Licensing Guidelines for the Cultivation of Food Crops: a Comparatively Comprehensive Licensing Regime

Overview

Minister of Agriculture Regulation No. 39/PERMENTAN/OT.140/6/2010 of 2010 on the Licensing Guidelines for the Cultivation of Food Crops (“Regulation”) has been in force since 14 June 2010. The Regulation addresses licensing in the crop cultivation business, and sets out the licensing regime for both domestic and foreign owned crop cultivation businesses.

 

The Regulation will serve as a guide to local governments, specifying how licensing must be conducted, and addressing:

-

the licenses required for the cultivation of food crops

-

the requirements and procedure for license application

-

partnership requirements

-

business development

-

guidance and supervision

-

community participation

-

administrative sanctions

 

Under Article 1 (1), the Regulation applies to food crop cultivation businesses engaged in the development and utilization of natural resources for the purpose of producing food crops for human consumption. More specifically, under Article 3, the Regulation applies to businesses engaged in:

-

land preparation

-

planting and growing

-

harvesting

-

processing

-

preservation, packaging and storage

-

distribution and marketing

 

This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight key features of the Regulation.

 

Purpose

The Regulation implements Government Regulation No. 18 of 2010 on Crop Cultivation Businesses by setting out the licensing regime applicable to cultivation businesses. While the, parent, Government Regulation itself is based on Law No. 12 of 1992 on the Crop Cultivation System.

 

The broader purpose of the Regulation, along with the Government Regulation that it implements, is to protect and assist farmers, both small-scale and large enterprises, while supporting the food security of Indonesia.

 

License Types

The Regulation specifies three license types:

 

Production (IUTP-P), under Article 3 (1) (a) as elaborated on in Article 3 (2), which covers:

-

land preparation

-

planting

-

growing (maintenance / plant protection)

-

harvesting

 

Post-Harvest (IUTP-PP), under Article 3 (1) (b) as elaborated on in Article 3 (3), which covers:

-

cleansing, peeling/threshing, and drying

-

sorting and grading

-

processing, preservation, packaging

-

Storage

-

standardization of quality

-

distribution and/or marketing

 

Integrated (IUTP), under Article 3 (1) (c) as elaborated on in Article 3 (4), which includes both production and post-harvest operations, as described above.

 

License Requirements

Businesses engaged in the production and post-harvest activities described above are required to obtain a license, as long as they do not fall under the small-scale farmer exemption, as described below.

 

A production licence (IUTP-P) is required under Article 7 (1) for any production enterprise of 25 hectares (ha) or more, or employing 10 or more people.

 

A post-harvest license (IUTP-PP) is required under Article 7 (2) for any post-harvest enterprise with capacity in excess of that specified in Appendix 1, or yearly revenues of IDR 2.5 billion or more, or employing 10 or more people.

 

An integrated license (IUTP) is required under Article 7 (3) for any integrated enterprise of 25 ha or more, or with capacity in excess of that specified in Appendix 1, or yearly revenues of IDR 2.5 billion or more, or employing 10 or more people.

 

The maximum land area that can be covered by a production license is set at 10,000 ha under Article 9 (1), with an exception being made for Papua, where the maximum is 20,000 ha under article 9 (3). However, these maximum limits do not apply to State Owned Enterprises and Regional Owned Enterprises, in accordance with Article 9 (2).

 

The Small-Scale Farmer Exemption

Operations which do not fall within the requirements for production, post-harvest, and integrated, licenses, as set out above, are not subject to the licensing procedure, and are instead required to obtain registration (TDU-P, TDU-PP, and TDU, respectively) from the local regent/mayor, under the provisions of Article 6.

 

During the drafting of the Regulation local farmers’ associations objected to the registration requirement, saying that it is overly burdensome, and creates an additional expense. Although the registration requirement survived in the final version of the Regulation, some of the concerns were addressed by Article 6 (5), which specifies that the registration is to be free of charge.

 

License Application Procedure

Initial Licensing

The documents that have to be submitted in order to obtain a production license are enumerated in Article 11 (a to l). The documentary requirements for a post-harvest license are set out in Article 12 (a to o). And the documentary requirements for an integrated license are the superset of those in Articles 11 and 12, as specified under Article 13.

