A Bill on Civil Forfeiture: Extensive Tracing and Seizure Without a Court Decision
Overview
The Bill on Civil Forfeiture is currently being discussed by the House of Representatives, and is part of the National Legislative Programme for the 2010-2014 period (and is therefore likely to further evolve from its current form). Discussion on the Bill was started in 2005 by the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK), and the Bill has since undergone a number of revisions before reaching the form of the current draft. The goal of the Bill is to create a framework that will enable the efficient recovery and management of assets that constitute the proceeds of crime.
Current legislation governing the recovery of proceeds of crime is seen as being insufficient, in that it is considered to be overly burdensome due to the fact that a criminal conviction is required in order to enable the state to recover assets that constitute the proceeds of crime. The Bill also aims to create clear and comprehensive regulation for the management of recovered assets, ensuring that this aspect of the recovery process is transparent and accountable.
The Bill, when passed into Law, will essentially create civil asset forfeiture, with its lower burden of proof, in addition to the criminal forfeiture already present in Indonesian legislation.
This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the Bill and provide analysis of the Bill’s provisions.
Purpose
The passage of the Bill would contribute to the harmonization of Indonesia’s legislation with the United Nations Convention against Corruption (UNCAC), which Indonesia signed in 2003 and ratified in 2006.
The Bill aims to overcome the constraints of the criminal mechanism of recovering assets that constitute proceeds of crime, by relaxing the criminal conviction requirement, being applicable retrospectively to crimes committed since 1998, and providing for an extensive tracing ability which will allow for the confiscation of substituted and further accrued assets. At the same time the Bill aims to maintain a fair process by ensuring that the confiscation is reviewed by a court prior to the assets being seized.
Additionally, the Bill will establish the Asset Management Institution (LPA), which will have the responsibility of managing the confiscated assets.
Applicability
Article 1 (2) contains a broad definition of proceeds of crime, including all assets of value which have been obtained, or are suspected of being obtained, as a result of criminal conduct. Further, assets are defined by Article 2 (2) to include assets obtained directly as a result of crime, accrued from such assets, and mixed with or substituted for such assets, in the event that the original assets are no longer in existence or outside of the court’s jurisdiction.
It is of note that the Bill does not contain any elaboration on level of suspicion that is required under the definition of proceeds of crime, as discussed above. However, the Bill does focus on assets of substantial value, as Article 2 (3) requires a value of at least IDR 500 million (approximately USD 50 thousand), which can be further valued by Government Regulation under Article 2 (4).
The situations in which the Bill applies to allow for the potential confiscation of proceeds of crime, without requiring a criminal conviction, are enumerated in Article 2 (1) as follows:
-
the suspect has died, become permanently ill, or cannot be located for trial;
-
the suspect has been found not guilty;
-
the trial is delayed or not forthcoming; or
-
the criminal case has been decided, however not all proceeds of crime have been confiscated.
With the added requirement, in Article 3, that the alleged criminal conduct is of a type that attracts a sentence of 4 or more years. And a reiteration in Article 4 that a mere suspicion of assets constituting the proceeds of crime is sufficient for the potential confiscation of the assets in question.
Search, Freezing, and Seizure
The Bill grants a range of powers to the investigators and prosecutors that span both the ability to conduct searches, and the power to freeze and seize assets prior to a court decision on the confiscation of the assets.
Search
Article 5 lays out the search powers available to investigators and prosecutors in order to implement the asset confiscation under Article 2, with Article 5 (2) granting the authority to request documents from individuals, companies, and government agencies, and Article 5 (3) requiring compliance with such requests.
Furthermore, Article 5 (4) states that the provided documents are not subject to confidentiality. And Article 6 states that anyone complying with such requests in good faith can not be prosecuted in civil or criminal court. This has the effect of creating a very extensive search power that does not provide any protection to the person being investigated, leaving only the recourse available under Chapter IV, as discussed below.
