New Government Policy Overhauls International School System in Indonesia

Overview

Education in Indonesia is never far from controversy. That continues to be the case with the recent release of Minister of Education Regulation No. 18 of 2009 on Foreign Education Service Agencies in Indonesia (“Ministerial Regulation”), which may dramatically impact the delivery of education at international schools throughout the country. Also released this year was Government Regulation No. 17 of 2010 on Education Management and Implementation (“Government Regulation”), which is designed to implement provisions of Law No. 20 of 2003 on the National Education System. Although the latter is less extensive with relation to international schools, the Government Regulation and Ministerial Regulation work towards the same nationalistic effect, and are best read in conjunction.

 

International schools (as opposed to national schools with ‘international standards’ and schools established by foreign embassies in Indonesia) are schools, such as the Jakarta International School, Surabaya International School, and Gandhi Memorial International School - among many others. Their curriculums incorporate international programs such as the International Baccalaureate (IB) system, and Advanced Placement (AP) system. Their established operations - particularly at the curricular level - will be modified by the recent, aforementioned regulations. 

 

This Indonesian Law Digest will highlight key provisions of the Ministerial and Government Regulations, with attention to the potential impact of their implementation in the international school system.

 

Purpose

Although it may be contended, it would appear that the Ministerial and Governmental Regulations are designed to protect national interests, largely by (1) enforcing the same Indonesian curricular requirements on any Indonesian student regardless of their school, and (2) enforcing partnership between international schools and their local counterparts.

 

Instrumental Features of the Regulations

International schools are anxious about the core provisions of the Ministerial and Governmental Regulations, which notably include:

 

Obligatory Cooperation with Local Schools

In order to continue legitimate operations in Indonesia, ‘foreign education agencies’ (i.e., international schools) are obliged to enter into formalized cooperation with accredited local schools: that much is set out by Article 2 of the Ministerial Regulation, and Article 161 (4 & 5) of the Government Regulation. 

 

In short, the cooperation agreement between the international school and local school results in an entity called a ‘Joint Education Body’ (Satuan Pendidikan Bersama). These cooperatives must comply with a number of requirements, which notably include:

 

Quotas

At least 51% of the teachers in any Joint Education Body must be Indonesian citizens (Article 5 (2) of the Ministerial Regulation).

 

Certain percentages of the teachers must have a Masters or Doctoral degree, although the quota differs at each level of education:

-

Elementary Schools: 10% of teachers must have a Masters/Doctorate.

-

Secondary Schools: 20% of teachers must have a Masters/Doctorate.

-

High Schools or equivalent: 30% of teachers must have a Masters/Doctorate.

 

Puzzlingly, in the Ministerial Regulation, 100% of ‘support staff’ (from the Head Master, to librarians, to janitors, to administrative employees and others) must be Indonesian, while the Government Regulation only requires that quota to be 80%.

 

Curricula

Article 8 of the Ministerial Regulation sets out that the curricula in any Joint Education Body is to be primarily based upon Indonesian national standards (Standar Isi, and Standar Kompetensi Lulus), with foreign education standards supporting ‘enrichment of the existing standards.’ In practice, and when read with the rest of the regulation, that provision chiefly requires that three Indonesian subjects be taught to Indonesian students in any Joint Education Body: civics, religion, and Bahasa Indonesia.

 

National Exam for Indonesian Students

Indonesian national students (i.e., those in a Joint Education Body taking civics, religion, and Bahasa Indonesia) must take the national exams; this is firmly stated in Article 161 (3) (c) of the Government Regulation. Perhaps of note, Article 10 (2) of the Ministerial Regulation appears to be ‘softer’ and less obligatory, saying that “a Joint Education Body gives the opportunity for Indonesian national students to take the national exams.”

 

Sanctions

The Ministerial and Government Regulations differ slightly in their provision of sanctions. The Government Regulation makes available: (1) written warning; (2) suspension of operations, and; (3) permanent closure of the entity. Meanwhile, the Ministerial Regulation makes available: (1) written warning; (2) prohibition of the entity from accepting new students; (3) revocation of the entity’s establishment license, and; (4) closure of the entity.

 

Compliance Date(s)

The timeframes for compliance differ between the two regulations: the Ministerial states that all existing international schools are expected to complete the transition process to a Joint Education Body with an accredited local school by 30 March 2012, while the Governmental states that it is 28 January 2013. In this case, given that the Government Regulation was most recently issued (28 January 2010), according to the principle of lex posteriori derogat lex priori (i.e., that the most recent law prevails over the least recent law), the date of compliance is 28 January 2013.

