Draft Government Regulation on Environmental Impact Assessment: Work in Progress

Overview

Since its release, Law No. 39 of 2009 on Environment Protection and Management (“Environment Law”) has been the subject of much controversy. Large swathes of the business community oppose it, particularly in the extractive sectors. Also, the Law is effectively incomplete: many implementing regulations are still forthcoming, and legal certainty in environmental matters is somewhat suspended for that reason. However, an implementing regulation on the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is being drafted, and because the EIA is the necessary antecedent for licensed environmental utilization under the new Law, it is particularly critical to lend structure to the environmental regulatory framework.

 

EIA are studies of the “important impact” a business activity will have on an environmental area. EIA were first used in Indonesia as early as 1982, but there have been problems: (1) lenient requirements for those who do the assessment lead to poor decisions about environmental use by officials, and; (2) in many cases the EIA is not required by officials at all, who simply allow a business activity to go ahead.

 

The Ministry of Environment is currently promoting the Draft Government Regulation on Environmental Impact Assessment (“EIA Draft Regulation”), and is soliciting inputs from the public. The latest Draft obtained by hukumonline at the end of April suggests that in some ways, the Draft is similar to its predecessor, Government Regulation No. 27 of 1999 (“1999 Regulation”), but is practically double the size and includes some new addendums.

 

This Indonesian Law Digest will briefly highlight key provisions of the Draft with comparative reference to the previous 1999 Regulation. Admittedly, the Draft is still subject to modification.

 

Purpose

The EIA Draft Regulation expands upon several new provisions of the Environment Law, and accommodates the similar provisions of the 1999 Regulation within the Law’s ‘umbrella’ framework. It also unifies a series of provisions that were scattered throughout different regulations in a singular regulation dedicated specifically to EIA. Finally, it introduces new provisions that are intended to make EIA more of a reality for prospective business activities with varying degrees of environmental risk.

 

EIA, UKL-UKP, and SPPL

The first stage is to assess whether or not there will be an ‘important impact’ to the environment as a result of a proposed activity.

 

If it is determined that an important impact will result, the party who wishes to engage in an environment-risking business activity must consult an accredited assessment agency for an EIA. If it is decided that there will not be an important impact, the business interest must still obtain what is known as ‘UKL-UPL,’ which is issued for less environmentally-endangering activities.

 

In turn, both UKL-UPL and EIA are required in processes to obtain subsequent licenses, such as a Mining Business License.

 

The Draft also introduces ‘SPPL’ for those small-sized and less-intensive business interests which do not need to obtain UKL-UPL or EIA due to the minimal level of environmental risk that is entailed by the business proposition. The SPPL is a statement of commitment from a business interest that the environmental integrity of a given area will remain intact, well-managed, and properly supervised.

 

Important Impact

According Article 1 (3) of the Draft, an ‘important impact’ is defined as a fundamental change in the environment that is caused by certain activities.

 

Identical to the 1999 Regulation, the Draft in Article 10 (2) states that an important impact can be verified through 7 criteria. Among other things, they include: the population size that will be affected by the impact, areas that will be affected by the impact’s widespread effect, intensity and time-frame of the impact, and an evaluation of what precisely in the environment will be affected by the impact. 

 

Activities with the potential to create an important impact are laid out in Article 11 (1) of the Draft, and they include: natural resource exploitation, introduction of new animals, microorganisms, and plants, application of technologies that may influence the environment, and other activities that will affect conservation areas.

 

Specific activities that automatically require an important impact assessment and presumably EIA are not actually set out by the Draft, and neither are they listed in the 1999 Regulation. Instead, they are listed in Minister of Environment Regulation No. 11 of 2006.

 

 

 

Environmental Impact Assessment Procedure

After a proposed activity is decided to require an EIA, the business interest must prepare a series of documents to obtain approval, which takes form as a ‘Decision of Environmental Worthiness’ from the Minister of Environment, governor, regent, or mayor depending on the jurisdiction. Required documents include the Terms of Reference for EIA (‘KA-AMDAL’), Environmental Impact Statement (‘ANDAL’), Environmental Management Plan (‘RKL’), and Environmental Monitoring Plan (‘RPL’). Each of those terms and documents is defined in Article 1 of the Draft.