Freezing
The Bill allows investigators and prosecutors to order the freezing of assets based on ‘strong suspicion’ under the provisions of Article 8 (1). And requires the immediate, or at least within 90 days under Article 9, compliance of institutions (banks and the National Land Agency) with such freezing orders under Article 8 (3). The effect of the freezing order is described under Article 11, and basically means that the assets can not be transferred.
Once again, as with the search, there is little recourse for the person being investigated, with Article 10 stating that the investigator/prosecutor issuing a freezing order in good faith is not subject to prosecution.
Seizure
Investigators and prosecutors are also endowed with the power to seize assets. Under Article 12 (1) such seizure requires the consent of the Chief Justice of the local District Court, however, in urgent circumstances, under Article 12 (2) where the assets are in danger of being moved, the seizure can be carried out without such preliminary approval as long as long as the Chief Justice is notified immediately after the seizure.
As such, the seizure will ordinarily require a warrant that ordinarily ahs to be presented to the owner of the assets, under Article 13. While, following the seizure, the assets will be handed over to the Asset Management Institution (LPA), for storage and maintenance, as discussed below.
It is of note that, under Article 18 (1), the LPA can delegate the management of the assets to third parties, even before the assets are permanently confiscated.
Confiscation
The sections of the Bill dealing with confiscation of assets that constitute the proceeds of crime set out the procedural and substantive requirements of the civil asset forfeiture court process. This covers the timelines for the application, and objections to it, the jurisdiction of the court, how the application is to be reviewed, the burden of proof, and the decision process.
Application
Upon the freezing or seizure of assets the investigator/prosecutor is required to immediately make an application for confiscation, under Article 19.
If the application is being made by an investigator, they are required to submit it to a prosecutor in accordance with Article 20 (1), who then has 14 days to determine if a prosecution should be brought, under Article 20 (2), or return the matter to the investigator requesting it to be completed within a period of 14 days, under Article 20 (3).
The prosecutor makes an application to the Chief Justice of the local District Court, under Article 21 (1), with the authority to act on behalf of the state stemming from Article 22, and with the specifics of the application form and requirements being set out in Articles 21 (2), 48, and 21 (3).
Additionally, Article 79 (1) allows third parties acting in good faith to submit and objection to the confiscation to the Chief Justice of the relevant District Court, however, the mere filing of such an objection will not prevent the enforcement of the confiscation under Article 79 (3). For such an objection to be effective the third party will have to prove ownership of the assets in question under Article 79 (2).
Jurisdiction
Article 23 (1) grants jurisdiction over asset confiscation to the local District Court, and Article 24 allows the Chief Justice of the District Court to designate the Supreme Court in the event that it is not feasible for the District Court to preside over the matter.
An exception to the above allocation of jurisdiction is when a request is made to remove assets, which are subject to confiscation, from Indonesia, in which case the Central Jakarta District Court has the authority to review any such request under Article 25.
The Hearing
Prior to hearing the case the Chief Justice of the District Court will review the application under Article 28, and hand it over to a different District Court, in accordance with Article 29, if it is seen as being the more appropriate forum.
The procedures followed by the District Court, under Article 30, are those of Law No. 8 of 1981 on the Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP).
In the event that the court decides to hear the case, Article 31 requires the announcement of the application for confiscation, and, within 30 days of the announcement, set a trial date, on which the trial will begin in accordance with Article 32.
The trial procedures, such as the submission of evidence are set out in Article 33; Articles 35 through 44, 46, and 47 deal with testimony, witnesses, experts and questioning; and Articles 50, 55, and 56 deal with evidence. The impartiality of the court process is further specifically ensured by Article 34, which disallows related witnesses, and Article 53, which prevents interested judges, prosecutors, and court clerks from taking part in the process.
Standard and Burden of Proof
The Bill creates a civil asset forfeiture mechanism, with the correspondingly lower standard of proof than criminal forfeiture. Requiring, under Article 58, the prosecutor to “prove that there is a strong correlation between ... the ... assets [and] the offense.” The Bill, however, does not specifically define how strong a link is required for the assets to be confiscated.
