Letter of Intent to Implement 'Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation' Program in Indonesia

Overview

To reduce domestic and global greenhouse gas emissions, Indonesia has begun to, or at least signal its willingness to implement the Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD) program, which seeks to organize and finance a concerted international effort to reduce carbon emissions caused by deforestation. Indonesia’s latest move towards REDD implementation was by way of an initial bilateral agreement with Norway, signing a Letter of Intent to collaborate to help Indonesia implement forest-conscious reforms, and cut emissions accordingly.

 

This Indonesian Law Digest will survey that Letter of Intent, highlighting critical aspects for domestic stakeholders, and with attention to potential issues of implementation.

 

Context

It is estimated that deforestation and related degradation activity contributes 17% of all global greenhouse gas emissions, outweighing the emissions of the entire transport sector internationally. Indonesia is no exception to this trend: almost 80% of its carbon emissions are resultant from deforestation, forest degradation, and peat land conversion - often for the purpose of farming and harvesting Crude Palm Oil (CPO), among other things. Forests contain large amounts of stored CO2, which is released when the trees are cut down. As the nation with the second largest rainforest in the world, Indonesia is able to play a critical role in emissions reductions programs.

 

Under President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, Indonesia has set an emissions reduction target of 26% by 2020, and up to 41% reductions if the necessary funding could be provided. Norway intends to provide USD 1 billion annually to assist Indonesia in REDD implementation to meet those goals.

 

Purpose

Indonesia’s collaboration with Norway, as facilitated by the Letter of Intent and subsequent engagements, is expected to (a) bring about substantial reductions in Indonesia’s greenhouse gas emissions, and (b) improve forest governance and law enforcement. The Letter of Intent sets out three distinct phases of implementation, from planning to execution, stipulating timelines for different activities. It also discusses the issue of financing, and how the funds provided by Norway (and perhaps other countries) will be managed throughout each phase.

 

The REDD Program

In short, REDD is a ‘mechanism’ that brings developed-country funds to bear upon developing country forest conservation. Although it was designed through intensive international collaboration, as opposed to an international treatise, it is a flexible program, laying out an archetypal structure that can be adapted to particular domestic projects. 

 

Through a series of progressive steps, REDD provides the framework for countries with rich biomass to prevent (a) deforestation and (b) forest degradation, thereby reducing substantial greenhouse gas emissions, and protecting the environment from abuse. Each series of steps designed to achieve specific targets, initially beginning with policy reform and capacity building, and ending with independently verifiable emissions cuts. Meanwhile, financial and market incentives are provided upon successful implementation of each set of steps; funding contingent upon demonstrable action.

 

The Letter of Intent: Three Phases of Implementation

Overall, the Indonesia-Norway project is designed in three stages: (1) Preparation, (2) Transformation, and (3) Contributions-for-Verified Emission Reduction.

 

In the first two stages, focus will be upon enacting policies and measures to support serious reductions in emissions and deforestation. In the third and final stage, focus will be upon verifiable reductions.

 

Norway’s continued financial support throughout each stage will be contingent upon Indonesia achieving different milestones, or ‘deliverables’ for each particular stage. This serves as an incentive structure to maintain the course of REDD-oriented reform.

 

‘Organs’ of Implementation

Indonesia and Norway will together establish a ‘Joint Consultation Group’ to coordinate effective implementation of the REDD partnership.

 

An ‘Independent Review Group’ agreed upon by both Norway and Indonesia will review the deliverables to determine whether Indonesia is meeting all requirements in each phase, and report to (a) the Joint Consultation Group and (b) the public.

 

Stage 1: Preparation: 2010 to January 2011

First, Indonesia must initially put forth a viable national strategy to address deforestation, forest degradation, and peat land-related emissions.

 

Second, an independent agency must be established to coordinate REDD implementation and policy strategy, and be able to report directly to the President.

 

Third, another independent agency must be established to monitor, report, and verify (MRV) technical aspects of forest-related emission reductions. This agency must develop a system to measure (a) forest carbon stocks and emissions, and (b) changes in the size of natural forest and peat land areas. Its assessment techniques and standards will need to be able to comply with Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) standards, which will be verified by independent international verification.

