Overview
The Director General of Mineral, Coal, and Geothermal at the Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources (“Director General”) recently issued Director General of Mineral, Coal, and Geothermal Regulation No. 376.K/30/DJB/2010 on the Procedures and Requirements for the Approval of Applications for the Participation of Subsidiaries and / or Affiliates in the Mining Service Business (“Regulation”). The Regulation has been in force since 10 May 2010.
The Regulation basically provides guidelines on the procedures and requirements for Mining Business License (IUP) and Special Mining Business License (IUPK) (mining license) holders to request approval from the Director General of Mineral, Coal, and Geothermal at the Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources to employ the services of their affiliates and subsidiaries in carrying out the mining license holders’ mining business activities.
This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the Regulation and provide analysis of the Regulation’s provisions.
Purpose
The Regulation was issued to clarify the restriction on mining license holders appointing affiliated mining service companies, whereas under its parent regulation, Articles 8 and 9 of Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources Regulation No. 28 of 2009 (“Regulation 28/2009”), such appointment could only be done following approval from the Director General.
Under the philosophy of the Regulation’s broader parent legislation, Law No. 4 of 2009 on Mineral and Coal Mining, the mining industry is expected to create a multiplier effect in the Indonesian economy, by means of engaging local mining companies in the industry. The concern being that if appointment of affiliated companies is not regulated, that local companies will be faced with significant barriers to entering the industry and obtaining projects, due to the special relationships between the holders of mining licenses and their subsidiaries. As such, the Regulation aims to prevent unfair competition in the mining services industry.
However, the mining service business often faces difficulty in finding mining service businesses in many regions of Indonesia that have the proper technology, facilities, a qualified workforce, and sufficient funds to support their core business. Therefore the above-described philosophy can not be implemented in a rigid manner, as it will disrupt the operations of the mining industry.
Definitions
A mining service business is defined in Article 4 of Regulation 28/2009, and includes both enterprises with mining services as their core business and those with mining services not as their core business. With further elaboration on the definition being contained in Appendix I of Regulation 28/2009.
An affiliated company of a mining license holder is defined under Article 1, as an affiliate or a subsidiary company in which the mining license holder:
|
a)
|
is a direct shareholder and owns at least 20% of the shares;
|
|
b)
|
is a direct shareholder and holds more than 50% of the voting rights, based on an agreement to directly control the financial policy and operations; or
|
|
c)
|
has the authority to appoint and dismiss the financial director and operational director or its equivalent.
|
Eligibility to Apply
Under Articles 3 (1) and (2), the mining license holder is only permitted to request the appointment of an affiliated company in the event that, after holding a tender, which must be announced 2 times within the span of 10 calendar days in a local and/or national newspaper. It is found that in the locality of the mining area (Wilayah Pertambangan / WP), no mining service company meets the specified requirements. Or in the event that such a mining company exists, the bidder fails to meet the criteria of working capital; sufficient investment; and a qualified workforce.
If the above requirement is met, the mining license holder can request permission from the Director General to appoint an affiliated mining service company.
Minimum requirements for bidders in service/goods procurement
Article 3 (1) (b) is quite vague, as it only states that not having sufficient working capital, sufficient investment, or a qualified workforce is a basis for disqualification. The intention being that these requirements are to be determined by the mining license holder. Nonetheless, Article 6 (2) states that the minimum working capital for an affiliated company is three months worth of operating costs. This would also appear to be the benchmark for a local bidder, following the reasoning of Article 3 (5) (d), which requires the tender requirements to match those faces by the affiliated company.
As for sufficient investment, Article 14 of Regulation 28/2009 only classifies companies into small mining companies with a net worth below IDR 5 billion, and large mining companies with a net worth above IDR 5 billion. Thus, the mining license holder retains substantial authority in determining supplementary requirements during the tender.
Application Process
The request letter should be submitted to the Director General, with the required elements of the request letter being set out under Article 3 (4). Including the identification of the applicant; reasons for the appointment of an affiliated mining company; identification of the affiliated mining service company; the types and volume of work; the value of the contract; the expected time of completion; and the payment terms.
The letter of request also has to be accompanied by the following supporting documents:
|
1.
|
A mining license (Ijin Usaha Jasa Pertambangan / IUJP) if the affiliated company’s core business is mining, or a registration certificate (Surat Keterangan Terdaftar / SKT) if not.
|
|
2.
|
Tender evaluation documentation from the pre-qualification and post-qualification stages, showing that the bidders do not meet with the mining license holder’s requirements.
|
|
3.
|
A letter guaranteeing that a profit transfer will not occur as a result of the relationship between the mining license holder and the affiliated company, which is signed by the President Director of the mining license holder.
|
|
4.
|
A letter guaranteeing that the administrative and technical requirements for the appointed affiliated company are the same as during the tender.
|
Upon the submission of the completed request letter and the supporting documents, the Director General will issue an approval or a rejection letter within 5 working days. However, the Regulation does not say whether an appeal path is available, or what procedure should be followed in the event that no decision is rendered within the deadline.
In issuing a rejection letter, the Director General acts as an administrative officer of the state, and in the event that the rejection letter meets the criteria of being individual, concrete, and final, the mining license holder may have an appeal path to the State Administrative Court.
Additional legal measures
The most significant supporting documents that must be provided by mining license holder is the letter guaranteeing that no transfer of profit will take place, this indeed, determines the success of a request. This requirement is set out under Article 3 (5) (c).
Based on OECD data, over 60% of global trade occurs between affiliated companies, due to this fact the Indonesian government has taken this legal measure to ensure that taxes are fully paid by mining operations.
No Favoritism
As provided under Article 4 the affiliated company must comply with the mining license requirements in providing mining working equipment.
Although having a special relationship with the mining license holder, in the event that is has insufficient equipment, it cannot merely borrow items from the mining license holder for free. An equipment rental agreement that fulfills requirements under Indonesian law is needed, and which minimally should contain the types of equipment being rented, its quantity, payment terms and the duration of the agreement.
Workforce qualifications for the affiliated company are determined by the mining license holder, the Regulation does not provide any guidance on this matter, and it is determined entirely by the mining license holder. However, the mining license holder is bound by the prevailing labor regulations applicable to the mining industry.
Local Delegation Obligation
Affiliated companies are obliged to delegate part of their work to a local company under Article 7, with the contracts governing such delegation having to be submitted to the Minister of Energy and Natural Resources. Notably, the Regulation does not set out the minimum of work that has to be delegated. However, failing to comply with this requirement can lead to the contract between the mining license holder and the affiliated company being annulled, creating substantial uncertainty, even when the affiliated company acts in good faith.
Sanctions
Contracts entered into by a mining license holder and an affiliated company are subject to annulment under Article 9, in the event that the Regulation’s provisions (such as obtaining permission under Article 3 (6), or complying with the local delegation requirement under Article 7) are not followed.
Conclusion
Appointing an affiliated mining service company is strictly prohibited, without first obtaining an approval from the Director General of Mineral, Coal, and Geothermal at the Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources.
Although many mining license holders may prefer to appoint an affiliated company to carry out the required mining service businesses, however, in order to have this option they must first prioritize the appointment of local mining business. Basically the Regulation provides a guide to mining license holders in employing their subsidiaries and affiliates to perform mining service business. However, gaps still exist in the Regulation, leaving such questions as: what are the minimum requirements in delegating part of the work being contracted out to the affiliated company to local mining companies?
......