 

A consultation requirement exists under Article 18, which states that written evidence of a consultation with the local indigenous people is required if the cultivation of food crops is to be carried out on land owned by the indigenous community.

 

The use of genetically modified plants requires the submission of an opinion on the biological safety of the genetic modifications, which is to be obtained from the Commission on Biological Safety, under Article 19. Furthermore, Government Regulation No. 21 of 2005 on the Safety of Genetically Engineered Biological Products must be adhered to.

 

The application procedure for the licenses is to apply, in writing, with the required documents, as described above, to the regent/mayor (if the business location is within of one district/city, according to Article 8 (1) (a)) or the governor (if the business location spans more than one district/city or province, according to Article 8 (1) (b)) according to Article 15 (1).

 

Within 15 business days of receiving an application, a response of whether the application has been approved, deferred, or rejected must be provided. If no response is forthcoming within the 15 business-day limit, the application is deemed to have been approved, under Article 15 (3), and the relevant license issued under Article 15 (4).

 

The application is to be deferred if the requirements are not met, the deferral and the reasons for it must be provided in a written response to the applicant. At which point the applicant will have 30 work-days to meet the requirements listed in the response, or else their application will be rejected.

 

The application is to be rejected if requirements are not fulfilled, or the business activities would be counter to public order, or the Spatial Plan (RTRW) of the district/city, according to Article 17 (1).

 

If the application is approved, the license is issued by the regent/mayor (if the business location is within of one district/city, according to Article 8 (1) (a)) or the governor (if the business location spans more than one district/city or province, according to Article 8 (1) (b)).

 

License Changes

The issued licenses are valid as long as the license holder continues to be engaged in the licensed business activity, and are not transferable, under the provisions in Article 10.

 

In the event that a license holder wishes to expand the scale of operation (defined as a change in production license land area or a change in post-harvest capacity, under Article 22), such expansion has to be done by means of a partnership, according to Article 20 (1).

 

The partnership requirement involves the cooperation with large-scale farmers, small-scale farmers, and local communities for the purpose of sustainable crop cultivation; specifically in provision of raw materials, production facilities, production, processing and marketing, transportation, operations, capital investment, and other support services. The partnership agreement must be in writing, and set out such terms as specified by Article 21 (1), for a term of at least one growing season, in accordance with Article 21 (2). The agreement must be signed by both parties and the regent/mayor, or governor, or another designated official. Government Regulation No. 44 of 1997 on Partnerships contains further provisions governing the establishment and operation of partnership schemes, such as the one required in this instance.

 

A change in production land area or post-harvest capacity must meet the documentary requirements, as specified for initial licenses under Articles 11 and 12 respectively, according to Article 23.

 

If the production land area is expanded to a total of more than 25 ha, or the post-harvest capacity is expanded by more than 25%, approval from the license issuer is required under Article 24 (1) and (2), respectively. The approval application process involves an application, in writing, that includes, for production licenses, the documents specified in Article 11 (e, f, g, h, and i) and, for post-harvest licenses, the documents specified in Article 12 (g, h, i, j, k, l, and m), according to Article 24 (3). The approval review process by the regent/mayor or governor is to be guided by the Spatial Plan (RTRW) and the Detailed Spatial Plan (RDTR), under Article 24 (4). Finally, changes that involve the use of land owned by indigenous people, require written evidence that consultation has been carried out, under Article 24 (5).

 

The approval, deferral, or rejection process, including the deadlines and procedures, mirrors that for the initial licensing, discussed above, as specified in Article 25 (the 15 work day limit, which mirrors Article 15), Article 26 (the 30 work day deferral, which mirrors Article 16), and Article 27 (the rejection, which mirrors Article 17).

 

Notification

Copies of the issued licenses have to be submitted to the respective provincial governors (if issued by the regent/mayor), the affected regent/mayor(s) (if issued by the governor), and the Minister of Agriculture, specifically the Director General in charge of production or post-harvest operations, as appropriate, under Article 28.

 

License Conditions

Production license holders have to begin business activities no later than 6 months from the issuance of the license, implement the applicable environmental requirements, assist the community and local cooperatives, and report to the regent/mayor or governor after every harvest, or whenever necessary, under Article 29.

