Foreign Property Ownership in Indonesia: Outlook on the Coming Change
Overview
The push to open Indonesia’s ‘closed-door’ policy for foreign land ownership in the country has been ongoing for some time. Indeed, Malaysia, Cambodia, Vietnam, and Singapore have invited foreigners to own land and property in their countries, whereas Indonesia has allowed only long-term leases and other forms of limited ownership.
It is a situation with many trade-offs, certainly. Still, it has been estimated that allowing foreigners to purchase properties in Indonesia (and later pay the lucrative property tax) could bring in revenues of up to USD 5 billion, or IDR 50 trillion per annum.
Although it appears unwilling to extend full ownership rights to foreigners, the government does appear willing to extend the amount of time allowed to foreigners for a lease of land for their exclusive use, and will soon release regulation to that effect.
The reform will modify the framework set forth by Government Regulation No. 41 of 1996 on Property or Residence Ownership by Foreigners Living in Indonesia (“Foreign Property Ownership Regulation”).
Although the Draft Regulation has not been circulated, much may be ascertained from the media statements of officials who have been involved in the drafting process.
This Indonesian Law Digest will both identify the core aspects of the coming reform as informed by pertinent officials, and also point out the issues with the currently-prevailing Foreign Property Ownership Regulation that created a necessity for reform in the first place.
The ‘Right to Use’: Foreigner’s Gateway to Utilize Lands in Indonesia
The first regulation to address foreign access to Indonesian land dates back to Law No. 5 of 1960 on the Basic Agrarian Law (“Agrarian Law”). The rights extended to foreigners by that Law are called ‘Right to Use’.
Article 41 (1) of the Agrarian Law defines the ‘Right to Use’ as the right to utilize and / or benefit from lands controlled by the state or Indonesian landowners. If the agreement is between a foreigner and the Indonesian state, formal approval must be issued from a government official. If the agreement is between a foreigner and an Indonesian landowner, the Right of Use must be formalized in a written lease agreement.
Any foreigner domiciled within Indonesia may utilize the ‘Right to Use’. As opposed to Indonesian nationals, who are extended the ‘Ownership Right,’ the Right to Use prohibits the free transfer of land ownership, and allows only a limited time for significant use of the land(s).
Yet, the Agrarian Law does not specify the time frame for Right to Use; it was later elaborated by Government Regulation No. 40 of 1996 on the Right to Exploit, Right to Build, and Right to Use Lands (“Right to Use Regulation”).
According to Article 45 (1) of the Right to Use Regulation, the state lands can be leased for a maximum of 25 years, with a one-time extension allowance of an additional 20 years. Still, according to Article 49 (1) of the same regulation, the Right to Use is simply for a 25 year period – no time extension is provided for. Article 49 (2) of the Right to Use Regulation goes on to state that extension must be negotiated with a Land Deed Official, but again provides no time limit. In short, the regulation is lacking on legal certainty as to what exact time period is entailed by Right to Use.
Existing Regulatory Framework on Property Ownership for Foreigners
In addition to uncertain timeframes, both the Agrarian Law and Right to Use Regulation are unclear as to what requirements must be satisfied by foreigners in order to obtain the Right to Use. The only clear requirement is that the domicile must be located within Indonesia. And then again, what precisely is meant by ‘domicile’?
Speaking to the uncertainty, Government Regulation No. 41 of 1996 on Property or Residence Ownership by Foreigners Living in Indonesia (“Foreign Property Ownership Regulation”) was issued, clarifying in Article 1 (1) that ‘domicile’ is equated with a single residence.
The residence can be:
1.
Build upon a state or citizen’s lot, the consequence being that the residence has a time limit of pseudo-ownership for 25 years, which can be renewed again for another 25 years at the maximum (i.e., 50 years in total).
2.
Units of apartment, which stands on Indonesian state land.
Yet more stringent requirements were placed upon foreign domiciles by State Minister for Agrarian Affairs / Head of the National Land Agency Regulation No. 7 of 1996 on the Requirements of Property or Residence Ownership by Foreigners Living in Indonesia (“Foreign Property Requirements Regulation”): if a foreigner has not made use of the residence for 12 months in a row, it can be declared ‘abandoned,’ and control of the property must be transferred to another recipient. If the one year timeframe has passed and no action by the foreigner has been taken, Article 6 (2) of the Foreign Property Ownership Regulation allows the property to be auctioned or given to the landowner.
Article 4 of the Foreign Property Requirements Regulation was later amended by State Minister for Agrarian Affairs / Head of the National Land Agency Regulation No. 8 of 1996, which essentially led to the mandate that foreigners would be granted residence (i.e., ‘Right to Use’) on the condition that ‘their being in Indonesia provides benefits to the national economy’. For many, this made matters less clear and contributed to even greater levels of uncertainty.
