Bill on Prevention and Eradication of Money Laundering
Overview
With context set by the recent Bank Century audit drama, the House of Representatives (‘DPR’) has begun to discuss a Bill that gives greater authority to the Financial Transaction and Reporting Analysis Center (‘PPATK’), and facilitates more aggressive action against money laundering. Listed in the 2010 Prioritized National Legislative Program, and received by the DPR in February 2010, the Bill on Prevention and Eradication of Money Laundering (“Bill”) expands the role of the PPATK to not only monitor and audit, but also to aggressively investigate suspicious transactions, suspend access to assets, and more effectively cooperate with enforcement agencies to recover proceeds of crime.
Having recently been submitted to the DPR for review and issuance as Law, this inquiry will briefly survey the Bill’s primary functions, with attention to potential discussion points in the coming parliamentary discussion.
Purpose
Expanding the authority of the PPATK is a core feature of the Bill; both to coordinate with other law enforcement institutions, and more effectively prevent money laundering in its own right. Those changes necessitate an updated legal framework, not only to give legal basis to PPATK efforts, but also to bring the law in line with international standards, as well as the heightened complexity of money laundering practices.
Expansive Definitions
‘Money laundering’ is expansively defined in Articles 3, 4, and 5 of the Bill, with each Article roughly corresponding to certain forms of participation in money laundering, and listing sanctions accountable to each. Taken together, money laundering includes (a) potentially less active roles: hiding the source, location, purpose of usage, or ownership of suspicious assets, and (b) potentially more active roles; placing, paying, expending, exchanging, taking abroad, transferring, accepting, giving, or even simply using assets suspected of deriving from or being the proceeds of crime.
‘Proceeds of crime’ are defined in Article 2 of the Bill, and, from forestry to fraud, cover an incredibly wide spectrum of source activities.
‘Suspicious financial transactions’ are defined in Article 1 (3) as, in short, those that: (a) deviate from the profile, characteristic, or usual transaction pattern of a customer; (b) are suspected of being transacted in order to avoid reporting obligations (see below); (c) use assets that are suspected of being derived from the proceeds of criminal acts, or; (d) are requested by the PPATK.
Reporting Obligations
In rather dramatic contrast to the existing legal framework set out in Law No. 15 of 2002 (as amended by Law No. 25 of 2003), which only extends reporting obligations to traditional financial institutions, the proposed Bill includes a series of ‘Designated Non-Financial Businesses and Professions’ in the list of those who must report certain-sized, certain-typed transactions to the PPATK.
Among others listed in Article 15 (1) of the Bill, Non-Financial Businesses and Professions include lawyers, financial consultants, notaries, Land Deed Officials, realtors, automotive dealers, jewelry sellers, art and antique sellers, and auction houses. Any transaction they conduct at or above a value of IDR 500 million - or its equivalent in assets - must be reported to the PPATK within 14 days of concluding the transaction.
Financial institutions include banks, financiers, investment companies, and so on. They are obliged to report all cash transactions valued at or above IDR 500 million, as well as all foreign exchange transactions to the PPATK within 14 days from transaction.
For both financial institutions and non-financial counterparts, suspicious transactions must be reported within 7 days.
Responding to issues around confidentiality (e.g., between a lawyer and their client), Article 27 of the Bill exempts professional secrecy obligations from all parties with information relating to suspicious transactions, whilst Article 28 goes on to provide immunity against either criminal or civil lawsuits.
Expanding PPATK Authority
General
The PPATK is generally able to (a) collect data and disseminate data, (b) provide guidance on the identification of suspicious transactions, (c) coordinate preventive efforts against money laundering with relevant domestic and international agencies, and (d) provide recommendations to the government, among other things.
Data Collection
Rather notably, the investigative authority of the PPATK has been expanded to allow the organization to request, and obtain data and information from ‘public bodies’ and ‘private institutions’ (Article 40 (1a)). Such parties, presumably including all state agencies (e.g., police) and private companies (e.g., law firms), are exempted from responsibilities towards confidentiality (Article 40 (2)). Those provisions allow PPATK investigations practically unlimited access to data and information.
