Applying Prudential Banking Principles to Commercial Bank Promotion of Offshore Financial Products
Overview
As part of a series of regulations to prevent excessive financial losses to consumers from increasingly complex, risky investments, Bank Indonesia recently issued Regulation No. 12/9/PBI/2010 (“Regulation”); it instructs commercial banks (bank umum) to apply ‘Prudential Banking Principles’ in the promotion of offshore financial products to Indonesian customers. Prudential Banking Principles are generally a set of measures for commercial banks, including conducting due diligence research on the financial products they endorse, clear reminders to customers of the risks involved, and so on.
The Regulation additionally regulates the methods for promotion of offshore financial products, what sorts of financial products can be promoted, and the types of customers eligible to be offered such products.
This Indonesian Law Digest will review notable features of the Regulation, with attention to implications for commercial banks engaged in the promotion of offshore financial products.
Purpose
Bank Indonesia seeks to issue formal protection to customers of commercial banks that are engaging in investment, but who are less experienced or informed about certain types of financial engagement.
Definitions
‘Offshore financial products’ are foreign-issued investment instruments, and are classified into two types: securities, and non-securities.
‘Promotional activities’ include both direct and indirect activities conducted by either Indonesian commercial banks, or branches of foreign banks operating in Indonesia, that involve:
(1)
Follow-ups on the requests of local customers on their preference for certain offshore investments;
(2)
Offers of an offshore financial product to a bank customer or potential customer, in whatever means that might persuade the buyer to buy such a product, or;
(3)
Referrals to another local or foreign bank’s offshore financial products or services.
Basic Requirements for Offshore Products Promotional Activities
A series of requirements must be met prior to the promotion of an offshore financial product. These are extended to the promoting bank, the product itself, and the issuing institution.
Promoting Banks Requirements
Approval from Bank Indonesia is the fundamental requisite for commercial banks to begin promoting offshore financial products. Specifically for commercial banks wishing to promote securities product, the bank must abide by all laws and regulations, with specific reference to those of the Capital Market and Financial Institution Supervisory Board (‘Bapepam-LK’).
The application for approval must include details and documents set out in Article 17 (2) of the Regulation, and among other requirements have already been approved by Bank Indonesia as a Foreign Exchange Bank (i.e., approved to conduct foreign exchange banking activities). Bank Indonesia will decide upon applications within 60 days of receiving the application and supporting documents.
Offshore Products Requirements
Offshore financial products must (a) be reported to Bank Indonesia by the commercial bank seeking to promote them, and (b) satisfy requirements by the authorized state agency in the country of origin. Additional requirements for securities and non-securities include:
Securities offshore investment instruments must be registered with Bapepam-LK.
Non-securities offshore investment instruments must additionally be structured products, and be issued by a foreign bank that has a branch office in Indonesia.
Issuing Institutions Requirements
Foreign issuers of financial products must enter an agreement with the promoting commercial bank in Indonesia, in accordance with terms and conditions set out in Article 10 (3) of the Regulation, which include rights and obligations of both parties, the agreement’s timeframe, a termination clause, and so on. The issuing party must also be licensed with its relevant national authority, and be monitored by that same authority.
Banking Customers Classification
In keeping with previous Bank Indonesia regulations relating to Prudential Banking Principles, customers are to be differentiated depending on certain characteristics (i.e., understanding of risks, and capital capacity). Article 5 of the Regulation defines customers who are approved to engage with offshore financial products as Non-Retail Customers: either (a) companies with capital of at least IDR 20 billion, and 36 consistent years of experience in business, or (b) single individuals with over IDR 5 billion in assets.
Risk Management
In keeping with Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 5/8/PBI/2003 (as amended by Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 11/25/PBI/2009) on Implementation of Risk Management for Commercial Banks, the Regulation requires commercial banks to apply risk management when promoting offshore financial products. ‘Risk management’ includes:
1.
Active supervision by the Board of Commissioners and Directors;
2.
Policy and procedures relating to risk-taking and promotional activities;
3.
Risk identification, measurement, oversight, and control processes, and;
4.
Other internal controls, such as evaluating and auditing the activities of related offshore financial product promoters.