 

The KA-AMDAL becomes the reference for subsequent documents - the ANDAL, RKL, and RPL. The KA-AMDAL must first however be approved by the EIA Appraisal Commission, an official commission established by the central or regional governments which is expressly formed to assess EIA documents.

 

Again, the ANDAL, RKL, and RPL documents must also be approved by the EIA Appraisal Commission, which will then relay their opinion to the appropriate authority (Minister, governor, regent, or mayor) regarding the Decision of Environmental Worthiness; the authority will deliberate on that opinion.

 

Throughout the deliberation process, the public’s opinion is also consulted and their recommendation is considered. The Decision of Environmental Worthiness must be issued (or declined) within 75 days of the documents and application being received.

 

Public Participation

If an activity poses the threat of an important impact, and an EIA is formulated accordingly, a public announcement including information about what activity is proposed - and where it will take place - must be made by both the relevant state authority and the business interest. After the announcement, 10 days are given for public inputs (whereas 30 days were given by the 1999 Regulation).

 

Further regulation on public information and participation in this process is to be found in the Environmental Impact Control Agency (‘Bappedal’) Decision No. 8 of 2000.

 

 

 

Certification and Licensing for Drafters of EIA Documents, and Appraisers for the EIA Appraisal Commission

 

The lackluster quality of appraisers in the EIA Appraisal Commission is evidenced by the massive environmental damage that has been allowed to take place in Indonesia since the very inception of the EIA itself. Both the Environmental Law and the EIA Draft Regulation thus place stringent prerequisites on who may be eligible to be an EIA document drafter and appraiser.

 

Drafters of EIA Documents

Drafters of EIA documents (KA-AMDAL, ANDAL, RPL, and so on) may work in the private sphere, must first take a certification test, which is to be held by the Competency Registration Institute, which is managed by the state. Companies that employ certified drafters must also be certified themselves, but by a different Competency Certification Institute, which can be private but working on behalf of the state. Although the 1999 Regulation provided that certification would be required, the implementing regulation to clarify the details was never released and thus the provision was never applied. It would appear the problematic accreditation quandary remains.

 

Appraisers of the EIA Appraisal Commission

Appraisers on the EIA Appraisal Commission work for the state, or public sphere. The issue of unqualified appraisers is perhaps one of the greatest factors contributing to the failure of EIA to protect and maintain the Indonesian environment; the EIA Draft Regulation sets out in Article 22 that all appraisers in the EIA Appraisal Commission must be licensed by either the central or regional government. In order to get the license, however, the requirements are referred to Minister of Environment Regulation No. 6 of 2008 on the Procedure to License EIA Appraisal Commission.

 

Expected Date of Issuance

It is unclear as to when this Draft will be finalized by the government. The 2009 Environment Law is clear however that the Draft must be concluded and issued by the government before 3 October 2010. 

 

Conclusion

The EIA Draft Regulation may have breadth, doubling the size of the 1999 Regulation, but in fact may lack substantially improved depth. Given that the EIA has been in existence since 1982, it is likely a lack of depth and detail that have inhibited its potential as a mechanism for environmental protection since its inception. Instead of going into specifics, this regulation’s breadth owes largely to its unification of other provisions in other subsequent implementing regulations to the 1999 predecessor: that adds to the current EIA Draft Regulation’s size, but perhaps only that.

 

One noticeable modification lies in the reduced time period for public consultation once an important impact is assessed; whereas the previous regulation allowed 30 days, the Draft allows 10. Even with 30 days of public consultation, the EIA itself is a highly technical, often quite lengthy document; it needs time to be critically evaluated if the public is to not be entirely unsuspecting of the changes to come.

 

Moreover, the EIA assesses for environmental impact, but does little to address what recourse the public communities may have if there should be wholesale destruction of their environment. For that reason, a shorter time-frame for public consultation is noticeable.

