Supervisory and Trading System Regulation for Alternative Futures Trading Systems

Overview

The initial regulation of Alternative Trading Systems (“ATS”) by the Futures Exchange Supervisory Body (Badan Pengawas Perdagangan Berjangka Komoditi / Bappebti) took the form of Bappebti Regulation No 55/BAPPEBTI/KP/I/2005, as amended by Regulation No. 58/BAPPEBTI/Per/1/2006, on Alternative Trading Systems (‘ATS Regulation’). Under which, members of the Jakarta Futures Stock Exchange operating ATS, are supposed to have trading systems which are reliable, fair, efficient, effective, and transparent, as required by Article 3 (1) (d) of the ATS Regulation.

However, the existence of such vague requirements resulted in a wide range of approaches by different ATS operators, with such divergence evidently resulting in difficulties for Bappebti and the Jakarta Futures Exchange (“JFX”), spurring them to attempt to bring order to the ATS markets. It for this reason that Bappebti Regulation No. 79/BAPPEBTI/PER/01/2010 on A Single Supervisory System and Trading Systems of Alternative Trading Systems (“Regulation”) was issued earlier this year.

The Regulation essentially aims to develop a reliable common standard for ATSs, so that fair, efficient, effective, and transparent futures trading can take place. The Regulation was issued on 21 January 2010, with the provisions having come into force on 1 October 2010.

This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the Regulation and provide analysis of the Regulation’s provisions.

 

Purpose

Under Article 1 (1) of the Regulation, an ATS is defined as a trading system in which the purchase and sale of derivative contracts is done bilaterally with margin calls. In an ATS, buyers and sellers do not engage the JFX in their futures trades, because the transaction does not take place within the JFX futures market.

ATS are usually used for financial reasons, such as lowers costs in the form of reduced transaction fees. While the requirements to become an ATS operator, as set out under Article 3 of Bappebti Regulation No. 58/BAPPEBTI/PER/1/2006, are not difficult to meet.  Combined with the simplicity of carrying out transactions remotely using an electronic trading system, these are tempting reasons for a futures trader to utilize the services of an ATS, leading ATS operators to provide a range of ATSs to meet such demand.

The consequences of not having a unified electronic platform system regulated by Bappebti has lead ATS operators to develop their own systems. Which evidently gave Bappebti impetus to supervise the ATSs in order to address the trading systems not being well integrated with the clearing house systems. Due to a lack of documentation of the systems this resulted in a difficult task for Bappebti in attempting to control and supervise the ATSs. This situation, and the vague regulation, has resulted in some ATS operators engaging in fraudulent acts, such as irregular trading methods and miss-selling of services and products. The lack of transparency, which has allowed the withholding complete information, and the absence of risk monitoring systems, have both enabled such fraudulent acts.

It should be noted that ATS operators’ source of income consists of the fees from every transaction, as such, whether a transaction results in a financial loss or a financial gain, the ATS operator would still collect the fees from the transaction. As such, it is essential that ATS operators are transparent with respect to the transactions.       

It is for these reasons that a negative perception of ATS exists, so, to restore the image of ATS as a regulated futures market and to provide assurance for investors trading through an ATS, Bappebti issued the Regulation in order to provide guidelines to parties engaged with the operation of ATSs in developing their systems, so as to allow for an easier administration of monitoring and supervisory tasks.  

In addition to the above, regulating the supervisory system and trading systems for ATSs will allow the development of a common platform that is agreed upon by all stakeholders, this will prevent the excessive expense of developing a “single platform” to be used by parties engaged with the operation of ATSs.  

 

Operational Structure

Parties affected by the Regulation pursuant to Article 2 are, the futures exchange, futures clearing houses, futures traders, and futures brokers. The following will provide a brief description of these parties, and what their obligations are under the Regulation:

Futures clearing house, under Article 1 (7) of Law No. 32 of 1997 on Commodity Futures Trading (Law 32/1997) is defined as a legal entity which provides and administers a system and the infrastructure to perform transaction clearing and guarantees transactions on a futures exchange. Under the Regulation, a futures clearing house guarantees futures transactions on an ATS. A clearing house, under Article 3 (2) of the Regulation, is obliged to provide a Supervisory System, a common platform the functionality of which is further explained in Appendix 1 of the Regulation.

