Regulatory Guidelines to Article 51 of the Anti-Monopoly Law: State-Managed Monopolies

Overview

Rather ironically, state monopolization of strategic industries is instructed, albeit vaguely, by Article 51 of Law No. 5 of 1999 on Prohibition of Monopolistic and Unfair Business Practices (“Anti-Monopoly Law”):

 

Monopolization and/or centralization of activities related to the production and/or marketing of goods and/or services that control the lives of many people and production branches vital to the state shall be regulated by law and shall be performed by State Owned Enterprises and/or entities or institutions established or appointed by the government.

 

Intending to clarify that provision, the Commission for Supervision of Business Competition (‘KPPU’) recently issued Regulation No. 3 of 2010 (“Regulation”), which serves as guidelines to systematize the state’s control of core national interests.

 

This Indonesian Law Digest will survey the Regulation’s guidelines, with attention to criteria for, and conditions upon state monopolies in strategic sectors.

 

Purpose

The Regulation’s fundamental purpose is twofold. First, it governs the establishment of state monopolies, providing criteria that warrant state control over a given industry, and setting out procedures for appointing monopoly organizers. Second, it provides legal restrictions, determining parameters for such monopolies to exist without actually engaging in predatory monopolistic practices.

 

Reasoning

Despite the inherent contradiction in an Anti-Monopoly Law that allows for monopolies, the provision is aligned almost literally with Article 33 of the 1945 Indonesian Constitution, which calls for the state’s “control” of (a) land, sea, and natural resources, and (b) branches of production that are of critical to the livelihoods of many people. The defined scope of “control” is clearly considered by the Regulation to extend to outright monopolization of an industry.

 

At the economic level, the Regulation considers ‘economy’ to be defined as having a primarily collectivistic function; “achieving common prosperity.” In that sense, ‘healthy economic activity’ is less dependent on ideals of market competition, and more dependent on satisfying the needs of the broader community: the latter taking a more permissive stance on monopolization of an industry.

 

Provided that it is state-managed and not solely driven by profits, the Regulation holds that a monopoly can exist without engaging in monopolistic practices. Whereas a monopoly is defined, in short, as control over the production or marketing of a good or service, monopolistic practices are equated with abuses of dominant position. To illustrate, while price fixing is unavoidable if there is only one supplier of a good or service, monopolistic practice is only considered to occur when a price is fixed higher than if competitors existed in the market - profit-oriented abuse of dominant position.

 

Conditions for Monopolization

The state may arrange a monopoly in any industry whose production is deemed to be critical for basic human welfare and livelihood, or relates to vital natural resources. Guidelines for that consideration include whether:

-

Goods are derived from natural resources, in which case they are to be directed for utmost prosperity of Indonesian citizens;

-

Demand for a critical good or service cannot be met;

-

Goods or services should be broadly accessible to the wider public;

-

There is a strategic interest to national security, and;

-

Financial goods or services are critical to the public interest.

 

Whether a given industry meets the aforementioned conditions will be determined by a specific law, which will provide legal basis for subsequent monopolization.

 

Appointing Monopoly Organizers

Monopoly organizers will be established or appointed by a law, which will further elaborate procedures and requirements for a situation-specific arrangement.

 

Eligibility

Monopolies are exclusively the business of the Indonesian state: “preferably organized” by State Owned Enterprises (SOEs); entities whose capital (i.e., equity) is all or “mostly” owned by the state. Failing that, any central government agency or institution that draws funding from the state budget or other public funds is authorized to organize a monopoly, if called for by a Law. 

 

Apart from state management, monopoly organizers must simply be accountable to the central government, and not solely be intended for profit.

 

The Regulation’s definition of ‘SOE’ notably excludes Regionally Owned Enterprises, which are administered and regulated differently, in accordance to local governance.

 

Restrictions

Given that they are intended to serve the wellbeing of the community, monopoly organizers are prohibited from engaging in ‘monopolistic and unfair business practices,’ though the Regulation itself is vague about what that entails.

 

Without ambiguity, monopoly organizers may not subcontract or otherwise designate any aspect of their exclusive activity to an unaffiliated actor: presumably it could raise concern over unfair business practices tantamount to collusion. Affiliated subsidiaries may however be employed for different aspects of an exclusive (i.e., monopolized) line of production

 

Otherwise, from hypothetical scenarios presented in Chapter III, and quips elsewhere in the Regulation, it may be surmised that abuse of dominant position includes: excessive price fixing relative to the cost of production; reducing quality of a good or service to cut expenditures and increase profits; collusion with unaffiliated business actors, and; generally bringing loss to consumers.

 

Further detail on legal parameters and restrictions for a given monopoly or centralization of activities is simply referred to the specific law that regulates a particular arrangement.

 

Conclusion

Though Article 51 of the Anti-Monopoly Law may allow for monopolies and centralization of certain activities, the Regulation certainly makes it clear that they are state operations that are subordinated to the public interest. Thus, it attempts to distinguish monopolies themselves from abuses of dominant position associated with ‘monopolistic and unfair business practices.’  Whether the Regulation succeeds in elaborating that distinction is debatable.

