New IPTV Regulation: an Update to the Regulatory Regime in Order to Keep Pace with Future Developments

Overview

Due to the perceived shortcomings of the existing regulation on Internet Protocol Television (IPTV) to accommodate current technological development and provide a roadmap for the future, the Minister of Communication and Information Technology (“Minister”) has released Minister of Communication and Information Technology Regulation No. 11/PER/M.KOMINFO/07/2010 (“Regulation”).

 

The Regulation, pursuant to Article 36, repeals and replaces the previous regulation on the same subject matter, namely Ministerial Regulation No. 30/PER/M.KOMINFO/8/2009. Coming into force on 30 July 2010, under Article 37.

 

IPTV is a technology that distributes radio and television broadcasts, video, audio, text, graphics, and data over Internet Protocol (IP) networks, while enabling a user experience that is more customized and interactive than traditional television services. In other words, IPTV is a system through which internet television services are delivered.

 

This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the Regulation and provide analysis of the Regulation’s provisions.

 

Purpose

According to Gatot Dewa Broto, the Head of the Information Centre and Public Relations Bureau of the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology:

 

“Compared to the previous one, the new regulation focuses more on the long-term; providing more possibilities and most importantly avoiding the impression that the regulation only benefits certain operators.”

 

As such, the Regulation is a sort of a finalization of the previous regulation, which was seen as something of trial piece of legislation. And therefore purports to set out a longer-term view of the regulation of IPTV services.

 

The broader purposes of the Regulation, such as simulating the growth of related domestic industries and encouraging infrastructure development, are set out in Article 2.

 

Applicability

The Regulation’s casts a relatively wide net in terms of the services falling within the IPTV definition, thereby purporting to regulate a broad spectrum of IP communication activities.

 

Article 1 (1) defines IPTV as radio, television, video, audio, text, graphic, and data services, including interactive services, delivered via an IP network. Further, Article 8 defines IPTV providers as those who provide broadcast (push), multimedia (pull/interactive), electronic transaction, and internet access services. However, under the Article 1 definitions, the Regulation only applies to those providers who are engaged in the provision and the delivery of IPTV content, and does not include internet service providers who merely provide a communication channel.

 

General Obligations

As is often typical with such regulations, Article 3 sets out a range of general obligations that IPTV service providers have to comply with. These include such ill-defined things as promoting national culture and maintaining a balance between technological development and social sensitivity, which can lead to uncertainty and create an opportunity for abuse.

 

Another set of general, this time technical, obligations in contained in Article 4, which requires cabled connections to be used for backbone and backhaul networks.

 

Administrative Pre-Requisites

Article 5 (1) of the Regulation requires IPTV service providers to be in the form of a consortium, established pursuant to a cooperation agreement under Article 6, consisting of two or more Indonesian legal entities who hold permits for: local fixed networks, internet access providers, and cable broadcasting. Furthermore, Article 5 (2) (e) prevents local fixed network and cable broadcasting consortium members to hold membership in more than one consortium. However, the consortium can also have members who do not hold any of the above permits, as long as the two permit holding members’ requirement is satisfied.

 

Under Article 5 (2) (f), the consortium has to appoint one of the members to serve as its Chairperson, with such an appointee having to hold at least one of the above-mentioned permits under Article 5 (2) (g).

 

Article 7 states that foreign ownership is possible, as long as long as it complies with laws and regulations on capital investment (such as Negative Investment List, Presidential Decree No. 36 of 2010 on Lists of Business Fields that are Closed to Investment and Business Fields that are Conditionally Open to Investment).

 

Licensing Requirements

In addition to the licenses that have to be held by certain consortium members under Article 5, the consortium itself, as the IPTV service provider, has to apply for the following licenses in accordance with Article 9:

•

Subscription-Based Television Service License for broadcast (push) services;

•

License from the relevant institution (to be created by the Minister pursuant to Article 10) for multimedia (pull/interactive) and electronic transaction services;

•

Internet Service Provider License for internet access services.

 

Licensing Procedure

The licensing application requirements are set out in Article 26, which also includes an extensive list of information and documents that have to be submitted along with the application. These range from such broad things as the ‘vision and mission’ of the IPTV service provider to the more specific, such as the Articles of Incorporation and the technical specifications of the operation.