Prudential Banking Measures
Chapter V of the Regulation sets out most substantive details around Prudential Banking Principles. Concretely, they include implementation of ‘Know Your Customer’ principles and diligence procedures, and Bank Indonesia’s ability to intervene in offshore financial product promotion that is exceedingly risky or violates regulation. Less concretely, they are reflected by not indicating to customers that profits in any amount are certain, that redemption of the products is guaranteed, or that the products are those of the commercial bank when in fact they are offshore products, among other things (Article 15 (1)).
Although not included in Chapter V, Article 14 of the Regulation also stipulates that diligence must be conducted on all offshore financial products, including risk assessment of the product and the issuing institution.
Reporting Obligation
For oversight purposes, the Regulation obligates commercial banks to report to Bank Indonesia when they plan to issue new offshore financial products, and when they are offering an offshore financial product for the first time. They must also submit monthly reports on promotional activities and the status of related offshore financial products.
Status of Existing Offshore Products Promotion Banks
Banks that are already engaged in the promotion of offshore financial products must comply with the provisions of this Regulation by 29 September 2010. Responsibilities could well include applying for an in-principle approval from Bank Indonesia in order to remain in operation.
Sanctions
Sanctions that will be imposed for violation of the provisions of the Regulation are generally administrative, and notably include written warnings, suspension or revocation of bank business licenses, and termination of bank executives, among others.
Enforcement Date
The Regulation has been in force since 29 June 2010.
Conclusion
Bank Indonesia, by issuing this regulation, (a) prevents the entry of smaller-sized ‘retail’ customers into offshore financial product markets (at least by way of commercial banks), and (b) seeks to mitigate excessive risk being taken on by ‘non-retail’ customers by mandating central bank approval of financial products to be promoted in Indonesia, and regulating supervision of product performance.
Although the Regulation is comprehensive, further clarity is anticipated by subsequent implementing regulation – typically taking form as a Bank Indonesia Circular Letter. As one example, Article 14 necessitates that commercial banks ‘investigate’ any offshore financial product it will promote to its customers, but does not explicitly state what processes are required by this investigation. Otherwise, the provisions appear to be executable in fairly straightforward manner.
As part of a series of regulations to prevent excessive financial losses to consumers from increasingly complex, risky investments, Bank Indonesia recently issued Regulation No. 12/9/PBI/2010 (“Regulation”); it instructs commercial banks (bank umum) to apply ‘Prudential Banking Principles’ in the promotion of offshore financial products to Indonesian customers. Prudential Banking Principles are generally a set of measures for commercial banks, including conducting due diligence research on the financial products they endorse, clear reminders to customers of the risks involved, and so on.
The Regulation additionally regulates the methods for promotion of offshore financial products, what sorts of financial products can be promoted, and the types of customers eligible to be offered such products.
This Indonesian Law Digest will review notable features of the Regulation, with attention to implications for commercial banks engaged in the promotion of offshore financial products.
Purpose
Bank Indonesia seeks to issue formal protection to customers of commercial banks that are engaging in investment, but who are less experienced or informed about certain types of financial engagement.
Definitions
‘Offshore financial products’ are foreign-issued investment instruments, and are classified into two types: securities, and non-securities.
‘Promotional activities’ include both direct and indirect activities conducted by either Indonesian commercial banks, or branches of foreign banks operating in Indonesia, that involve:
(1)
Follow-ups on the requests of local customers on their preference for certain offshore investments;
(2)
Offers of an offshore financial product to a bank customer or potential customer, in whatever means that might persuade the buyer to buy such a product, or;
(3)
Referrals to another local or foreign bank’s offshore financial products or services.
Basic Requirements for Offshore Products Promotional Activities
A series of requirements must be met prior to the promotion of an offshore financial product. These are extended to the promoting bank, the product itself, and the issuing institution.
Promoting Banks Requirements
Approval from Bank Indonesia is the fundamental requisite for commercial banks to begin promoting offshore financial products. Specifically for commercial banks wishing to promote securities product, the bank must abide by all laws and regulations, with specific reference to those of the Capital Market and Financial Institution Supervisory Board (‘Bapepam-LK’).