 

Post-harvest license holders have to begin business activities no later than 6 months from the issuance of the license, implement the applicable environmental requirements, assist the community and local cooperatives, and report to the regent/mayor or governor every 12 months or whenever necessary, under Article 30.

 

Integrated license holders have to comply with both of the above requirements, under Article 31.

 

The production, post-harvest, or integrated licenses that are obtained with respect to land in which the applicant has a Right to Exploit (Hak Guna Usaha / HGU), require that the licensed operations begin no later than 3 years from the issuance of the license, according to Article 14. Due to the overlap with the provisions in Articles 29 and 30, the exact operation of this time limit is left open to interpretation, as discussed in the Conclusion, below.

 

The form of the reports, required by Articles 29 and 30, as discussed above, is specified in Article 32 (1), as being in accordance with the form specified in Appendix 2. With a further requirement that the regent/mayor receiving the report has to forward it on to the to the governor, while the governor has to in turn forward the report to the Minister of Agriculture, in accordance with Article 32 (2).

 

General requirements contained in Article 33 state that the license holders must ensure the continuity of business, preservation of the environment and genetic resources, prevent the outbreak of harmful pests (organisme pengganggu tumbuhan / OPT), and prevent harm to other parties and the public interest.

 

The Provincial Government and the Regency/Municipality will provide guidance and supervision, within the scope of their authority, based on their evaluation of the above-described reports, under Article 34.

 

License holders (with the exception of farmers utilizing less than 2 ha, under Article 1 definitions 5 and 6, according to Article 36) who, in the course of their business, make use of government facilities that are subject to non-tax usage fees are obliged to pay the fees as specified by the applicable legislation, in accordance with Article 35.

 

Community Participation

General provisions concerning community participation are contained in Articles 37 and 38, with further procedures for community participation to be regulated by the regent/mayor of governor, according to Article 37 (4). The participation is conducted by means of accepting suggestions from the community, the implementation of partnerships (as per Articles 20 and 21, as discussed above), and the reporting and monitoring (as per Articles 29 and 30, as discussed above), according to Article 38.

 

Transitional

Any licenses and registrations issued prior to the coming into force of the Regulation, on 14 June 2010, will remain valid, under Article 42.

 

Foreign Investors

The Regulation addresses the licensing requirement for foreign investors in crop cultivation businesses in quite a tangential manner. The specific requirements for foreign investors are to cooperate with an Indonesian legal entity, according to Article 5 (1). And the restriction on foreign ownership is a maximum of 49%, according to Article 5 (2).

 

The, parent, Government Regulation No. 18 of 2010 on Crop Cultivation Businesses specifies, in more general terms, that Indonesian investors will continue to receive preferential treatment in carrying on crop cultivation businesses, by means of a requirement that the majority share of any such business is to be owned by Indonesian citizens, under Article 5 (2) of the Government Regulation. With foreign investors consequentially being required to cooperate with Indonesian businesses engaged in a similar line of business, and a requirement for any operating company to be incorporated in Indonesia, under Indonesian law.

 

Presidential Regulation No. 36 of 2010 on Lists of Business Sectors that are Closed to Investment and Business Sectors that are Conditionally Open to Investment (the Negative Investment List) is also synchronised with the above discussed regulations in this regard, and specifies a maximum permitted foreign ownership of 49% under Point 11 of the Attachment II to the Presidential Regulation.

 

Sanctions

The Regulation provides for, unspecified, sanctions against officials who charge a fee for the registration (under Article 6) of small-scale farmers, in accordance with Article 39.

 

The license holders are subject to a more defined sanction regime. With Article 40 (1) specifying that written warnings will be issued in case of a failure to fulfil the duties under Articles 29 (b, c, and d) and 30 (b, c, and d), namely, to implement the applicable environmental requirements, assist the community and local cooperatives, and report to the regent/mayor or governor, or the Article 33 duties, such as ensuring the continuity of business, preservation of the environment and genetic resources, prevent the outbreak of harmful pests (OPT), and prevent harm to other parties and the public interest. Two written warnings will be issued for each violation, each with a 3 month grace period, and in the event that both are ignored, the relevant license will be revoked under Article 40 (2). Upon the revocation of a production or integrated license, the revocation of the Right to Exploit (HGU) will also be made to the relevant authorities, in accordance with Article 41.