 

Fourth, a ‘funding instrument’ must be established to collaborate with donors, as well as receive and distribute funds. Although transparently managed by an international financial institution, the funding instrument will compose of local stakeholders, from indigenous community leaders to government representatives.

 

Fifth, a particular province - one with significance to, and threatened by forestry activities - must be selected for a REDD pilot project, which will also need to be developed during this first stage.

 

Stage 2: Preparation: January 2011 to December 2013

In addition to administering one or more full-scale province-wide REDD pilot projects, the second stage focuses on policy and legal development, law enforcement, and capability building: the ‘infrastructure’ for serious emissions cuts in 2014, if not earlier.

 

First, by 1 January 2011, the funding instrument must be operational, and able to receive, and coordinate distribution of funds.

 

Second, by December 2013, the independent national MRV technical facility must be operational, and complying with ‘Tier 2’ measurement and estimation requirements of the IPCC standards (which are separated into three progressive ‘Tiers’ for precision and accuracy).

 

Third, Indonesia must implement nation-wide policy instruments, and develop enforcement capacities. These requirements include, but are not limited to: (1) Two year moratorium on forest or peat land concessions (to be discussed subsequently); (2) Establish a degraded land database; (3) Enforce existing laws against illegal forestry activity, and establish a specialized enforcement unit for that purpose, and; (4) Resolve land tenure conflicts and compensation claims.

 

Fourth, be able to demonstrate progress in the first REDD pilot project. Deliverables (upon which further funding is contingent) include: (1) province-wide implementation of all strategies from Stage 1; (2) by December 2011, a province-wide MRV system conforming to Tier 2 IPCC standards is able to assess changes to (a) forest space and (b) emissions and reductions, and; (3) land tenure conflicts have been resolved.

 

Fifth, a second province-wide REDD pilot project is implemented by ‘early 2012’.

 

Stage 3: January 2014 onwards

The third stage is, in short, a national implementation of Indonesia’s REDD plan, along with full-scale implementation of the pilot-tested MRV technical assessment mechanism to measure the country’s proportional progress towards meeting pledged emissions cuts; at least 26% reduction by 2020.

 

Indonesia will receive annual USD 1 billion contributions (and more, from other financial partners) to assist, and sustain incentive for emissions reductions and forest protection. At this point, the MRV institution must be able to provide ‘Tier 3’ IPCC accuracy assessments of biomass carbon stocks and emissions, and must be able to have those results independently and internationally verified.

 

Implementation Concerns

One particular aspect of the Letter of Intent - the two-year moratorium on forest concessions beginning from 1 January 2011 - raises short and long-term concern for at least three elements in the business sectors.

 

First, the pulp and paper industry is critically dependent upon activities to exploit peat lands. Without access to new peat lands via suspended expansion licenses, the pulp and paper industry will be circumscribed to existing concession areas, which tend to be exploited at a rate much greater than their replenishment. As the 9th largest pulp and paper producer in the world, Indonesia’s REDD implementation not only threatens its comparative advantage in the area, but also risks the opportunity cost from lost state revenues; some USD 4 billion a year.

 

Second, the crude palm oil industry is concerned that its scope for expansion will be threatened. Muhammad Fadhil Hasan, the Executive Director of the Crude Palm Oil Businesspersons Coalition (‘GAPKI’), argued that expansion of the industry not only benefits business interests, but also contributes significantly to state revenues, employment opportunities, and local community-level economic activities (Warta Ekonomi, 31/5). President Yudhoyono, however, assured that the industry will be protected: “We have a policy to use degraded land…for the continuation of the palm oil industry in Indonesia,” as quoted from the Jakarta Post (27/5).

 

Indeed, an aspect of the REDD program is to more effectively exploit and cultivate already-degraded land, rather than rainforests and peat lands rich in biomass and carbon. The remaining issue is that there is little universal agreement on what land characteristics can be used to define ‘degraded land’; Norway and Indonesia will need to reach agreement on the issue as implementation gets underway.

