Geothermal Energy Development and Regulatory Framework

Overview

 

Indonesia hosted the 2010 World Geothermal Congress in Nusa Dua, Bali this week. The international symposium is held every 5 years, and encourages the use of geothermal energy as an environmentally friendly, renewable energy supply; the theme this year was ‘Geothermal: The Energy to Change the World’. Indonesia’s hosting of the event likely brought the spotlight of investment interest onto the domestic geothermal sector, which has significant indwelling potential.

 

Indonesia contains some 40% of the world’s geothermal energy potential, estimated Suryadarma, the President of the Indonesian Geothermal Association (INAGA) (WCG2010 Daily News II, 26/4); potential that is almost entirely neglected.

 

Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources data from last year (3/12/09) indicate that Indonesia’s geothermal energy potential is in excess of 28,000 megawatts (MW). Only 4% of that energy - some 1.189 MW - is actually used for geothermal power generation.

 

Apart from issues around political will, Indonesia has been unable to develop its geothermal resources due to a lack of funding; the initial investment required in this particular field is substantial, although the renewable long-term benefits are certainly more than proportional.

 

Prior to the congress in Bali, Indonesia endeavored to promote investment in the geothermal energy sector, partly by crafting what was thought to be a favorable regulatory framework for geothermal miners and investors. The objectives of those regulations have evidently not been realized. Mr. Suryadarma drew attention to some of the troublesome dynamics in the Bali conference, which as he later explained to Bisnis Indonesia (27/4), tend to be issues around divergent implementation from what is stated in the regulation.

 

This Indonesian Law Digest seeks to assess the most pertinent existing regulations on geothermal energy resources, inquiring as to why those regulations have failed to achieve their desired effect, and what might be done to rectify the issues.

 

The National Geothermal Regulatory Framework in a Nutshell

 

‘Umbrella Regulation’

 

Although disunified legal ‘bits and pieces’ existed previously, Law No. 27 of 2003 on Geothermal (“Geothermal Law”) was the first comprehensive effort to specifically regulate geothermal matters in Indonesia.  It was released with the intention of facilitating an upsurge of development in the sector and improving Indonesia’s energy independence, thereby improving the lives of citizens. To realize those goals, the state would have to call upon substantial investment and development assistance from the private sector domestically and abroad. That is reflected by many accommodations for business involvement in the Geothermal Law. 

 

Under the Law, businesses are invited to take part in the exploration and exploitation of geothermal energy. In order to do so, businesses must have a ‘Geothermal Mining Business License’. In short, the arrangement is such that state retains ultimate control over the activities of geothermal energy production, and procures related services as needed from the private sector.

 

Implementing Regulation

 

Equally fundamental to the Geothermal Law is one particular implementing regulation, Government Regulation No. 59 of 2007 on Geothermal Business Activities (“2007 Regulation”). It elaborates geothermal extraction processes from start to finish in greater detail, with topics covering: (1) ‘Initial Survey’ to establish geothermal potential in areas; (2) determination of geothermal drilling areas, and holding a tender offer to interested businesses; (3) exploration; (4) feasibility study; (5) exploitation, and; (6) utilization.    

 

The Initial Survey of an area collects and analyzes data on a prospective geothermal resource location, which is typically one associated with a fault line or other tectonic activity. Depending on the jurisdiction, the respective governments will coordinate to have this Survey done, and subsequently publicize the findings.

 

Private sector entities interested in being involved with further geothermal development of an area must bid for the procurement contract in a tender process, which is intimately detailed in the 2007 Regulation. The regulation covers how the tender committee is established, what requirements must be fulfilled by applicants, dispute settlement for applicants, and how to hold a second round of tendering if the first proves unsuccessful.

 

Once a business is awarded a geothermal mining area, they must obtain the respective mining and business licenses before being able to explore and produce geothermal energy resources.

 

Other Regulations

 

The Geothermal Law and its implementing 2007 Regulation merely govern matters related to upstream geothermal mining activities: spatial planning, downstream distribution of geothermal energy, state procurement of goods and services conditions, electricity consumption activities - these are subjects of other regulation. For example, transforming geothermal energy into electricity for distribution is subject to provisions of Law No. 30 of 2009 on Electricity.

 

For further reading of Law No. 30 of 2009 on Electricity, see ILB No. 1184 9/9/2009 and ILD No. 132 23/10/2009.

 

Issues of Implementation

 

The number of different regulations relating directly and indirectly to geothermal energy exploitation creates rife opportunity for conflict and legal tension. Legal certainty has been particularly lacking in the mining sector; it is not just a lack of funds and human capital that underlies the failure to capitalize on Indonesia’s vast geothermal potential. 

