The Use of Publicity Sanctioning for Consumer Protection Purposes: A Highlight of the Regulatory Framework in Indonesia
Overview
The consumer protection laws in most legal systems around the world generally recognize and implement the use of publicity as a punitive tool for offences committed by business actors, whether individuals or business organizations. And Indonesia, in this case, is no exception.
Under Law No. 8 of 1999 on Consumer Protection (“Consumer Protection Law”) and its implementing regulations, the government, non-governmental organizations (NGOs), and / or the public may employ ‘publicity sanctioning’ when they find that certain goods and / or services already in the market contravene the laws and regulations and / or endanger consumers.
Unfortunately, based on hukumonline’s research, the existing, relevant consumer protection laws and regulations on publicity sanctioning are not particularly adequate. It is unclear as to who would monitor the implementation of such sanctions, what is required before publicizing the findings, and what recourse is available if the findings turn out to be incorrect.
The absence of clarity on the subject matter consequently results in the arbitrary use of publicity. The effects clearly have led to a wide spectrum of outcomes, but what is certain, as shown by a number of cases, is that the business actors suffer the most, when the use of such sanctions is left unchecked.
Recently, the Ministry of Trade, particularly its Director General of Domestic Trade, has issued a Circular Letter (No. 03/PDN/SE/6/2010) to regulate how Consumer Protection NGOs (‘LPKSM’), as NGOs acknowledged by the government, are to responsibly reveal the result of their findings of the conditions of goods and / or services in the market. Regardless of the limitations of the Circular, it appears to be an attempt by the government to clarify the existing problems of implementing publicity sanctioning.
This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will focus its inquiry on the publicity sanctioning regulatory framework and the various issues that relate to this type of penalty.
Adverse Publicity as an Alternative Sentencing Method: A General Perspective
The use of publicity, specifically adverse publicity, stems from the notion of shaming: the purpose of imposing such a sentence is solely to damage the offender’s reputation (D.A. Skeel, Symposium Norms and Corporate Law: Shaming in Corporate Law, 149 U. Penn. L. Rev. 1811, 2001). Adverse publicity is arguably the most effective way to sanction businesspeople, especially corporations, compared to the standard sanctions of imprisonment and fines. Whereas imprisonment is practically impossible to impose on corporations, and fines can be easily paid by corporations, adverse publicity, which damages the corporation’s reputation, could affect the corporation’s consumers’ confidence to buy or use their products and / or services, and result in a greater losses to the company.
The use of adverse publicity, therefore, may sufficiently punish businesspeople and also deter them from re-offending. Thus, the use of this type of sanction fits in with the general theory of criminal law, that penalties must aim at achieving deterrence. However it must be noted that publicity sanctioning may also have drawbacks.
One of the most important side effects of the sanctions is their uncertain effect: because imposition of adverse publicity is uncontrollable, depending on the public’s response to the business actors’ offences, the impact of the penalty on the business actors can not be predicted. In extreme cases, the “loose canon,” as Professor of Law at ColombiaLawSchool, John C. Coffee puts it, may lead to a decline in sales, closure of the business, and loss of jobs. In such instances, the sanction became disproportionate, as innocent workers and other related parties may also suffer the effect.
Indonesia’s Regulatory Framework on Publicity Sanctioning in Consumer-Related Matters
In Indonesia, publicity as a means of penalties in consumer-related cases was firstly regulated on 20 April 1999, when the Consumer Protection Law came into existence. Article 30 of the Law provides that the implementation of the Law will be overseen not only by the government alone, but also by the LPKSMs and the community as a whole.
‘Oversee’ in this context, based on Elucidation of Article 30 (3), is defined as the supervision of goods and / or services available in the market by way of research, testing, and / or surveys. What the LPKSMs and the public will oversee regarding the goods and services will be, among other things, whether their safety, labeling, advertisement, and others required matters are in line with the laws, regulations, and business customs.
