Government Regulation on Supervision of Mineral and Coal Mining Operations
Overview
Government Regulation No. 55 of 2010 on Guidance and Supervision of the Management of Mineral and Coal Mining Operations (“Regulation”) was issued on 5 July 2010, and is one of four long-anticipated implementing regulations to Law No. 4 of 2009 on Mineral and Coal Mining (“Mining Law”). This latest regulation governs a host of matters relating to supervision of the extractive industries, implementing Article 144 of the Mining Law. The regulatory scope of supervision extends to holders of: Mining Business Licenses (‘IUP’), Community Mining Licenses (‘IPR’), and Special Mining Business Licenses (‘IUPK’).
This Indonesian Law Digest will survey the Regulation with attention to the practical arrangement for supervision of the mining sector.
Purpose
The Regulation intends to set forth an umbrella for the practical implementation of supervision in the licensed mining sector, covering an extensive spectrum of oversight, and identifying the various governmental authorities responsible for each element of supervision.
General Division of Authority
Within the umbrella of ‘oversight’ provided by the Regulation, a series of measures are set out that range from passive monitoring of data, to active technical supervision of mining activities. The Regulation goes on to distinguish responsibilities that are held by (a) Mining Inspectors from the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, and (b) governments (i.e., central, provincial, mayor, regency) and their representatives.
Special Authorities
Although both mining inspectors and regional government representatives are entitled to enter a mine at any time, Mining Inspectors are exclusive in one respect, which is the authority to temporarily stop any mining activity in part, or entirely. From there, they may also recommend that an activity be stopped permanently to the Chief Mining Inspector.
Mining Inspectors: Technical Oversight
Overview
As appointees of the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, Mining Inspectors are representatives of the central government, and are essentially the primary supervisors of the mining sector. They hold authority over a wide range of technical aspects of mine oversight, supervising: mining techniques and operations, safety and employee health, environmental management, post-mining activities, and conservation of mineral and coal resources.
Specifics
Mining techniques and operations include: mine construction, mining methods, equipment use, exploration techniques, procedures for calculating reserves and resources, processing methods, transportation, and sales. It also includes engineering and technology assessment with respect to regulation and other standards.
Mine safety assessment will evaluate safety management systems, mitigation of occupational hazards, and other elements of work safety, including the competency of the miners with respect to their mining tasks. They may also coordinate with other related officials to evaluate a mine’s compliance with other safety and employment regulatory standards.
Environmental oversight principally includes assessment of a given mining activity with respect to (a) all applicable regulation, and (b) conditions contained in environmental utilization permits. Ministry of Environment officials and others may be invited to coordinate with Inspectors in this element of supervision.
More generally, Mining Inspectors will monitor fulfillment of post-mining land reclamation responsibilities, assessing whether companies have satisfied their post-mining guarantees (mining companies are obliged to deposit a collateral to guarantee that they will maintain, and subsequently ‘clean up’ a given concession area). In short, the authority to determine whether a mining company may be re-compensated rests with Mining Inspectors.
Finally, Mining Inspectors are given wide authority to collect data on mineral and coal reserves, and on all mining and processing activities. On that basis, they are instructed to assess the management, rate, and method for utilization of marginal reserves, as well as of low quality minerals and coal. Although it is not explicit, the purpose of that oversight is ostensibly to determine if mining activities are efficient, maximally extracting mineral and coal resources, and at a rate conducive to the long-term interests of the country.
Government Representatives: Regulatory Oversight
Overview
The Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources, governors, regents, and mayors will appoint representatives at each respective level of government that are charged with the broader, regulatory side of oversight. Among other things, government regulators supervise: issuance of concessions and licenses, marketing of resources within Indonesia, financial matters relating to the state, data management, human capital development, empowerment of local communities, public interests in mining areas, amounts and qualities of production, and more.
Specifics
Perhaps predictably, governmental regulators are mandated to collect data on the issuance of licenses and other permits, and implement follow-ups based on evaluation of that data. Presumably, the intention is to ensure that there is coordination - and restraint - in the granting of mining concessions.
Oversight over the marketing of mineral and coal includes: monitoring the sales of concessions and awarding of contracts to mining companies, supervision of mineral and coal prices and processing costs, and the fulfillment of domestic sales obligations. Briefly, mining companies are obliged to prioritize the sales of resources within the domestic market, thus satisfying the domestic demand before exporting resources elsewhere: it is formally regulated as the ‘Domestic Market Obligation’ (DMO), and state regulators will focus on ensuring companies comply.
The appointed representatives at each level of government are further instructed to supervise budgetary and payment-related matters for the mining sector. The oversight is generally to (a) scrutinize budgetary balances on the state’s side, and (b) supervise the collection of numerous payment obligations - elaborated in Article 23 of the Regulation - on the company side.
Article 24 of the Regulation calls for data management for virtually all information relating to the mining sector. Though it may be a straightforward instruction, it is only vaguely elaborated in that provision. Further implementing regulation is not demanded.
