Draft Government Regulation on Merger and Acquisition Post-Notification
Overview
Mandatory pre-notification to the Commission for Supervision of Business Competition (‘KPPU’) of certain-sized mergers and acquisitions prior to legally binding agreement was once - but is no longer - a feature of the Draft Government Regulation to implement Articles 28 (3) and 29 (2) of Law No. 5 of 1999 on Prohibition of Monopolistic and Unfair Business Practices (“Anti-Monopoly Law”). The KPPU recently submitted the Draft to the State Secretariat Office for interdepartmental approval, indicating that unless changes are demanded by other agencies, it has been finalized; presumably to be issued shortly by the President.
This Indonesian Law Digest will survey the latest Draft Government Regulation (available on the KPPU website), and identify its final purpose in light of the removal of pre-notification.
For a review of the previous Draft Government Regulation, see: ILB No. 1453 9/7/2010.
Purpose
Lacking pre-notification, the current Draft Government Regulation’s purpose is essentially to:
-
Specify merger and acquisition sizes that must be notified to the KPPU within 30 days of legally-binding agreement;
-
Detail the post-notification procedure, and;
-
Elaborate the KPPU assessment used to subsequently approve or reject an agreement.
Context of Anti-Monopoly Law Implementation
Articles 28 and 29 of the Anti-Monopoly Law govern mergers and acquisitions in Indonesia: they prohibit actions that cause monopolistic or unfair business practices, and mandate notification of certain-sized of agreements to the KPPU within 30 days of completion.
Article 28 (3) calls for further detail on the types of mergers and acquisitions that can be prohibited.
Article 29 (2) demands specification of the size - in terms of value of assets and sales - of mergers and acquisitions that must be notified to the KPPU, and additional procedures relating to the notification procedure.
Latest Draft Government Regulation
Notification
Mergers and acquisitions that must be notified to the KPPU are those that have a combined value of assets of IDR 2.5 trillion, or combined value of sales of IDR 5 trillion. For banks, the threshold is higher; transactions need only be reported when a transaction’s combined value of assets exceeds IDR 20 trillion. These notification thresholds remain consistent with the previous Draft.
Within 30 days of legally-binding agreement being met, mergers or acquisitions at or exceeding those sizes must be reported to the KPPU. The form for notification will be provided by the KPPU, and will require, among others: (a) company name, address, profile, and relevant executive names; (b) merger plan summary, and; (c) statement of the combined value of assets or sales.
As one exception to the aforementioned requirements, transactions between affiliated companies - those who are controlled by the same party or group - will not need to be notified to the KPPU, whatever their size.
Prohibition
Apart from outright conspiracy, mergers and acquisitions that are prohibited are essentially those that the KPPU disapproves of, with respect to its assessment of potential for monopolistic and unfair business practices.
KPPU Assessment
The KPPU will seek to discern if a merger or acquisition leads to: excessive market control, oligopolistic practices, price fixing, territory division, cartel formation, abuse of dominant position, and vertical integration, among other things.
Assessment of market and consumer threat will focus on, among others, market concentration, market entry barriers, anti-competitive behavior, efficiency, and potential to cause a bankruptcy. During this investigation, information from executives and others (e.g., suppliers, competitors, specialists) may be requested by the KPPU.
KPPU Follow-Up
Within 90 days of receiving notification, the KPPU will respond with approval or rejection of the merger or acquisition.
Rejection of a post-notification will, as is said in Article 9 (4) of the latest Draft, lead the KPPU to “…take action in accordance with their authority,” or in other words, issue a KPPU Decision. Though not explicitly stated, such Decisions can be appealed through the court system, starting with the court of first instance.
Sanctions
Parties failing to notify the KPPU within the 30-day post-transaction window will be subject to sanctions of IDR 1 billion per day, up to a maximum of IDR 25 billion.
As with the previous Draft, further administrative sanctions are made available, but referred to the Anti-Monopoly Law. Articles 47 to 49 of that Law empower the KPPU to, among other things, annul contracts, order the suspension of activities, revoke a business license, and impose criminal fines between IDR 25 and 100 billion.
Mandatory Pre-notification
The core difference between the previous and current Draft Government Regulation is the removal of provisions mandating pre-notification to the KPPU before the transaction is finalized.
Article 16 (now removed) from the previous Draft held that, if the transaction met the same specified value of assets or sales, notification to the KPPU was mandatory within 30 days of a preliminary agreement (e.g., Memorandum of Understanding). The KPPU could subsequently (a) approve the agreement, almost guaranteeing it legal certainty, or (b) reject it, preventing market-undermining agreements from legal formation - or at least creating a basis for sanctioning the deal if it did proceed.
Context for introducing pre-notification to the Draft is among other things set by enormous recent antitrust cases against the Singaporean firm, Temasek Holdings, and the French retailer, Carrefour. In short, arduous proceedings in both cases lent support to the perception that Indonesia’s business climate lacks legal certainty, due in part to conflicting indications of approval from regulators. Appreciating that perspective, early intervention of the KPPU in the formation of potentially problematic agreements can be weighed against criticism of overbearing market regulation.