 

Conclusion

The Regulation creates a reasonably comprehensive licensing regime for crop cultivation businesses. What is left lacking, however, is any detailed regulation concerning foreign investors, with Article 5 providing, at best, a cursory discussion of the obligations and restrictions applicable to foreign investors in crop cultivation businesses.

 

License types differentiate between crop production and post-harvest businesses, with a comprehensive applicability and initial licensing as well as licence change regime being specified by the Regulation. The initial licensing and license change regimes specify an exhaustive list of the required documentation and provide for a 15 work day processing time, with automatic approval in the event of delays, creating what should be a relatively painless bureaucratic process, at least at the licensing stage.

 

The partnership requirement, applicable to expansion of land area and capacity, appears to be motivated by a desire to ensure that any small-scale farmers who are affected by the expansion (e.g. due to their lands being acquired by the expanding enterprise) are still able to retain a level of participation. This requirement, however, has the undesirable effect of creating an inconsistency in that a very minor expansion of an existing business will trigger the requirement of participating in a partnership scheme, while the creation of a new business, of much larger size, is not subject to the same partnership requirement.

 

Similarly, the community participation provisions, although partially defined in Article 38, remain somewhat vague. Thereby retaining the potential to become unduly burdensome in the event that the general nature of Article 37 is interpreted by the local authorities, by means of the power granted by Article 37 (4), to include a high level of community involvement, which may lead to additional demands on the business owner and delays in developing the business.

 

A technical issue exists with the generally applicable provisions of Articles 29 and 30, which specify that business activities have to begin within 3 months of the issuance of the license, and Article 14, which states that for license holders holding Right to Exploit (HGU) land, business operations have to begin within 3 years. The combination of these articles leaves open a question of statutory interpretation, as to whether holders of right to use land are granted an extension to begin operations, overriding the time limits in Articles 29 and 30, or whether Article 14 is simply a redundant provision, with the 3 months time limit applying to holders of right to use land as well.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

Minister of Agriculture Regulation No. 39/PERMENTAN/OT.140/6/2010 of 2010 on the Licensing Guidelines for the Cultivation of Food Crops (“Regulation”) has been in force since 14 June 2010. The Regulation addresses licensing in the crop cultivation business, and sets out the licensing regime for both domestic and foreign owned crop cultivation businesses.

 

The Regulation will serve as a guide to local governments, specifying how licensing must be conducted, and addressing:

-

the licenses required for the cultivation of food crops

-

the requirements and procedure for license application

-

partnership requirements

-

business development

-

guidance and supervision

-

community participation

-

administrative sanctions

 

Under Article 1 (1), the Regulation applies to food crop cultivation businesses engaged in the development and utilization of natural resources for the purpose of producing food crops for human consumption. More specifically, under Article 3, the Regulation applies to businesses engaged in:

-

land preparation

-

planting and growing

-

harvesting

-

processing

-

preservation, packaging and storage

-

distribution and marketing

 

This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will highlight key features of the Regulation.

 

Purpose

The Regulation implements Government Regulation No. 18 of 2010 on Crop Cultivation Businesses by setting out the licensing regime applicable to cultivation businesses. While the, parent, Government Regulation itself is based on Law No. 12 of 1992 on the Crop Cultivation System.

 

The broader purpose of the Regulation, along with the Government Regulation that it implements, is to protect and assist farmers, both small-scale and large enterprises, while supporting the food security of Indonesia.

 

License Types

The Regulation specifies three license types:

 

Production (IUTP-P), under Article 3 (1) (a) as elaborated on in Article 3 (2), which covers:

-

land preparation

-

planting

-

growing (maintenance / plant protection)

-

harvesting

 

Post-Harvest (IUTP-PP), under Article 3 (1) (b) as elaborated on in Article 3 (3), which covers:

-

cleansing, peeling/threshing, and drying

-

sorting and grading

-

processing, preservation, packaging

-

Storage

-

standardization of quality

-

distribution and/or marketing

 

Integrated (IUTP), under Article 3 (1) (c) as elaborated on in Article 3 (4), which includes both production and post-harvest operations, as described above.