ATS operator, under Article 1 (2) of the Regulation, is defined as a member of a futures exchange whose business it is to trade derivative contracts on its own behalf on the ATS.  An ATS operator, as per Article 3 (3), is obliged to provide a Trading System that fulfills the requirements of Article 5, and which is in compatible and integrated with the Supervisory System provided by futures clearing house.

Futures broker is defined merely as a member of an ATS, and under Article 1 (3) its activities are defined as trading derivative contracts on behalf of a customer. It should be taken into account that a futures broker trading through an ATS is not allowed to enter into bilateral contracts outside of the trading system provided by an ATS operator, as per Article 3 (5).

Futures exchange as defined under Article 1 (3) of Law 32/1997, is defined as a legal entity which administers and provides a system and the infrastructure for commodity futures and futures option contracts trading. The JFX, although not having many roles in relation to ATSs, has a function, under Article 11 (1), is to ensure that every transaction on an ATS uses the ATS operator trading system, and is recorded by the Supervisory System. Making its role under the Regulation a second layer of supervision.       

 

Supervisory System

A clearing house has to provide a Supervisory System for the ATSs, as specified under Article 4 the requirements for it are as follows:

 

Requirements

Comment / Analysis

a

Has a specification standard and functions in accordance with the functionality standard as set out in Appendix 1 

 

b

Uses real time communication

To ensure the accuracy of the spread 

c

Has the ability to receive at least the following reports from the Trading Systems:

a.    Transactions

b.    Price quotes

c.    Opening balance and open positions

d.    Irregular transactions  

This is the critical requirement allowing for the integration and smooth operation of the various ATSs, from the clearing house / Supervisory System side

d

Has a Business Continuity Plan (BCP) and a Disaster Recovery Center (DRC)

In the event that the operation of the Supervisory System is disrupted, a contingency plan has to exist to assist with recovery and restoring operations.

e

Receives margin data on a daily basis

 

f

Ability to verify margin sufficiency

 

g

Is interconnected with the Trading Systems, the clearing house back office, the futures exchange system, and the Bappebti system

 

h

Has an early warning system

In case of price fluctuation leading to the likelihood of a margin call the investor should be given an advance warning 

i

Can simultaneously compare price quotes from ATS operators with the reference price providers.

 

j

Fulfill the database requirements to store data for:

1)    5 years for transaction data and financial data

2)    6 months for price quote data, after which time the data can be moved to external storage

 

 

Trading system

ATS operators are required to provide a Trading System, the requirements for which are set out under Article 5 (1), and are as follows:

 

Requirements

Comments / Analysis

a

The system has to be compatible with the Supervisory System, as well as being accurate, current, secure, reliable, online, and real-time

The compatibility requirement ensures the integration and smooth operation of the ATSs, from the ATS operator / Trading System side.

b

Fulfilling the functionality standard as set out in Appendix 2 of the Regulation

 

c

Ensure that the features and functions are compatible with the ATS

Ensuring internal compatibility, and therefore compliance with the Regulation, of the features of the Trading System

d

Able to protect and control the access to financial data of customers

 

e

Have an up to date Business Continuity Plan

 

f

Having a Disaster Recovery Center located no further than 20 km from the main server

The contingency requirements essentially require a secondary location from which the ATS can be operated

g

Having a configuration with specifications that can:

1)    Ensure communication with the Supervisory System and the real-time registration of ATS transactions

2)    Having security system that is able to handle internal and external threats

 

h

Fulfill the database requirements to store data for:

1)    5 years for transaction data and financial data

2)    6 months for price quote data, after which time the data can be moved to external storage

 

i

Having a server that is:

a.    Located in Indonesia

b.    Has a backup

c.    Supported by sufficient facilities and infrastructure

 

 

Application and approval process

Before submitting an approval to Bappebti, an ATS operator’s trading system must first be audited by an independent information system auditor approved by Bappebti. If the audit finds the trading system to be incompatible with the Supervisory System or not in compliance with the requirements of Article 5, the ATS operator is obliged to make adjustments no later than 3 months from the issuance of the auditor’s findings.    