New Foreign Property Ownership Regulation in the Works
Wider foreign ownership in the property sector is likely a favorable to the property sector in Indonesia. Moreover, it might also benefit such industries as cement, construction, furniture, and so on; all can be seen as direct and indirect (e.g., tax) revenues to the state.
As quoted from Kompas.com, CEO and President Director of Bakrieland Development, Hiramsyah S. Thaib told reporters before a congress in Jakarta last month (7/4) that currently there are around 83,000 expatriates – as opposed to tourists – in Indonesia. Almost invariably, they require a permanent abode. Mr. Thaib posited that reform towards foreign land ownership would quickly produce enormous revenues for the state.
The government is currently reviewing the Foreign Property Ownership Regulation, and is planning to release a new regulation – likely to contain substantive differences – in the near future. “Very soon,” said Jamil Ansari, speaking for the Ministry of Public Housing at a seminar in Jakarta last week (Kompas.com 5/5).
“The revision has to go through a reporting procedure to the President, and then inter-departmental coordination. I expect the Draft Revision will be concluded at the end of May,” said Mr. Ansari.
According to Suharso Monoarfa (3/3), the Minister of Public Housing, the revision will increase the maximum timeframe of ‘Right to Use’ to up to 95 years, including extensions.
See also: ILB No. No. 1373 30/3/2010 on Expatriate Property Right – Draft Regulation Update.
Mr. Monoarfa also cautioned that only certain foreigners would be allowed to ‘own’ certain properties; those who could purchase properties above a certain minimal price (anywhere between USD 150,000 to USD 250,000).
Conclusion
Although the precise details of the forthcoming regulation on foreign property rights in Indonesia are yet unknown, what is certainly clear is that the existing regulatory framework on foreign land ownership is contradictory and unclear. Apart from content itself, the coming revision is able to provide a clear structure to ‘Right to Use’ and the conditions that are obliged of holders to that right.
As for content, at least from official statements, it is relatively clear that full foreign ownership of property in Indonesia (as defined by exclusive rights over the land and capacity to freely transfer its legal status to another recipient) cannot be promised by the coming regulation. Reports indicate that foreigners will maximally be able to lease property for up to 95 years under a ‘Right to Use’.
Still, that timeframe is nearly double than that which is afforded by the current prevailing regulation. Additionally, greater legal certainty over the status of a foreign-controlled ‘domicile’ in Indonesia may well give the property sector a healthy stimulus, though perhaps not to the extent hoped by real estate developers.
The push to open Indonesia’s ‘closed-door’ policy for foreign land ownership in the country has been ongoing for some time. Indeed, Malaysia, Cambodia, Vietnam, and Singapore have invited foreigners to own land and property in their countries, whereas Indonesia has allowed only long-term leases and other forms of limited ownership.
It is a situation with many trade-offs, certainly. Still, it has been estimated that allowing foreigners to purchase properties in Indonesia (and later pay the lucrative property tax) could bring in revenues of up to USD 5 billion, or IDR 50 trillion per annum.
Although it appears unwilling to extend full ownership rights to foreigners, the government does appear willing to extend the amount of time allowed to foreigners for a lease of land for their exclusive use, and will soon release regulation to that effect.
The reform will modify the framework set forth by Government Regulation No. 41 of 1996 on Property or Residence Ownership by Foreigners Living in Indonesia (“Foreign Property Ownership Regulation”).
Although the Draft Regulation has not been circulated, much may be ascertained from the media statements of officials who have been involved in the drafting process.
This Indonesian Law Digest will both identify the core aspects of the coming reform as informed by pertinent officials, and also point out the issues with the currently-prevailing Foreign Property Ownership Regulation that created a necessity for reform in the first place.
The ‘Right to Use’: Foreigner’s Gateway to Utilize Lands in Indonesia
The first regulation to address foreign access to Indonesian land dates back to Law No. 5 of 1960 on the Basic Agrarian Law (“Agrarian Law”). The rights extended to foreigners by that Law are called ‘Right to Use’.
Article 41 (1) of the Agrarian Law defines the ‘Right to Use’ as the right to utilize and / or benefit from lands controlled by the state or Indonesian landowners. If the agreement is between a foreigner and the Indonesian state, formal approval must be issued from a government official. If the agreement is between a foreigner and an Indonesian landowner, the Right of Use must be formalized in a written lease agreement.
Any foreigner domiciled within Indonesia may utilize the ‘Right to Use’. As opposed to Indonesian nationals, who are extended the ‘Ownership Right,’ the Right to Use prohibits the free transfer of land ownership, and allows only a limited time for significant use of the land(s).
Yet, the Agrarian Law does not specify the time frame for Right to Use; it was later elaborated by Government Regulation No. 40 of 1996 on the Right to Exploit, Right to Build, and Right to Use Lands (“Right to Use Regulation”).