Of particular importance is Article 30 (5), where it is stipulated that the results of surveys, research, and testing conducted by the LPKSMs and / or the public can be distributed to the public and the government. This provision provides a legal basis for LPKSMs and the community to disclose all information relating to the already-circulated goods and / or services that they oversaw in the market to the public. The Law, however, provides no further provisions regarding publicity nor a reference to a subsequent implementing regulation of the provision.
Perhaps due to the abovementioned reasons, the Law’s implementing regulation provides very little additional explanation with respect to publicity on top of the Law. The implementing regulation, Government Regulation No. 58 of 2001 (“2001 Regulation adds that it is not only the LPKSMs (Article 10 (5)) and the public (Article 9 (4)) that are capable of unveiling their findings in the national market of the conditions of goods and / or services to the public, but the also government that can now act in such capacity (Article 8 (3)).
Nonetheless, in Minister of Trade Regulation No. 20/M-DAG/PER/5/2009 on the Provisions and Procedures on the Supervision of Goods and / or Services (“2009 Ministerial Regulation”), publicity is regulated in some detail. The 2009 Ministerial Regulation states that disclosure and recalls will be conducted in the event that the goods:
-
Endanger the safety, security, and health of consumers, as well as the environment;
-
Bring losses to consumers or cause a number of victims;
-
Are not in compliance with the requirements as set out by the Indonesian National Standard (‘SNI’);
-
Are not consistent with the technical requirements of the relevant governmental authorities.
Furthermore, disclosure of the suspension of services could also be made where the business actors fail to perform their obligations as agreed, and cause the consumers to suffer losses.
Although the 2009 Ministerial Regulation provided more guidance as to how publicity is to be implemented, the provisions are still far from sufficient. Even though the Ministerial Regulation specifies when and in what circumstances publicity can be enforced, such matters are only described in a very general sense. Most importantly, the Ministerial Regulation – and the Law and the 2001 Regulation – fail to answer the critical questions of what form of publicity can be disclosed, who should be supervising the publicity, and what ways the business actors can resort to, to negate the publicity.
The government’s failure to provide certainty on the subject matter has, in many instances, led to a number of cases of arbitrary publicity, and as such has caused losses to the targeted businesspeople.
In March 2009, an LPKSM called the Indonesian Consumer Protection Foundation (‘YLKI’) released its findings, claiming that 10 products available in the marketplace have been found to contain melamine (Kompas.com, 4/3/09). These 10 products included the Nestle Bear Brand Sterilized Low Fat Milk, Yake Assorted Candies, Dutch Mill Yogurt, and Kino Bear Chocolate – among others.
The claim, nevertheless, was never entirely proven; only few of YLKI’s findings were proven by the National Agency for Drug and Food Control (‘BPOM’). The businesses, whose products were not shown to contain melamine, ended up being wrongfully accused, and it is very possible that despite the fact that that their products are safe for consumption, the public will still be hesitant to do so because of the false allegation of YLKI. What do the laws and regulations on consumer protection say about this? They do not say anything.
The Consumer Protection Law, the 2001 Regulation, and the Ministerial Regulation are all silent on this matter.
In another case, the BPOM itself has contributed to the losses suffered by businesspeople. Four years ago, the BPOM disclosed publicly that a tofu product, called Kuning Sari Pamulang tofu, was found to contain formaldehyde. The producer claimed that the publicity was incorrect but BPOM has never responded to this complaint. The producer estimated that the publicity had caused its business to lose 50% of its usual profits (Tempo Interaktif, 12/1/06).
The question that must properly be raised is what redress can the business actor seek in such a case? Or what means should be put in place to prevent such incidents from occurring again? The relevant laws and regulations ironically are also silent on this matter.
The Circular Letter: A Means to Regulate the Use of Publicity in Consumer Protection Matters
The Director General of Domestic Trade of the Ministry of Trade on 9 June 2010 signed and released Circular Letter No. 03/PDN/SE/6/2010 (“Circular Letter”). The Circular Letter essentially provides guidance for LPKSMs to follow prior to publicizing any of their findings publicly.