 

The EIA Draft Regulation is currently just that - a draft. It is currently being circulated to the public for inputs, and with a relatively long window for change, it is possible that the finalized version may be improved with greater specificity and appreciation for public consultation.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

Since its release, Law No. 39 of 2009 on Environment Protection and Management (“Environment Law”) has been the subject of much controversy. Large swathes of the business community oppose it, particularly in the extractive sectors. Also, the Law is effectively incomplete: many implementing regulations are still forthcoming, and legal certainty in environmental matters is somewhat suspended for that reason. However, an implementing regulation on the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is being drafted, and because the EIA is the necessary antecedent for licensed environmental utilization under the new Law, it is particularly critical to lend structure to the environmental regulatory framework.

 

EIA are studies of the “important impact” a business activity will have on an environmental area. EIA were first used in Indonesia as early as 1982, but there have been problems: (1) lenient requirements for those who do the assessment lead to poor decisions about environmental use by officials, and; (2) in many cases the EIA is not required by officials at all, who simply allow a business activity to go ahead.

 

The Ministry of Environment is currently promoting the Draft Government Regulation on Environmental Impact Assessment (“EIA Draft Regulation”), and is soliciting inputs from the public. The latest Draft obtained by hukumonline at the end of April suggests that in some ways, the Draft is similar to its predecessor, Government Regulation No. 27 of 1999 (“1999 Regulation”), but is practically double the size and includes some new addendums.

 

This Indonesian Law Digest will briefly highlight key provisions of the Draft with comparative reference to the previous 1999 Regulation. Admittedly, the Draft is still subject to modification.

 

Purpose

The EIA Draft Regulation expands upon several new provisions of the Environment Law, and accommodates the similar provisions of the 1999 Regulation within the Law’s ‘umbrella’ framework. It also unifies a series of provisions that were scattered throughout different regulations in a singular regulation dedicated specifically to EIA. Finally, it introduces new provisions that are intended to make EIA more of a reality for prospective business activities with varying degrees of environmental risk.

 

EIA, UKL-UKP, and SPPL

The first stage is to assess whether or not there will be an ‘important impact’ to the environment as a result of a proposed activity.

 

If it is determined that an important impact will result, the party who wishes to engage in an environment-risking business activity must consult an accredited assessment agency for an EIA. If it is decided that there will not be an important impact, the business interest must still obtain what is known as ‘UKL-UPL,’ which is issued for less environmentally-endangering activities.

 

In turn, both UKL-UPL and EIA are required in processes to obtain subsequent licenses, such as a Mining Business License.

 

The Draft also introduces ‘SPPL’ for those small-sized and less-intensive business interests which do not need to obtain UKL-UPL or EIA due to the minimal level of environmental risk that is entailed by the business proposition. The SPPL is a statement of commitment from a business interest that the environmental integrity of a given area will remain intact, well-managed, and properly supervised.

 

Important Impact

According Article 1 (3) of the Draft, an ‘important impact’ is defined as a fundamental change in the environment that is caused by certain activities.

 

Identical to the 1999 Regulation, the Draft in Article 10 (2) states that an important impact can be verified through 7 criteria. Among other things, they include: the population size that will be affected by the impact, areas that will be affected by the impact’s widespread effect, intensity and time-frame of the impact, and an evaluation of what precisely in the environment will be affected by the impact. 

 

Activities with the potential to create an important impact are laid out in Article 11 (1) of the Draft, and they include: natural resource exploitation, introduction of new animals, microorganisms, and plants, application of technologies that may influence the environment, and other activities that will affect conservation areas.

 

Specific activities that automatically require an important impact assessment and presumably EIA are not actually set out by the Draft, and neither are they listed in the 1999 Regulation. Instead, they are listed in Minister of Environment Regulation No. 11 of 2006.

 

 

 

Environmental Impact Assessment Procedure

After a proposed activity is decided to require an EIA, the business interest must prepare a series of documents to obtain approval, which takes form as a ‘Decision of Environmental Worthiness’ from the Minister of Environment, governor, regent, or mayor depending on the jurisdiction. Required documents include the Terms of Reference for EIA (‘KA-AMDAL’), Environmental Impact Statement (‘ANDAL’), Environmental Management Plan (‘RKL’), and Environmental Monitoring Plan (‘RPL’). Each of those terms and documents is defined in Article 1 of the Draft.