According to Article 45 (1) of the Right to Use Regulation, the state lands can be leased for a maximum of 25 years, with a one-time extension allowance of an additional 20 years. Still, according to Article 49 (1) of the same regulation, the Right to Use is simply for a 25 year period – no time extension is provided for. Article 49 (2) of the Right to Use Regulation goes on to state that extension must be negotiated with a Land Deed Official, but again provides no time limit. In short, the regulation is lacking on legal certainty as to what exact time period is entailed by Right to Use.
Existing Regulatory Framework on Property Ownership for Foreigners
In addition to uncertain timeframes, both the Agrarian Law and Right to Use Regulation are unclear as to what requirements must be satisfied by foreigners in order to obtain the Right to Use. The only clear requirement is that the domicile must be located within Indonesia. And then again, what precisely is meant by ‘domicile’?
Speaking to the uncertainty, Government Regulation No. 41 of 1996 on Property or Residence Ownership by Foreigners Living in Indonesia (“Foreign Property Ownership Regulation”) was issued, clarifying in Article 1 (1) that ‘domicile’ is equated with a single residence.
The residence can be:
1.
Build upon a state or citizen’s lot, the consequence being that the residence has a time limit of pseudo-ownership for 25 years, which can be renewed again for another 25 years at the maximum (i.e., 50 years in total).
2.
Units of apartment, which stands on Indonesian state land.
Yet more stringent requirements were placed upon foreign domiciles by State Minister for Agrarian Affairs / Head of the National Land Agency Regulation No. 7 of 1996 on the Requirements of Property or Residence Ownership by Foreigners Living in Indonesia (“Foreign Property Requirements Regulation”): if a foreigner has not made use of the residence for 12 months in a row, it can be declared ‘abandoned,’ and control of the property must be transferred to another recipient. If the one year timeframe has passed and no action by the foreigner has been taken, Article 6 (2) of the Foreign Property Ownership Regulation allows the property to be auctioned or given to the landowner.
Article 4 of the Foreign Property Requirements Regulation was later amended by State Minister for Agrarian Affairs / Head of the National Land Agency Regulation No. 8 of 1996, which essentially led to the mandate that foreigners would be granted residence (i.e., ‘Right to Use’) on the condition that ‘their being in Indonesia provides benefits to the national economy’. For many, this made matters less clear and contributed to even greater levels of uncertainty.
New Foreign Property Ownership Regulation in the Works
Wider foreign ownership in the property sector is likely a favorable to the property sector in Indonesia. Moreover, it might also benefit such industries as cement, construction, furniture, and so on; all can be seen as direct and indirect (e.g., tax) revenues to the state.
As quoted from Kompas.com, CEO and President Director of Bakrieland Development, Hiramsyah S. Thaib told reporters before a congress in Jakarta last month (7/4) that currently there are around 83,000 expatriates – as opposed to tourists – in Indonesia. Almost invariably, they require a permanent abode. Mr. Thaib posited that reform towards foreign land ownership would quickly produce enormous revenues for the state.
The government is currently reviewing the Foreign Property Ownership Regulation, and is planning to release a new regulation – likely to contain substantive differences – in the near future. “Very soon,” said Jamil Ansari, speaking for the Ministry of Public Housing at a seminar in Jakarta last week (Kompas.com 5/5).
“The revision has to go through a reporting procedure to the President, and then inter-departmental coordination. I expect the Draft Revision will be concluded at the end of May,” said Mr. Ansari.
According to Suharso Monoarfa (3/3), the Minister of Public Housing, the revision will increase the maximum timeframe of ‘Right to Use’ to up to 95 years, including extensions.
See also: ILB No. No. 1373 30/3/2010 on Expatriate Property Right – Draft Regulation Update.
Mr. Monoarfa also cautioned that only certain foreigners would be allowed to ‘own’ certain properties; those who could purchase properties above a certain minimal price (anywhere between USD 150,000 to USD 250,000).
Conclusion
Although the precise details of the forthcoming regulation on foreign property rights in Indonesia are yet unknown, what is certainly clear is that the existing regulatory framework on foreign land ownership is contradictory and unclear. Apart from content itself, the coming revision is able to provide a clear structure to ‘Right to Use’ and the conditions that are obliged of holders to that right.
As for content, at least from official statements, it is relatively clear that full foreign ownership of property in Indonesia (as defined by exclusive rights over the land and capacity to freely transfer its legal status to another recipient) cannot be promised by the coming regulation. Reports indicate that foreigners will maximally be able to lease property for up to 95 years under a ‘Right to Use’.
Still, that timeframe is nearly double than that which is afforded by the current prevailing regulation. Additionally, greater legal certainty over the status of a foreign-controlled ‘domicile’ in Indonesia may well give the property sector a healthy stimulus, though perhaps not to the extent hoped by real estate developers.