 

Impacts

According to the Ministry of Education’s Directorate General of Elementary and Secondary Level Education Management, there are 105 international schools throughout Indonesia; they will all have to comply with the regulations and form a Joint Education Body with their accredited local counterparts. Regarding that process, at least three core issues will likely be taken by teachers and parents at international schools:

 

First, the forced inclusion of Indonesian subjects, such as religion, to the curriculum of Indonesian students at international schools could be exceedingly difficult to accommodate. The Jakarta International School, for example, promotes the International Baccalaureate Diploma program, which is rigorous and time-consuming - adding civics, religion, and Bahasa Indonesia to that schedule is difficult, if not detrimental to the students. This is particularly the case when considering the additional time required by involvements in extracurricular activities, which are rendered almost impossible by three additional courses.

 

Second, the impact of forcing Indonesian students at international schools to take national exams could be detrimental to students, who would have to study for two sets of exams in order to graduate, or at least to be recognized as formally graduated in Indonesia.

 

Third, the obligation to employ 51% Indonesian teachers in an international school is potentially quite problematic. Beyond the simple fact that most teachers of international schools are foreigners (and the question of what would have to happen to those teachers in order to reduce the ratio), it is also an issue for the reason that foreign-language teachers can more easily communicate with foreign-language students (which of course make up the majority of enrollment). 

 

Conclusion:

Despite the opposition raised in the expatriate community to the changes brought by these regulations, the government remains firm in its decision to implement these regulations by (presumably) 28 January 2013. Although the schedule of what must be done by that date seems mostly clear (i.e., that international schools and local counterparts form Joint Education Bodies with Indonesian students taking certain courses from the Indonesian curriculum), operational questions remain an issue for how this relationship works in practice. Presumably the two schools have a single headmaster, but it is not explicitly stated in either the Ministerial or Government Regulation. The two regulations also differ on the required percentage of Indonesian ‘support staff’ - is it to be 80 or 100%? The issues and uncertainties have prompted international schools, such as the Jakarta International School, to phase out their Indonesian students by 2013. Perhaps that is not the desired effect of the regulatory effort, which is ostensibly to serve Indonesian interests. More broadly, whatever the effect, foreigners may be more reluctant to come to or stay in Indonesia if the consistency or quality of education in the country’s international schools is uncertain.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

Education in Indonesia is never far from controversy. That continues to be the case with the recent release of Minister of Education Regulation No. 18 of 2009 on Foreign Education Service Agencies in Indonesia (“Ministerial Regulation”), which may dramatically impact the delivery of education at international schools throughout the country. Also released this year was Government Regulation No. 17 of 2010 on Education Management and Implementation (“Government Regulation”), which is designed to implement provisions of Law No. 20 of 2003 on the National Education System. Although the latter is less extensive with relation to international schools, the Government Regulation and Ministerial Regulation work towards the same nationalistic effect, and are best read in conjunction.

 

International schools (as opposed to national schools with ‘international standards’ and schools established by foreign embassies in Indonesia) are schools, such as the Jakarta International School, Surabaya International School, and Gandhi Memorial International School - among many others. Their curriculums incorporate international programs such as the International Baccalaureate (IB) system, and Advanced Placement (AP) system. Their established operations - particularly at the curricular level - will be modified by the recent, aforementioned regulations. 

 

This Indonesian Law Digest will highlight key provisions of the Ministerial and Government Regulations, with attention to the potential impact of their implementation in the international school system.

 

Purpose

Although it may be contended, it would appear that the Ministerial and Governmental Regulations are designed to protect national interests, largely by (1) enforcing the same Indonesian curricular requirements on any Indonesian student regardless of their school, and (2) enforcing partnership between international schools and their local counterparts.

 

Instrumental Features of the Regulations

International schools are anxious about the core provisions of the Ministerial and Governmental Regulations, which notably include:

 

Obligatory Cooperation with Local Schools

In order to continue legitimate operations in Indonesia, ‘foreign education agencies’ (i.e., international schools) are obliged to enter into formalized cooperation with accredited local schools: that much is set out by Article 2 of the Ministerial Regulation, and Article 161 (4 & 5) of the Government Regulation. 

 

In short, the cooperation agreement between the international school and local school results in an entity called a ‘Joint Education Body’ (Satuan Pendidikan Bersama). These cooperatives must comply with a number of requirements, which notably include:

 

Quotas

At least 51% of the teachers in any Joint Education Body must be Indonesian citizens (Article 5 (2) of the Ministerial Regulation).