The rationale behind the Circular Letter is to ensure that no publicity of LPKSMs’ findings will be used as an anti-competition tool, which would unfairly reduce competition. Besides that, it can also serve as protection from the arbitrary use of publicity.
Although the document itself is relatively brief, the Circular Letter’s content arguably provides exactly what businesspeople have been waiting for, which is protection. Under the Circular, such protection is given in the form of having the right to object to the findings prior to their disclosure. Hence, this creates an ‘equality of arms’ between the business actors and the initiators of the publicity (i.e., the LPKSM).
According to Point 5 (b), the complaint, or the ‘right to answer’ as the Circular terms it, must be made within 14 business days from the day the findings were received. The outcomes are:
1.
If no responses is provided within that timeframe, the LPKSM’s findings will be considered to have obtained the business actor’s consent and will therefore be publicized, or;
2.
If a deadlock results, the matter must be brought to the relevant governmental authorities’ (Minister of Trade, or Governor/Regent/Mayor) attention for further examination of the LPKSM’s findings.
The further examination process will determine whether or not the findings can be publicized. In the event that the findings are not proven to be accurate, publication cannot take place. But when the further examination supports its accuracy, disclosure of LPKSM’s findings will be permitted.
Conclusion
Prior to the issuance of the Circular Letter, our research found that the legal infrastructure, which provides protection to business actors in consumer-related cases, was poorly regulated. The cases in 2006 and 2009, as discussed before, are only two amongst many other examples that support this assertion. The existence of the Circular Letter, therefore, is expected to address the gap that existed for many years.
However, if the government is relying only on the Circular Letter as a legal basis to protect business actors from adverse publicity, this means that the government has made another mistake, because the Circular alone is not enough to provide protection. It can be seen from the content of the Circular that it is inadequate, as it only regulates a means to prevent arbitrary adverse publicity, and specifically publicity initiated by the LPKSMs. This is why the government must develop the necessary and appropriate legal infrastructures to govern this subject matter comprehensively.
The consumer protection laws in most legal systems around the world generally recognize and implement the use of publicity as a punitive tool for offences committed by business actors, whether individuals or business organizations. And Indonesia, in this case, is no exception.
Under Law No. 8 of 1999 on Consumer Protection (“Consumer Protection Law”) and its implementing regulations, the government, non-governmental organizations (NGOs), and / or the public may employ ‘publicity sanctioning’ when they find that certain goods and / or services already in the market contravene the laws and regulations and / or endanger consumers.
Unfortunately, based on hukumonline’s research, the existing, relevant consumer protection laws and regulations on publicity sanctioning are not particularly adequate. It is unclear as to who would monitor the implementation of such sanctions, what is required before publicizing the findings, and what recourse is available if the findings turn out to be incorrect.
The absence of clarity on the subject matter consequently results in the arbitrary use of publicity. The effects clearly have led to a wide spectrum of outcomes, but what is certain, as shown by a number of cases, is that the business actors suffer the most, when the use of such sanctions is left unchecked.
Recently, the Ministry of Trade, particularly its Director General of Domestic Trade, has issued a Circular Letter (No. 03/PDN/SE/6/2010) to regulate how Consumer Protection NGOs (‘LPKSM’), as NGOs acknowledged by the government, are to responsibly reveal the result of their findings of the conditions of goods and / or services in the market. Regardless of the limitations of the Circular, it appears to be an attempt by the government to clarify the existing problems of implementing publicity sanctioning.
This edition of the Indonesian Law Digest will focus its inquiry on the publicity sanctioning regulatory framework and the various issues that relate to this type of penalty.