There also exists what appears to be a potential shift in the burden of proof, with Article 57 allowing the judge(s) to infer from the inability of the defendant to show that the assets have been obtained by lawful means, that such assets are the proceeds of crime.
Decision
Article 45 allows for unanimous and majority decisions, and states that the decision can be announced on the same date that it is reached.
The decision to confiscate assets can only be based on the Law that will result from the current Bill, under Article 45, and can be either of the two possible verdicts under Article 51: confiscation or the return of assets. With the exact form of the decision being further set out in Article 60.
Finally, under Article 61, the decision has to be implemented within 7 days after being announced.
Appeal
The decision can be appealed under Article 52 (1), with the time limit on any such appeal being 14 days of the reading of the verdict, under Article 52 (2).
Other Considerations
The procedure and form of the summons that has to be sent to the parties is set out in Articles 26 and 27, respectively.
A point of note is that, under Article 17, the confiscation of assets does not prevent further criminal prosecution of the party alleged to have engaged in the criminal conduct that gave rise to the assets in question.
Asset Management Institution (LPA)
The regulatory framework (Criminal Procedure Code and Law No. 12 of 1995 on Correctional Institutions), that serves as the legal basis of the body currently responsible for the management of confiscated assets (Rumah Penyimpanan Benda Sitaan Negara / Rupbasan), which operates under the authority of the Ministry of Law and Human Rights, has been considered as insufficient, since such regulations merely designate the Rupbasan as an institution to store assets confiscated following a court decision in a criminal case. The Bill, on the other hand, also deals with assets that are temporarily seized, as well as those that are permanently confiscated.
For this reason, among others, the Bill provides for the establishment of a new institution, the Asset Management Institution (LPA), which, under Article 1 (7), will operate under the authority of the Ministry of Finance, and be tasked with the management of the confiscated assets. Furthermore, within 1 year of the Bill being passed into Law the LPA has to be established, under Article 84, by the Minister of Finance, according to Article 64 (2).
Chapter III of the Bill deals with the LPA and sets out its mandate. The general principles of asset management, such as transparency, are set out in Article 63 (1). And the specific duties of the LPA are set out in Article 67, with further elaboration in Article 68, and a requirement for the LPA to value the assets being received under Article 69. Additionally, the LPA is allowed to delegate its asset management duties to third parties, under Article 67 (3).
Once the assets are confiscated, the LPA has to sell them in accordance with Article 70, either by auction, to be attempted at most 3 times under Article 71, or by tender, also to be attempted at most 3 times. And with the proceeds to be paid into the state treasury. Interestingly, the Bill does not provide for a procedure to be followed if the assets can not be sold in such a manner.
Alternatively, the assets can be used by the LPA or the state, with such use being governed by Article 72.
If the assets are not confiscated, the LPA is tasked with administering their return under Article 73, with an audit requirement for any such returns under Article 74.
Finally, Article 75 deals with the proceeds of the managed assets, which are to be deposited to the treasury. While Article 76 deals with the possible uses that such funds can be utilized for.
Protection and Compensation
Chapter IV of the Bill deals with the protection and compensation that is available to the individuals whose assets are targeted under its provisions, and as such forms a critical part of the legislative scheme for anyone whose assets fall under suspicion.
The assets have to be returned, in accordance with Article 77 (1), in the event that their owner is cleared of the related criminal charges, and the assets that the suspect possesses have been proven to originate from a lawful source. The timelines and the procedure for the return of assets is set out in Article 77 (3), providing for 2 years for the proceeds to be retuned in case the assets have already been sold, and 3 months for the actual assets to be returned in case they are still under the control of the LPA.
Additionally, the party who is entitled to the return of their assets is also able to obtain compensation under Article 77 (4). Furthermore, anyone negatively affected by freezing, seizure, or confiscation is entitled to file a lawsuit under Article 78 (1), seeking the price of the assets if they had been destroyed, under Article 78 (2), or further compensation and damages by means of Government Regulation, which is to be issued at a later date, under Article 78 (3).