 

A third business interest concerned about the moratorium is the Indonesian state’s mega ‘food estate’ project in Merauke, Papua. The massive food estate is designed to be an integrated food production zone, attracting investment in the agriculture sector and bolstering domestic food security in the process.

 

Government Regulation No. 18 of 2010 on Crop Cultivation Businesses, the prevailing regulation for the Merauke project, allows each investor a maximum of 20,000 hectares for the purposes of farming, plantation, or livestock. The Minister of Agriculture, Suswono, told Kompas.com two months ago (3/3) that the project had attracted many investors - but it now appears that, as a result of the moratorium (and whatever long-term forest conservation policy that follows it), they will be unable to secure concession-related licenses to engage in food production. That will certainly dissuade investment participation, and likely stagnate the project as a whole.

 

Conclusion

Indonesia will move to seriously protect its massive endowment of biomass in order to substantially reduce its carbon emissions - for which it will receive financial compensation. The REDD project will encounter obstacles, from weak enforcement of forestry regulation (i.e., illegal logging activities), to confrontation with business interests relating to forest and peat land activities. Also, given the lack of international consensus around particular aspects of the REDD program (definitions of ‘degraded land’ for example), once a Joint Consultation Group is established with representatives from both Norway and Indonesia, several issues await clarification and consensus.

 

Still, in light of the relative disappointment from the December 2009 Copenhagen summit and the failure to reach an internationally binding treatise on action against climate change, REDD projects are increasingly regarded as a viable alternative for substantive greenhouse gas reduction strategies. As a country with the second largest rainforest endowment in the world, Indonesia’s engagement in a REDD project will be followed closely. The project has the potential to demonstrate the viability of the REDD strategy, and also to cultivate Indonesia’s reputation as an exemplar for the international community to reduce emissions.

 

Although the Letter of Intent itself is not legally binding on either country, it does call for legal instruments to be promulgated in the near future. First, a formal bilateral agreement will be signed between Indonesia and Norway. Second, either a Presidential Regulation or Law will be issued to ratify that agreement.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

To reduce domestic and global greenhouse gas emissions, Indonesia has begun to, or at least signal its willingness to implement the Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD) program, which seeks to organize and finance a concerted international effort to reduce carbon emissions caused by deforestation. Indonesia’s latest move towards REDD implementation was by way of an initial bilateral agreement with Norway, signing a Letter of Intent to collaborate to help Indonesia implement forest-conscious reforms, and cut emissions accordingly.

 

This Indonesian Law Digest will survey that Letter of Intent, highlighting critical aspects for domestic stakeholders, and with attention to potential issues of implementation.

 

Context

It is estimated that deforestation and related degradation activity contributes 17% of all global greenhouse gas emissions, outweighing the emissions of the entire transport sector internationally. Indonesia is no exception to this trend: almost 80% of its carbon emissions are resultant from deforestation, forest degradation, and peat land conversion - often for the purpose of farming and harvesting Crude Palm Oil (CPO), among other things. Forests contain large amounts of stored CO2, which is released when the trees are cut down. As the nation with the second largest rainforest in the world, Indonesia is able to play a critical role in emissions reductions programs.

 

Under President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, Indonesia has set an emissions reduction target of 26% by 2020, and up to 41% reductions if the necessary funding could be provided. Norway intends to provide USD 1 billion annually to assist Indonesia in REDD implementation to meet those goals.

 

Purpose

Indonesia’s collaboration with Norway, as facilitated by the Letter of Intent and subsequent engagements, is expected to (a) bring about substantial reductions in Indonesia’s greenhouse gas emissions, and (b) improve forest governance and law enforcement. The Letter of Intent sets out three distinct phases of implementation, from planning to execution, stipulating timelines for different activities. It also discusses the issue of financing, and how the funds provided by Norway (and perhaps other countries) will be managed throughout each phase.

 

The REDD Program

In short, REDD is a ‘mechanism’ that brings developed-country funds to bear upon developing country forest conservation. Although it was designed through intensive international collaboration, as opposed to an international treatise, it is a flexible program, laying out an archetypal structure that can be adapted to particular domestic projects. 