Adverse Publicity as an Alternative Sentencing Method: A General Perspective
The use of publicity, specifically adverse publicity, stems from the notion of shaming: the purpose of imposing such a sentence is solely to damage the offender’s reputation (D.A. Skeel, Symposium Norms and Corporate Law: Shaming in Corporate Law, 149 U. Penn. L. Rev. 1811, 2001). Adverse publicity is arguably the most effective way to sanction businesspeople, especially corporations, compared to the standard sanctions of imprisonment and fines. Whereas imprisonment is practically impossible to impose on corporations, and fines can be easily paid by corporations, adverse publicity, which damages the corporation’s reputation, could affect the corporation’s consumers’ confidence to buy or use their products and / or services, and result in a greater losses to the company.
The use of adverse publicity, therefore, may sufficiently punish businesspeople and also deter them from re-offending. Thus, the use of this type of sanction fits in with the general theory of criminal law, that penalties must aim at achieving deterrence. However it must be noted that publicity sanctioning may also have drawbacks.
One of the most important side effects of the sanctions is their uncertain effect: because imposition of adverse publicity is uncontrollable, depending on the public’s response to the business actors’ offences, the impact of the penalty on the business actors can not be predicted. In extreme cases, the “loose canon,” as Professor of Law at ColombiaLawSchool, John C. Coffee puts it, may lead to a decline in sales, closure of the business, and loss of jobs. In such instances, the sanction became disproportionate, as innocent workers and other related parties may also suffer the effect.
Indonesia’s Regulatory Framework on Publicity Sanctioning in Consumer-Related Matters
In Indonesia, publicity as a means of penalties in consumer-related cases was firstly regulated on 20 April 1999, when the Consumer Protection Law came into existence. Article 30 of the Law provides that the implementation of the Law will be overseen not only by the government alone, but also by the LPKSMs and the community as a whole.
‘Oversee’ in this context, based on Elucidation of Article 30 (3), is defined as the supervision of goods and / or services available in the market by way of research, testing, and / or surveys. What the LPKSMs and the public will oversee regarding the goods and services will be, among other things, whether their safety, labeling, advertisement, and others required matters are in line with the laws, regulations, and business customs.
Of particular importance is Article 30 (5), where it is stipulated that the results of surveys, research, and testing conducted by the LPKSMs and / or the public can be distributed to the public and the government. This provision provides a legal basis for LPKSMs and the community to disclose all information relating to the already-circulated goods and / or services that they oversaw in the market to the public. The Law, however, provides no further provisions regarding publicity nor a reference to a subsequent implementing regulation of the provision.
Perhaps due to the abovementioned reasons, the Law’s implementing regulation provides very little additional explanation with respect to publicity on top of the Law. The implementing regulation, Government Regulation No. 58 of 2001 (“2001 Regulation adds that it is not only the LPKSMs (Article 10 (5)) and the public (Article 9 (4)) that are capable of unveiling their findings in the national market of the conditions of goods and / or services to the public, but the also government that can now act in such capacity (Article 8 (3)).
Nonetheless, in Minister of Trade Regulation No. 20/M-DAG/PER/5/2009 on the Provisions and Procedures on the Supervision of Goods and / or Services (“2009 Ministerial Regulation”), publicity is regulated in some detail. The 2009 Ministerial Regulation states that disclosure and recalls will be conducted in the event that the goods:
-
Endanger the safety, security, and health of consumers, as well as the environment;
-
Bring losses to consumers or cause a number of victims;
-
Are not in compliance with the requirements as set out by the Indonesian National Standard (‘SNI’);
-
Are not consistent with the technical requirements of the relevant governmental authorities.
Furthermore, disclosure of the suspension of services could also be made where the business actors fail to perform their obligations as agreed, and cause the consumers to suffer losses.
Although the 2009 Ministerial Regulation provided more guidance as to how publicity is to be implemented, the provisions are still far from sufficient. Even though the Ministerial Regulation specifies when and in what circumstances publicity can be enforced, such matters are only described in a very general sense. Most importantly, the Ministerial Regulation – and the Law and the 2001 Regulation – fail to answer the critical questions of what form of publicity can be disclosed, who should be supervising the publicity, and what ways the business actors can resort to, to negate the publicity.