Extra-Territorial Issues
The Bill has a number of provisions dealing with the international aspects likely to be encountered in the operation of the legislative scheme, such as the general discussion of extra-territorial searches in Article 7; freezing and seizure in Article 16; and freezing, seizure and confiscation in Article 80. While Article 81 deals with Indonesia providing assistance to other countries with their efforts to recover assets under similar provisions in their legislation.
Of note is the possibility of freezing or seizure of assets located in Indonesia, to essentially substitute for assets of the same value that can not be frozen or seized extra-territorially, that is available under Article 15.
Other Considerations
The implementation of the legislative scheme laid out in the Bill is to be funded from the State Budget under Article 82.
And one of the most significant provisions of the Bill is that it will apply retroactively, to all criminal acts committed after 1998, under Article 85.
Conclusion
Civil forfeiture is a relatively new legislative innovation, with only a few countries, including: Colombia, Ireland, South Africa, UK, US, and several Australian and Canadian provinces, having passed such legislation so far. In light of this, the Indonesian legislative efforts in this regard are to be commended, and provide an indication of the Indonesian government’s commitment to the recovery of ill-gotten gains. However, the Bill is only likely to be passed into Law during the period of 2010 to 2014, and as such the prospect of the provisions being watered down, as well as of the ultimate enforcement being lacking, remains a real possibility.
The Bill is most notable in that it applies a civil standard of proof, creating a civil forfeiture regime, while also arguably shifting the burden of proof in certain circumstances.
Additionally, the possibility of freezing of assets, and in certain circumstances seizure, being done without a court order creates a potentially very powerful tool that can be used by the investigators and prosecutors. Combined with the requirement that banks have to comply with such orders, and the fact that there is no way to challenge the freezing/seizure and no provisions specifying what actions can be taken by those affected in the event that a court case is not initiated following the freezing/seizure, there exists a potential window for abuse.
Finally, a notable potential shortcoming of the Bill is that the definition of proceeds of crime includes assets that are ‘suspected’ to be proceeds of crime, without containing a definition of what form such suspicion might take, or to what level it has to rise in order to be actionable.
The Bill on Civil Forfeiture is currently being discussed by the House of Representatives, and is part of the National Legislative Programme for the 2010-2014 period (and is therefore likely to further evolve from its current form). Discussion on the Bill was started in 2005 by the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK), and the Bill has since undergone a number of revisions before reaching the form of the current draft. The goal of the Bill is to create a framework that will enable the efficient recovery and management of assets that constitute the proceeds of crime.
Current legislation governing the recovery of proceeds of crime is seen as being insufficient, in that it is considered to be overly burdensome due to the fact that a criminal conviction is required in order to enable the state to recover assets that constitute the proceeds of crime. The Bill also aims to create clear and comprehensive regulation for the management of recovered assets, ensuring that this aspect of the recovery process is transparent and accountable.
The Bill, when passed into Law, will essentially create civil asset forfeiture, with its lower burden of proof, in addition to the criminal forfeiture already present in Indonesian legislation.
This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight the key features of the Bill and provide analysis of the Bill’s provisions.
Purpose
The passage of the Bill would contribute to the harmonization of Indonesia’s legislation with the United Nations Convention against Corruption (UNCAC), which Indonesia signed in 2003 and ratified in 2006.
The Bill aims to overcome the constraints of the criminal mechanism of recovering assets that constitute proceeds of crime, by relaxing the criminal conviction requirement, being applicable retrospectively to crimes committed since 1998, and providing for an extensive tracing ability which will allow for the confiscation of substituted and further accrued assets. At the same time the Bill aims to maintain a fair process by ensuring that the confiscation is reviewed by a court prior to the assets being seized.
Additionally, the Bill will establish the Asset Management Institution (LPA), which will have the responsibility of managing the confiscated assets.
Applicability
Article 1 (2) contains a broad definition of proceeds of crime, including all assets of value which have been obtained, or are suspected of being obtained, as a result of criminal conduct. Further, assets are defined by Article 2 (2) to include assets obtained directly as a result of crime, accrued from such assets, and mixed with or substituted for such assets, in the event that the original assets are no longer in existence or outside of the court’s jurisdiction.