 

Once completed, the application has to be submitted to the Minister, in three copies, as required by Article 27 (1). Whereupon, under Articles 27 (2) and (3), it will undergo an evaluation by a team that will be established by the Minister.

 

The timeline of the evaluation process is set out under Article 28, and is as follows:

i)

Administrative evaluation will be conducted within 15 working days (Article 28 (2));

ii)

In-principle approval or rejection will be issued within a further 30 working days (Article 28 (3));

iii)

In the event of rejection, the applicant will have 30 working days to make any amendments (Article 28 (4));

iv)

Technical evaluation will be carried out within 15 working days of the administrative approval being received (Article 28 (5));

v)

In the event of rejection, the applicant will have 30 working days to make any necessary modifications to the network (Article 28 (6));

vi)

The team will then have 15 working days to complete the administrative and technical evaluation report (Article 28 (8)), and a further 10 working days to deliver the report to the Minister (Article 28 (9)).

 

If both the administrative and the technical evaluations produce a positive result, the Minister, pursuant to Article 29, will issue an approval letter (Surat Persetujuan Layanan IPTV), within 15 working days of receiving the report. Under Article 31 (1), the approval letter is given to the Chairperson of the consortium, however, under Article 31 (2), it is binding on all of the consortium’s members.

 

Once issued, the approval letter is valid for a period of 10 years, pursuant to Article 30 (1), with renewal having to be applied for at least 3 month prior to expiry, pursuant to Article 30 (2).

 

An ‘inspection’ will then be conducted every 5 years, according to Article 32 (1), by a specific team that is established under Article 32 (2).

 

The overall licensing process also provides for public input on IPTV implementation, which can be submitted to the Minister, as per Article 33.

 

Once the approval letter is issued, the IPTV service area cannot exceed the specified license area, according to Article 16 (1), however an expansion of the license area can be obtained pursuant to Article 16 (2).

 

Service Requirements

Broad service level requirements are set out in Article 11, calling for the IPTV providers to ensure sufficient infrastructure capacity to support the customers, and that the infrastructure complies with all relevant regulations. Additionally, under Article 12, network capacity has to be provided for independent content providers, who, consequently, have to be considered when estimating the necessary network capacity.

 

Software system requirements are set out in Article 13 (1), and include back-end (which under Article 13 (1) has to be located in Indonesia), transactions, security, monitoring, complaints, and billing systems.

 

IPTV Set-Top-Boxes have to be supplied by the IPTV providers under Article 14 (1), with domestically produced components making up at least 20%, and rising to 50% within five years, under Article 14 (2). Furthermore, the set-top-boxes will have to comply with further ministerial regulation, which will be issued at a later date, under Article 14 (3).

 

Technical requirements are set out in Article 15, and range from the broad, and undefined, ‘international technical standards,’ to the more specific. For instance, pursuant to Article 15 (4), the IPTV providers have to migrate to IPv6 within two years of the Regulation being passed (making the deadline 30 July 2012).

 

More general requirements are contained in Article 17, dealing with service quality issues related to the network, reception, responsiveness, and customer care, all of which will be set out in further ministerial regulation that is to be issued at a later date.

 

Content

Domestic content requirements are set out in Article 18, with at least 10% of broadcast (push) content having to be domestically produced, pursuant to Article 18 (1), and at least 30% of the multimedia library, pursuant to Article 18 (2).

 

Independent content provider requirements are contained in Article 18 (3), with a requirement of at least 10% of the content initially, rising to at least 50% within five years. With IPTV providers having to grant access to independent content providers under Article 19 (1). And further elaboration on dealing with independent content providers under Article 20.

 

The provision of the content itself is regulated under Articles 19 (2) and (3), which specify that services have to be organized into packages and sub-packages.

 

Finally, public service announcements and natural disaster warnings have to be broadcast by the IPTV service providers under Article 25.

 

Security and Protection

An obligation to protect the IP network, in accordance with the relevant legislative provisions exists under Article 21.

 

The security of the provider-customer data channel is addressed in Article 22.

 

While an obligation to ensure that intellectual property rights of the content being distributed are respected in set out in Article 23.

 

And the protection of customers is addressed in Article 24.