Both, the Supervisory System (by the clearing house) and the Trading System (by an ATS operator), must first obtain approval from Bappebti, by submitting the supporting documents, as set out in Articles 7 and 8:

1.

Audit report of the system

2.

Business continuity plan, and

3.

Complete list of the facilities and infrastructure for the system.      

 

The approval process, following the submission of the required documentation involves Bappebti appointed officials inspecting the physical facilities and infrastructure of the Supervisory System and the Trading System. After which, Bappebti issues a decision on whether to give an approval or a rejection to the operation of the systems, within no longer than 45 working days, as required by Article 9.      

The regulation does not provide for an appeal process following a rejection. However, theoretically, the Head of Bappebti, in issuing a rejection, acts as a state administrative officer, nonetheless, due to the nature Regulation and the industry, filling a complaint to the State Administrative Court is unlikely to be a fruitful appeal path.   

 

Obligations in operating the systems

To ensure the proper use of the Supervisory System, the clearing house is obliged to monitor the use of the system, which involves administering user id’s, passwords, and granting access rights to use the Supervisory System, as well as providing training for the users of the Supervisory System.

The guidelines for operating the Supervisory System are also essentially set out under Article 10. The most important being the monitoring of the interconnection between the Trading Systems and the Supervisory System. It is for this reason that a common platform, namely the Supervisory System is developed and regulated.  

Trading System use by ATS customers forms the final price of the regulatory framework, since trading outside the Trading System would mean a violation of Article 13 (a). Besides providing the use the Trading System, ATS operators, under Article 12, have to provide price quotations based on a reliable source of data, which, along with any calculation formula used, have to be reported to the clearing house (for the purposes of the Supervisory System).     

And to ensure transparency, the ATS operator has to report every ATS transaction to the JFX, and register it with a clearing house. 

 

Obligations with benefits

Although not a party who is directly involved with the ATSs, JFX under Article 11 has the obligation to monitor ATS trades and make sure that ATS customers transact using the Trading System, so that transaction are recorded in the Supervisory System. In doing so the futures exchange has to monitor spread prices, ATS transactions during trade hours, price quotations and the data source.

Realizing these obligations, JFX coordinates such task with the Director of Futures Brokers Compliance. It should be noted that under the Regulation JFX is given the authority to gather information from ATS customers by acquiring trade activity reports.

It is notable that ATSs do not use the JFX to facilitate trading, however, under the Regulation obligations are imposed on the JFX as the main market of futures trading. These obligations are balanced with a benefit for the JFX, whereas under Article 14 the JFX is entitled to receive profit sharing on ATS trades from the clearing house. However, it is not specified how profits are to be shared under the JFX - clearing house agreement, leaving room for conflicts to occur between JFX and the clearing house.     

 

Further examination

Provided under Article 6, upon an approval of the systems by Bappebti, a further examination can be conducted by Bappebti or a Bappebti appointed party. Such further examination is another supervisory function that serves to ensure the continuing system compatibility and compliance with the Article 4 and 5 requirements. In exercising this right Bappebti would have a choice of examining the systems periodically or on an ad-hoc basis.     

 

Sanctions

Sanctions are not set out under the Regulation, which instead refers to the parent legislation, in the form of Law 32/1997 and its implementing regulations. Whereas, Articles 69 through 76 of Law 32/1997 provide for administrative as well as criminal sanctions.  

 

Conclusion

The Regulation is a start in ensuring some much needed consistency in the sphere of ATS for customers as well as operators, because if every member was to follow a different approach, incompatibility would arise, resulting in the ATSs operators undergoing an unguided compliance approval process with Bappeti, JFX, an the clearing house for their trading systems. Having a common approach bring benefit and allows costs to be reduced, while ensuring adequate monitoring and consistent reporting.

Moreover the Regulation goes some ways towards addressing the transparency and supervisory issues which have previously been the biggest obstacle to Bappebti monitoring. 

However, the Regulation fails to provide some specific requirements that are alluded to. For instance, the process of appointing an independent auditor is left unaddressed (Article 5 (3)), as are the specifics of the profit sharing between the JFX and a clearing house (Article 14).