Supervision of human capital development involves two dimensions: (1) implementation of employee development programs, and; (2) implementation of competency testing. Further details are not provided, nor is subsequent implementing regulation demanded: the message appears to be that the appointed representatives at each level of government must coordinate amongst themselves to ensure that mining employees are given professional development opportunities.
Oversight of the empowerment of local communities is similarly vague, with the Regulation merely calling for ‘program development,’ ‘community development,’ and financial oversight of those initiatives. Unlike other distinctly vague provisions, however, further detail is demanded of subsequent Ministerial regulation.
Moreover, the Regulation goes on to specify that regulators must serve the public interest by financing and constructing public facilities in mining areas. Implementation of this provision (i.e., identifying what facilities would best serve the public interest in a given mining area) is left to supervisory officials at each level of government.
In exercising control over the amount, type, and quality of mineral and coal production, regulators must assess the method for extraction, the method for production, and all of the methods involved from extracting the materials to the final point of sales.
Finally, as with Mining Inspectors, appointed supervisory officials at each level of government are generally tasked with evaluating a mining operation to ensure that it complies with all parameters set out in regulation, licensing, and other mining permits.
Further Specification
The Regulation may identify core supervisory responsibilities of state officials, but it leaves a great deal of the critical detail to further Ministerial Regulation. It is perhaps generally clarified what will be assessed in a mining operation but the criteria that must be met by mining companies in order to satisfy that assessment is not elaborated whatsoever.
As is contained in Article 5 (3), further implementation regulation issued by the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources will, among other things, address:
-
Technical guidelines (i.e., standards) for mining;
-
Management guidelines (i.e., standards) for mining;
-
Guidelines (i.e., forms and requirements) for reporting: site investigation, feasibility studies, as well as a series of operations, including mining, processing, refining, transportation, and sales;
-
Guidelines for the (preferential) import of capital goods, equipment, and raw materials for mining;
-
Guidelines (i.e., requirements) for empowerment of communities in mining areas;
-
Guidelines for state officials in evaluating the various mining operation reports;
-
Guidelines for environmental monitoring, reclamation, and other post-mining activities.
Conclusion
The Regulation is clearly an umbrella giving legal basis to further, more specific regulation. Though it broadly defines different focal points of oversight in the mining sector, it leaves a fabulous amount of detail to further Ministerial Regulation, and policies of provincial and district governments. In short, the Regulation instructs what must be assessed, but fails to elaborate criteria for that assessment that will determine if a mining operation is permissible or problematic: legal certainty is still in question.
Government Regulation No. 55 of 2010 on Guidance and Supervision of the Management of Mineral and Coal Mining Operations (“Regulation”) was issued on 5 July 2010, and is one of four long-anticipated implementing regulations to Law No. 4 of 2009 on Mineral and Coal Mining (“Mining Law”). This latest regulation governs a host of matters relating to supervision of the extractive industries, implementing Article 144 of the Mining Law. The regulatory scope of supervision extends to holders of: Mining Business Licenses (‘IUP’), Community Mining Licenses (‘IPR’), and Special Mining Business Licenses (‘IUPK’).
This Indonesian Law Digest will survey the Regulation with attention to the practical arrangement for supervision of the mining sector.
Purpose
The Regulation intends to set forth an umbrella for the practical implementation of supervision in the licensed mining sector, covering an extensive spectrum of oversight, and identifying the various governmental authorities responsible for each element of supervision.
General Division of Authority
Within the umbrella of ‘oversight’ provided by the Regulation, a series of measures are set out that range from passive monitoring of data, to active technical supervision of mining activities. The Regulation goes on to distinguish responsibilities that are held by (a) Mining Inspectors from the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, and (b) governments (i.e., central, provincial, mayor, regency) and their representatives.
Special Authorities
Although both mining inspectors and regional government representatives are entitled to enter a mine at any time, Mining Inspectors are exclusive in one respect, which is the authority to temporarily stop any mining activity in part, or entirely. From there, they may also recommend that an activity be stopped permanently to the Chief Mining Inspector.
Mining Inspectors: Technical Oversight
Overview
As appointees of the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources, Mining Inspectors are representatives of the central government, and are essentially the primary supervisors of the mining sector. They hold authority over a wide range of technical aspects of mine oversight, supervising: mining techniques and operations, safety and employee health, environmental management, post-mining activities, and conservation of mineral and coal resources.
Specifics
Mining techniques and operations include: mine construction, mining methods, equipment use, exploration techniques, procedures for calculating reserves and resources, processing methods, transportation, and sales. It also includes engineering and technology assessment with respect to regulation and other standards.
Mine safety assessment will evaluate safety management systems, mitigation of occupational hazards, and other elements of work safety, including the competency of the miners with respect to their mining tasks. They may also coordinate with other related officials to evaluate a mine’s compliance with other safety and employment regulatory standards.