 

Sanctions

Events giving rise to administrative sanctions are set out in Article 34 (1), and cover the violation of:

Article 3 - the general obligations provision

Article 9 - the license requirement

Article 14 (1) - the requirement to provide set-top-boxes

Article 14 (3) - the requirement for such set-top-boxes to comply with the technical requirements set out by further ministerial regulation

Article 15 (1) - the ‘international standards’ requirement

Article 21 - the requirement to safeguard the IP network

Article 22 (1) - the requirement to safeguard the services offered to customers

Article 23 - the requirement to protect intellectual property rights

Article 24 (e) - the requirement to allow customers to submit complaints interactively

Article 25 - the requirement to broadcast public service announcements and natural disaster warnings

 

The sanctions themselves are set out in Article 34 (3), and consist of:

a.

written warnings;

b.

temporary suspension of IPTV services;

c.

refusing to extend the validity of the approval letter; and/or

d.

revocation of the approval letter.

 

With the imposition of the administrative sanctions not absolving the IPTV provider from further criminal liability, pursuant to Article 34 (3).

 

The progression, and timeline, of the sanctions is set out in Article 35, and is as follows:

i)

First written warning under Article 35 (1);

ii)

Second written warning, issued within 7 working days, in the event that the first written warning is ignored, under Article 35 (2);

iii)

Third written warning and a temporary suspension of IPTV services, within 7 working days, if the second written warning is ignored, under Article 35 (3);

iv)

Finally, a refusal to extend the validity or the revocation of the approval letter, within 7 working days of the third written warning being ignored, pursuant to Article 35 (4).

 

Conclusion

The Regulation sets out a more comprehensive, and more long-term oriented, view of the regulatory framework applicable to IPTV service providers. In doing so, it sets out such administrative pre-requisites as the formation of a consortium, which is then able to provide IPTV services, the license requirements, and the licensing procedure. Then, for IPTV service providers who obtain the necessary license, the Regulation addresses the service and content requirements, as well as the security and intellectual property rights protection obligations. Finally, the Regulation contains a reasonably comprehensive administrative sanction regime, and corresponding timeline of sanction escalation.

 

However, several aspects of IPTV service provision are left for later, more specific, ministerial regulations, implying that the still changing landscape of IPTV services does not, as of yet, have a definitive legislative framework, and is therefore almost certain to see further regulations governing the operation of IPTV services.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

Due to the perceived shortcomings of the existing regulation on Internet Protocol Television (IPTV) to accommodate current technological development and provide a roadmap for the future, the Minister of Communication and Information Technology (“Minister”) has released Minister of Communication and Information Technology Regulation No. 11/PER/M.KOMINFO/07/2010 (“Regulation”).

 

The Regulation, pursuant to Article 36, repeals and replaces the previous regulation on the same subject matter, namely Ministerial Regulation No. 30/PER/M.KOMINFO/8/2009. Coming into force on 30 July 2010, under Article 37.

 

IPTV is a technology that distributes radio and television broadcasts, video, audio, text, graphics, and data over Internet Protocol (IP) networks, while enabling a user experience that is more customized and interactive than traditional television services. In other words, IPTV is a system through which internet television services are delivered.

 

This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the Regulation and provide analysis of the Regulation’s provisions.

 

Purpose

According to Gatot Dewa Broto, the Head of the Information Centre and Public Relations Bureau of the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology:

 

“Compared to the previous one, the new regulation focuses more on the long-term; providing more possibilities and most importantly avoiding the impression that the regulation only benefits certain operators.”

 

As such, the Regulation is a sort of a finalization of the previous regulation, which was seen as something of trial piece of legislation. And therefore purports to set out a longer-term view of the regulation of IPTV services.

 

The broader purposes of the Regulation, such as simulating the growth of related domestic industries and encouraging infrastructure development, are set out in Article 2.

 

Applicability

The Regulation’s casts a relatively wide net in terms of the services falling within the IPTV definition, thereby purporting to regulate a broad spectrum of IP communication activities.

 

Article 1 (1) defines IPTV as radio, television, video, audio, text, graphic, and data services, including interactive services, delivered via an IP network. Further, Article 8 defines IPTV providers as those who provide broadcast (push), multimedia (pull/interactive), electronic transaction, and internet access services. However, under the Article 1 definitions, the Regulation only applies to those providers who are engaged in the provision and the delivery of IPTV content, and does not include internet service providers who merely provide a communication channel.