It is of note that the Bill does not contain any elaboration on level of suspicion that is required under the definition of proceeds of crime, as discussed above. However, the Bill does focus on assets of substantial value, as Article 2 (3) requires a value of at least IDR 500 million (approximately USD 50 thousand), which can be further valued by Government Regulation under Article 2 (4).
The situations in which the Bill applies to allow for the potential confiscation of proceeds of crime, without requiring a criminal conviction, are enumerated in Article 2 (1) as follows:
-
the suspect has died, become permanently ill, or cannot be located for trial;
-
the suspect has been found not guilty;
-
the trial is delayed or not forthcoming; or
-
the criminal case has been decided, however not all proceeds of crime have been confiscated.
With the added requirement, in Article 3, that the alleged criminal conduct is of a type that attracts a sentence of 4 or more years. And a reiteration in Article 4 that a mere suspicion of assets constituting the proceeds of crime is sufficient for the potential confiscation of the assets in question.
Search, Freezing, and Seizure
The Bill grants a range of powers to the investigators and prosecutors that span both the ability to conduct searches, and the power to freeze and seize assets prior to a court decision on the confiscation of the assets.
Search
Article 5 lays out the search powers available to investigators and prosecutors in order to implement the asset confiscation under Article 2, with Article 5 (2) granting the authority to request documents from individuals, companies, and government agencies, and Article 5 (3) requiring compliance with such requests.
Furthermore, Article 5 (4) states that the provided documents are not subject to confidentiality. And Article 6 states that anyone complying with such requests in good faith can not be prosecuted in civil or criminal court. This has the effect of creating a very extensive search power that does not provide any protection to the person being investigated, leaving only the recourse available under Chapter IV, as discussed below.
Freezing
The Bill allows investigators and prosecutors to order the freezing of assets based on ‘strong suspicion’ under the provisions of Article 8 (1). And requires the immediate, or at least within 90 days under Article 9, compliance of institutions (banks and the National Land Agency) with such freezing orders under Article 8 (3). The effect of the freezing order is described under Article 11, and basically means that the assets can not be transferred.
Once again, as with the search, there is little recourse for the person being investigated, with Article 10 stating that the investigator/prosecutor issuing a freezing order in good faith is not subject to prosecution.
Seizure
Investigators and prosecutors are also endowed with the power to seize assets. Under Article 12 (1) such seizure requires the consent of the Chief Justice of the local District Court, however, in urgent circumstances, under Article 12 (2) where the assets are in danger of being moved, the seizure can be carried out without such preliminary approval as long as long as the Chief Justice is notified immediately after the seizure.
As such, the seizure will ordinarily require a warrant that ordinarily ahs to be presented to the owner of the assets, under Article 13. While, following the seizure, the assets will be handed over to the Asset Management Institution (LPA), for storage and maintenance, as discussed below.
It is of note that, under Article 18 (1), the LPA can delegate the management of the assets to third parties, even before the assets are permanently confiscated.
Confiscation
The sections of the Bill dealing with confiscation of assets that constitute the proceeds of crime set out the procedural and substantive requirements of the civil asset forfeiture court process. This covers the timelines for the application, and objections to it, the jurisdiction of the court, how the application is to be reviewed, the burden of proof, and the decision process.
Application
Upon the freezing or seizure of assets the investigator/prosecutor is required to immediately make an application for confiscation, under Article 19.
If the application is being made by an investigator, they are required to submit it to a prosecutor in accordance with Article 20 (1), who then has 14 days to determine if a prosecution should be brought, under Article 20 (2), or return the matter to the investigator requesting it to be completed within a period of 14 days, under Article 20 (3).
The prosecutor makes an application to the Chief Justice of the local District Court, under Article 21 (1), with the authority to act on behalf of the state stemming from Article 22, and with the specifics of the application form and requirements being set out in Articles 21 (2), 48, and 21 (3).