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

The initial regulation of Alternative Trading Systems (“ATS”) by the Futures Exchange Supervisory Body (Badan Pengawas Perdagangan Berjangka Komoditi / Bappebti) took the form of Bappebti Regulation No 55/BAPPEBTI/KP/I/2005, as amended by Regulation No. 58/BAPPEBTI/Per/1/2006, on Alternative Trading Systems (‘ATS Regulation’). Under which, members of the Jakarta Futures Stock Exchange operating ATS, are supposed to have trading systems which are reliable, fair, efficient, effective, and transparent, as required by Article 3 (1) (d) of the ATS Regulation.

However, the existence of such vague requirements resulted in a wide range of approaches by different ATS operators, with such divergence evidently resulting in difficulties for Bappebti and the Jakarta Futures Exchange (“JFX”), spurring them to attempt to bring order to the ATS markets. It for this reason that Bappebti Regulation No. 79/BAPPEBTI/PER/01/2010 on A Single Supervisory System and Trading Systems of Alternative Trading Systems (“Regulation”) was issued earlier this year.

The Regulation essentially aims to develop a reliable common standard for ATSs, so that fair, efficient, effective, and transparent futures trading can take place. The Regulation was issued on 21 January 2010, with the provisions having come into force on 1 October 2010.

This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the Regulation and provide analysis of the Regulation’s provisions.

 

Purpose

Under Article 1 (1) of the Regulation, an ATS is defined as a trading system in which the purchase and sale of derivative contracts is done bilaterally with margin calls. In an ATS, buyers and sellers do not engage the JFX in their futures trades, because the transaction does not take place within the JFX futures market.

ATS are usually used for financial reasons, such as lowers costs in the form of reduced transaction fees. While the requirements to become an ATS operator, as set out under Article 3 of Bappebti Regulation No. 58/BAPPEBTI/PER/1/2006, are not difficult to meet.  Combined with the simplicity of carrying out transactions remotely using an electronic trading system, these are tempting reasons for a futures trader to utilize the services of an ATS, leading ATS operators to provide a range of ATSs to meet such demand.

The consequences of not having a unified electronic platform system regulated by Bappebti has lead ATS operators to develop their own systems. Which evidently gave Bappebti impetus to supervise the ATSs in order to address the trading systems not being well integrated with the clearing house systems. Due to a lack of documentation of the systems this resulted in a difficult task for Bappebti in attempting to control and supervise the ATSs. This situation, and the vague regulation, has resulted in some ATS operators engaging in fraudulent acts, such as irregular trading methods and miss-selling of services and products. The lack of transparency, which has allowed the withholding complete information, and the absence of risk monitoring systems, have both enabled such fraudulent acts.

It should be noted that ATS operators’ source of income consists of the fees from every transaction, as such, whether a transaction results in a financial loss or a financial gain, the ATS operator would still collect the fees from the transaction. As such, it is essential that ATS operators are transparent with respect to the transactions.       

It is for these reasons that a negative perception of ATS exists, so, to restore the image of ATS as a regulated futures market and to provide assurance for investors trading through an ATS, Bappebti issued the Regulation in order to provide guidelines to parties engaged with the operation of ATSs in developing their systems, so as to allow for an easier administration of monitoring and supervisory tasks.  

In addition to the above, regulating the supervisory system and trading systems for ATSs will allow the development of a common platform that is agreed upon by all stakeholders, this will prevent the excessive expense of developing a “single platform” to be used by parties engaged with the operation of ATSs.  

 

Operational Structure

Parties affected by the Regulation pursuant to Article 2 are, the futures exchange, futures clearing houses, futures traders, and futures brokers. The following will provide a brief description of these parties, and what their obligations are under the Regulation:

Futures clearing house, under Article 1 (7) of Law No. 32 of 1997 on Commodity Futures Trading (Law 32/1997) is defined as a legal entity which provides and administers a system and the infrastructure to perform transaction clearing and guarantees transactions on a futures exchange. Under the Regulation, a futures clearing house guarantees futures transactions on an ATS. A clearing house, under Article 3 (2) of the Regulation, is obliged to provide a Supervisory System, a common platform the functionality of which is further explained in Appendix 1 of the Regulation.