The application for approval must include details and documents set out in Article 17 (2) of the Regulation, and among other requirements have already been approved by Bank Indonesia as a Foreign Exchange Bank (i.e., approved to conduct foreign exchange banking activities). Bank Indonesia will decide upon applications within 60 days of receiving the application and supporting documents.
Offshore Products Requirements
Offshore financial products must (a) be reported to Bank Indonesia by the commercial bank seeking to promote them, and (b) satisfy requirements by the authorized state agency in the country of origin. Additional requirements for securities and non-securities include:
Securities offshore investment instruments must be registered with Bapepam-LK.
Non-securities offshore investment instruments must additionally be structured products, and be issued by a foreign bank that has a branch office in Indonesia.
Issuing Institutions Requirements
Foreign issuers of financial products must enter an agreement with the promoting commercial bank in Indonesia, in accordance with terms and conditions set out in Article 10 (3) of the Regulation, which include rights and obligations of both parties, the agreement’s timeframe, a termination clause, and so on. The issuing party must also be licensed with its relevant national authority, and be monitored by that same authority.
Banking Customers Classification
In keeping with previous Bank Indonesia regulations relating to Prudential Banking Principles, customers are to be differentiated depending on certain characteristics (i.e., understanding of risks, and capital capacity). Article 5 of the Regulation defines customers who are approved to engage with offshore financial products as Non-Retail Customers: either (a) companies with capital of at least IDR 20 billion, and 36 consistent years of experience in business, or (b) single individuals with over IDR 5 billion in assets.
Risk Management
In keeping with Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 5/8/PBI/2003 (as amended by Bank Indonesia Regulation No. 11/25/PBI/2009) on Implementation of Risk Management for Commercial Banks, the Regulation requires commercial banks to apply risk management when promoting offshore financial products. ‘Risk management’ includes:
1.
Active supervision by the Board of Commissioners and Directors;
2.
Policy and procedures relating to risk-taking and promotional activities;
3.
Risk identification, measurement, oversight, and control processes, and;
4.
Other internal controls, such as evaluating and auditing the activities of related offshore financial product promoters.
Prudential Banking Measures
Chapter V of the Regulation sets out most substantive details around Prudential Banking Principles. Concretely, they include implementation of ‘Know Your Customer’ principles and diligence procedures, and Bank Indonesia’s ability to intervene in offshore financial product promotion that is exceedingly risky or violates regulation. Less concretely, they are reflected by not indicating to customers that profits in any amount are certain, that redemption of the products is guaranteed, or that the products are those of the commercial bank when in fact they are offshore products, among other things (Article 15 (1)).
Although not included in Chapter V, Article 14 of the Regulation also stipulates that diligence must be conducted on all offshore financial products, including risk assessment of the product and the issuing institution.
Reporting Obligation
For oversight purposes, the Regulation obligates commercial banks to report to Bank Indonesia when they plan to issue new offshore financial products, and when they are offering an offshore financial product for the first time. They must also submit monthly reports on promotional activities and the status of related offshore financial products.
Status of Existing Offshore Products Promotion Banks
Banks that are already engaged in the promotion of offshore financial products must comply with the provisions of this Regulation by 29 September 2010. Responsibilities could well include applying for an in-principle approval from Bank Indonesia in order to remain in operation.
Sanctions
Sanctions that will be imposed for violation of the provisions of the Regulation are generally administrative, and notably include written warnings, suspension or revocation of bank business licenses, and termination of bank executives, among others.
Enforcement Date
The Regulation has been in force since 29 June 2010.
Conclusion
Bank Indonesia, by issuing this regulation, (a) prevents the entry of smaller-sized ‘retail’ customers into offshore financial product markets (at least by way of commercial banks), and (b) seeks to mitigate excessive risk being taken on by ‘non-retail’ customers by mandating central bank approval of financial products to be promoted in Indonesia, and regulating supervision of product performance.
Although the Regulation is comprehensive, further clarity is anticipated by subsequent implementing regulation – typically taking form as a Bank Indonesia Circular Letter. As one example, Article 14 necessitates that commercial banks ‘investigate’ any offshore financial product it will promote to its customers, but does not explicitly state what processes are required by this investigation. Otherwise, the provisions appear to be executable in fairly straightforward manner.