On the other hand, Article 29 (1) of the Anti-Monopoly Law only explicitly speaks of mandatory notification to the KPPU within 30 days of a completed merger or acquisition: in other words, a post-notification procedure.
Article 29 (2) only explicitly states that subsequent Government Regulation will implement the notification procedure referred to in the previous paragraph: in other words, elaboration of the 30-day post-notification procedure.
Whether the KPPU is conferred authority to introduce a mandatory pre-notification procedure by those provisions is dubious, and implicit at best.
Voluntary Pre-Notification
Voluntary pre-notification to the KPPU (i.e., consultation) remains a feature of the Draft (Articles 10 & 11), and will not have legally binding outcomes. The procedures for this are referred to KPPU Regulation No. 1 of 2009 on Pre-Notification of Mergers, Consolidations, and Acquisitions. For a brief review, see: ILD No. 141 29/1/2010.
Implementation Issue
Aside from the Anti-Monopoly Law, Article 134 of Law No. 40 of 2007 on Limited Liability Companies also calls for implementing Government Regulation for KPPU post-notification of mergers and acquisitions. However, the preamble of the current Draft Government Regulation states only that it implements Articles 28 (3) and 29 (2) of the Anti-Monopoly Law.
That could be problematic if a second Government Regulation were to be issued in response to Article 134 of Law No. 40 of 2007: the principle of lex posteriori derogat lex priori - that recent regulation replaces older regulation - would ostensibly nullify the current Government Regulation. The solution would be to implement both Law’s provisions in the current regulation.
Enforcement
Officials have been loath to confirm a date of issuance for this Draft Government Regulation. Given that it has reached the State Secretariat Office (i.e., the final step before the President’s signature), it will presumably be issued in the relatively near future.
Conclusion
Ten years on from the Anti-Monopoly Law’s call in Articles 28 (3) and 29 (2) for implementation of merger and acquisition notification procedures, a Government Regulation will soon be issued to implement the requisite into reality. Agreements between non-affiliated companies with combined value of assets or sales at IDR 2.5 or 5 trillion respectively will need to be notified to the KPPU within 30 days of completion: that much is clear, and is unlikely to change through interdepartmental discussion.
Once notified, the KPPU is in a position to, upon assessment, approve and subsequently monitor the business arrangement, or reject and subsequently sanction the business arrangement. Although pre-notification was previously mandatory, legal certainty for a merger or acquisition can still be practically guaranteed if parties submit to voluntary consultation with the KPPU, and the risk of arduous court proceedings is taken on by businesses declining to do so.
Mandatory pre-notification to the Commission for Supervision of Business Competition (‘KPPU’) of certain-sized mergers and acquisitions prior to legally binding agreement was once - but is no longer - a feature of the Draft Government Regulation to implement Articles 28 (3) and 29 (2) of Law No. 5 of 1999 on Prohibition of Monopolistic and Unfair Business Practices (“Anti-Monopoly Law”). The KPPU recently submitted the Draft to the State Secretariat Office for interdepartmental approval, indicating that unless changes are demanded by other agencies, it has been finalized; presumably to be issued shortly by the President.
This Indonesian Law Digest will survey the latest Draft Government Regulation (available on the KPPU website), and identify its final purpose in light of the removal of pre-notification.
For a review of the previous Draft Government Regulation, see: ILB No. 1453 9/7/2010.
Purpose
Lacking pre-notification, the current Draft Government Regulation’s purpose is essentially to:
-
Specify merger and acquisition sizes that must be notified to the KPPU within 30 days of legally-binding agreement;
-
Detail the post-notification procedure, and;
-
Elaborate the KPPU assessment used to subsequently approve or reject an agreement.
Context of Anti-Monopoly Law Implementation
Articles 28 and 29 of the Anti-Monopoly Law govern mergers and acquisitions in Indonesia: they prohibit actions that cause monopolistic or unfair business practices, and mandate notification of certain-sized of agreements to the KPPU within 30 days of completion.
Article 28 (3) calls for further detail on the types of mergers and acquisitions that can be prohibited.
Article 29 (2) demands specification of the size - in terms of value of assets and sales - of mergers and acquisitions that must be notified to the KPPU, and additional procedures relating to the notification procedure.
Latest Draft Government Regulation
Notification
Mergers and acquisitions that must be notified to the KPPU are those that have a combined value of assets of IDR 2.5 trillion, or combined value of sales of IDR 5 trillion. For banks, the threshold is higher; transactions need only be reported when a transaction’s combined value of assets exceeds IDR 20 trillion. These notification thresholds remain consistent with the previous Draft.
Within 30 days of legally-binding agreement being met, mergers or acquisitions at or exceeding those sizes must be reported to the KPPU. The form for notification will be provided by the KPPU, and will require, among others: (a) company name, address, profile, and relevant executive names; (b) merger plan summary, and; (c) statement of the combined value of assets or sales.
As one exception to the aforementioned requirements, transactions between affiliated companies - those who are controlled by the same party or group - will not need to be notified to the KPPU, whatever their size.