The government’s failure to provide certainty on the subject matter has, in many instances, led to a number of cases of arbitrary publicity, and as such has caused losses to the targeted businesspeople.
In March 2009, an LPKSM called the Indonesian Consumer Protection Foundation (‘YLKI’) released its findings, claiming that 10 products available in the marketplace have been found to contain melamine (Kompas.com, 4/3/09). These 10 products included the Nestle Bear Brand Sterilized Low Fat Milk, Yake Assorted Candies, Dutch Mill Yogurt, and Kino Bear Chocolate – among others.
The claim, nevertheless, was never entirely proven; only few of YLKI’s findings were proven by the National Agency for Drug and Food Control (‘BPOM’). The businesses, whose products were not shown to contain melamine, ended up being wrongfully accused, and it is very possible that despite the fact that that their products are safe for consumption, the public will still be hesitant to do so because of the false allegation of YLKI. What do the laws and regulations on consumer protection say about this? They do not say anything.
The Consumer Protection Law, the 2001 Regulation, and the Ministerial Regulation are all silent on this matter.
In another case, the BPOM itself has contributed to the losses suffered by businesspeople. Four years ago, the BPOM disclosed publicly that a tofu product, called Kuning Sari Pamulang tofu, was found to contain formaldehyde. The producer claimed that the publicity was incorrect but BPOM has never responded to this complaint. The producer estimated that the publicity had caused its business to lose 50% of its usual profits (Tempo Interaktif, 12/1/06).
The question that must properly be raised is what redress can the business actor seek in such a case? Or what means should be put in place to prevent such incidents from occurring again? The relevant laws and regulations ironically are also silent on this matter.
The Circular Letter: A Means to Regulate the Use of Publicity in Consumer Protection Matters
The Director General of Domestic Trade of the Ministry of Trade on 9 June 2010 signed and released Circular Letter No. 03/PDN/SE/6/2010 (“Circular Letter”). The Circular Letter essentially provides guidance for LPKSMs to follow prior to publicizing any of their findings publicly.
The rationale behind the Circular Letter is to ensure that no publicity of LPKSMs’ findings will be used as an anti-competition tool, which would unfairly reduce competition. Besides that, it can also serve as protection from the arbitrary use of publicity.
Although the document itself is relatively brief, the Circular Letter’s content arguably provides exactly what businesspeople have been waiting for, which is protection. Under the Circular, such protection is given in the form of having the right to object to the findings prior to their disclosure. Hence, this creates an ‘equality of arms’ between the business actors and the initiators of the publicity (i.e., the LPKSM).
According to Point 5 (b), the complaint, or the ‘right to answer’ as the Circular terms it, must be made within 14 business days from the day the findings were received. The outcomes are:
1.
If no responses is provided within that timeframe, the LPKSM’s findings will be considered to have obtained the business actor’s consent and will therefore be publicized, or;
2.
If a deadlock results, the matter must be brought to the relevant governmental authorities’ (Minister of Trade, or Governor/Regent/Mayor) attention for further examination of the LPKSM’s findings.
The further examination process will determine whether or not the findings can be publicized. In the event that the findings are not proven to be accurate, publication cannot take place. But when the further examination supports its accuracy, disclosure of LPKSM’s findings will be permitted.
Conclusion
Prior to the issuance of the Circular Letter, our research found that the legal infrastructure, which provides protection to business actors in consumer-related cases, was poorly regulated. The cases in 2006 and 2009, as discussed before, are only two amongst many other examples that support this assertion. The existence of the Circular Letter, therefore, is expected to address the gap that existed for many years.
However, if the government is relying only on the Circular Letter as a legal basis to protect business actors from adverse publicity, this means that the government has made another mistake, because the Circular alone is not enough to provide protection. It can be seen from the content of the Circular that it is inadequate, as it only regulates a means to prevent arbitrary adverse publicity, and specifically publicity initiated by the LPKSMs. This is why the government must develop the necessary and appropriate legal infrastructures to govern this subject matter comprehensively.