 

Through a series of progressive steps, REDD provides the framework for countries with rich biomass to prevent (a) deforestation and (b) forest degradation, thereby reducing substantial greenhouse gas emissions, and protecting the environment from abuse. Each series of steps designed to achieve specific targets, initially beginning with policy reform and capacity building, and ending with independently verifiable emissions cuts. Meanwhile, financial and market incentives are provided upon successful implementation of each set of steps; funding contingent upon demonstrable action.

 

The Letter of Intent: Three Phases of Implementation

Overall, the Indonesia-Norway project is designed in three stages: (1) Preparation, (2) Transformation, and (3) Contributions-for-Verified Emission Reduction.

 

In the first two stages, focus will be upon enacting policies and measures to support serious reductions in emissions and deforestation. In the third and final stage, focus will be upon verifiable reductions.

 

Norway’s continued financial support throughout each stage will be contingent upon Indonesia achieving different milestones, or ‘deliverables’ for each particular stage. This serves as an incentive structure to maintain the course of REDD-oriented reform.

 

‘Organs’ of Implementation

Indonesia and Norway will together establish a ‘Joint Consultation Group’ to coordinate effective implementation of the REDD partnership.

 

An ‘Independent Review Group’ agreed upon by both Norway and Indonesia will review the deliverables to determine whether Indonesia is meeting all requirements in each phase, and report to (a) the Joint Consultation Group and (b) the public.

 

Stage 1: Preparation: 2010 to January 2011

First, Indonesia must initially put forth a viable national strategy to address deforestation, forest degradation, and peat land-related emissions.

 

Second, an independent agency must be established to coordinate REDD implementation and policy strategy, and be able to report directly to the President.

 

Third, another independent agency must be established to monitor, report, and verify (MRV) technical aspects of forest-related emission reductions. This agency must develop a system to measure (a) forest carbon stocks and emissions, and (b) changes in the size of natural forest and peat land areas. Its assessment techniques and standards will need to be able to comply with Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) standards, which will be verified by independent international verification.

 

Fourth, a ‘funding instrument’ must be established to collaborate with donors, as well as receive and distribute funds. Although transparently managed by an international financial institution, the funding instrument will compose of local stakeholders, from indigenous community leaders to government representatives.

 

Fifth, a particular province - one with significance to, and threatened by forestry activities - must be selected for a REDD pilot project, which will also need to be developed during this first stage.

 

Stage 2: Preparation: January 2011 to December 2013

In addition to administering one or more full-scale province-wide REDD pilot projects, the second stage focuses on policy and legal development, law enforcement, and capability building: the ‘infrastructure’ for serious emissions cuts in 2014, if not earlier.

 

First, by 1 January 2011, the funding instrument must be operational, and able to receive, and coordinate distribution of funds.

 

Second, by December 2013, the independent national MRV technical facility must be operational, and complying with ‘Tier 2’ measurement and estimation requirements of the IPCC standards (which are separated into three progressive ‘Tiers’ for precision and accuracy).

 

Third, Indonesia must implement nation-wide policy instruments, and develop enforcement capacities. These requirements include, but are not limited to: (1) Two year moratorium on forest or peat land concessions (to be discussed subsequently); (2) Establish a degraded land database; (3) Enforce existing laws against illegal forestry activity, and establish a specialized enforcement unit for that purpose, and; (4) Resolve land tenure conflicts and compensation claims.

 

Fourth, be able to demonstrate progress in the first REDD pilot project. Deliverables (upon which further funding is contingent) include: (1) province-wide implementation of all strategies from Stage 1; (2) by December 2011, a province-wide MRV system conforming to Tier 2 IPCC standards is able to assess changes to (a) forest space and (b) emissions and reductions, and; (3) land tenure conflicts have been resolved.

 

Fifth, a second province-wide REDD pilot project is implemented by ‘early 2012’.