 

Essentially, the Regulation instructs state-run monopolies to strike a balance between profit generation and public service provision, but leaves the finite legal details of a particular arrangement to be regulated by the related law. Laws are used to (a) determine that there is a public interest in the state’s control of a good or service, and (b) organize the monopoly or centralization of activities. The extent to which that successfully ‘systematizes’ the process is similarly debatable: whether an industry may be monopolized - and by whom - is effectively at the whim of lawmakers at the House of Representatives.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

Rather ironically, state monopolization of strategic industries is instructed, albeit vaguely, by Article 51 of Law No. 5 of 1999 on Prohibition of Monopolistic and Unfair Business Practices (“Anti-Monopoly Law”):

 

Monopolization and/or centralization of activities related to the production and/or marketing of goods and/or services that control the lives of many people and production branches vital to the state shall be regulated by law and shall be performed by State Owned Enterprises and/or entities or institutions established or appointed by the government.

 

Intending to clarify that provision, the Commission for Supervision of Business Competition (‘KPPU’) recently issued Regulation No. 3 of 2010 (“Regulation”), which serves as guidelines to systematize the state’s control of core national interests.

 

This Indonesian Law Digest will survey the Regulation’s guidelines, with attention to criteria for, and conditions upon state monopolies in strategic sectors.

 

Purpose

The Regulation’s fundamental purpose is twofold. First, it governs the establishment of state monopolies, providing criteria that warrant state control over a given industry, and setting out procedures for appointing monopoly organizers. Second, it provides legal restrictions, determining parameters for such monopolies to exist without actually engaging in predatory monopolistic practices.

 

Reasoning

Despite the inherent contradiction in an Anti-Monopoly Law that allows for monopolies, the provision is aligned almost literally with Article 33 of the 1945 Indonesian Constitution, which calls for the state’s “control” of (a) land, sea, and natural resources, and (b) branches of production that are of critical to the livelihoods of many people. The defined scope of “control” is clearly considered by the Regulation to extend to outright monopolization of an industry.

 

At the economic level, the Regulation considers ‘economy’ to be defined as having a primarily collectivistic function; “achieving common prosperity.” In that sense, ‘healthy economic activity’ is less dependent on ideals of market competition, and more dependent on satisfying the needs of the broader community: the latter taking a more permissive stance on monopolization of an industry.

 

Provided that it is state-managed and not solely driven by profits, the Regulation holds that a monopoly can exist without engaging in monopolistic practices. Whereas a monopoly is defined, in short, as control over the production or marketing of a good or service, monopolistic practices are equated with abuses of dominant position. To illustrate, while price fixing is unavoidable if there is only one supplier of a good or service, monopolistic practice is only considered to occur when a price is fixed higher than if competitors existed in the market - profit-oriented abuse of dominant position.

 

Conditions for Monopolization

The state may arrange a monopoly in any industry whose production is deemed to be critical for basic human welfare and livelihood, or relates to vital natural resources. Guidelines for that consideration include whether:

-

Goods are derived from natural resources, in which case they are to be directed for utmost prosperity of Indonesian citizens;

-

Demand for a critical good or service cannot be met;

-

Goods or services should be broadly accessible to the wider public;

-

There is a strategic interest to national security, and;

-

Financial goods or services are critical to the public interest.

 

Whether a given industry meets the aforementioned conditions will be determined by a specific law, which will provide legal basis for subsequent monopolization.

 

Appointing Monopoly Organizers

Monopoly organizers will be established or appointed by a law, which will further elaborate procedures and requirements for a situation-specific arrangement.

 

Eligibility

Monopolies are exclusively the business of the Indonesian state: “preferably organized” by State Owned Enterprises (SOEs); entities whose capital (i.e., equity) is all or “mostly” owned by the state. Failing that, any central government agency or institution that draws funding from the state budget or other public funds is authorized to organize a monopoly, if called for by a Law. 

 

Apart from state management, monopoly organizers must simply be accountable to the central government, and not solely be intended for profit.

 

The Regulation’s definition of ‘SOE’ notably excludes Regionally Owned Enterprises, which are administered and regulated differently, in accordance to local governance.

 

Restrictions

Given that they are intended to serve the wellbeing of the community, monopoly organizers are prohibited from engaging in ‘monopolistic and unfair business practices,’ though the Regulation itself is vague about what that entails.

 

Without ambiguity, monopoly organizers may not subcontract or otherwise designate any aspect of their exclusive activity to an unaffiliated actor: presumably it could raise concern over unfair business practices tantamount to collusion. Affiliated subsidiaries may however be employed for different aspects of an exclusive (i.e., monopolized) line of production

 

Otherwise, from hypothetical scenarios presented in Chapter III, and quips elsewhere in the Regulation, it may be surmised that abuse of dominant position includes: excessive price fixing relative to the cost of production; reducing quality of a good or service to cut expenditures and increase profits; collusion with unaffiliated business actors, and; generally bringing loss to consumers.

 

Further detail on legal parameters and restrictions for a given monopoly or centralization of activities is simply referred to the specific law that regulates a particular arrangement.

 

Conclusion

Though Article 51 of the Anti-Monopoly Law may allow for monopolies and centralization of certain activities, the Regulation certainly makes it clear that they are state operations that are subordinated to the public interest. Thus, it attempts to distinguish monopolies themselves from abuses of dominant position associated with ‘monopolistic and unfair business practices.’  Whether the Regulation succeeds in elaborating that distinction is debatable.

 

Essentially, the Regulation instructs state-run monopolies to strike a balance between profit generation and public service provision, but leaves the finite legal details of a particular arrangement to be regulated by the related law. Laws are used to (a) determine that there is a public interest in the state’s control of a good or service, and (b) organize the monopoly or centralization of activities. The extent to which that successfully ‘systematizes’ the process is similarly debatable: whether an industry may be monopolized - and by whom - is effectively at the whim of lawmakers at the House of Representatives.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info