Environmental oversight principally includes assessment of a given mining activity with respect to (a) all applicable regulation, and (b) conditions contained in environmental utilization permits. Ministry of Environment officials and others may be invited to coordinate with Inspectors in this element of supervision.
More generally, Mining Inspectors will monitor fulfillment of post-mining land reclamation responsibilities, assessing whether companies have satisfied their post-mining guarantees (mining companies are obliged to deposit a collateral to guarantee that they will maintain, and subsequently ‘clean up’ a given concession area). In short, the authority to determine whether a mining company may be re-compensated rests with Mining Inspectors.
Finally, Mining Inspectors are given wide authority to collect data on mineral and coal reserves, and on all mining and processing activities. On that basis, they are instructed to assess the management, rate, and method for utilization of marginal reserves, as well as of low quality minerals and coal. Although it is not explicit, the purpose of that oversight is ostensibly to determine if mining activities are efficient, maximally extracting mineral and coal resources, and at a rate conducive to the long-term interests of the country.
Government Representatives: Regulatory Oversight
Overview
The Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources, governors, regents, and mayors will appoint representatives at each respective level of government that are charged with the broader, regulatory side of oversight. Among other things, government regulators supervise: issuance of concessions and licenses, marketing of resources within Indonesia, financial matters relating to the state, data management, human capital development, empowerment of local communities, public interests in mining areas, amounts and qualities of production, and more.
Specifics
Perhaps predictably, governmental regulators are mandated to collect data on the issuance of licenses and other permits, and implement follow-ups based on evaluation of that data. Presumably, the intention is to ensure that there is coordination - and restraint - in the granting of mining concessions.
Oversight over the marketing of mineral and coal includes: monitoring the sales of concessions and awarding of contracts to mining companies, supervision of mineral and coal prices and processing costs, and the fulfillment of domestic sales obligations. Briefly, mining companies are obliged to prioritize the sales of resources within the domestic market, thus satisfying the domestic demand before exporting resources elsewhere: it is formally regulated as the ‘Domestic Market Obligation’ (DMO), and state regulators will focus on ensuring companies comply.
The appointed representatives at each level of government are further instructed to supervise budgetary and payment-related matters for the mining sector. The oversight is generally to (a) scrutinize budgetary balances on the state’s side, and (b) supervise the collection of numerous payment obligations - elaborated in Article 23 of the Regulation - on the company side.
Article 24 of the Regulation calls for data management for virtually all information relating to the mining sector. Though it may be a straightforward instruction, it is only vaguely elaborated in that provision. Further implementing regulation is not demanded.
Supervision of human capital development involves two dimensions: (1) implementation of employee development programs, and; (2) implementation of competency testing. Further details are not provided, nor is subsequent implementing regulation demanded: the message appears to be that the appointed representatives at each level of government must coordinate amongst themselves to ensure that mining employees are given professional development opportunities.
Oversight of the empowerment of local communities is similarly vague, with the Regulation merely calling for ‘program development,’ ‘community development,’ and financial oversight of those initiatives. Unlike other distinctly vague provisions, however, further detail is demanded of subsequent Ministerial regulation.
Moreover, the Regulation goes on to specify that regulators must serve the public interest by financing and constructing public facilities in mining areas. Implementation of this provision (i.e., identifying what facilities would best serve the public interest in a given mining area) is left to supervisory officials at each level of government.
In exercising control over the amount, type, and quality of mineral and coal production, regulators must assess the method for extraction, the method for production, and all of the methods involved from extracting the materials to the final point of sales.
Finally, as with Mining Inspectors, appointed supervisory officials at each level of government are generally tasked with evaluating a mining operation to ensure that it complies with all parameters set out in regulation, licensing, and other mining permits.
Further Specification
The Regulation may identify core supervisory responsibilities of state officials, but it leaves a great deal of the critical detail to further Ministerial Regulation. It is perhaps generally clarified what will be assessed in a mining operation but the criteria that must be met by mining companies in order to satisfy that assessment is not elaborated whatsoever.
As is contained in Article 5 (3), further implementation regulation issued by the Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources will, among other things, address:
-
Technical guidelines (i.e., standards) for mining;
-
Management guidelines (i.e., standards) for mining;
-
Guidelines (i.e., forms and requirements) for reporting: site investigation, feasibility studies, as well as a series of operations, including mining, processing, refining, transportation, and sales;
-
Guidelines for the (preferential) import of capital goods, equipment, and raw materials for mining;
-
Guidelines (i.e., requirements) for empowerment of communities in mining areas;
-
Guidelines for state officials in evaluating the various mining operation reports;
-
Guidelines for environmental monitoring, reclamation, and other post-mining activities.
Conclusion
The Regulation is clearly an umbrella giving legal basis to further, more specific regulation. Though it broadly defines different focal points of oversight in the mining sector, it leaves a fabulous amount of detail to further Ministerial Regulation, and policies of provincial and district governments. In short, the Regulation instructs what must be assessed, but fails to elaborate criteria for that assessment that will determine if a mining operation is permissible or problematic: legal certainty is still in question.