Previously, the PPATK could only request information and data from financial institutions, and only that relating to “the development of investigations” from other law enforcement agencies (Article 27 (1a, 1b) of Law No. 15 of 2002, as amended by Law No. 25 of 2003). The limits of that authority were made clear during the Bank Century audit, when the PPATK in conjunction with the Supreme Audit Agency (‘BPK’) were unable to (as one example) access information retained by police as evidence.
Blocking Access to Accounts
According to Article 44 (g) of the Bill, the PPATK is, upon suspicion of money laundering, granted authority to block access to assets suspected of deriving from criminal acts. Conditions warranting the PPATK to freeze assets, as listed in Article 64 (2), chiefly include the suspicion that the assets are the result of, or will be used for criminal acts, or that the origin of the assets cannot be explained - either by the owner or otherwise.
Within 30 days of assets being frozen, the PPATK must publicize that action; the Bill states that the reason for this is to entitle third party objections.
Assets may only be frozen for a 90-day timeframe, during which time the PPATK may investigate further, and coordinate an appropriate response with other institutions, such as the Corruption Eradication Commission, Police, Attorney Generals Office, and so on.
Role in Criminal Proceedings
Although the autonomy of the PPATK in data collection and asset suspension is certainly bolstered, it continues to play at most a supporting role in criminal proceedings, which are referred to the Indonesian Criminal Procedural Code (‘KUHAP’) and related Laws. To that extent, apart from being able to freeze assets, the role of the PPATK is essentially evidentiary.
Sanctions
Sanctions are provided throughout the Bill for violations associated with each of its provisions.
Chief amongst sanctions provided in the Bill are those relating to money laundering activity. Using an assessment in Article 6 (2), the Bill differentiates between whether sanctions are to be imposed on individuals, or on corporations.
For individuals, depending on the type of money laundering activity, Articles 3, 4, and 5 set out a range of sanctions, including: imprisonment between 1 and 20 years, and criminal fines between IDR 50 million and IDR 10 billion.
For corporations, depending on the type of money laundering activity, Articles 7, 8, and 9 set out a range of sanctions, which, in short, include: criminal fine between IDR 1 billion and IDR 100 billion (or seizure of assets corresponding to the fine’s value); revoked business license; corporate dissolution or takeover; asset confiscation, and; anything else included in a judge’s decision.
Reporting obligation failures are also associated with significant sanctions, albeit of the administrative variant; warnings, publicity, administrative fines, and so on. Moreover, reporting obligations could well arouse PPATK suspicion, which could in turn lead to frozen assets.
Recovering the Proceeds of Crime?
Although money laundering is in itself a criminal act, and may simply be employed to hide or otherwise disguise legitimate assets, it often overlaps with proceeds of other criminal activities - which may well be identified by the PPATK in the identification of money laundering. However, whether it is the PPATK or the Police, there is no Law that actually provides for the state recovery of those assets.
A Bill on recovering the proceeds of crime is on the 2010 - 2014 National Legislative Program: it may also have relevance to the PPATK with respect to authorities, and available sanctions.
Enforcement Date
Given that the Bill is included in the 2010 Prioritized National Legislation Program, an optimistic outlook is that it will be passed as Law by the end of the year.
Conclusion
The Bill clearly intends to give the PPATK an expanded, more active role in investigating, preventing, and combating money laundering. It does this in many ways, among other things by (1) giving authority to the PPATK to demand information from both state institutions and private organizations, (2) significantly widening the spectrum of parties that are obliged to report transactions to the PPATK, and (3) allowing the PPATK to freeze assets it suspects of being proceeds of crime, or involved in money laundering. Those modifications are quite substantial, and are likely to attract debate as discussion of the Bill moves forward at the DPR. Although the Bill details sanctions for violations of a wide variety of provisions, ultimately enforcement of those sanctions is outside the realm of PPATK operations, and relies upon inter-agency, and international cooperation.