Additionally, Article 79 (1) allows third parties acting in good faith to submit and objection to the confiscation to the Chief Justice of the relevant District Court, however, the mere filing of such an objection will not prevent the enforcement of the confiscation under Article 79 (3). For such an objection to be effective the third party will have to prove ownership of the assets in question under Article 79 (2).
Jurisdiction
Article 23 (1) grants jurisdiction over asset confiscation to the local District Court, and Article 24 allows the Chief Justice of the District Court to designate the Supreme Court in the event that it is not feasible for the District Court to preside over the matter.
An exception to the above allocation of jurisdiction is when a request is made to remove assets, which are subject to confiscation, from Indonesia, in which case the Central Jakarta District Court has the authority to review any such request under Article 25.
The Hearing
Prior to hearing the case the Chief Justice of the District Court will review the application under Article 28, and hand it over to a different District Court, in accordance with Article 29, if it is seen as being the more appropriate forum.
The procedures followed by the District Court, under Article 30, are those of Law No. 8 of 1981 on the Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP).
In the event that the court decides to hear the case, Article 31 requires the announcement of the application for confiscation, and, within 30 days of the announcement, set a trial date, on which the trial will begin in accordance with Article 32.
The trial procedures, such as the submission of evidence are set out in Article 33; Articles 35 through 44, 46, and 47 deal with testimony, witnesses, experts and questioning; and Articles 50, 55, and 56 deal with evidence. The impartiality of the court process is further specifically ensured by Article 34, which disallows related witnesses, and Article 53, which prevents interested judges, prosecutors, and court clerks from taking part in the process.
Standard and Burden of Proof
The Bill creates a civil asset forfeiture mechanism, with the correspondingly lower standard of proof than criminal forfeiture. Requiring, under Article 58, the prosecutor to “prove that there is a strong correlation between ... the ... assets [and] the offense.” The Bill, however, does not specifically define how strong a link is required for the assets to be confiscated.
There also exists what appears to be a potential shift in the burden of proof, with Article 57 allowing the judge(s) to infer from the inability of the defendant to show that the assets have been obtained by lawful means, that such assets are the proceeds of crime.
Decision
Article 45 allows for unanimous and majority decisions, and states that the decision can be announced on the same date that it is reached.
The decision to confiscate assets can only be based on the Law that will result from the current Bill, under Article 45, and can be either of the two possible verdicts under Article 51: confiscation or the return of assets. With the exact form of the decision being further set out in Article 60.
Finally, under Article 61, the decision has to be implemented within 7 days after being announced.
Appeal
The decision can be appealed under Article 52 (1), with the time limit on any such appeal being 14 days of the reading of the verdict, under Article 52 (2).
Other Considerations
The procedure and form of the summons that has to be sent to the parties is set out in Articles 26 and 27, respectively.
A point of note is that, under Article 17, the confiscation of assets does not prevent further criminal prosecution of the party alleged to have engaged in the criminal conduct that gave rise to the assets in question.
Asset Management Institution (LPA)
The regulatory framework (Criminal Procedure Code and Law No. 12 of 1995 on Correctional Institutions), that serves as the legal basis of the body currently responsible for the management of confiscated assets (Rumah Penyimpanan Benda Sitaan Negara / Rupbasan), which operates under the authority of the Ministry of Law and Human Rights, has been considered as insufficient, since such regulations merely designate the Rupbasan as an institution to store assets confiscated following a court decision in a criminal case. The Bill, on the other hand, also deals with assets that are temporarily seized, as well as those that are permanently confiscated.
For this reason, among others, the Bill provides for the establishment of a new institution, the Asset Management Institution (LPA), which, under Article 1 (7), will operate under the authority of the Ministry of Finance, and be tasked with the management of the confiscated assets. Furthermore, within 1 year of the Bill being passed into Law the LPA has to be established, under Article 84, by the Minister of Finance, according to Article 64 (2).