ATS operator, under Article 1 (2) of the Regulation, is defined as a member of a futures exchange whose business it is to trade derivative contracts on its own behalf on the ATS.  An ATS operator, as per Article 3 (3), is obliged to provide a Trading System that fulfills the requirements of Article 5, and which is in compatible and integrated with the Supervisory System provided by futures clearing house.

Futures broker is defined merely as a member of an ATS, and under Article 1 (3) its activities are defined as trading derivative contracts on behalf of a customer. It should be taken into account that a futures broker trading through an ATS is not allowed to enter into bilateral contracts outside of the trading system provided by an ATS operator, as per Article 3 (5).

Futures exchange as defined under Article 1 (3) of Law 32/1997, is defined as a legal entity which administers and provides a system and the infrastructure for commodity futures and futures option contracts trading. The JFX, although not having many roles in relation to ATSs, has a function, under Article 11 (1), is to ensure that every transaction on an ATS uses the ATS operator trading system, and is recorded by the Supervisory System. Making its role under the Regulation a second layer of supervision.       

 

Supervisory System

A clearing house has to provide a Supervisory System for the ATSs, as specified under Article 4 the requirements for it are as follows:

 

Requirements

Comment / Analysis

a

Has a specification standard and functions in accordance with the functionality standard as set out in Appendix 1 

 

b

Uses real time communication

To ensure the accuracy of the spread 

c

Has the ability to receive at least the following reports from the Trading Systems:

a.    Transactions

b.    Price quotes

c.    Opening balance and open positions

d.    Irregular transactions  

This is the critical requirement allowing for the integration and smooth operation of the various ATSs, from the clearing house / Supervisory System side

d

Has a Business Continuity Plan (BCP) and a Disaster Recovery Center (DRC)

In the event that the operation of the Supervisory System is disrupted, a contingency plan has to exist to assist with recovery and restoring operations.

e

Receives margin data on a daily basis

 

f

Ability to verify margin sufficiency

 

g

Is interconnected with the Trading Systems, the clearing house back office, the futures exchange system, and the Bappebti system

 

h

Has an early warning system

In case of price fluctuation leading to the likelihood of a margin call the investor should be given an advance warning 

i

Can simultaneously compare price quotes from ATS operators with the reference price providers.

 

j

Fulfill the database requirements to store data for:

1)    5 years for transaction data and financial data

2)    6 months for price quote data, after which time the data can be moved to external storage

 

 

Trading system

ATS operators are required to provide a Trading System, the requirements for which are set out under Article 5 (1), and are as follows:

 

Requirements

Comments / Analysis

a

The system has to be compatible with the Supervisory System, as well as being accurate, current, secure, reliable, online, and real-time

The compatibility requirement ensures the integration and smooth operation of the ATSs, from the ATS operator / Trading System side.

b

Fulfilling the functionality standard as set out in Appendix 2 of the Regulation

 

c

Ensure that the features and functions are compatible with the ATS

Ensuring internal compatibility, and therefore compliance with the Regulation, of the features of the Trading System

d

Able to protect and control the access to financial data of customers

 

e

Have an up to date Business Continuity Plan

 

f

Having a Disaster Recovery Center located no further than 20 km from the main server

The contingency requirements essentially require a secondary location from which the ATS can be operated

g

Having a configuration with specifications that can:

1)    Ensure communication with the Supervisory System and the real-time registration of ATS transactions

2)    Having security system that is able to handle internal and external threats

 

h

Fulfill the database requirements to store data for:

1)    5 years for transaction data and financial data

2)    6 months for price quote data, after which time the data can be moved to external storage

 

i

Having a server that is:

a.    Located in Indonesia

b.    Has a backup

c.    Supported by sufficient facilities and infrastructure

 

 

Application and approval process

Before submitting an approval to Bappebti, an ATS operator’s trading system must first be audited by an independent information system auditor approved by Bappebti. If the audit finds the trading system to be incompatible with the Supervisory System or not in compliance with the requirements of Article 5, the ATS operator is obliged to make adjustments no later than 3 months from the issuance of the auditor’s findings.    