 

Law No. 41 of 1999 on Forestry has posed perhaps the most serious obstacle thus far: Article 38 (4) of the Law prohibits mining (including geothermal mining) to take place in any Protected Forest Area. But 70% of the geothermal ‘hot spots’ for energy resources are located in Protected Forests. This continues to be a problem for development of and investment in the sector.

 

Government Regulation No. 24 of 2010 on Forest Area Utilization came into force recently on 1 February 2010: Article 5 (1) (b) sets out that mining (geothermal included) can be done in Protected Forests, provided the activity does not cause (a) land subsidence, (b) a permanent change in the real function of the forest, or (c) damage to the aquifer. However, according to Article 5 (2) of the same Regulation, further details will be elaborated in a Presidential Regulation that does not yet exist, adding no small degree of lingering uncertainty as to what other conditions are forthcoming.

 

Conclusion

 

Looking forward: Indonesia is currently engaged in a 10,000 MW energy acceleration project, which it hopes to have completed by 2015. The cost of the project is estimated to be in the area of USD 12 billion. Almost half the desired energy capacity expansion - 4,713 MW - is intended to be generated from geothermal resources, according to Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources data obtained by hukumonline. Although perhaps not overly ambitious, it is dubious as to whether the targets can be met unless the government clearly dismantles the ‘red tape’ holding back geothermal mining activities, and creates incentives for mining investors by way of a straightforward, legally certain, and perhaps preferential regulatory framework.

 

Certain preferences have indeed been extended by recent reforms. Public-private partnerships offer greater security and incentives to private investors. Removal or reduction of import tariffs on material imports required to develop the sector reduce opportunity costs for investors. Simplified licensing procedures have been discussed in much recent regulation. Although currently under judicial review, the 2009 Electricity Law allows private parties to organize electricity distribution businesses under certain conditions, as opposed to reserving that right exclusively for the State Electricity Company (‘PLN’). Among other things, these efforts reflect a dedicated multi-pronged approach to cultivating a more favorable investment climate in the developing geothermal energy sector.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku

Overview

 

Indonesia hosted the 2010 World Geothermal Congress in Nusa Dua, Bali this week. The international symposium is held every 5 years, and encourages the use of geothermal energy as an environmentally friendly, renewable energy supply; the theme this year was ‘Geothermal: The Energy to Change the World’. Indonesia’s hosting of the event likely brought the spotlight of investment interest onto the domestic geothermal sector, which has significant indwelling potential.

 

Indonesia contains some 40% of the world’s geothermal energy potential, estimated Suryadarma, the President of the Indonesian Geothermal Association (INAGA) (WCG2010 Daily News II, 26/4); potential that is almost entirely neglected.

 

Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources data from last year (3/12/09) indicate that Indonesia’s geothermal energy potential is in excess of 28,000 megawatts (MW). Only 4% of that energy - some 1.189 MW - is actually used for geothermal power generation.

 

Apart from issues around political will, Indonesia has been unable to develop its geothermal resources due to a lack of funding; the initial investment required in this particular field is substantial, although the renewable long-term benefits are certainly more than proportional.

 

Prior to the congress in Bali, Indonesia endeavored to promote investment in the geothermal energy sector, partly by crafting what was thought to be a favorable regulatory framework for geothermal miners and investors. The objectives of those regulations have evidently not been realized. Mr. Suryadarma drew attention to some of the troublesome dynamics in the Bali conference, which as he later explained to Bisnis Indonesia (27/4), tend to be issues around divergent implementation from what is stated in the regulation.

 

This Indonesian Law Digest seeks to assess the most pertinent existing regulations on geothermal energy resources, inquiring as to why those regulations have failed to achieve their desired effect, and what might be done to rectify the issues.

 

The National Geothermal Regulatory Framework in a Nutshell

 

‘Umbrella Regulation’

 

Although disunified legal ‘bits and pieces’ existed previously, Law No. 27 of 2003 on Geothermal (“Geothermal Law”) was the first comprehensive effort to specifically regulate geothermal matters in Indonesia.  It was released with the intention of facilitating an upsurge of development in the sector and improving Indonesia’s energy independence, thereby improving the lives of citizens. To realize those goals, the state would have to call upon substantial investment and development assistance from the private sector domestically and abroad. That is reflected by many accommodations for business involvement in the Geothermal Law. 

 

Under the Law, businesses are invited to take part in the exploration and exploitation of geothermal energy. In order to do so, businesses must have a ‘Geothermal Mining Business License’. In short, the arrangement is such that state retains ultimate control over the activities of geothermal energy production, and procures related services as needed from the private sector.