 

License Requirements

Businesses engaged in the production and post-harvest activities described above are required to obtain a license, as long as they do not fall under the small-scale farmer exemption, as described below.

 

A production licence (IUTP-P) is required under Article 7 (1) for any production enterprise of 25 hectares (ha) or more, or employing 10 or more people.

 

A post-harvest license (IUTP-PP) is required under Article 7 (2) for any post-harvest enterprise with capacity in excess of that specified in Appendix 1, or yearly revenues of IDR 2.5 billion or more, or employing 10 or more people.

 

An integrated license (IUTP) is required under Article 7 (3) for any integrated enterprise of 25 ha or more, or with capacity in excess of that specified in Appendix 1, or yearly revenues of IDR 2.5 billion or more, or employing 10 or more people.

 

The maximum land area that can be covered by a production license is set at 10,000 ha under Article 9 (1), with an exception being made for Papua, where the maximum is 20,000 ha under article 9 (3). However, these maximum limits do not apply to State Owned Enterprises and Regional Owned Enterprises, in accordance with Article 9 (2).

 

The Small-Scale Farmer Exemption

Operations which do not fall within the requirements for production, post-harvest, and integrated, licenses, as set out above, are not subject to the licensing procedure, and are instead required to obtain registration (TDU-P, TDU-PP, and TDU, respectively) from the local regent/mayor, under the provisions of Article 6.

 

During the drafting of the Regulation local farmers’ associations objected to the registration requirement, saying that it is overly burdensome, and creates an additional expense. Although the registration requirement survived in the final version of the Regulation, some of the concerns were addressed by Article 6 (5), which specifies that the registration is to be free of charge.

 

License Application Procedure

Initial Licensing

The documents that have to be submitted in order to obtain a production license are enumerated in Article 11 (a to l). The documentary requirements for a post-harvest license are set out in Article 12 (a to o). And the documentary requirements for an integrated license are the superset of those in Articles 11 and 12, as specified under Article 13.

 

A consultation requirement exists under Article 18, which states that written evidence of a consultation with the local indigenous people is required if the cultivation of food crops is to be carried out on land owned by the indigenous community.

 

The use of genetically modified plants requires the submission of an opinion on the biological safety of the genetic modifications, which is to be obtained from the Commission on Biological Safety, under Article 19. Furthermore, Government Regulation No. 21 of 2005 on the Safety of Genetically Engineered Biological Products must be adhered to.

 

The application procedure for the licenses is to apply, in writing, with the required documents, as described above, to the regent/mayor (if the business location is within of one district/city, according to Article 8 (1) (a)) or the governor (if the business location spans more than one district/city or province, according to Article 8 (1) (b)) according to Article 15 (1).

 

Within 15 business days of receiving an application, a response of whether the application has been approved, deferred, or rejected must be provided. If no response is forthcoming within the 15 business-day limit, the application is deemed to have been approved, under Article 15 (3), and the relevant license issued under Article 15 (4).

 

The application is to be deferred if the requirements are not met, the deferral and the reasons for it must be provided in a written response to the applicant. At which point the applicant will have 30 work-days to meet the requirements listed in the response, or else their application will be rejected.

 

The application is to be rejected if requirements are not fulfilled, or the business activities would be counter to public order, or the Spatial Plan (RTRW) of the district/city, according to Article 17 (1).

 

If the application is approved, the license is issued by the regent/mayor (if the business location is within of one district/city, according to Article 8 (1) (a)) or the governor (if the business location spans more than one district/city or province, according to Article 8 (1) (b)).

 

License Changes

The issued licenses are valid as long as the license holder continues to be engaged in the licensed business activity, and are not transferable, under the provisions in Article 10.

 

In the event that a license holder wishes to expand the scale of operation (defined as a change in production license land area or a change in post-harvest capacity, under Article 22), such expansion has to be done by means of a partnership, according to Article 20 (1).