Both, the Supervisory System (by the clearing house) and the Trading System (by an ATS operator), must first obtain approval from Bappebti, by submitting the supporting documents, as set out in Articles 7 and 8:

1.

Audit report of the system

2.

Business continuity plan, and

3.

Complete list of the facilities and infrastructure for the system.      

 

The approval process, following the submission of the required documentation involves Bappebti appointed officials inspecting the physical facilities and infrastructure of the Supervisory System and the Trading System. After which, Bappebti issues a decision on whether to give an approval or a rejection to the operation of the systems, within no longer than 45 working days, as required by Article 9.      

The regulation does not provide for an appeal process following a rejection. However, theoretically, the Head of Bappebti, in issuing a rejection, acts as a state administrative officer, nonetheless, due to the nature Regulation and the industry, filling a complaint to the State Administrative Court is unlikely to be a fruitful appeal path.   

 

Obligations in operating the systems

To ensure the proper use of the Supervisory System, the clearing house is obliged to monitor the use of the system, which involves administering user id’s, passwords, and granting access rights to use the Supervisory System, as well as providing training for the users of the Supervisory System.

The guidelines for operating the Supervisory System are also essentially set out under Article 10. The most important being the monitoring of the interconnection between the Trading Systems and the Supervisory System. It is for this reason that a common platform, namely the Supervisory System is developed and regulated.  

Trading System use by ATS customers forms the final price of the regulatory framework, since trading outside the Trading System would mean a violation of Article 13 (a). Besides providing the use the Trading System, ATS operators, under Article 12, have to provide price quotations based on a reliable source of data, which, along with any calculation formula used, have to be reported to the clearing house (for the purposes of the Supervisory System).     

And to ensure transparency, the ATS operator has to report every ATS transaction to the JFX, and register it with a clearing house. 

 

Obligations with benefits

Although not a party who is directly involved with the ATSs, JFX under Article 11 has the obligation to monitor ATS trades and make sure that ATS customers transact using the Trading System, so that transaction are recorded in the Supervisory System. In doing so the futures exchange has to monitor spread prices, ATS transactions during trade hours, price quotations and the data source.

Realizing these obligations, JFX coordinates such task with the Director of Futures Brokers Compliance. It should be noted that under the Regulation JFX is given the authority to gather information from ATS customers by acquiring trade activity reports.

It is notable that ATSs do not use the JFX to facilitate trading, however, under the Regulation obligations are imposed on the JFX as the main market of futures trading. These obligations are balanced with a benefit for the JFX, whereas under Article 14 the JFX is entitled to receive profit sharing on ATS trades from the clearing house. However, it is not specified how profits are to be shared under the JFX - clearing house agreement, leaving room for conflicts to occur between JFX and the clearing house.     

 

Further examination

Provided under Article 6, upon an approval of the systems by Bappebti, a further examination can be conducted by Bappebti or a Bappebti appointed party. Such further examination is another supervisory function that serves to ensure the continuing system compatibility and compliance with the Article 4 and 5 requirements. In exercising this right Bappebti would have a choice of examining the systems periodically or on an ad-hoc basis.     

 

Sanctions

Sanctions are not set out under the Regulation, which instead refers to the parent legislation, in the form of Law 32/1997 and its implementing regulations. Whereas, Articles 69 through 76 of Law 32/1997 provide for administrative as well as criminal sanctions.  

 

Conclusion

The Regulation is a start in ensuring some much needed consistency in the sphere of ATS for customers as well as operators, because if every member was to follow a different approach, incompatibility would arise, resulting in the ATSs operators undergoing an unguided compliance approval process with Bappeti, JFX, an the clearing house for their trading systems. Having a common approach bring benefit and allows costs to be reduced, while ensuring adequate monitoring and consistent reporting.

Moreover the Regulation goes some ways towards addressing the transparency and supervisory issues which have previously been the biggest obstacle to Bappebti monitoring. 

However, the Regulation fails to provide some specific requirements that are alluded to. For instance, the process of appointing an independent auditor is left unaddressed (Article 5 (3)), as are the specifics of the profit sharing between the JFX and a clearing house (Article 14).

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info