 

Implementing Regulation

 

Equally fundamental to the Geothermal Law is one particular implementing regulation, Government Regulation No. 59 of 2007 on Geothermal Business Activities (“2007 Regulation”). It elaborates geothermal extraction processes from start to finish in greater detail, with topics covering: (1) ‘Initial Survey’ to establish geothermal potential in areas; (2) determination of geothermal drilling areas, and holding a tender offer to interested businesses; (3) exploration; (4) feasibility study; (5) exploitation, and; (6) utilization.    

 

The Initial Survey of an area collects and analyzes data on a prospective geothermal resource location, which is typically one associated with a fault line or other tectonic activity. Depending on the jurisdiction, the respective governments will coordinate to have this Survey done, and subsequently publicize the findings.

 

Private sector entities interested in being involved with further geothermal development of an area must bid for the procurement contract in a tender process, which is intimately detailed in the 2007 Regulation. The regulation covers how the tender committee is established, what requirements must be fulfilled by applicants, dispute settlement for applicants, and how to hold a second round of tendering if the first proves unsuccessful.

 

Once a business is awarded a geothermal mining area, they must obtain the respective mining and business licenses before being able to explore and produce geothermal energy resources.

 

Other Regulations

 

The Geothermal Law and its implementing 2007 Regulation merely govern matters related to upstream geothermal mining activities: spatial planning, downstream distribution of geothermal energy, state procurement of goods and services conditions, electricity consumption activities - these are subjects of other regulation. For example, transforming geothermal energy into electricity for distribution is subject to provisions of Law No. 30 of 2009 on Electricity.

 

For further reading of Law No. 30 of 2009 on Electricity, see ILB No. 1184 9/9/2009 and ILD No. 132 23/10/2009.

 

Issues of Implementation

 

The number of different regulations relating directly and indirectly to geothermal energy exploitation creates rife opportunity for conflict and legal tension. Legal certainty has been particularly lacking in the mining sector; it is not just a lack of funds and human capital that underlies the failure to capitalize on Indonesia’s vast geothermal potential. 

 

Law No. 41 of 1999 on Forestry has posed perhaps the most serious obstacle thus far: Article 38 (4) of the Law prohibits mining (including geothermal mining) to take place in any Protected Forest Area. But 70% of the geothermal ‘hot spots’ for energy resources are located in Protected Forests. This continues to be a problem for development of and investment in the sector.

 

Government Regulation No. 24 of 2010 on Forest Area Utilization came into force recently on 1 February 2010: Article 5 (1) (b) sets out that mining (geothermal included) can be done in Protected Forests, provided the activity does not cause (a) land subsidence, (b) a permanent change in the real function of the forest, or (c) damage to the aquifer. However, according to Article 5 (2) of the same Regulation, further details will be elaborated in a Presidential Regulation that does not yet exist, adding no small degree of lingering uncertainty as to what other conditions are forthcoming.

 

Conclusion

 

Looking forward: Indonesia is currently engaged in a 10,000 MW energy acceleration project, which it hopes to have completed by 2015. The cost of the project is estimated to be in the area of USD 12 billion. Almost half the desired energy capacity expansion - 4,713 MW - is intended to be generated from geothermal resources, according to Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources data obtained by hukumonline. Although perhaps not overly ambitious, it is dubious as to whether the targets can be met unless the government clearly dismantles the ‘red tape’ holding back geothermal mining activities, and creates incentives for mining investors by way of a straightforward, legally certain, and perhaps preferential regulatory framework.

 

Certain preferences have indeed been extended by recent reforms. Public-private partnerships offer greater security and incentives to private investors. Removal or reduction of import tariffs on material imports required to develop the sector reduce opportunity costs for investors. Simplified licensing procedures have been discussed in much recent regulation. Although currently under judicial review, the 2009 Electricity Law allows private parties to organize electricity distribution businesses under certain conditions, as opposed to reserving that right exclusively for the State Electricity Company (‘PLN’). Among other things, these efforts reflect a dedicated multi-pronged approach to cultivating a more favorable investment climate in the developing geothermal energy sector.

 

......

Subscribe to read more legal analysis.

Hukumonline Pro Intelligence

Platform AI hukum terpercaya sebagai solusi komprehensif riset Anda

professionalprofessionalProfessional Solutions
professionalprofessionalUniversity Solutions
*Syarat dan ketentuan berlaku
2026 Hak Cipta Milik Hukumonline.com
Cookies Info