 

Certain percentages of the teachers must have a Masters or Doctoral degree, although the quota differs at each level of education:

-

Elementary Schools: 10% of teachers must have a Masters/Doctorate.

-

Secondary Schools: 20% of teachers must have a Masters/Doctorate.

-

High Schools or equivalent: 30% of teachers must have a Masters/Doctorate.

 

Puzzlingly, in the Ministerial Regulation, 100% of ‘support staff’ (from the Head Master, to librarians, to janitors, to administrative employees and others) must be Indonesian, while the Government Regulation only requires that quota to be 80%.

 

Curricula

Article 8 of the Ministerial Regulation sets out that the curricula in any Joint Education Body is to be primarily based upon Indonesian national standards (Standar Isi, and Standar Kompetensi Lulus), with foreign education standards supporting ‘enrichment of the existing standards.’ In practice, and when read with the rest of the regulation, that provision chiefly requires that three Indonesian subjects be taught to Indonesian students in any Joint Education Body: civics, religion, and Bahasa Indonesia.

 

National Exam for Indonesian Students

Indonesian national students (i.e., those in a Joint Education Body taking civics, religion, and Bahasa Indonesia) must take the national exams; this is firmly stated in Article 161 (3) (c) of the Government Regulation. Perhaps of note, Article 10 (2) of the Ministerial Regulation appears to be ‘softer’ and less obligatory, saying that “a Joint Education Body gives the opportunity for Indonesian national students to take the national exams.”

 

Sanctions

The Ministerial and Government Regulations differ slightly in their provision of sanctions. The Government Regulation makes available: (1) written warning; (2) suspension of operations, and; (3) permanent closure of the entity. Meanwhile, the Ministerial Regulation makes available: (1) written warning; (2) prohibition of the entity from accepting new students; (3) revocation of the entity’s establishment license, and; (4) closure of the entity.

 

Compliance Date(s)

The timeframes for compliance differ between the two regulations: the Ministerial states that all existing international schools are expected to complete the transition process to a Joint Education Body with an accredited local school by 30 March 2012, while the Governmental states that it is 28 January 2013. In this case, given that the Government Regulation was most recently issued (28 January 2010), according to the principle of lex posteriori derogat lex priori (i.e., that the most recent law prevails over the least recent law), the date of compliance is 28 January 2013.

 

Impacts

According to the Ministry of Education’s Directorate General of Elementary and Secondary Level Education Management, there are 105 international schools throughout Indonesia; they will all have to comply with the regulations and form a Joint Education Body with their accredited local counterparts. Regarding that process, at least three core issues will likely be taken by teachers and parents at international schools:

 

First, the forced inclusion of Indonesian subjects, such as religion, to the curriculum of Indonesian students at international schools could be exceedingly difficult to accommodate. The Jakarta International School, for example, promotes the International Baccalaureate Diploma program, which is rigorous and time-consuming - adding civics, religion, and Bahasa Indonesia to that schedule is difficult, if not detrimental to the students. This is particularly the case when considering the additional time required by involvements in extracurricular activities, which are rendered almost impossible by three additional courses.

 

Second, the impact of forcing Indonesian students at international schools to take national exams could be detrimental to students, who would have to study for two sets of exams in order to graduate, or at least to be recognized as formally graduated in Indonesia.

 

Third, the obligation to employ 51% Indonesian teachers in an international school is potentially quite problematic. Beyond the simple fact that most teachers of international schools are foreigners (and the question of what would have to happen to those teachers in order to reduce the ratio), it is also an issue for the reason that foreign-language teachers can more easily communicate with foreign-language students (which of course make up the majority of enrollment). 

 

Conclusion:

Despite the opposition raised in the expatriate community to the changes brought by these regulations, the government remains firm in its decision to implement these regulations by (presumably) 28 January 2013. Although the schedule of what must be done by that date seems mostly clear (i.e., that international schools and local counterparts form Joint Education Bodies with Indonesian students taking certain courses from the Indonesian curriculum), operational questions remain an issue for how this relationship works in practice. Presumably the two schools have a single headmaster, but it is not explicitly stated in either the Ministerial or Government Regulation. The two regulations also differ on the required percentage of Indonesian ‘support staff’ - is it to be 80 or 100%? The issues and uncertainties have prompted international schools, such as the Jakarta International School, to phase out their Indonesian students by 2013. Perhaps that is not the desired effect of the regulatory effort, which is ostensibly to serve Indonesian interests. More broadly, whatever the effect, foreigners may be more reluctant to come to or stay in Indonesia if the consistency or quality of education in the country’s international schools is uncertain.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info