With context set by the recent Bank Century audit drama, the House of Representatives (‘DPR’) has begun to discuss a Bill that gives greater authority to the Financial Transaction and Reporting Analysis Center (‘PPATK’), and facilitates more aggressive action against money laundering. Listed in the 2010 Prioritized National Legislative Program, and received by the DPR in February 2010, the Bill on Prevention and Eradication of Money Laundering (“Bill”) expands the role of the PPATK to not only monitor and audit, but also to aggressively investigate suspicious transactions, suspend access to assets, and more effectively cooperate with enforcement agencies to recover proceeds of crime.
Having recently been submitted to the DPR for review and issuance as Law, this inquiry will briefly survey the Bill’s primary functions, with attention to potential discussion points in the coming parliamentary discussion.
Purpose
Expanding the authority of the PPATK is a core feature of the Bill; both to coordinate with other law enforcement institutions, and more effectively prevent money laundering in its own right. Those changes necessitate an updated legal framework, not only to give legal basis to PPATK efforts, but also to bring the law in line with international standards, as well as the heightened complexity of money laundering practices.
Expansive Definitions
‘Money laundering’ is expansively defined in Articles 3, 4, and 5 of the Bill, with each Article roughly corresponding to certain forms of participation in money laundering, and listing sanctions accountable to each. Taken together, money laundering includes (a) potentially less active roles: hiding the source, location, purpose of usage, or ownership of suspicious assets, and (b) potentially more active roles; placing, paying, expending, exchanging, taking abroad, transferring, accepting, giving, or even simply using assets suspected of deriving from or being the proceeds of crime.
‘Proceeds of crime’ are defined in Article 2 of the Bill, and, from forestry to fraud, cover an incredibly wide spectrum of source activities.
‘Suspicious financial transactions’ are defined in Article 1 (3) as, in short, those that: (a) deviate from the profile, characteristic, or usual transaction pattern of a customer; (b) are suspected of being transacted in order to avoid reporting obligations (see below); (c) use assets that are suspected of being derived from the proceeds of criminal acts, or; (d) are requested by the PPATK.
Reporting Obligations
In rather dramatic contrast to the existing legal framework set out in Law No. 15 of 2002 (as amended by Law No. 25 of 2003), which only extends reporting obligations to traditional financial institutions, the proposed Bill includes a series of ‘Designated Non-Financial Businesses and Professions’ in the list of those who must report certain-sized, certain-typed transactions to the PPATK.
Among others listed in Article 15 (1) of the Bill, Non-Financial Businesses and Professions include lawyers, financial consultants, notaries, Land Deed Officials, realtors, automotive dealers, jewelry sellers, art and antique sellers, and auction houses. Any transaction they conduct at or above a value of IDR 500 million - or its equivalent in assets - must be reported to the PPATK within 14 days of concluding the transaction.
Financial institutions include banks, financiers, investment companies, and so on. They are obliged to report all cash transactions valued at or above IDR 500 million, as well as all foreign exchange transactions to the PPATK within 14 days from transaction.
For both financial institutions and non-financial counterparts, suspicious transactions must be reported within 7 days.
Responding to issues around confidentiality (e.g., between a lawyer and their client), Article 27 of the Bill exempts professional secrecy obligations from all parties with information relating to suspicious transactions, whilst Article 28 goes on to provide immunity against either criminal or civil lawsuits.
Expanding PPATK Authority
General
The PPATK is generally able to (a) collect data and disseminate data, (b) provide guidance on the identification of suspicious transactions, (c) coordinate preventive efforts against money laundering with relevant domestic and international agencies, and (d) provide recommendations to the government, among other things.
Data Collection
Rather notably, the investigative authority of the PPATK has been expanded to allow the organization to request, and obtain data and information from ‘public bodies’ and ‘private institutions’ (Article 40 (1a)). Such parties, presumably including all state agencies (e.g., police) and private companies (e.g., law firms), are exempted from responsibilities towards confidentiality (Article 40 (2)). Those provisions allow PPATK investigations practically unlimited access to data and information.