 

General Obligations

As is often typical with such regulations, Article 3 sets out a range of general obligations that IPTV service providers have to comply with. These include such ill-defined things as promoting national culture and maintaining a balance between technological development and social sensitivity, which can lead to uncertainty and create an opportunity for abuse.

 

Another set of general, this time technical, obligations in contained in Article 4, which requires cabled connections to be used for backbone and backhaul networks.

 

Administrative Pre-Requisites

Article 5 (1) of the Regulation requires IPTV service providers to be in the form of a consortium, established pursuant to a cooperation agreement under Article 6, consisting of two or more Indonesian legal entities who hold permits for: local fixed networks, internet access providers, and cable broadcasting. Furthermore, Article 5 (2) (e) prevents local fixed network and cable broadcasting consortium members to hold membership in more than one consortium. However, the consortium can also have members who do not hold any of the above permits, as long as the two permit holding members’ requirement is satisfied.

 

Under Article 5 (2) (f), the consortium has to appoint one of the members to serve as its Chairperson, with such an appointee having to hold at least one of the above-mentioned permits under Article 5 (2) (g).

 

Article 7 states that foreign ownership is possible, as long as long as it complies with laws and regulations on capital investment (such as Negative Investment List, Presidential Decree No. 36 of 2010 on Lists of Business Fields that are Closed to Investment and Business Fields that are Conditionally Open to Investment).

 

Licensing Requirements

In addition to the licenses that have to be held by certain consortium members under Article 5, the consortium itself, as the IPTV service provider, has to apply for the following licenses in accordance with Article 9:

•

Subscription-Based Television Service License for broadcast (push) services;

•

License from the relevant institution (to be created by the Minister pursuant to Article 10) for multimedia (pull/interactive) and electronic transaction services;

•

Internet Service Provider License for internet access services.

 

Licensing Procedure

The licensing application requirements are set out in Article 26, which also includes an extensive list of information and documents that have to be submitted along with the application. These range from such broad things as the ‘vision and mission’ of the IPTV service provider to the more specific, such as the Articles of Incorporation and the technical specifications of the operation.

 

Once completed, the application has to be submitted to the Minister, in three copies, as required by Article 27 (1). Whereupon, under Articles 27 (2) and (3), it will undergo an evaluation by a team that will be established by the Minister.

 

The timeline of the evaluation process is set out under Article 28, and is as follows:

i)

Administrative evaluation will be conducted within 15 working days (Article 28 (2));

ii)

In-principle approval or rejection will be issued within a further 30 working days (Article 28 (3));

iii)

In the event of rejection, the applicant will have 30 working days to make any amendments (Article 28 (4));

iv)

Technical evaluation will be carried out within 15 working days of the administrative approval being received (Article 28 (5));

v)

In the event of rejection, the applicant will have 30 working days to make any necessary modifications to the network (Article 28 (6));

vi)

The team will then have 15 working days to complete the administrative and technical evaluation report (Article 28 (8)), and a further 10 working days to deliver the report to the Minister (Article 28 (9)).

 

If both the administrative and the technical evaluations produce a positive result, the Minister, pursuant to Article 29, will issue an approval letter (Surat Persetujuan Layanan IPTV), within 15 working days of receiving the report. Under Article 31 (1), the approval letter is given to the Chairperson of the consortium, however, under Article 31 (2), it is binding on all of the consortium’s members.

 

Once issued, the approval letter is valid for a period of 10 years, pursuant to Article 30 (1), with renewal having to be applied for at least 3 month prior to expiry, pursuant to Article 30 (2).

 

An ‘inspection’ will then be conducted every 5 years, according to Article 32 (1), by a specific team that is established under Article 32 (2).

 

The overall licensing process also provides for public input on IPTV implementation, which can be submitted to the Minister, as per Article 33.

 

Once the approval letter is issued, the IPTV service area cannot exceed the specified license area, according to Article 16 (1), however an expansion of the license area can be obtained pursuant to Article 16 (2).

 

Service Requirements

Broad service level requirements are set out in Article 11, calling for the IPTV providers to ensure sufficient infrastructure capacity to support the customers, and that the infrastructure complies with all relevant regulations. Additionally, under Article 12, network capacity has to be provided for independent content providers, who, consequently, have to be considered when estimating the necessary network capacity.