 

Stage 3: January 2014 onwards

The third stage is, in short, a national implementation of Indonesia’s REDD plan, along with full-scale implementation of the pilot-tested MRV technical assessment mechanism to measure the country’s proportional progress towards meeting pledged emissions cuts; at least 26% reduction by 2020.

 

Indonesia will receive annual USD 1 billion contributions (and more, from other financial partners) to assist, and sustain incentive for emissions reductions and forest protection. At this point, the MRV institution must be able to provide ‘Tier 3’ IPCC accuracy assessments of biomass carbon stocks and emissions, and must be able to have those results independently and internationally verified.

 

Implementation Concerns

One particular aspect of the Letter of Intent - the two-year moratorium on forest concessions beginning from 1 January 2011 - raises short and long-term concern for at least three elements in the business sectors.

 

First, the pulp and paper industry is critically dependent upon activities to exploit peat lands. Without access to new peat lands via suspended expansion licenses, the pulp and paper industry will be circumscribed to existing concession areas, which tend to be exploited at a rate much greater than their replenishment. As the 9th largest pulp and paper producer in the world, Indonesia’s REDD implementation not only threatens its comparative advantage in the area, but also risks the opportunity cost from lost state revenues; some USD 4 billion a year.

 

Second, the crude palm oil industry is concerned that its scope for expansion will be threatened. Muhammad Fadhil Hasan, the Executive Director of the Crude Palm Oil Businesspersons Coalition (‘GAPKI’), argued that expansion of the industry not only benefits business interests, but also contributes significantly to state revenues, employment opportunities, and local community-level economic activities (Warta Ekonomi, 31/5). President Yudhoyono, however, assured that the industry will be protected: “We have a policy to use degraded land…for the continuation of the palm oil industry in Indonesia,” as quoted from the Jakarta Post (27/5).

 

Indeed, an aspect of the REDD program is to more effectively exploit and cultivate already-degraded land, rather than rainforests and peat lands rich in biomass and carbon. The remaining issue is that there is little universal agreement on what land characteristics can be used to define ‘degraded land’; Norway and Indonesia will need to reach agreement on the issue as implementation gets underway.

 

A third business interest concerned about the moratorium is the Indonesian state’s mega ‘food estate’ project in Merauke, Papua. The massive food estate is designed to be an integrated food production zone, attracting investment in the agriculture sector and bolstering domestic food security in the process.

 

Government Regulation No. 18 of 2010 on Crop Cultivation Businesses, the prevailing regulation for the Merauke project, allows each investor a maximum of 20,000 hectares for the purposes of farming, plantation, or livestock. The Minister of Agriculture, Suswono, told Kompas.com two months ago (3/3) that the project had attracted many investors - but it now appears that, as a result of the moratorium (and whatever long-term forest conservation policy that follows it), they will be unable to secure concession-related licenses to engage in food production. That will certainly dissuade investment participation, and likely stagnate the project as a whole.

 

Conclusion

Indonesia will move to seriously protect its massive endowment of biomass in order to substantially reduce its carbon emissions - for which it will receive financial compensation. The REDD project will encounter obstacles, from weak enforcement of forestry regulation (i.e., illegal logging activities), to confrontation with business interests relating to forest and peat land activities. Also, given the lack of international consensus around particular aspects of the REDD program (definitions of ‘degraded land’ for example), once a Joint Consultation Group is established with representatives from both Norway and Indonesia, several issues await clarification and consensus.

 

Still, in light of the relative disappointment from the December 2009 Copenhagen summit and the failure to reach an internationally binding treatise on action against climate change, REDD projects are increasingly regarded as a viable alternative for substantive greenhouse gas reduction strategies. As a country with the second largest rainforest endowment in the world, Indonesia’s engagement in a REDD project will be followed closely. The project has the potential to demonstrate the viability of the REDD strategy, and also to cultivate Indonesia’s reputation as an exemplar for the international community to reduce emissions.

 

Although the Letter of Intent itself is not legally binding on either country, it does call for legal instruments to be promulgated in the near future. First, a formal bilateral agreement will be signed between Indonesia and Norway. Second, either a Presidential Regulation or Law will be issued to ratify that agreement.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info