Previously, the PPATK could only request information and data from financial institutions, and only that relating to “the development of investigations” from other law enforcement agencies (Article 27 (1a, 1b) of Law No. 15 of 2002, as amended by Law No. 25 of 2003). The limits of that authority were made clear during the Bank Century audit, when the PPATK in conjunction with the Supreme Audit Agency (‘BPK’) were unable to (as one example) access information retained by police as evidence.
Blocking Access to Accounts
According to Article 44 (g) of the Bill, the PPATK is, upon suspicion of money laundering, granted authority to block access to assets suspected of deriving from criminal acts. Conditions warranting the PPATK to freeze assets, as listed in Article 64 (2), chiefly include the suspicion that the assets are the result of, or will be used for criminal acts, or that the origin of the assets cannot be explained - either by the owner or otherwise.
Within 30 days of assets being frozen, the PPATK must publicize that action; the Bill states that the reason for this is to entitle third party objections.
Assets may only be frozen for a 90-day timeframe, during which time the PPATK may investigate further, and coordinate an appropriate response with other institutions, such as the Corruption Eradication Commission, Police, Attorney Generals Office, and so on.
Role in Criminal Proceedings
Although the autonomy of the PPATK in data collection and asset suspension is certainly bolstered, it continues to play at most a supporting role in criminal proceedings, which are referred to the Indonesian Criminal Procedural Code (‘KUHAP’) and related Laws. To that extent, apart from being able to freeze assets, the role of the PPATK is essentially evidentiary.
Sanctions
Sanctions are provided throughout the Bill for violations associated with each of its provisions.
Chief amongst sanctions provided in the Bill are those relating to money laundering activity. Using an assessment in Article 6 (2), the Bill differentiates between whether sanctions are to be imposed on individuals, or on corporations.
For individuals, depending on the type of money laundering activity, Articles 3, 4, and 5 set out a range of sanctions, including: imprisonment between 1 and 20 years, and criminal fines between IDR 50 million and IDR 10 billion.
For corporations, depending on the type of money laundering activity, Articles 7, 8, and 9 set out a range of sanctions, which, in short, include: criminal fine between IDR 1 billion and IDR 100 billion (or seizure of assets corresponding to the fine’s value); revoked business license; corporate dissolution or takeover; asset confiscation, and; anything else included in a judge’s decision.
Reporting obligation failures are also associated with significant sanctions, albeit of the administrative variant; warnings, publicity, administrative fines, and so on. Moreover, reporting obligations could well arouse PPATK suspicion, which could in turn lead to frozen assets.
Recovering the Proceeds of Crime?
Although money laundering is in itself a criminal act, and may simply be employed to hide or otherwise disguise legitimate assets, it often overlaps with proceeds of other criminal activities - which may well be identified by the PPATK in the identification of money laundering. However, whether it is the PPATK or the Police, there is no Law that actually provides for the state recovery of those assets.
A Bill on recovering the proceeds of crime is on the 2010 - 2014 National Legislative Program: it may also have relevance to the PPATK with respect to authorities, and available sanctions.
Enforcement Date
Given that the Bill is included in the 2010 Prioritized National Legislation Program, an optimistic outlook is that it will be passed as Law by the end of the year.
Conclusion
The Bill clearly intends to give the PPATK an expanded, more active role in investigating, preventing, and combating money laundering. It does this in many ways, among other things by (1) giving authority to the PPATK to demand information from both state institutions and private organizations, (2) significantly widening the spectrum of parties that are obliged to report transactions to the PPATK, and (3) allowing the PPATK to freeze assets it suspects of being proceeds of crime, or involved in money laundering. Those modifications are quite substantial, and are likely to attract debate as discussion of the Bill moves forward at the DPR. Although the Bill details sanctions for violations of a wide variety of provisions, ultimately enforcement of those sanctions is outside the realm of PPATK operations, and relies upon inter-agency, and international cooperation.