 

The partnership requirement involves the cooperation with large-scale farmers, small-scale farmers, and local communities for the purpose of sustainable crop cultivation; specifically in provision of raw materials, production facilities, production, processing and marketing, transportation, operations, capital investment, and other support services. The partnership agreement must be in writing, and set out such terms as specified by Article 21 (1), for a term of at least one growing season, in accordance with Article 21 (2). The agreement must be signed by both parties and the regent/mayor, or governor, or another designated official. Government Regulation No. 44 of 1997 on Partnerships contains further provisions governing the establishment and operation of partnership schemes, such as the one required in this instance.

 

A change in production land area or post-harvest capacity must meet the documentary requirements, as specified for initial licenses under Articles 11 and 12 respectively, according to Article 23.

 

If the production land area is expanded to a total of more than 25 ha, or the post-harvest capacity is expanded by more than 25%, approval from the license issuer is required under Article 24 (1) and (2), respectively. The approval application process involves an application, in writing, that includes, for production licenses, the documents specified in Article 11 (e, f, g, h, and i) and, for post-harvest licenses, the documents specified in Article 12 (g, h, i, j, k, l, and m), according to Article 24 (3). The approval review process by the regent/mayor or governor is to be guided by the Spatial Plan (RTRW) and the Detailed Spatial Plan (RDTR), under Article 24 (4). Finally, changes that involve the use of land owned by indigenous people, require written evidence that consultation has been carried out, under Article 24 (5).

 

The approval, deferral, or rejection process, including the deadlines and procedures, mirrors that for the initial licensing, discussed above, as specified in Article 25 (the 15 work day limit, which mirrors Article 15), Article 26 (the 30 work day deferral, which mirrors Article 16), and Article 27 (the rejection, which mirrors Article 17).

 

Notification

Copies of the issued licenses have to be submitted to the respective provincial governors (if issued by the regent/mayor), the affected regent/mayor(s) (if issued by the governor), and the Minister of Agriculture, specifically the Director General in charge of production or post-harvest operations, as appropriate, under Article 28.

 

License Conditions

Production license holders have to begin business activities no later than 6 months from the issuance of the license, implement the applicable environmental requirements, assist the community and local cooperatives, and report to the regent/mayor or governor after every harvest, or whenever necessary, under Article 29.

 

Post-harvest license holders have to begin business activities no later than 6 months from the issuance of the license, implement the applicable environmental requirements, assist the community and local cooperatives, and report to the regent/mayor or governor every 12 months or whenever necessary, under Article 30.

 

Integrated license holders have to comply with both of the above requirements, under Article 31.

 

The production, post-harvest, or integrated licenses that are obtained with respect to land in which the applicant has a Right to Exploit (Hak Guna Usaha / HGU), require that the licensed operations begin no later than 3 years from the issuance of the license, according to Article 14. Due to the overlap with the provisions in Articles 29 and 30, the exact operation of this time limit is left open to interpretation, as discussed in the Conclusion, below.

 

The form of the reports, required by Articles 29 and 30, as discussed above, is specified in Article 32 (1), as being in accordance with the form specified in Appendix 2. With a further requirement that the regent/mayor receiving the report has to forward it on to the to the governor, while the governor has to in turn forward the report to the Minister of Agriculture, in accordance with Article 32 (2).

 

General requirements contained in Article 33 state that the license holders must ensure the continuity of business, preservation of the environment and genetic resources, prevent the outbreak of harmful pests (organisme pengganggu tumbuhan / OPT), and prevent harm to other parties and the public interest.

 

The Provincial Government and the Regency/Municipality will provide guidance and supervision, within the scope of their authority, based on their evaluation of the above-described reports, under Article 34.

 

License holders (with the exception of farmers utilizing less than 2 ha, under Article 1 definitions 5 and 6, according to Article 36) who, in the course of their business, make use of government facilities that are subject to non-tax usage fees are obliged to pay the fees as specified by the applicable legislation, in accordance with Article 35.

 

Community Participation

General provisions concerning community participation are contained in Articles 37 and 38, with further procedures for community participation to be regulated by the regent/mayor of governor, according to Article 37 (4). The participation is conducted by means of accepting suggestions from the community, the implementation of partnerships (as per Articles 20 and 21, as discussed above), and the reporting and monitoring (as per Articles 29 and 30, as discussed above), according to Article 38.