 

The KA-AMDAL becomes the reference for subsequent documents - the ANDAL, RKL, and RPL. The KA-AMDAL must first however be approved by the EIA Appraisal Commission, an official commission established by the central or regional governments which is expressly formed to assess EIA documents.

 

Again, the ANDAL, RKL, and RPL documents must also be approved by the EIA Appraisal Commission, which will then relay their opinion to the appropriate authority (Minister, governor, regent, or mayor) regarding the Decision of Environmental Worthiness; the authority will deliberate on that opinion.

 

Throughout the deliberation process, the public’s opinion is also consulted and their recommendation is considered. The Decision of Environmental Worthiness must be issued (or declined) within 75 days of the documents and application being received.

 

Public Participation

If an activity poses the threat of an important impact, and an EIA is formulated accordingly, a public announcement including information about what activity is proposed - and where it will take place - must be made by both the relevant state authority and the business interest. After the announcement, 10 days are given for public inputs (whereas 30 days were given by the 1999 Regulation).

 

Further regulation on public information and participation in this process is to be found in the Environmental Impact Control Agency (‘Bappedal’) Decision No. 8 of 2000.

 

 

 

Certification and Licensing for Drafters of EIA Documents, and Appraisers for the EIA Appraisal Commission

 

The lackluster quality of appraisers in the EIA Appraisal Commission is evidenced by the massive environmental damage that has been allowed to take place in Indonesia since the very inception of the EIA itself. Both the Environmental Law and the EIA Draft Regulation thus place stringent prerequisites on who may be eligible to be an EIA document drafter and appraiser.

 

Drafters of EIA Documents

Drafters of EIA documents (KA-AMDAL, ANDAL, RPL, and so on) may work in the private sphere, must first take a certification test, which is to be held by the Competency Registration Institute, which is managed by the state. Companies that employ certified drafters must also be certified themselves, but by a different Competency Certification Institute, which can be private but working on behalf of the state. Although the 1999 Regulation provided that certification would be required, the implementing regulation to clarify the details was never released and thus the provision was never applied. It would appear the problematic accreditation quandary remains.

 

Appraisers of the EIA Appraisal Commission

Appraisers on the EIA Appraisal Commission work for the state, or public sphere. The issue of unqualified appraisers is perhaps one of the greatest factors contributing to the failure of EIA to protect and maintain the Indonesian environment; the EIA Draft Regulation sets out in Article 22 that all appraisers in the EIA Appraisal Commission must be licensed by either the central or regional government. In order to get the license, however, the requirements are referred to Minister of Environment Regulation No. 6 of 2008 on the Procedure to License EIA Appraisal Commission.

 

Expected Date of Issuance

It is unclear as to when this Draft will be finalized by the government. The 2009 Environment Law is clear however that the Draft must be concluded and issued by the government before 3 October 2010. 

 

Conclusion

The EIA Draft Regulation may have breadth, doubling the size of the 1999 Regulation, but in fact may lack substantially improved depth. Given that the EIA has been in existence since 1982, it is likely a lack of depth and detail that have inhibited its potential as a mechanism for environmental protection since its inception. Instead of going into specifics, this regulation’s breadth owes largely to its unification of other provisions in other subsequent implementing regulations to the 1999 predecessor: that adds to the current EIA Draft Regulation’s size, but perhaps only that.

 

One noticeable modification lies in the reduced time period for public consultation once an important impact is assessed; whereas the previous regulation allowed 30 days, the Draft allows 10. Even with 30 days of public consultation, the EIA itself is a highly technical, often quite lengthy document; it needs time to be critically evaluated if the public is to not be entirely unsuspecting of the changes to come.

 

Moreover, the EIA assesses for environmental impact, but does little to address what recourse the public communities may have if there should be wholesale destruction of their environment. For that reason, a shorter time-frame for public consultation is noticeable.

 

The EIA Draft Regulation is currently just that - a draft. It is currently being circulated to the public for inputs, and with a relatively long window for change, it is possible that the finalized version may be improved with greater specificity and appreciation for public consultation.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info