 

Software system requirements are set out in Article 13 (1), and include back-end (which under Article 13 (1) has to be located in Indonesia), transactions, security, monitoring, complaints, and billing systems.

 

IPTV Set-Top-Boxes have to be supplied by the IPTV providers under Article 14 (1), with domestically produced components making up at least 20%, and rising to 50% within five years, under Article 14 (2). Furthermore, the set-top-boxes will have to comply with further ministerial regulation, which will be issued at a later date, under Article 14 (3).

 

Technical requirements are set out in Article 15, and range from the broad, and undefined, ‘international technical standards,’ to the more specific. For instance, pursuant to Article 15 (4), the IPTV providers have to migrate to IPv6 within two years of the Regulation being passed (making the deadline 30 July 2012).

 

More general requirements are contained in Article 17, dealing with service quality issues related to the network, reception, responsiveness, and customer care, all of which will be set out in further ministerial regulation that is to be issued at a later date.

 

Content

Domestic content requirements are set out in Article 18, with at least 10% of broadcast (push) content having to be domestically produced, pursuant to Article 18 (1), and at least 30% of the multimedia library, pursuant to Article 18 (2).

 

Independent content provider requirements are contained in Article 18 (3), with a requirement of at least 10% of the content initially, rising to at least 50% within five years. With IPTV providers having to grant access to independent content providers under Article 19 (1). And further elaboration on dealing with independent content providers under Article 20.

 

The provision of the content itself is regulated under Articles 19 (2) and (3), which specify that services have to be organized into packages and sub-packages.

 

Finally, public service announcements and natural disaster warnings have to be broadcast by the IPTV service providers under Article 25.

 

Security and Protection

An obligation to protect the IP network, in accordance with the relevant legislative provisions exists under Article 21.

 

The security of the provider-customer data channel is addressed in Article 22.

 

While an obligation to ensure that intellectual property rights of the content being distributed are respected in set out in Article 23.

 

And the protection of customers is addressed in Article 24.

 

Sanctions

Events giving rise to administrative sanctions are set out in Article 34 (1), and cover the violation of:

Article 3 - the general obligations provision

Article 9 - the license requirement

Article 14 (1) - the requirement to provide set-top-boxes

Article 14 (3) - the requirement for such set-top-boxes to comply with the technical requirements set out by further ministerial regulation

Article 15 (1) - the ‘international standards’ requirement

Article 21 - the requirement to safeguard the IP network

Article 22 (1) - the requirement to safeguard the services offered to customers

Article 23 - the requirement to protect intellectual property rights

Article 24 (e) - the requirement to allow customers to submit complaints interactively

Article 25 - the requirement to broadcast public service announcements and natural disaster warnings

 

The sanctions themselves are set out in Article 34 (3), and consist of:

a.

written warnings;

b.

temporary suspension of IPTV services;

c.

refusing to extend the validity of the approval letter; and/or

d.

revocation of the approval letter.

 

With the imposition of the administrative sanctions not absolving the IPTV provider from further criminal liability, pursuant to Article 34 (3).

 

The progression, and timeline, of the sanctions is set out in Article 35, and is as follows:

i)

First written warning under Article 35 (1);

ii)

Second written warning, issued within 7 working days, in the event that the first written warning is ignored, under Article 35 (2);

iii)

Third written warning and a temporary suspension of IPTV services, within 7 working days, if the second written warning is ignored, under Article 35 (3);

iv)

Finally, a refusal to extend the validity or the revocation of the approval letter, within 7 working days of the third written warning being ignored, pursuant to Article 35 (4).

 

Conclusion

The Regulation sets out a more comprehensive, and more long-term oriented, view of the regulatory framework applicable to IPTV service providers. In doing so, it sets out such administrative pre-requisites as the formation of a consortium, which is then able to provide IPTV services, the license requirements, and the licensing procedure. Then, for IPTV service providers who obtain the necessary license, the Regulation addresses the service and content requirements, as well as the security and intellectual property rights protection obligations. Finally, the Regulation contains a reasonably comprehensive administrative sanction regime, and corresponding timeline of sanction escalation.

 

However, several aspects of IPTV service provision are left for later, more specific, ministerial regulations, implying that the still changing landscape of IPTV services does not, as of yet, have a definitive legislative framework, and is therefore almost certain to see further regulations governing the operation of IPTV services.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info