Chapter III of the Bill deals with the LPA and sets out its mandate. The general principles of asset management, such as transparency, are set out in Article 63 (1). And the specific duties of the LPA are set out in Article 67, with further elaboration in Article 68, and a requirement for the LPA to value the assets being received under Article 69. Additionally, the LPA is allowed to delegate its asset management duties to third parties, under Article 67 (3).
Once the assets are confiscated, the LPA has to sell them in accordance with Article 70, either by auction, to be attempted at most 3 times under Article 71, or by tender, also to be attempted at most 3 times. And with the proceeds to be paid into the state treasury. Interestingly, the Bill does not provide for a procedure to be followed if the assets can not be sold in such a manner.
Alternatively, the assets can be used by the LPA or the state, with such use being governed by Article 72.
If the assets are not confiscated, the LPA is tasked with administering their return under Article 73, with an audit requirement for any such returns under Article 74.
Finally, Article 75 deals with the proceeds of the managed assets, which are to be deposited to the treasury. While Article 76 deals with the possible uses that such funds can be utilized for.
Protection and Compensation
Chapter IV of the Bill deals with the protection and compensation that is available to the individuals whose assets are targeted under its provisions, and as such forms a critical part of the legislative scheme for anyone whose assets fall under suspicion.
The assets have to be returned, in accordance with Article 77 (1), in the event that their owner is cleared of the related criminal charges, and the assets that the suspect possesses have been proven to originate from a lawful source. The timelines and the procedure for the return of assets is set out in Article 77 (3), providing for 2 years for the proceeds to be retuned in case the assets have already been sold, and 3 months for the actual assets to be returned in case they are still under the control of the LPA.
Additionally, the party who is entitled to the return of their assets is also able to obtain compensation under Article 77 (4). Furthermore, anyone negatively affected by freezing, seizure, or confiscation is entitled to file a lawsuit under Article 78 (1), seeking the price of the assets if they had been destroyed, under Article 78 (2), or further compensation and damages by means of Government Regulation, which is to be issued at a later date, under Article 78 (3).
Extra-Territorial Issues
The Bill has a number of provisions dealing with the international aspects likely to be encountered in the operation of the legislative scheme, such as the general discussion of extra-territorial searches in Article 7; freezing and seizure in Article 16; and freezing, seizure and confiscation in Article 80. While Article 81 deals with Indonesia providing assistance to other countries with their efforts to recover assets under similar provisions in their legislation.
Of note is the possibility of freezing or seizure of assets located in Indonesia, to essentially substitute for assets of the same value that can not be frozen or seized extra-territorially, that is available under Article 15.
Other Considerations
The implementation of the legislative scheme laid out in the Bill is to be funded from the State Budget under Article 82.
And one of the most significant provisions of the Bill is that it will apply retroactively, to all criminal acts committed after 1998, under Article 85.
Conclusion
Civil forfeiture is a relatively new legislative innovation, with only a few countries, including: Colombia, Ireland, South Africa, UK, US, and several Australian and Canadian provinces, having passed such legislation so far. In light of this, the Indonesian legislative efforts in this regard are to be commended, and provide an indication of the Indonesian government’s commitment to the recovery of ill-gotten gains. However, the Bill is only likely to be passed into Law during the period of 2010 to 2014, and as such the prospect of the provisions being watered down, as well as of the ultimate enforcement being lacking, remains a real possibility.
The Bill is most notable in that it applies a civil standard of proof, creating a civil forfeiture regime, while also arguably shifting the burden of proof in certain circumstances.
Additionally, the possibility of freezing of assets, and in certain circumstances seizure, being done without a court order creates a potentially very powerful tool that can be used by the investigators and prosecutors. Combined with the requirement that banks have to comply with such orders, and the fact that there is no way to challenge the freezing/seizure and no provisions specifying what actions can be taken by those affected in the event that a court case is not initiated following the freezing/seizure, there exists a potential window for abuse.
Finally, a notable potential shortcoming of the Bill is that the definition of proceeds of crime includes assets that are ‘suspected’ to be proceeds of crime, without containing a definition of what form such suspicion might take, or to what level it has to rise in order to be actionable.