduces new principles and imposes heavier sanctions. In particular, the reverse burden of proof will bring significant changes to how money laundering cases are prosecuted, and will likely result in more work for the lawyers defending money laundering cases.
......