 

Transitional

Any licenses and registrations issued prior to the coming into force of the Regulation, on 14 June 2010, will remain valid, under Article 42.

 

Foreign Investors

The Regulation addresses the licensing requirement for foreign investors in crop cultivation businesses in quite a tangential manner. The specific requirements for foreign investors are to cooperate with an Indonesian legal entity, according to Article 5 (1). And the restriction on foreign ownership is a maximum of 49%, according to Article 5 (2).

 

The, parent, Government Regulation No. 18 of 2010 on Crop Cultivation Businesses specifies, in more general terms, that Indonesian investors will continue to receive preferential treatment in carrying on crop cultivation businesses, by means of a requirement that the majority share of any such business is to be owned by Indonesian citizens, under Article 5 (2) of the Government Regulation. With foreign investors consequentially being required to cooperate with Indonesian businesses engaged in a similar line of business, and a requirement for any operating company to be incorporated in Indonesia, under Indonesian law.

 

Presidential Regulation No. 36 of 2010 on Lists of Business Sectors that are Closed to Investment and Business Sectors that are Conditionally Open to Investment (the Negative Investment List) is also synchronised with the above discussed regulations in this regard, and specifies a maximum permitted foreign ownership of 49% under Point 11 of the Attachment II to the Presidential Regulation.

 

Sanctions

The Regulation provides for, unspecified, sanctions against officials who charge a fee for the registration (under Article 6) of small-scale farmers, in accordance with Article 39.

 

The license holders are subject to a more defined sanction regime. With Article 40 (1) specifying that written warnings will be issued in case of a failure to fulfil the duties under Articles 29 (b, c, and d) and 30 (b, c, and d), namely, to implement the applicable environmental requirements, assist the community and local cooperatives, and report to the regent/mayor or governor, or the Article 33 duties, such as ensuring the continuity of business, preservation of the environment and genetic resources, prevent the outbreak of harmful pests (OPT), and prevent harm to other parties and the public interest. Two written warnings will be issued for each violation, each with a 3 month grace period, and in the event that both are ignored, the relevant license will be revoked under Article 40 (2). Upon the revocation of a production or integrated license, the revocation of the Right to Exploit (HGU) will also be made to the relevant authorities, in accordance with Article 41.

 

Conclusion

The Regulation creates a reasonably comprehensive licensing regime for crop cultivation businesses. What is left lacking, however, is any detailed regulation concerning foreign investors, with Article 5 providing, at best, a cursory discussion of the obligations and restrictions applicable to foreign investors in crop cultivation businesses.

 

License types differentiate between crop production and post-harvest businesses, with a comprehensive applicability and initial licensing as well as licence change regime being specified by the Regulation. The initial licensing and license change regimes specify an exhaustive list of the required documentation and provide for a 15 work day processing time, with automatic approval in the event of delays, creating what should be a relatively painless bureaucratic process, at least at the licensing stage.

 

The partnership requirement, applicable to expansion of land area and capacity, appears to be motivated by a desire to ensure that any small-scale farmers who are affected by the expansion (e.g. due to their lands being acquired by the expanding enterprise) are still able to retain a level of participation. This requirement, however, has the undesirable effect of creating an inconsistency in that a very minor expansion of an existing business will trigger the requirement of participating in a partnership scheme, while the creation of a new business, of much larger size, is not subject to the same partnership requirement.

 

Similarly, the community participation provisions, although partially defined in Article 38, remain somewhat vague. Thereby retaining the potential to become unduly burdensome in the event that the general nature of Article 37 is interpreted by the local authorities, by means of the power granted by Article 37 (4), to include a high level of community involvement, which may lead to additional demands on the business owner and delays in developing the business.

 

A technical issue exists with the generally applicable provisions of Articles 29 and 30, which specify that business activities have to begin within 3 months of the issuance of the license, and Article 14, which states that for license holders holding Right to Exploit (HGU) land, business operations have to begin within 3 years. The combination of these articles leaves open a question of statutory interpretation, as to whether holders of right to use land are granted an extension to begin operations, overriding the time limits in Articles 29 and 30, or whether Article 14 is simply a redundant provision, with the 3 months time limit applying to holders of right to use land as well.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info