Prohibition
Apart from outright conspiracy, mergers and acquisitions that are prohibited are essentially those that the KPPU disapproves of, with respect to its assessment of potential for monopolistic and unfair business practices.
KPPU Assessment
The KPPU will seek to discern if a merger or acquisition leads to: excessive market control, oligopolistic practices, price fixing, territory division, cartel formation, abuse of dominant position, and vertical integration, among other things.
Assessment of market and consumer threat will focus on, among others, market concentration, market entry barriers, anti-competitive behavior, efficiency, and potential to cause a bankruptcy. During this investigation, information from executives and others (e.g., suppliers, competitors, specialists) may be requested by the KPPU.
KPPU Follow-Up
Within 90 days of receiving notification, the KPPU will respond with approval or rejection of the merger or acquisition.
Rejection of a post-notification will, as is said in Article 9 (4) of the latest Draft, lead the KPPU to “…take action in accordance with their authority,” or in other words, issue a KPPU Decision. Though not explicitly stated, such Decisions can be appealed through the court system, starting with the court of first instance.
Sanctions
Parties failing to notify the KPPU within the 30-day post-transaction window will be subject to sanctions of IDR 1 billion per day, up to a maximum of IDR 25 billion.
As with the previous Draft, further administrative sanctions are made available, but referred to the Anti-Monopoly Law. Articles 47 to 49 of that Law empower the KPPU to, among other things, annul contracts, order the suspension of activities, revoke a business license, and impose criminal fines between IDR 25 and 100 billion.
Mandatory Pre-notification
The core difference between the previous and current Draft Government Regulation is the removal of provisions mandating pre-notification to the KPPU before the transaction is finalized.
Article 16 (now removed) from the previous Draft held that, if the transaction met the same specified value of assets or sales, notification to the KPPU was mandatory within 30 days of a preliminary agreement (e.g., Memorandum of Understanding). The KPPU could subsequently (a) approve the agreement, almost guaranteeing it legal certainty, or (b) reject it, preventing market-undermining agreements from legal formation - or at least creating a basis for sanctioning the deal if it did proceed.
Context for introducing pre-notification to the Draft is among other things set by enormous recent antitrust cases against the Singaporean firm, Temasek Holdings, and the French retailer, Carrefour. In short, arduous proceedings in both cases lent support to the perception that Indonesia’s business climate lacks legal certainty, due in part to conflicting indications of approval from regulators. Appreciating that perspective, early intervention of the KPPU in the formation of potentially problematic agreements can be weighed against criticism of overbearing market regulation.
On the other hand, Article 29 (1) of the Anti-Monopoly Law only explicitly speaks of mandatory notification to the KPPU within 30 days of a completed merger or acquisition: in other words, a post-notification procedure.
Article 29 (2) only explicitly states that subsequent Government Regulation will implement the notification procedure referred to in the previous paragraph: in other words, elaboration of the 30-day post-notification procedure.
Whether the KPPU is conferred authority to introduce a mandatory pre-notification procedure by those provisions is dubious, and implicit at best.
Voluntary Pre-Notification
Voluntary pre-notification to the KPPU (i.e., consultation) remains a feature of the Draft (Articles 10 & 11), and will not have legally binding outcomes. The procedures for this are referred to KPPU Regulation No. 1 of 2009 on Pre-Notification of Mergers, Consolidations, and Acquisitions. For a brief review, see: ILD No. 141 29/1/2010.
Implementation Issue
Aside from the Anti-Monopoly Law, Article 134 of Law No. 40 of 2007 on Limited Liability Companies also calls for implementing Government Regulation for KPPU post-notification of mergers and acquisitions. However, the preamble of the current Draft Government Regulation states only that it implements Articles 28 (3) and 29 (2) of the Anti-Monopoly Law.
That could be problematic if a second Government Regulation were to be issued in response to Article 134 of Law No. 40 of 2007: the principle of lex posteriori derogat lex priori - that recent regulation replaces older regulation - would ostensibly nullify the current Government Regulation. The solution would be to implement both Law’s provisions in the current regulation.
Enforcement
Officials have been loath to confirm a date of issuance for this Draft Government Regulation. Given that it has reached the State Secretariat Office (i.e., the final step before the President’s signature), it will presumably be issued in the relatively near future.
Conclusion
Ten years on from the Anti-Monopoly Law’s call in Articles 28 (3) and 29 (2) for implementation of merger and acquisition notification procedures, a Government Regulation will soon be issued to implement the requisite into reality. Agreements between non-affiliated companies with combined value of assets or sales at IDR 2.5 or 5 trillion respectively will need to be notified to the KPPU within 30 days of completion: that much is clear, and is unlikely to change through interdepartmental discussion.
Once notified, the KPPU is in a position to, upon assessment, approve and subsequently monitor the business arrangement, or reject and subsequently sanction the business arrangement. Although pre-notification was previously mandatory, legal certainty for a merger or acquisition can still be practically guaranteed if parties submit to voluntary consultation with the KPPU, and the risk of arduous court proceedings is taken on by businesses declining to do so.